Goodfellas pizza is a good go to...for our first visit we had pizza. The restaurant is a nice cozy spot in a plaza. The inside is really cool, a few tables, some unique decorations and great smells. Everyone was super friendly and accomodating. We ordered a large sausage and pepperoni as well as a large veggie. It was fresh and good as well as reasonably priced. We enjoyed the pizza but weren't blown away...that said, we've heard amazing things about their pastas, will definitely give those a shot next time. Overall I would recommend this place over a lot of other places. read more

See all

We ordered Goodfellas take-out for a work party and they were fantastic. They took our order a couple of days in advance and were completely reliable, with everything ready right on time. We ordered salads, garlic knots, and pizza, and everything was amazingly tasty. The pizza is great New York-style with a really flavorful crust that holds up well even for take-out. The garlic knots were a standout...generously coated in butter and fresh grated garlic and so good. Easy ordering, dependable service, and consistently delicious food make this a great option for groups and events. read more

Spaghetti and meatballs are outstanding! The meatballs are homemade, delicious! Order delivery, so cannot comment on service or atmosphere. Highly recommend read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Not my first time here. Pizza is always good and that garlic oil is off the chain. Had wings this time around. I always call ahead before picking up my order because I never know what the situation is seating wise read more

Goodfellas...what can I say. A 5-star staple in and around Orlando for 30+ years. The garlic knots are the best. The pizza is undeniable. A++ Italian read more

Wow, they now have eggplant parmigiana. Fantastic. It is enough for 2 persons. Fast friendly service. Small place, clean, bright. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Eggplant parmigiana w perfect al dente ziti. Enough for two. Made fresh, hot gooey deliciousness. - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Got pizza from goodfellas last night. It was pretty decent. It was like a 6-7/10. ‍ I would say the lack of sauce was disappointing but other than that, the pizza was delicious! It was a great new york style pizza. read more

In case you're wondering, THIS is how you do a veggie pie. More green than white - it's that simple. My first visit to the local Goodfellas did not disappoint. My pick-up order was ready in 15 minutes and had just been pulled out as I walked in. This restaurant is long, not wide, but spacious enough to seat family-sized parties. I cannot speak to service because my personal size 12-inch was to go (and to get me ready for TNF). Their thin crust pizza was delicious and I quickly polished off three slices. The gravy didn't really stand out but I was truly impressed with the amount of veg on that pie (mushrooms, onions, etc.). I would definitely return to try either their sausage or meatball pie. There are, by my count, three pizza places in the immediate area. Pretty sure tonight I ordered from the best one. Grazie! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Excellent veggie 12" personal pie... - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

I came in not expecting much , a cute hole in the wall spot. Boy was I wrong first off the service was amazing thank you Chance ! and on top of everything, food came out in good time and it was amazing. We got the Bianca pizza special and the meat calzone. Let me tell you something about this calzone each bite was better than the last, I needed a room with this calzone ... I left this pizza joint shoes in hand after the love me and that calzone had. Ps how does everyone like it but leave 4 out of 5 stars with no reason for the fifth being left out read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

This is without a doubt the best home style neighborhood Italian pizza shop south of Philadelphia / New Jersey. The staff - awesome. Friendly, efficient, treat you like family. The Food - Everything, and I mean EVERYTHING, is homemade, made from scratch. Without a doubt the best damn chicken parm subs and meatball subs in the state. The meatballs taste just like a 90 year South Philly or Staten Island grandmother would make. Subs are huge and the portions are awesome. Pizza - amazing. Great toppings, cooked perfectly, tastes great. They have a few tables for dine in and do a hell of a take out business. This place is a GEM! read more

Nice casual spot with great service. I've been here with friends before and they have great pizza but I didn't review until now. My husband and I ordered to go. We haven't tired their other dishes so we thought it would be a good idea. We were right! The woman I spoke to on the phone was super kind and helpful! She took our order quickly and efficiently and helped me make my final decision on what to eat lol. We both got pasta dishes. Hubby got the Shrimp Sinatra and I got the blackened shrimp alfredo with blackened chicken added to it. Both were delicious! The shrimp Sinatra was definitely our favorite though. Portions are great! The cannoli's are great and their garlic oil is amazing. Only complaint was wishing there was more sauce on the pasta because when you heat it up later it will be a little dry. Definitely try them out! read more

See all

Running around doing some errands in the area and I searched for a quick bite to eat. Saw this location close by and we gave it a shot. It's a small and casual and exactly what we were looking for. The service was great (our server was very pleasant and was on it) and the food tasted fresh and didn't take too long. We ordered a meatball sub (I was told they're made fresh daily) and the wifey ordered two meatballs (they were HUGE). Everything tasted delicious. Next time I'll order a pizza to see how it compares. This is a nice spot and the service is great. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Found this convenient place on a business trip and cannot complain. Excellent customer service, good Prices and tasty food! I tried their lunch specials: Caesar salad, garlic knots, red spaghetti, eggplant, chicken parmesan, and pizza. All of them are a must-try. The place is nice and clean, and the waitress staff members were friendly. read more

