Mister 01 Extraordinary Pizza is extraordinary for a reason. Seriously, this place cleared my expectations. I had heard about them for about two years prior to actually going. It was one of those places, where it's on my list but I think I just never ended up going. That is until recently to the Lake Mary location. Mister 01 has many, many locations all over Florida. So the history is that a chef who was raised in Southern Italy came to Florida and set up his first shop in Miami. It was so popular that they've expanded to Georgia, North Carolina, and even Texas. Their claim to fame is they have some specialized pizzas where the crust is folded and the whole pie kind of resembles a star. They even have a special pizza that has coffee on it, not that it's the one I got but I think it's very unique. We got there on a Friday night and it was very busy. It was about a 20-30 minute wait. Conveniently, they have a trail right behind the building, so we walked a part of it while waiting and it was a nice walk at sunset. It's really fun to be seated and enjoy as you can see the cooking and baking process while getting a slightly high end dining experience. Not that it was that expensive, but it felt slightly more elevated than a Domino's. I got the Star Luca. The Star Luca is a star shaped pizza with ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce, spicy salami Calabrese, and basil. The 20 inch costs $20.99. My rating for this one is a 9.5/10. I mean it was insanely delicious. They bring a spicy olive oil to the table, which I loved and used. The crust is so cool that it's filled with ricotta. So it feels like you got the best parts of a calzone and a pizza into one, if I am being honest. I also got a flute of Prosecco Clara C', which was a sparkling white wine with notes of apple. It was good, although a bit pricey at $14.95 a glass. For dessert, we tried the Nutella banana calzone, which was recommended by our waiter. This was an 8/10. It was really good and sweet. I liked that they use their own fermented dough, which is another cool note. My overall rating of this place is a 9/10. I mean the food is really really good. There is a clear reason for how busy it is. It's a step up from your casual pizza joint, but I enjoyed it. read more

See all

I went to Mister 01 on a Saturday night around 6 and it was packed. I asked the hostess how long the wait was and she didn't know. We put our name down anyways, and it was actually a very quick wait. We had a table about 10 minutes later. Our server was great. He was busy, but took time to pass by our table to let us know he'd be right over. When we were seated, there was already water on the table, which was appreciated. I ordered the Marco and my friend ordered the star Beckham. Both were delicious, light and the crust was very thin and crunchy. For dessert, we ordered the Nutella banana calzone and it was gooey, warm and the perfect sweet treat. Despite how busy it was, we were only there for about an hour. The food and service were both excellent. This is some of my favorite pizza in Orlando and I'll be back soon! read more

See all

Okay first of all thank you to Andrew who is very knowledgeable wait staff and helped us out and explaining the different choices of pizzas and helped us out with other options that were on the menu Great customer service second this was our first time attending Mr zero extraordinary pizza as I understand it's has several locations across Florida their pizzas are more of a Neapolitan style which I really did look forward to trying. Since it was lent our only choices were non meat-based style so we didn't get a chance to try a lot we did go with the traditional margarita pizza which allowed us to taste the sauce the cheese how it's constructed overall I really enjoyed the pizza that we had in addition I think probably the biggest deal was wifey liked the wine The this was a huge differentiator for us and guarantees that we will be returning over and over again. So specifically about the pizza it was thin it was a little bit thinner than Neapolitan it was cooked and a traditional steel oven steel pizza oven that one would find New York style pizzas cooked in that was probably the only thing that held back if I would have preferred I would have enjoyed it if it was cooked in a wood fired oven that doesn't stop the fact that it still gets a five-star for the great customer service ambiance was incredible and we will return again read more

See all

The service was speedy and attentive. The drinks are bottled. They have a wine selection. We ordered pizza. One Maria and one sausage. The pizza is medium sized. The crust is thiiiinnn. The toppings are also thin. There is little sauce and cheese. But it is tasty. They brought olive oil and balsamic vinegar to the table. Also, we had pepper flakes but no Parmesan. For dessert we had the Nutella Banana Calzone. It is rich and chocolaty. Well done. As far as the restaurant it's newer and very clean. We had a view of the tiny lake. read more

See all

The happy hour here is by far one of the best in the area and I hope they still offer the same deals! But the pizza is so good and the burrata is top notch. Reminds me of visiting Italy in a casual atmosphere. The service is amazing as well! read more

