Located right beside the Newcastle Commons Apartment complex. Parking can be a challenge but you can drive a little further in, make the first left and park inside the garage at the main apartment leasing building. The retail spaces there are rarely full. It's a 3 minutes walk to MOD but it's a nice scenic walk. The restaurant is airy, with tall ceilings with comfortable seating. I suggest eating the pizza inside if you can for the best pizza taste and experience. Custom Order Pizza (4/5) I ordered the regular 11" classic thin pizza: Spicy Tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, salami, chicken, spicy sausage, onions, tomatoes, minced garlic, arugula, jalapeños, bell peppers, and some olives. The ingredients seem fresh and the flavor is pretty good. The dough is thin and just a tad crunchy at the crust and kinda reminds me of flatbread. I love how spicy it is with the spicy tomato and jalapeños. My only nitpick is that this is not cheesy enough, next time I'll ask them to add more cheese. Everyone here is super nice and courteous and I had an enjoyable experience eating here. read more

See all

We just moved near recently and we will definitely be back. The staff is so welcoming and kind. Great vibes all around. The inside was clean with plenty of seating and an outdoor area as well. I've always enjoyed MOD pizza and this location was great! Pizza was crisp & delicious. read more

MOD Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

It's been well over 10 years since I've been here and things have changed needless to say. I ordered the regular mod pizza and realized that the crust was thinner than I anticipated. I like that you can have unlimited toppings. On the website, it limits you to 8 or something. I did half/half. Folks are nice and I appreciate that they were patient with me while I pointed out what I wanted . Luckily, no one was waiting. I liked that there's an option of a light bake. I hate my pizza burnt. All in all, okay. Maybe I chose the wrong crust. It's nice that's personal sized read more

MOD Pizza - Half, half pizza 5/25 - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

Normally I like MOD pizzas. It's easy to order and a hassle-free pick up. I was expecting this place to be crowded, so ordered my pizza in advance before even starting my drive. One hell of an effort to find a parking near this place.. phew! I will blame it on the nearby Starbucks drive-thru, but still it's an inconvenience for other customers. Ambiance of this place is cool like any other MOD locations. My order wasn't ready when I showed up - that was close to 25 mins after I placed my order. I patiently waited and reminded the gentleman that I am waiting for my pizzas. They were serving the customers who are placing the order at the counter - but my pizzas were no show! I was kind of pissed after waiting for almost 10 minutes. By the time I walked to the counter to ask again, my pizzas magically showed up right there. Nothing more to complain, I walked out. Loved the pizzas; but not a pleasant experience to be honest! read more

MOD Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

Appalling discrimination and illegal behavior!I was kicked out of this location by two extremely arrogant and condescending staff members because of my service dog. I was there with my friend and two children. Before the situation escalated, I asked the employee if she knew the laws regarding service animals. She said "yes" but proceeded to deliberately violate them.She weaponized the threat of calling the police against me to intimidate me, and then openly stated: "I am confident that this is not a service dog."Under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Washington State law (RCW 9.91.170), businesses are strictly prohibited from making personal judgments or denying access based on their own skepticism. Her actions were a direct, admitted violation of my civil rights.The public humiliation in front of my children was deeply upsetting. I have already filed a formal complaint with MOD Pizza Corporate and am moving forward with official reports to the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Washington State Human Rights Commission.Train your staff before they get your business hit with a massive federal lawsuit! Avoid this place if you have a disability or a service animal. read more

EVERYONE HERE IS SOOOO NICE, all the time. i'm not joking, every time we go here they're insanely, exceptionally kind and friendly. also Mods is awesome for how they employ folks to give them a second chance too. even when it's being busy they're friendly and helpful to every need. we go to this location all the time read more

See all

Services is always nice and friendly. However, I can't really recommend the pizza at this location. My orders recently look more like flat bread, tasty flatbread. read more

See all

This was absolute chaos. They waited till they were 45 minutes behind to turn off mobile orders. Had people yelling at the staff FOR ME because my order took an hour and a half. Placed my order at 6:30 got it at 8. Still had to help them fix my order, and almost gave me half of someone else's order. People who game in 20 minutes after me got their orders of 5, sat, ate and left. By the way. We stopped eating here 8 months ago because it's service and quality. This takes the cake. And they forgot my no name cake. I recommend going to Dominos instead or just investing in Resonate or Jet City. Both having faster times and consistent quality. Also for those eating in there was no clean tables, trash thrown by the bins, and a cluster of people by the handoff from wait times. Happy Eating... Somewhere else. read more

