As a frequent visitor to the Millburn location, I was THRILLED when I learned the Morristown location was opening. But, I was hesitant. "Could a second location be as good as the OG?" As good...and maybe even better?! Millburn Deli knocks it out of the park every time. This is our go-to "we have guests in town, so what do we give them for lunch?" place. I often get a "custom" sandwich, either a CYO or a "no sauce" request, "cheddar instead please!" plea or a "hold the T and O" note and they never get it wrong. Ever. Batting 1000 when cranking out the volume of sandwiches they do is a feat on its own... but the quality is truly the unmatched star. Their chicken cutlets are the best I've had; their bread is fresher than anything I've ever bought; and they continuously find the perfect ratio of ingredients. They always nail the cold-to-hot meats, cheeses and toppings... and you never feel like you could've used a little more of anything. My favorites are of course a CYO sandwich, but also the Jay Ray, Godfadda, and the Mad Max. My husband tries something new every time and I swear he ends every meal with "ok, that one is my favorite now." You can't go wrong with Millburn Deli! read more

Millburn deli has been a standard in my family for decades. Great sandwiches. Great staff good prices 10/10

Great sandwiches and customer service! I placed a large order for my job of employment off the website and was able to customize items very easily. Everything was delicious. Definitely 5 star status. That being said, I tried calling and was unable to talk to someone. I arrived an hour early to speak to someone face to face and was told there's no landline. I explained my situation to them and I was able to receive my order with in 15 minutes. Will order again. Thank you all for your hard work. read more

First time visiting the Morristown location. My husband and I had two of the vegeterian sandwiches which were fine, a little soggy. My concern was seeing a handful of the workers handling the food and the woman who handed me my order not wearing their masks correctly...noses need to be covered too. read more

It's great to have a new deli come to Morristown and the reputation of Millburn Deli is highly regarded. My wife ordered a turkey grilled cheese sandwich (cheesy and gooey) and it was delicious. The issue came when we were charged. On our initial trip, we were charged $17.99. When I asked for the receipt, the cashier corrected it to just under $11. On a second visit, it was $12.75 because they added a second piece of cheese ($1 per slice). The food I would recommend - just watch the prices. They are very inconsistent. read more

The most amazing sandwiches we ever had. They have a wonderful selection broken down by meat types and you can also build your own. I had The Gobbler, a Thanksgiving meal on a sandwich. I could eat that every day. They also have great dressings. Try an sandwich with their Pesto. Portions are large and the staff is friendly and accommodating. read more

This place really, really deserves 5 stars. I havent had a bad sandwich yet. I feel really conflicted eating here because it's certainly not low-cal, but it's not stopping my husband and I from ordering 1-2 per week. As, for what i'd recommend, i find their steak or vegetarian sandwiches to be the best. Black bull, wild bull, and the perfect 10. On the veg side threes company is SO good. Sides are good too, especially their mac n cheese and spicy pasta salad. It's easily one of the top 3 delis in the county. read more

Millburn Deli - Perfect 10 sandwich - Delis Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Gossip girl!!! Is the way to go, and their ice teas are heaven sent from the skies above. Easy to order online and get a text when your food is ready to be picked up. Easy!!! read more

I visited this joint about 3 weeks ago. Tipical (for this area) . The food is mehh. The store itself is nothing to write home about. Prices are Morris County-tastic aka expensive as hell. The people there were ok, but in my opinion also felt a little pretentious. I got the buffalo big bird, asked for no lettuce...got a look from the counter person for that. For almost $16 with tax would have expected a little better, the chicken was a bit chewy. They seem to think that they somehow reinvented the sandwich itself. (lol) ok. read more

Highly recommend the Millburn Deli. The sandwiches and subs are huge and delicious. Was glad I stopped in to try the food. Now I go every week to try something new. The bread used to make the subs is the best especially the multi grain. Definitely worth a trip for lunch. Also the staff is super friendly. read more

I am so grateful that they opened a second location closer to my mom's when I visit! Griller #8 is what I always go for, but The Godfadda and the gobbler are also amazing. Can't go wrong here! It's a must try. read more

I'd say Millburn location is 4 stars, morristown is 3. Quality is just always better at Millburn and they are much quicker and efficient. Overall great sandwiches. I will say I ordered the Buffalo chicken salad and it was really good but Buffalo sauce was way too hot. Not to. be a baby but like WAY too hot. Feel like it doesn't need to be this spicy? Can we make it more mild. read more

Beat around hands down ! They are crazy swamped with orders and always find a way to make it happen!!

What I got compared to what is advertised. I was looking forward to trying this places after hearing great things about it. I was very disappointed though. Although the sandwich was tasty, I had to take everything off of one half and put it on the other to make the sandwich actually substantial. It was just lacking substance and presentation. I would maybe try again but definitely wouldn't go out of my way to give it another attempt. read more

Millburn Deli - Soprano. What is advertised on the menu - Delis Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Always consistently great! Had the Turkey sub sandwich which was delicious. Great place for a perfect lunch.

Love this place! I ordered 1 sandwich 3 weeks ago and every week after. NOW I AM HOOKED!!!!! LOVE THIS PLACE!!! So happy to have found a great deli after my old one closed this year after being opened for 42 years! read more

The food may be good ok but the life experience of ordering and picking up is atrocious and the size of the waiting area is terrible never coming here again go back to millburn!!! read more

Absolutely delicious! Their sandwiches & salads are delicious and taste great for pick up & delivery. My only recommendation is that if you get regular bread, to avoid watery toppings as one of the sandwiches only order got a bit soggy bc if the tomatoes and thin bread. Can't go wrong with the ciabatta that held yo with all the toppings. Great place for delicious sandwiches and tasty salads. The quality and quantity is great read more

The sloppy joe is very good but their potato salad had undercooked potatoes. Place isn't cheap but the sandwich is a good size. If in the mood for a solid sloppy joe, I would come back but if 8n the mood for a sub, Longfellow's is a better choice. read more

This deli is amazing. I ordered the corned beef and pastrami monster Joe and it was great. My friend got the Cuban and the best thing to do is share. Half of a Joe half Cuban. Amazing... The service was friendly and professional. I picked up the M&M rice crispy treat, and it was a treat, one of the best crispy treat I ever ate. The home made Iced tea it to die for. I wish It was close enough for DoorDash delivery I would get every day. . If in the area you must stop. Call ahead or order on line to keep it super easy. No waiting. I will be back very soon ... read more

Same great quality as the Millburn location, and they always get my custom orders 100% right!

