This isn't your typical pizza place. You can only order a pizza if they are not sold out for the day. You can order online starting at 8am. Your pizza will be ready for the time you choose. If the venue looks familiar, it's in the former Gina's Italian Ice shop that was there for decades. Still on the wall is a reminder of the building's history. Also on the wall is a picture of Burt's Place, which I believe had a similar crispy cheese border crust. This is not a sit down place, though...more of a pick up place. Very simple. But the venue is not the draw....the pizza is. I'm sure many will wax poetic about the cheesy border(which is great), but for me, the best part of the pizza is the crust. I'm a baker, and have baked many a from-scratch pizza. I wish I could produce a crust as perfect as Millie's! I also liked the sauce, which is not sweet, as some are. The sausage is admirable. The staff is pleasant, too. If you like attention to detail, ingredients and baking, go to Millie's. Delicious! read more

Absolutely delicious. The crust had that perfect crispy edge, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the pepperoni cups were exactly how they should be. Everything tasted incredibly fresh. You can taste that real care goes into how they make each pizza. Easily the best in Berwyn! Make sure you pre-order! read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - 14" Half Pepperoni + fresh mozz on whole - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Love Milly's! We found out about this spot recently and had to try it. Logged on and ordered a cheese pizza and a sausage pizza. Both were completely delicious and the sausage was excellent. Just the right amount of sauce and toppings on both pizzas. Pickup was easy and straightforward - though parking can sometimes be a bit hard right in the area. Those working there (owners? Not sure) we're super nice. Very friendly. There's not much in the way of ambiance - this is a pickup spot but it is clean and not crowded due to the way they space out their orders. Worth it!!! read more

Wow. Just wow. Authentic Chicago-style pizza with a legit sauce and dough to die for. You need to check the website for an ascribed time and date. It sells out quickly! There is no seating inside, so take yours to go. We took ours to the park outside of the Oak Park conservatory and had a picnic. Bring your own pizza cutter since they don't cut it. What a treat! read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Pizza was great! However, the ordering experience is not. Price point is insane for what you get. $80 and a mandatory tip for pick up rounding it up to $90 for two pizzas. I would get it again, but with the ordering experience, it probably won't happen. It's kinda hard to plan out eating a pizza when you have to order it at 7:59 AM. read more

Don't sleep on this gem!! We just ordered the 'Onlypans' pizza and it was absolutely delicious! From the honey drizzle to the ricotta and the sauce! Every part of your pallet is ignited with magnificent flavors!! I highly recommend this place! read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Onlypans 14 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

I loved this pizza! It's pricy but a nice gift for Valentine's Day surprise! The everything bagel seasoning for the crust was super tasty in my option especially if you don't mind a salty flavor. Service was fast-you do have to preorder and they sell out! read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

Great Pan Pizza, they are very popular, so order in advance. Pretty standard price for pizza of this quality and size. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Untitled #1 - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

This is currently my favorite pizza. The crust is thick, pan-style. It's crisp, yet airy like detroit-style pizza. The toppings are super fresh and you can really tell. The sauce, tomatoes, pickled peppers, spinach and the meats are all high quality. This pizza is definitely saucy, so you have to be careful when transporting it. It's well worth the price and the drive. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Friendly staff when I came in for my order. We tried two different pizzas. The crust is buttery and delicious. There are several toppings on each pizza so every bite is slightly different. I liked the pepperoni slightly more than the sausage. Next time I order, I would try fewer ingredients as I preferred the bites with just one or two toppings. They are filling, we ordered way too much. The only I thing I didn't like was that even though I got there at the set time, my pizza wasn't hot when I got home. I live less than 10 minutes away. I recommend heating up a little bit before eating. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Awesome, awesome!! The ideal pan pizza in my opinion. Was my first time trying Milly's and I'll definitely be coming back. The crust was perfectly. Soft crust but crispy in the right areas. Amazing sauce as well. The Only Pans pizza was amazing but I'm intrigued to try their other pizzas on my next visit. Plus, the staff was very friendly. Job well done! read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Millys is one of the best pizzas I have tried. I am a life-long Chicagoan and when my best friend told me he had the best pizza ever, I knew I had to try Millys. Millys is now in my rotation of go-to pizzas and the fact that they make a limited amount a day makes it even more special when i do have millys. I highly recommend them. Quality over quantity :) read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

See all

Great pizza. Fantastic crust and ingredients. Thanks Milly's. Wish you could have stayed in Berwyn. I will try to get to the West Town location . read more

Worth it. We were eying this place for quite a while. I should say, worth it if it was eaten fresh. We placed an order online, drove 30 minutes from our hotel to get to the restaurant, picked up our pizza, drove back to our hotel to eat. By the time we got back to our hotel the pizzas were kinda cold already. Hard to eat it fresh since we're out of towners and didn't know the area well. Wished it was dine-in so we could've eaten it fresh. read more

