I love this spot! For me, it's close to work so I can grab their lunch specials or pick up pizza Friday supplies! I've ordered both online and in person with no hiccups. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. The pizza is so good! I really like their Bianca, it's so well seasoned and full of flavor. I've tried most others and never had a bad slice. They make huge side salads so you can get away with getting a small salad for lunch. If you're not that hungry. this location has plenty of booths and tables, but is still cozy. They share lots of family photos on the wall and have the kind of fun old school family theme in everything. The one and only downside of this place is they don't have Coca-Cola on the fountain. read more

The Pesto Pizza is SO good! I'm not a huge pizza person, but I get very excited whenever my company caters them, or when I have the opportunity to order catering for a work event. We have a pretty large vegetarian population, so I appreciate that there's a large variety outside of plain cheese. The pizza quality is consistently delicious and the employees are great. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Pesto Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

See all

The pizza itself is not bad new york style, but the prices are ridiculous. Almost 6 dollars (5.87 to be exact) for a single slice robbery. There are plenty of new york style restaurants in the area that have much better deals for more than one slice at that price. read more

Came here twice for lunch during work. I'm not a fan of pizza for lunch but man is Tomasino's the exception. Slices were massive, fresh, and delicious. Did the lunch special with a Cesar salad, 2 slices, and a drink. If you're are looking for a chill place to get a deal on lunch this is your spot. read more

See all

Cute restaurant we hoped would be 5 . The best item ordered was the Mac & Cheese. The pizzas were thick and not reminiscent of NY as it suggests. Service was good but we won't be back. read more

Friendly staff, great pizza. You get the feeling of being in a New York style pizzeria. A little pricey, but it is well worth it!

The price for the pizza doesn't make sense. A slice at lazy moon is way better macros and way cheaper. Not sure why you would go here instead of papa joes or lazy moon read more

The pizza here is really good and the ambience fits the mode totally. Highly recommend. Also, they have lunch specials on Saturdays, with 2 slices and a choice of salad or soda read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - A slice of Butchers and a slice of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

The last two orders I placed to take out, pizzas were undercooked. For $70, plus tip for two large o pizzas, one of which only had one topping!!) you expect top-notch and zero mistakes. Our last pizza Friday we decided to go to Walmart and buy two of their fresh pizzas for $18 both. And they were excellent.!!!! Sorry, no wonder why restaurants are closing down across the country. read more

Pizza was under cooked and doughy. Last time had a great crispy pizza. Will consider if I go back or not. $23.00 is a lot to spend on a medium pizza with mushrooms that you can't eat. read more

I tried the cheese pizza and found it quite decent. The cheese is plentiful and fragrant, but the crust is a bit thick. The price is reasonable, but the restaurant space is a bit noisy. The staff is enthusiastic. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

I want to be clear, food is good, tastes like home cooking and the vibe is nice. What is making this a one is service, I went with a date, on Valentines, who loves their food and they refused allow her 1 glass of wine. Now I talked to the server about something personal, but it was not affecting her, and she only stumbled due to her wearing heels that she was not used to. When asked, the server made a statement that upset her and me. When arguing the point, we proceeded to the manager and were treated the same. This is not the first time I have had issues with this location as well. Last Valentines we arrived while the store was still open, but they no longer were serving at the location, so I had to order out and drive back home just to make do with the night we had. This place service has changed from 5 years ago and not for the better. read more