We came in for a work lunch and had a great experience. We enjoyed sitting outside on the patio. Service was good and our server was very nice. We got 7 pizzas and loved all of them. The toppings were fresh and full of flavor. We loved the thin crusts baked to perfection. We loved the star shaped pizzas, the coffee pizza, and the blanco pizza with truffle and honey. This was a great meal for a large group. I'm definitely coming back soon. read more

See all

Mister 01 is incredible. The food is always consistent. It's cooked and flavored well. The inside and outside are always so clean and the staff is incredible. Out most recent visit - 03/18 - they brought out pizza dough for my kids to play with. My kids were in heaven. I love the consistency and how great every experience here is! read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

We came in on a Friday night and were seated right away! The vibe inside is casual but definitely a step up from your average pizza joint. Clean, modern, and welcoming. Service was super friendly and very helpful with any questions we had. We ordered the Claudio and the Maria pizzas, and both were incredible. The Claudio was so unique. The stracciatella poured over the top with a touch of truffle made it absolutely delicious. If you're into those flavors, it's a must-try. The Maria was equally fantastic. You really can't go wrong with prosciutto on a pizza. The pizzas came out quickly and were hot, fresh, and full of flavor. Overall, we had a great time and an even better meal. Definitely recommend Mister O1 if you're craving creative, high-quality pizza! read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Claudio - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

See all

We were looking for a pizza place in our new neighborhood and found this cute little restaurant. Now this is not the typical pizza I go for, I am not usually a thin crust pizza fan, but this pizza made me a thin crust believer. Everything is always so delicious and fresh. Such wonderful combination of flavors and unique pizzas. Their signature star pizza is one of our favorites, And we always get the caprese as well. The service is always friendly and fast. Cute little neighborhood joint that keeps us coming back over and over again. They have both indoor and outdoor seating. Very cozy space . read more

See all

My family went back to Mr. 01 Extraordinary Pizza in Lake Mary today. My review and opinion of this restaurant has absolutely changed. My review was responded to right away by Fabiana. Dealing with Mike and the rest of his staff today has solidified that reversal . We ordered the Caprese Salad and a sampling of their pizzas to share, everything was delicious . I'm extremely happy that we gave them another chance, we now have a new pizza place to add into our rotation. read more

I really like the pizza here. Service was amazing, and they have a nice outdoor area in addition to sitting inside. The pizzas are super thin, just the way I like them. Sitting in, I went for the classic pepperoni version, and it was awesome. The first time I tried one of their pizzas (takeout), I went for the Star Luca just to try something that looked really different. Though the pizza itself was great, the "star" part filled with ricotta cheese was just a bit too much for my style. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

First thing you need to do is not compare this to a "pizza place". It's upscale style/artisan and while very expensive for what you get ($9 bottle of beer) it was clean, friendly and tasty. But our meal was the same cost as a nice sit down a couple doors down. As a pizza person who lived in NYC area and Chicago and travelled to Italy several times...I have a vision of what my pizza (what I like) is... This was "interesting". But, the salad was nice, the service by both Jasur (waiter) and amazingly our bus person Vaughn..was uber, uber nice. Will I come back? Probably. Will it become our "pizza place"? Nah. But if you're looking for something a little different, with good quality, clean and friendly...sure. Thanks Jasur and Vaughn, you guys rocked it. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Not typical...very little on top and slightly underdone but tasty. $$ - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

I'm absolutely obsessed! This is my second time reviewing this spot, and I stand by it--this might just be the best pizza in Florida. This place is a true gem. My husband and I came in for dine-in and shared a pizza and a salad. Both were incredible--fresh, flavorful, and perfectly done. On top of that, the laid-back atmosphere and friendly staff made the experience even better. Without a doubt, this is our new go-to spot. I've been telling everyone who will listen about it, and if you haven't tried it yet--do yourself a favor and go. You'll love it! read more

See all

Great thin and slightly crispy crust pizza and wonderful service! Fresh ingredients and the Starr pizza style was unique and delicious.