My favorite pizza has been Pequod's forever! I moved to Berwyn and I do love paisan pizza because their sauce is sweet. Today I had Milly's I thinks it's my new favorite. It's tastes so good I got the CLICKBAIT-Olives, red onion, mushrooms, mini peppers, kumato tomatoes, jalapeno, Calabrian chilis & fresh ricotta cheese and I added sausage. I can't wait to try it with pepperoni. You need to try this pizza. Highly recommend. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

Milly's Pizza in the Pan in Berwyn is fantastic! I've had plenty of pizza in the Oak Park-Berwyn area and put them at the top of the list! Their pizzas are hand-crafted in the truest sense of the term and their quality reflects this effort. Delicious and very well done! read more

Absolutely to die for pizza that I am so lucky is now in my neighborhood. The crust is so crispy and delicious, and the topping combos are also perfection! read more

I love that this is a local artisanal pizza restaurant staffed by great folks who really believe in their product. I hope they expand to another location. Every element of their pizza is uniquely delicious and cooked to perfection. read more

Ordered delivery.....very specifically asked for NO PESTO on one of their specialty pizzas. It came covered in pesto. Also, would have to say it was almost cold when it arrived and super greasy...it had surely sat for some time as I had a 6pm pre-delivery time. For $50 (once hit with fees and tip), I will never order again from this place. read more

We got married in 2022 and had our rehearsal dinner at George's Deep Dish in Edgewater. That was our first experience with this type of pizza but it's so far away. When Millys opened down the street, we were excited to try it. Very happy to report it was amazing! Just pay attention and order ahead. It's well worth it read more

This pizza is amazing. Yes, they sell out. Yes, you have to plan in advance, but know that they are a small family business, so idk maybe just be patient. We love Onlypans the best out of the three we've tried so far. read more

One of if not best pizza I've had. Dough is incredible. Sauce is fantastic. Staff extremely friendly. Picking up is a breeze. Would recommend to anyone. Got the Onlypan pizza read more

The pizza's were point! Service was pleasant as expected. Our family will be repeat customers. read more

Hot Damn! This pizza is delicious and some the very best I've ever had. Ordered the OnlyPans with extra pepperoni. You can easily taste the freshness of every ingredient. No doubt that dough and pesto are made that day. No need for ranch. I heated it up (oven) the last of it two days later, and it was just as fantastic. Highly recommend Milly's and I can't wait to try Craigslist.org next. Once you have this pizza, every other place will be mediocre. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - OnlyPans - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

Amazing pizza. We ordered a 14 inch Updog, which was plenty big for 3-4 people. The style is Chicago deep dish meets Detroit-style pan pizza, with a crust that is similar to Chicago pizzeria, Pequods. Be sure to order days ahead online to get your pie when you want it. read more

See all

Good pizza, but they do some bs where you have to order in advance, cant just walk in and come out with a pizza, but the pizza is good, expensive af, but i get out once in a while, it's different than normal pizza, as its pan pizza, I had some during covid at the og location, but i have to say this ones better read more

So excited to have a Milly's open up here. We're in the city but the Argyle location is not as convenient. Love the pizza. Fresh ingredients. Love the fresh jalapeños! Delicious crust. Definitely worth a try if you are looking for something different. read more

Milly's pizza is my favorite in the city - absolutely delicious and like no other pizza I've had before. The crust is perfection. They sell out quick so be sure to order ahead! read more

I'll start by saying the pre-ordering situation is odd. When they've made enough pizzas for the day, they're done, so plan ahead if you think you want their pizza. I had heard a lot about how fantastic this pizza is but hesitated because of the price. I had friends over so I splurged. The toppings are scant. Others say it's full of cheese which was not my experience, though there was a lot of sauce. The sauce was good. The crust was interesting, very light for a pan-type pizza. It reminded me of the old Pizza Hit pan pizza. I'd suggest you give it a try once as it is a "different" type of pizza for the area. read more

Milly's Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Berwyn, Illinois

I don't know where else you can go where a simple Greek tomato burst with flavor when you bite into it the pizza is completely full of grape flavor. Get yourself pizza from here if you're interested and what a good pizza is. read more

This is probably the best pizza in the Chicago area and maybe the best I've ever had. For a pan pizza, it is amazingly light, and has very tasty sauce, cheese and toppings. The creator of Milly's clearly has a passion for this, and has come up with a fantastic pan pizza. It is a better version of Pequod's which is pretty great in its own rite. read more

It's a unique style all its own. It's somehow a blend of deep dish, Detroit style and classic pan pizza. But It's surprisingly light. My favorite thing about it might be the fresh tangy sauce! read more

Great pan pizza If you're in Berwyn definitely stop by and grab one or if you want one delivered, just call them

The pizza is fabulous, but their customer service and ordering system is seriously flawed-/ not what I'm looking for when ordering pizza (for example, there is no email confirmation of an order even though you're encouraged to order online. I saved them from sending the same order twice because I double checked. No accountability on their part. Instead, " this is how we've always done it" is the response provided. ) I have never encountered an online ordering system that does not provide a confirmation. They believe they are worth their rigidity and inconvenience. To me, nothing is worth enduring insufferable arrogance. Somebody else will come along and do it better and be more gracious. read more