I went with my colleagues during our lunch break and Tomasinos was only a 10 minute drive from us. We arrived around 1145, but some parking spaces were blocked due to the traffic line for Starbucks. Even though there was a bit of a crowd, we were seated immediately in a booth. It took some time to get acknowledged, but after 10 minutes a waitress came and asked if we wanted lunch menus. I am glad I said yes as I found it to have better deals. I went with the Italian Sub (about 10 dollars), and asked if I could substitute salad instead of fries. I was told that they can do that. We waited a while for our food to come, and my colleagues food came before mine. About 20 to 30 minutes later, my sub came, but was missing the salad. I told them it was ok, and didn't need it. The sub was fine with a good amount of meats (ham, pepperoni, and salami), as lettuce plus diced tomatoes on top. There was some Italian dressing on the side, which helped provide flavor. I found the bread too be a bit too hard and lacking flavor, so I ate mostly the meats and veggies. I guess the veggies were my salad that was lacking. Even though it was a bit busy for lunch, I found the service to be too slow for me. It took time to get acknowledged, get our food, and pay the bill. They mentioned that they would take the salad off the bill, but I didn't see any difference in my price. When I questioned it, that mentioned that there was no salad in my bill. I guess to substitute salad from fries was an extra cost, which they didn't mention. So I paid the lunch special price, even though I neither had fries or salad as a side. The atmosphere was casual and small. Only a few tables/booths were available. The counter area wasn't too far away. It was pretty talkative with the noise, but I think there was basic American music in the background. Overall, I think that this restaurant would have been better as a counter service than a table service. I thought it would be a quick lunch, but the service made us go back to our office an hour and half later. If they took the order at the counter, it would have been much faster. I found some pizzas at the counter as well, so I thought the food would be ready more quickly. The food was still alright, but to be a good lunch restaurant, the service needs to be a bit faster. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Italian sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Tomasino's Pizza has four locations throughout Orlando, Florida and the surrounding area. This particular location is in Lake Mary, Florida. The staff here is friendly and professional and the overall ambiance is pleasant enough. The pizza here is pretty good. Not the best that I have ever had, but definitely pretty good. I grew up.in New and I always pretty much took it for granted that great pizza was available pretty much on every corner. When I moved to Florida back in 2001, I was shocked and more than a bit dismayed to find that great pizza (or even good pizza for that matter) was not available on every corner. In fact, great pizza (or even good pizza for that matter) was not available in every town or city. Great pizza was something that had to be sought out and when found, it was truly a reason for celebration (and what better way to celebrate finding great pizza than with a slice of pizza in hand?). As I said, this is not the best pizza that I have ever had, but it is pretty good. I would definitely recommend here. read more

It's hard to find any decent delivery pizza in our area. They are all the same and pretty mediocre. Soggy crust and meager toppings. Not just this place, but every place we have tried in the Lake Mary area. The frozen pizza from Publix is better than any Italian place locally. read more

Buy by the slice or order a whole pie. Pasta, subs and desserts too! Customer service is 100%. Everyone is family here. Dine in, carryout, curbside and delivery available. Inside and outside dining available. This establishment is located in a plaza with a shared parking lot. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Lunch special - 2 slices of your choice plus a side salad OR soda. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Went here to try the pizza and we thought it was horrible. Apparently they had a new guy making the pizza and we asked for extra sauce and the pizza was swimming in sauce. It wasn't cut properly so we had big pieces and little pieces. Very bland pizza and definitely not New York style crust. The only reason I can give them two stars is because I got the arugula salad, which was good, although not as advertised. The picture shows sliced chicken and it was actually tiny little nuggets and probably pressed meat. One and done. read more

We always enjoy Tomasinos! The pizza is New York style and being from NY we enjoy it! The penne Alfredo and chicken Tomasino is also really good! The staff here is also great they really hustle! read more

I've tried both the Winter Springs location and the one in Heathrow/Lake Mary and both are top notch pizza restaurants. Both locations can get very busy and the Winter Springs location has misplaced my order occasionally but has sprays corrected their mistakes. In particular I find their "joe the distributor" pizza to be one of my all time favorites and their meat lovers pizza is stacked with your favorites. These are not skimpy pizzas, with skimpy toppings, you get your moneys worth and it's delicious. read more

I would give this place zero stars if I could. First time I visit this establishment and I will never return. As soon as I walked in to this place with my service animal I was not greeted with a "welcome" I was greeted with "we do not allow pets". I said to him "this was my service animal" and he said "we do not allow service animals you would have to eat outside". So I said "no worries I will take my business elsewhere". The young man turned around, walked away, and ignored me. Here is the problem I want to bring to light to the owner of this establishment so he/she can better train their employees. Sometimes a disability is not immediately seen by those that are ignorant to what is unseen. My sugar levels at that time were extremely low. I could not sit outside because it was cold, and I suffer from asthma and allergies. I had to leave even though my rights were violated by this young man's ignorance and disrespectful attitude. Then I had to walk another two blocks to get some food in my stomach before almost passing out by the time I got to the other restaurant. Luckily, the other restaurant understood my rights to have a service animal and I was able to eat and feel better. I am just one customer but I hope that by posting this review the owner of this establishment better trains their employees not only to exhibit good customer service but to also educate them on the rights of a person's disabilities. I also hope that they lose potential customers who read this. Now I know why this place had no customers inside while the other establishment that I had to walk to was full. Tomasino's Pizza does not know how to treat customers - while the other restaurant was full of customers because they obviously know what good customer service is all about. read more

Just got back from ordering a mushroom pizza from Tomasinos pizza and I was extremely disappointed. Spending $23.00 on a pizza and getting uncooked doughy bread with almost all cheese and we looked for the sauce, but it was hard to find. We go there when we are in the mood for a pizza even though it is quite pricy And it's usually good. But not this time . You gain your customers one at a time and lose them the same way, one at a time. read more