This was my first time here and everyone was so nice. I came here for my friends birthday and they did the birthday chant it was amazing. I like how the restaurant is warmly lit, it makes the pizza place cozy. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a half hawaiian and cheese pizza. Both soooo good. I didnt take a photo of it but their nutella pizza was my favorite id come here again. One thing that was just like weird but I guess i can see why they do it is the plastic cups for drinks but that isnt rlly an issue. Had a great time here!! read more

This spot had been on my list for about a year, and I'm so glad I finally got to try it! The decor strikes a perfect balance between casual and minimalist, making a subtle yet stylish statement. I was greeted promptly and handed a menu to place my to-go order. I chose the Star Luca ($18.99), a star-shaped pizza filled with ricotta cheese, spicy salami calabrese, mozzarella, Italian tomato sauce, and basil. The flavors were fantastic and complemented each other beautifully. The pizza came with a side of hot olive oil, which I absolutely loved--it added a spicy kick that elevated the experience. I'd definitely order from here again! read more

See all

Umn yum! Super friendly helpful staff, absolutely delicious and fun to eat thin crust star shaped pizzas with ricotta stuffed up in the pointed crust. Creative Coffee Paola pizza with honey and coffee doesn't normally come star shaped but they did it up for me anyway. Who'd of thunk?! Not usually a fan of calzones, but this one was very nice with an awesome marinara I could drink. Fun and delicious! read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Coffee Paola ...with special star crust - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

See all

Some of the best pizza I've had in Orlando! Servers are friendly and helpful. Love this place for a quick lunch spot or dinner. You can also bring your bike and use the trail in the back which is beautiful. The star Luca is a must try, and so is the Nutella pizza read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Kids personal pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza has a very interesting story behind the extraordinary, but I'll let the folks here let you know why. The service is A1 and the staff is sure to make sure you have an amazing experience at their restaurant. How about the food? I mean that's why we're really here, right? The pizzas are great and if you go with a group my recommendation is to share and get at least one star pizza. The star pizza has curled edges with burrata cheese. It's like a calzone and pizza combined. I enjoyed one of their salads, pizza and their blonde ale from Italy. It was such a good time & I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

First time visiting Mister 01 Pizza after hearing great things about it for a very long time. My friends and I decided to do girls night out at this restaurant and everything went great. The establishment is cute and clean. Our server was amazing, gave us recommendations and was very attentive the entire time we were there. We ordered burrata as an appetizer, 3 pizzas and 1 Nutella calzone for dessert for 5 people. We had plenty of food. Everything was delicious but my favorite thing was the Star Alessandro. The Nutella calzone had bananas in the middle which made it even more perfect. It was pretty big so, definitely a plate to be shared. I will definitely be back. I want to bring my hubby for a date night. Lovely place, delicious food and excellent service. So happy to have found a new pizza place in Sanford/Lake Mary. read more

See all

I've tried Mister O1 in south Florida and most recently again in Lake Mary. We ordered two pizzas for pick up, the Star Luca and Elisa. They were delicious and very different from your typical pizza. The crust was very thin, but the flavors were bursting. It almost felt guilt free. read more

We decided to try this place after hearing great things! We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon around lunchtime and it was empty. Greeted and seated immediately- our server was friendly and gave us the details on the restaurant and walked us through the pizzas. We opted for canned Dr Pepper and Diet Coke to drink and water came to the table as soon as we were seated. We opted for the Daniele ($20-13inch) and the Star pizza with pepperoni only ($20-13inch). The Daniele had prosciutto, mozzarella and fresh basil. Super thin and sort of crispy, it was good. The star pizza with pepperoni had ricotta cheese around the crust and the pepperoni tasted like cup pepperoni (iykyk). I thought it was good-my husband thought it was mediocre. They bring a spicy olive oil and crushed red pepper flakes to the table and when I added the spicy oil to the prosciutto pizza, it took it up a notch. So yummy-I bought a bottle and brought it home! All in all, a nice little local pizza place with good pizza and relaxed atmosphere. Give them a try! read more

See all

I've tried a few locations that were decent,but this one is by far the worst. The pizza overall was extremely dry and baked to the point there was no sauce. Felt like I was eating a giant piece of crust the minimal sauce evaporated the cheese no longer existed. This style reminds me of dehydrated/ dried pizza. Not something I'll try again or recommend. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Coffee Paola - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

I am loving this restaurant and the concept of the extraordinary pizza, it's so unbelievably good. Such a great combination with the ricotta cheese- excellent! I want to mention that the salad is so big and I appreciate the variety of flavors/ingredients. I actually have a tough time finding restaurants with really good salads and this place is where it's at. The ambiance is chill, the service is great, it's pricey but I think worth it compared to other places where the pizza isn't as good. I highly recommend! read more