Last time I ordered here they got my order wrong and there were way less toppings on it than usual. I ordered on the app for it to be fast and ready when I arrived but I had to wait an additional 10-15 minutes at least, for them to even realize I was there picking up my order because they were busy with other customers and also taking their time with them, and maybe lack of workers, idk the issue. Either way just disappointed my order came out soggy (like it hadnt been fired up crispy enough) and toppings were missing and lightly added. I get almost the same order every time and this was probably the worst location I've received it from, unfortunately. read more

COVID TIMES: masks required. We do visit MOD quite often. So they've set the bar high. At this location probably I'd give them a 3.5 stars sometimes and other times 4 stars, which makes me think that there's a little bit of inconsistency in how this place is run. Food quality is always nice and fresh. They do not disappoint, even when I've asked for "lots of cheese on my pizza" . The Garden salad is my favorite one. While I was waiting for my order, I saw a couple of curve-side-pick up customers that seem to be confused how or where to pick up their orders. Maybe a sign would help them. They used to have Just a chocolate cake (aka no name cake) and now they introduced a new flavor: cherry cake. It's too sweet for me BUT I think it's a genuine effort to keep items to their menu. Finally, men's restroom was broken and oh man!!!! The smell was AWFUL. My kid needed to use the restroom and we barely made it because the odor (even using the ladies restroom) From other visits I gotta say the cleanliness in their restrooms is not their strong suit. read more

See all

Fantastic experience, came in 30 minutes before close and both John and Victor were some of the friendliest people I've ever met. Both the pizzas we ordered tasted amazing and will definitely be coming back! Vibes were good and it was all smiles from both customers and crew members. read more

I work at Hazelwood Elementary School, and we had the best experience with this location. We were told by a different location, that they would not be able to accommodate our large order. We then contacted Newcastle, and the manager Jennifer, stated that they would gladly help us out, and have it ready for us first thing. We put in our orders on Friday, so that they could prepare for our order of 120+ pizzas. It is Tuesday, and we arrived at around 10:30am to start packing up our order, that was set for pickup at 11am. Jennifer had brought in several employees, including some from other stores to help out. They were like a fine oiled machine, who pumped our pizzas out quickly, accurately, and with a smile on their faces. Every single employee that was there was incredibly kind and humorous. Us here at Hazelwood Elementary School, staff, students and families alike appreciate the willingness and hard work that Newcastle Mod put into pleasing our students. Thank you so much, from the very bottom of our hearts. Hazelwood Elementary School Get Outlook for iOS read more

See all

holy f*ck, there is this one tall asshole who doesn't follow the instructions on the Internet order at all. and upon being asked for it to be redone. I watched him just slap it together and forget reading the actual instructions. nothing of what was requested in the original order. and he acted like an absolute dick. read more

I particularly enjoy Mod because of the unlimited topping options you can add. However, I feel like every time I order, the workers get annoyed because of how many toppings. It's kind of irritating when I am paying for the service and food... if its such a problem, let me just make my own. Other than horrendous service, pizza is delicious. read more

It is ready in 10 minutes. So fast n affordable price. It is not greasy with thin crust so I like it. Staffs are kind. Parking lot is spacious. There is not many traffics yet. read more

MOD Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Through the tree-line boulevards of Newcastle lies this cool pizza outpost up in the hills. Standard, pretty clean & spacious. Staff is friendly, chill... I always appreciate when folks compliment my pies: "Oh, that smells good." But Daren, how do you make it smell good? Skip the meat & dairy, pile on any creative fancy or simple combination of vegetables and the key is to add copious amounts of herbs & spices (black pepper, oregano and rosemary). If you haven't really dived into spices & herbs, give it 'em a whirl! read more

First time trying MOD pizza today with my daughter. While the lady behind the counter began making our pizza, another worker walked over and asked me if I would mind having the order for the person before us redone because she accidentally ruined it. I said it was not a problem at all. It must have been my lucky day because she thanked us with two free beverages and did not charge me for my order! Good pizza and nice people - we will definitely be coming back! read more

The best place ever, Very friendly staff, I love to eat mod pizza in Newcastle, so fresh!! Thanks read more

MOD Pizza - Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

This location is filthy. Their ingredients also seem to have been sitting out forever. You should go to the nearby Factoria location instead. read more