Tomasino's is my favorite pizza place in the area. At work, we order from this store almost weekly for events, parties, and employee lunches. We haven't received a bad pie or any other food item yet. The staff is friendly and welcoming and when they know it's us calling, they always give us the hook up on toppings and garlic knots. Be sure to ask for extra sauce, this stuff is good enough to drink out of the cups they serve it in! My two favorite pies are "the Butcher's Pie," and "Joncarlo's VIP." The Butcher's pie is a meat lover's dream come true. Melted mozzarella topped with a plethora of pepperoni, sausage, sliced meatballs, bacon, and ham served on a perfectly baked hand-tossed crust. The VIP is one of the best stuffed pizzas I have ever had and is literally a pizza pie. I can only imagine the skill the chef must have to toss this pie, stuff it, and bake it perfectly so that all of the ingredients are cooked to perfection all while keeping the crust crispy on all sides, simply amazing! The 18" VIP is a bit pricey at $34.99, but it is worth every penny! It's like two pizzas in one and stuffed with lots of cheese, premium ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, sausage, and sliced meatballs. I'm not sure if this is something to be proud about, but I have eaten two slices of the VIP in one sitting along with wings, salad and garlic knot's while most who encounter the VIP are lucky if they can finish one slice; it is a lot of food! Believe it or not, the VIP gets better with age! A day or two later, the VIP tastes as good as the day we ordered it. We love to re-bake leftover slices, cut them up into cubed 'hors d'oeuvres, and dip them in heated marinara sauce, so good! I could go on and on about the pies; however, Tomasino's has quite a selection of other food items to choose from. We regularly order wings that are of good quality and can be served in a variety of heat levels and flavors such as BBQ, Sriracha Chili, Mango Habanero, & garlic parmesan. A 10-piece wing is $10.99 and a 20-piece is $19.99. We also love the Garlicky Cheese Knots & Marinara ($3.99), you really cannot go wrong with garlic butter brushed baked knots, sprinkled with Romano and mozzarella cheese served with homemade marinara sauce. The hot fresh bread, melty cheese mixture, and dipping sauce are too tempting to avoid. I look forward to trying some of their other menu items especially the baked specialties and subs. Baked specialties such as the Chicken Tomasino, Eggplant Parmigiana, and Baked Ziti come with a choice of spaghetti or penne and garlic knots; for $1.99 more, you can add a side salad. This is a great Togo lunch option that two people can share and is affordable when splitting the $10.99-$14.99 price tag. Tomasino's 10" old-fashioned N.Y. style subs are reasonably priced from $7.99-$9.99. Although I haven't had one yet, the menu suggests that Tomasino's is using high-quality bread, meats, and cheeses among the 6-options noted. I would say pricing is comparative to a sub you would order at Publix, or Sobik's subs nearby. If you have not been to Tomasino's yet, what are you waiting for? This restaurant produces some amazing food and the staff is phenomenal. I highly recommend you give them a try read more

See all

mushy bland eggplant parm sandwich on mushy bread. Penne Alfredo tasted like something you can just get in a frozen food section at grocery store... the wings were good .. Ceasar salad was good read more

Amazing food and service..... this place is a gem , everyone is so nice and always so welcoming. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Hawaiian pizza, and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

We really enjoy this place. Every single time we go the food is on point. Portions are generous, prices are great. The service is always great. Last night we got 4 slices. 2 salads, and an order of knots. Everything was delicious. My husbands favorite is the butcher and I like the white pizza or the gardener. The salad (I don't remember the name but the bottom one on the menu) is amazing - lots of meats and cheeses - great flavor and huge! I would definitely recommend Tomasinos + love supporting the smaller places like this! read more

My husband and I just cannot say enough about the wonderful food at Tomasino's. Absolutely fabulous food, great service and a great variety of food to choose from! When you go to Tomasino's in person and walk through the door, the aroma of their Italian food makes your tastebuds want to do a happy dance; even after receiving your food to go (if that's what you choose), you still want to linger and savor the aroma at Tomasino's. Although a very small place, you can eat in or carry out. They also have delivery service. Give your tastebuds a real treat and give Tomasino's a try, you will be very happy you did! read more