See all

Finally got to try this spot out and the only reason we didn't give it 5 stars was due to out server... who seemed to be having a bad day. SUPER filling salads and super unique pizzas. The star pizzas were absolutely delicious but it's a lot of ricotta! Also, don't leave unless you have the nutella pizza (get the small one). It's worth it. read more

Phenomenal food and service! Quality is unmatched! Ambience on the patio is very enjoyable in the evening. read more

Mister O1 is great! Delicious thin crust pizza with a cool concept of stuffing ricotta in a little crust pocket. The service was excellent and the atmosphere perfect for a pizza spot. Highly recommend! read more

My first review of 2025! If you have not visited this place yet, what are you waiting for? Not sure why it took myself so long... their pizza is absolutely delicious. I haven't had the pleasure of dining in the restaurant just yet, but we have done takeout three times. Their coffee pizza and star Luca pies are sooooo tasty. The crust is perfectly crisp. I am looking forward to visiting asap to try more of their "extraordinary" pies (that's what they call their speciality pies). read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

See all

I haven't posted in a a couple of years, but this pizza was definitely worth getting back on Yelp for a review. This is my favorite style of Pizza and Mister 01 knocked it out of the park. Their star pizzas were amazing! They add ricotta cheese in little pockets that make the shape of a star around the pizza. I was totally impressed with the food, the service and the atmosphere. Would highly recomme read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Star Luca pizzas (with added toppings) - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

Highly recommend, especially if you want an elevated pizza experience. I had the signature star-shaped pizza style stuffed with the ricotta crust. It's definitely a unique take on pizza. I also got the Nutella pizza to go, which was good, but I'd recommend eating fresh at the restaurant. Regardless, I will be returning! read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Nutella pizza - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

See all

It was good but not great. Not very memorable . Not a lot of flavor on the pizzas we had . Restaurant is clean though

Went to try this place out last night and OMG. It was amazingly good. We got there a little later in the evening so there was no wait or anything and the pizza came out fast. Our server was very knowledgeable and told us the history behind the name. And the manager checked on us throughout our time there. It's a cool little place with outside seating. It's the old peach valley in Heathrow, so it's small and homey feeling. Now let's get to the pizza. I was a little skeptical about the ricotta in the star pizza when reading about it. So I had to try it out since that's what it's famous for. And it works perfectly. The crust is a thin crust and the entire pizza is light and airy. It's not over filling. And also come to find out they don't use any sugar in the ingredients (dough or sauce). I got the Star Beckham, which is the meat lovers. She got the Star Michele. Both top notch. And will definitely be back for more read more

See all

Ordered for pickup for the office. Tried calling ahead but the phones don't open til 11:30, the same as their opening time. My order was over $100, so they asked for credit card payment over the phone. When I arrived, I waited about 10 min for my order. It was packed neatly. I ordered the small Daniele, small Elisa, small vittoria, star Luca, Caesar salad and a Sabrina salad customized. I appreciated the silverware setups and napkins. They offered sauces on the side like hot oil and ranch but I declined. They sell olive oil and wine etc up front. The pizzas stayed hot and were great, even 30 min after pickup. I'd love to try one of their calzones and more of their pizzas. Everything was delicious! Service was kind and smooth. They participate in some delivery service online if you want delivery. Parking is tight at that strip mall but people come and go quickly. Restaurant looked very clean. read more

See all

This place is a great reminder that It's the simple things in life. A glass of wine and some delicious thin crust pizza, that's it. No need to complicate things. Our daughter devoured a small cheese in a way that would make you think we didn't feed her. Andrew, our server, took the time to give some history and explain the favorites. 10 out of 10 experience. read more

Dissapointed in this spot, which promised O1-Visa (I should know)-level pizza. The pizza was ok, but overpriced. The server provided an overly long monologue style introduction to the restaurant. He asked if we knew what an O1 visa was, to which I replied, truthfully, "yes, I had one". The waiter man-splained, with a look of annoyance, ignoring my statement, and explaining what it was, seeming perturbed that I had interrupted him. Maybe he was tired at the end of a long day, because he later spilled water all over our table. The pizza itself excelled with it's unique star-shaped edges, though the flavors were on the simple side, and the bread to toppings ratio was higher than I'd like, especially for the price! The place came highly recommended but due to the mediocre flavor, unpleasant service, and high priced menu items, we were disappointed and underwhelmed. Coming from an O1-Visa recipient herself, I would say that this restaurant's naming is a misnomer. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