Stopped in after hiking at Black Bear and I had to use the restroom and was impressed the bathroom was immaculate! Ordered a Pizza Bianca, my sister ordered a pepperoni and mushroom and also a salad. My great niece ordered spaghetti and it came with a meatball that tasted delicious! My pizzas wonderful! Crispy crust, ricotta, garlic and olive oil. The salad was crisp, fresh cold and delicious. We all left happy and full. I also ordered a take away pepperoni and cheese for my husband! The server was superb and attentive! Great stop here. read more

See all

Been going to the pizza place up the block but heard good things about this place. First attempt failed as their website hours are wrong (and no one responds to email listed there). Tried again. Super nice server small eat in area. Friendly. Pizza was very good as was the Cesar salad. Overall good but we'll do takeout next time. Tiny little table felt way too confining. Good alternative to the other place and an A health department score. read more

Authentic NY style pizza, the real deal! Best Sicilian pie I've had in Florida so far, moved from NY in 2019. read more

Love the calzones! The knots were amazing with the fresh garlic and the salad was good.

you want a great experience. go to goodfellas of Sanford. This is my third visit, and they do not let you down. The waiter you name is chance make you visit even more special. The quality of food let say if 5 starts is prefect, let give them 6 stars. it is a family restaurant and they should be very proud. the place is small but I am sure will make a big impression. read more

Great service, amazing pizza and salads! We're happy to have another place in Sanford! read more

See all

Why did it take me so long to order from here? This is the best pizza I have tried in Central Florida. I had Margarita and Meatball pizzas. The crust is perfect, the ingrediants were good and fantastic taste. I also got a side of meatballs that were excellent. A great choice to watch the final four! I will have to try in person and get a pie fresh from the oven! No photos because I was starving and we took this pizza out! read more

Our family has come here many times and we have always had excellent food, excellent service and a perfect evening! The garlic knots, meatballs, chicken Sinatra, pizza and chicken parm are some of our favorites! read more

We had a party of 6 come in on a Friday night. The staff was waiting for their large table to leave (they'd already finished eating and paid) so they could clean their table for us. That family chose to stay and chat for a while so the staff went above and beyond to make sure we were comfortable during our wait, offering drinks and bringing over extra chairs. They ended up combining a couple other tables for us after about 15 minutes. Our waiter was funny and had a great personality. Drinks stayed full and the service was fantastic. For an appetizer, we had the garlic knots, which were delicious. We ordered 2 of the Goodfellas Special pizzas, a Margarita Pizza, Calzone, and lasagna. It was all amazing and everyone left feeling full and happy! We will definitely be back the next time we're in town! read more

This is my favorite restaurant. Food is ALWAYS DELICIOUS. The staff is AMAZING. They give you a nice sunnily. Prices are good. Is a nice environment. Love love this restaurant!!!! read more

Wonderful service, large portion sizes, and cozy atmosphere!!!! Just as good as the Debary location. So glad it's closer!!!!

Their pizza is always great and if you haven't had the chicken parmigiana Stromboli with a glass of red wine you are missing out.

Great staff, amazing food. I'm a Chicago guy & this is probably the best NY pizza I've ever had. Looking forward to trying more of their menu. read more

Amazing food! Quality ingredients. Excellent service. The best cannolis you will ever have. Top notch!!

The wife and I stopped in tonight on the way home for a pizza and some pasta. We walked in the door and were immediately greeted and invited to sit where ever we liked. Our server approached the table in less than 1 Minuit giving us a brief but concise rundown of the menu and took our drink order. They had a large selection of beer and wine to choose from. Drinks arrived in 2 minuets flat. We placed an order for some garlic knots, my wife ordered the baked cheese ravioli. Our server asked if we would like to upgrade to another sauce naming 5 or 6 choices. She picked the Alfredo, love the custom touch. I ordered a godfellas pizza with sausage pepperoni peppers onions and mushrooms. The garlick knots came out and let me say that were spectacular. Large slivers of garlic sitting in a pool of extra virgin olive oil and tons of shredded Romano cheese on top and a large side of sauce. I came out on top 4 to 2 with the knots my wife is a slow eater lol. I could have eaten all 6 and called it a night they were so delicious. Next the pizza oh boy what a masterpiece. All fresh veggies and sliced sausage, not the low quality crumbled style most places use these days and the onions were fresh and still had a little snap. Picked up a slice and it had zero flop!!! Super thin and crispy like pizza should be. My wife's pasta was equally delicious with tons of cheese stringing down to the Dish every bite she took we couldn't get enough. next time you're cruising down hwy46 in Sanford roll into Goodfellas. You will be happy you did. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - a person dipping a pastry into a bowl of sauce - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

This place is AMAZING and I recommend everyone comes and gets a pizza here. I am so glad they are down the street from me.

Great food but an even better family experience! Chance took great care of us and we will definitely be back! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Ordered antipasta salad , small for 14 bucks, took a long time to get it. Wings were hard had to sent back. People not very attentive. Could be an off night, but will be the last one for me. This is on a Thursday evening. read more

I ordered 2 pizzas the other day, one 3 topping pizza and one Hawaiian. The 3 topping pizza was good, one of the toppings was extra cheese, but the Hawaiian pizza was below average. It was difficult to see any ham on it, let alone taste any. With so many good pizza places in this area, I probably wouldn't choose to go back. read more