We've been pretty loyal to another pizza place but decided to try this place for delivery last night at 8 through GrubHub. I ordered a penne Alfredo with a side of meatballs and a calzone and was notified it would take 2 hours for delivery which I had no problem with. Food was delivered on time. However, instead of a calzone there were 3 different slices of pizza stacked on top of each other in one of the boxes which looked liked somebody's leftover slices. I texted the delivery person who was very apologetic and said they weren't allowed to open and check food they were to deliver. I then called the restaurant. The lady I spoke to asked if she can give me restaurant credit for my calzone. I said no as I don't know if and when I'll order from them again and I'd rather have the $$ back to my credit card. She said that wasn't a problem and that it will show 2 charges on my card but original amount will not go through. As of this time, (about 12 hours later) only the original charge is showing on my card activity. As for the penne Alfredo with meatballs, pasta was cooked perfectly and meatballs tasted good but the Alfredo sauce itself was very soupy. It's very disappointing. I was hoping this would be a good alternative. I think I'll go back to my regular pizza joint. Went to the restaurant a few minutes ago to follow up on my credit and show them the pizza that was delivered. I spoke to Rachel and Angie and was assured that they cancelled the transaction last night. I guess I will give it a couple of days and hopefully the credit card charge will be straightened out. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Pizza stack? - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Pros: NY Style pizza (perfection) Garlic Knot Bruschetta Friend Mozzarella Friendly Service Clean Restaurant Booth Seating Cons: Pepsi products read more

They served meatball Parmesan and chicken Parmesan sub with ketchup on the side and hardly any sauce Eggplant red colored bread not enough sauce I loved their gluten free pizza but today it was awful we loved this place except today Serve was poor no serving utensils for a large sharing salad Disappointed for our Friday Pizza get Together Today will be our last time usually a lot of take out saw only one tonight read more

Not a good experience. Ordered a half pepperoni / half cheese on Christmas Eve for pick up at 3:30 in the afternoon. Arrived and went in only to find out (after paying) that my order had not even been started. I just can't believe that a establishment with only four customers in the place would have dropped the ball like this on Christmas Eve. Another 20 minutes passes and I go in to pick up my pizza. Staff is friendly and I really like the atmosphere of this particular location. I arrived home and opened the box to find that once again, Tomasino's has gotten over on me when it comes to pepperoni. I paid $24 for this large pie and it could not have had more than 15 pieces of pepperoni on it. I am more than slightly disappointed as I've had the same experience at the Winter Springs location,...get me once shame on you... Give me twice shame on me. read more

Great pizza and customer service. Their "mechanic" pizza is the bomb, but sometimes they put too much black olives, so if you're not a fan, take 'em off. They also have a dairy free pizza and the cheese is actually really good. When ordering online, make sure you're ordering directly from them and not GrubHub, as they mark everything up crazy amounts to do nothing. read more

As soon as you walk in you're greeted. We ordered one large pepperoni pizza. The pizza was loaded with pepperoni. The flavor in the sauce was great . This establishment is definitely well kept. We will definitely be back . read more

Good grief. Possibly the best pizza we have ever had. Chicago. New York. Anywhere. In Lake Mary, FL of all places! We had garlic knots and they were really good. Then pepperoni pizza and it was top notch. But then...(drum roll)...the Momma's Mozz-a-rella! Unbelievably delicious! Highly recommend! I wish I'd taken a picture. But all I could do was eat. read more

Always amazing Pizza, service and ambiance! Just picking up, they treat you like Gold. Oh, and yea, I'm from NYC, I KNOW MY PIZZA, this place ROCKS! read more

On our way to Ponce Inlet decided to grab something and try a new place. The inside reminded me a lot of Gramaldi's . Fancy Diner style: red booths with Chandeliers. They don't have slices and we didn't want a whole pizza so my hubby got the wings with a side of Fries and I got the cheesesteak. Everything looked amazing but the taste fell a bit short. My hubby said the wings needed salt and I felt the same about my Cheesesteak. If it didn't have the peppers and onions it had no flavor. Seemed like the actual steak wasn't seasoned. Anyways, it wasn't bad by any means. The table next to us had a very delicious looking pizza. Maybe next time we'll try it and I can update my review. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Two things first the appetizer the not your average bruschetta was amazing. Second the dessert the tiramisu alone was worth the two hour drive it was the best tiramisu I've ever had read more

Best pizza in town ambience is very Italian should play Italian music instead of rock and roll read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Lake Mary - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

See all

Been going to tomasinos in winter springs for years and love it. Stayed in heathrow and figured we would try this location. Tuesday night we were the only table. Ordered and food came very quickly. The food was not like the other location and we could not stay to eat due to all the fruit flies. We would not return to the location. read more

Pizza was great. Enjoyed Ashlynn she made things so fun and took great care of us. Will be back!

Went for the first time yesterday and had an excellent dinner!! Best pizza crust I've had in ages too. We ordered appetizers, a cheese pizza as well as a margarita pizza. Excellent service and value. We will be back!! read more