Love the pizza! Especially the Hawaiian and the classic. You can't go wrong with whatever you order on the menu. It's all amazing! And the service is A-1, especially from our favorite server in Lake Mary, Katherine. She's always go the extra mile with our large and rowdy family. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Burrata with prosciutto! Perfect appetizer. - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

See all

Best pizza around. I'm honestly not the biggest pizza person, but I would give mine a 10/10. Loved the thin crust. It's nice and light, not really greasy at all. And for once I didn't need to bring a box home. Service was great as well, everyone was very friendly. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Heathrow, Florida

Fantastic pizza spot! We were greeted by friendly staff and seated immediately upon arrival. This place is also very kid-friendly -- my kids were given fresh balls of pizza dough to play with while we waited for our order, which was such a clever touch. We ordered the 16-inch Margherita pizza and the star pizza with prosciutto. Both were amazing. The crust was thin and crispy, and they use high-quality ingredients. They even have a red pepper-infused olive oil that adds the perfect kick of heat, so good! The salads are huge too -- the Caesar and Greek are both delicious. We've been here three times now, and it never disappoints! They offer tons of seating and the ambiance is very chill and relaxed. read more

We've already been to Mister O1 twice since they opened and I have to say... I'm a big fan! I had heard so many amazing things about this concept from my Miami friends, and it definitely lived up to the hype. It's clear why they're included in the Michelin guide for their award-winning pizza, and I'm glad we now have the new Lake Mary location. It's a much more casual place than I had originally imagined, but the service is top notch and they also have a really nice patio for outdoor dining. When you first walk in, you can see the open concept kitchen with multiple chefs on the line tossing dough and making the pizzas. We've gotten to try 4 different pizzas now as well as their burrata with white truffle oil and prosciutto, and their nutella & banana dessert calzone. Everything has been soooo fresh and delicious. That burrata has to be one of the best I've ever had and the rosemary focaccia bread that's served on the side is phenomenal. 13-in pizzas we've had: Star Luca (*most popular/award winning recipe) Star Carlos Star Beckham Coffee Paolo (yes, with actual coffee grounds on top!) Their signature star-shaped pizzas are the ones that have the ricotta stuffed crust. They also have traditional pizzas and other signature recipes to choose from. I think my favorite so far is the Star Luca with spicy salami and calabrese on top... I love the meats. The Coffee Paolo is their most adventurous pizza and was a pleasant surprise. All the flavors (tomato sauce, mozzarella, gorgonzola blue cheese, honey, coffee and spicy salami) are well balanced and actually work together. It's definitely worth a try! I'm not big on nutella or dessert pizza, so the calzone was just ok to me. I'm glad I tried it once, but probably wouldn't order it again. We were also sitting outside on a breezy day so the powdered sugar on top blew everywhere and we were covered in it. I suggest eating that one indoors lol. read more

See all

Stopped by to experience the extraordinary pizza! Our server Katherine did a great job in explaining the origins of the extraordinary pizza and answered all of the questions that we had. Unfortunately, there is no kids menu or any small plates that are toddler-friendly (fries, mac n cheese, pasta, etc) There is a cute little kids coloring book though. I decided to buy a salad for my baby, since he likes tomatoes and avocado. I did the create your own, it came down to $15 for romaine, tomato, avocado, and feta. I thought it was a bit expensive. We started off with one Star Luca and once we tried it we knew it was one of the best pizzas we've had! It's thin yet thick, it's crunchy yet soft, it's spicy yet pleasant. We had to order another one. Only thing I would say is that we wish it had more pepperoni, since it's about $19 per pizza. We asked for honey and got charged .50 cents. I don't mind paying the .50 cents but it was the first time a pizza restaurant has ever charged for plain honey. It's more of an "upscale" dining experience so I understand the charges and prices, I just feel that using only canned drinks with plastic cups took off a lot of the "upscale" they are trying to present themselves as. The staff was all really nice and welcoming, especially the manager. Can't say I'll be back soon, in total we spent $77 for Two pizzas, two cokes (no refills), and a salad. Once we saw how expensive it was for what we got, it suddenly wasn't the best pizza we've had. For this price, we could've gotten Korean bbq (unlimited) or even had a sushi night. I'm glad we gave it a try though!!! read more

See all