Easily the best sandwiches I've ever had. My family used to drive 40 minutes to Millburn just to get their sandwiches! Couldn't be happier that they opened their Morristown location which has an identical menu and is way closer. Super convenient as it's take out only and located right by the train station...easy to grab a meal on the run while commuting! Would recommend to anyone! read more

Sandwich was awesome. Highly recommend it. Place was busy so I suggest you order ahead. Sandwich was fresh, so was macaroni salad. read more

Millburn Deli - Chicken brushetta sandwich - Delis Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

See all

Kinda disgusting. Ordered from here twice: 1. What's Up Doc on a baguette - weird bitter taste had me wondering if the veggies had gone bad. And who the F wants carrots on a sandwich? 2. The Mutz Sub - menu states it comes with pesto. Well, no not exactly. It comes with a watery pesto aioli. Is this their way of saving money, by watering down the pesto until it's light green watery mayo? The menu clearly states pesto, NOT pesto aioli. When I brought that to their attention, I was offered the opportunity to call Customer Service. Yeah, no. I'll be heading on back to the South Street Creamery. But thanks anyway. read more

Poor service. Went to pick order up a bit later than assigned time. They didn't even have our names on the board yet. I was okay to wait but when I asked to exchange my $ note for quarters for parking. A man said he can give them but then a lady came and said theyre not allowed to give change. If you're late on someone's order, you should at least accommodate with a giving them change for the meter. Walked into jungle juice next door and he gave me quarters right away. Thank you jingle juice for saving me a high parking ticket for a sandwich. read more

Sloppy Joe was decent, the salad had barely any tuna on it. The place again is just ok. Been to the original in Milburn and now Morristown over the last month. I think I have had my fill. read more

My review is strictly based off of the salads. I have had two salads from this location and I was disappointed both times. The salads are tiny and there are way too many onions. I got the Caesar and the Buffalo Chicken and both salads are watery and taste bland. Even with the dressing the salad was terrible. Sandwiches are good for the most part. Customer service has always been great for me. read more

Best of the best. The best sandwich spot in NJ and maybe the galaxy. You really can't go wrong, but my go to is the turkey joe (obviously), and the gazoo grinder read more

Disgusting food and horrendous prices won't last long in Morristown that's for sure ... I order the Mac daddy and Mac and cheese ... the Mac daddy was bland ...cold.... the Mac and cheese was rock hard not surprised honestly when you got disgusting employees your going to have disgusting food !! read more

Millburn Deli - Mac & Cheese??? If that's what you can even call it - Delis Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

Great salad. Would give 4.5 stars but no option - so went higher because they deserve it. Got a grilled chicken and kale salad for lunch. I was worried the portion would be small but this was a great size with plenty of chicken. No skimping and well made. Ordered online for takeout and it was ready in 15 min. Pickup was easy. Employees were masked up, clean kitchen, friendly and quality. Only minus was the lemon vinaigrette I got was low on flavor and despite endless shaking never mixed well before pouring. read more

I got a gluten free turkey sandwich...let me just say BEST SANDWICH EVER! At first i was nervous because some gluten free bread can be not too tasty but my sandwich was amazing! I got it delivered to my work and the food came quick and instructions were followed perfectly! Cant wait to order from here again read more

Millburn Deli - Gluten free turkey sandwich - Delis Near Me - Morristown, New Jersey

I am always searching for an excellent roast beef sandwich.... I had an incredible and perfect sandwich. The roast beef was perfect not too rare just the perfect amount of redness & very little brown... The ratio of everything on the sandwich was perfect and the ciabatta bread was very fresh... I work at Elysium salon right around the corner on South Street so I will be making sure this is one of our go to spots for lunch!!! read more

Definitely not the same as MILLBURN DELI-having grown up in Short Hills, this location was a real let down. Tried it a few times and disappointed every time. Although I now live in Bernardsville, if I'm in the mood for MILLBURN DELI, I'm driving to Millburn! read more

We love Millburn Deli! We get sandwiches here at least 1x per week. There's so many different sandwiches that we are currently working through the menu! Our favorite is the gobbler but the godfadda is solid as well. read more

Sadly not a good sandwich wanted a simple rare roast beef sandwich got a skinny sandwich with 5 slices of well done beef. Very disappointing especially since I asked specifically for rare roast beef. People were nice place was clean but not returning. read more

Way over priced! Super disappointing. Paid $15 for a mediocre, tasteless pastrami and Swiss on rye. If the pastrami was made in house, I could rationalize the price. read more

Best sandwiches in Morristown, easily. Sloppy Joe is a classic and chicken cutlet sandwiches are consistently good. Also have fresh and nicely-packaged salads. read more

Below average and overpriced! Skimpy on the meat. Shoprite makes better sandwiches! Maybe we caught them on a bad day?

As great as the original. Easy pickup and go. Staff is pleasant and process is orderly. Great job, guys

The Millburn location is like an entirely different deli compared to the Morristown location. I've now had three really poor experiences at Morristown. They're all out of chances. read more