This restaurant allows you to order online and then pick up your food. They have a failure rate of about 30% though and we oftentimes find they did not receive our order at all. This can be frustrating. Most recently we decided to try their gluten free crust and dairy free cheese. I would not recommend either of those things. The dairy free cheese gave me diarrhea for two days and the gluten free crust was hard enough to break a few teeth. To be fair, this is characteristic of most gluten free crusts I've tried at other places. But the dairy free cheese was truly bad. Not sure what brand they use, but it had no taste really and definitely has the consistency of wax. We will not order the above again. Smoking Monkey has quality ingredients and will go there in the future. Heck, I would even say that Papa John's Pizza tastes better. read more

John, Tiger, and Eziz did an excellent job today at the Newcastle Mod pizza location. Will definitely recommend this place to people around me, very clean, fast and professional team. Tiger was out pizza maker, very generous on the topping and did a fantastic job. Ordered 3 pizzas, came out excellent. read more

MOD Pizza - 3 pizzas from Newcastle location - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

MOD Pizza offers something I have been missing for years - a chance to eat pizza with my best friend. As many of my reviews note I am allergic to egg whites, but my best friend is allergic to milk. While I can happily munch on pizza he can't without any cheese and well pizza without cheese is acceptable only a handful of times before it just feels boring. MOD offers a dairy free cheese option that my friend loves. It is the first vegan style cheese that doesn't have a weird flavor or consistency. My friend loves it. He loves the super thin crust too. I enjoy more doughy pizza crust and once again MOD comes through by giving us both what we want. The wide variety of toppings and sauces provides endless combinations. The pizzas are assembled in a line with wicked efficiency. When I was there everyone was super nice and polite. There were laughs. I was impressed considering shortly after we arrived a huge group of teenagers - about ten strong - came in right after us and then a family of four. The line went to the door. On top of that they had Door Dash and Uber Eats meals that needed to be addressed as well. But the crew just kept the rhythm and kept going. I thought it was excellent choice for people with as diverse tastes and preferences as my friend and I. It was nice to be able to eat pizza with him even if we were eating different pizzas. read more

Order pizza here whenever I want something fast. Gets done easily via online order and team bakes a great pizza. Can't complain

There is a young lady named Emily that works at the Newcastle location that just goes above and beyond for the customers that come in. As usual my pizza was delicious I will definitely be back. read more

Lovely pizza, disrespectful rude service. Some of the teens working there need a couple lessons in customer service. Not OK to leave the customer's pizza sitting in the open air getting cool, ignoring a polite customer request to cut and close the box; while you turn your back and re-organize 20 other pies in the oven. (One or two to keep them from burning, fine. Yes, spent 3 years making pizza and know what I'm talking about.) read more

MOD Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

We love MOD Pizza and were excited to se this location close to our house open. The pizza was good, as always; fresh and tasty. I love their berry lemonade! Unfortunately they got my order wrong and I didn't realize it until I got my pizza. I'd ordered the extra thick pizza dough, and the paper under my pizza said it was supposed to be that, but it wasn't - thankfully I wasn't charged for the thick dough. I find the thin crust pizza a little less filling, so I wish they'd given me what I asked for. The other issue is that the restaurant was SO VERY COLD! For some odd reason, even though it was only 61F outside, they decided to turn on the air conditioning. It was very uncomfortable and made our pizzas cool down even quicker than normal. Restaurants should only turn on the AC when really needed. We will be back again to this location to try it again. I hope they turn off the AC unless it's actually hot outside! Feb 2020: We came here on a cold, rainy night. The pizza was excellent, but the cold air blowing on the table we were at was so freezing it made the meal unpleasant. We left with half our food uneaten and went home to eat it. I don't know what is wrong with management at this store and why they refuse to stop the freezing cold air. read more

MOD Pizza - Dillon James pizza with pesto sauce added. - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

See all

So this is not the Mod pizza place I ate at but I'm going to guess they are all the same or very close. This was my first time here and I have to say I loved it. Pizza is thin crust like I like. They have a ton of toppings and unlike Subway with the same idea yet it a pizza, Mod was NOT shy about topping and I only had about 4 out of maybe 25 topping my pizza was almost too big for me to eat but I did it anyway. Salads are about the same you buy it and add as much stuff as you like. Great job read more

See all

MOD is my favorite in general, but I especially love this location. They really took the time on our pizzas, and even though we came in like 10 minutes before closing like jerks, they had good attitudes and made the pies with such care. Delicious and cooked perfectly, too. The store manager is absolutely the chillest. I loved talking with her the other night, so personable and funny. This is a great MOD and since it's so close I'll be back often :) read more

Much like every mod pizza lately, they don't have enough staff. Their employees were friendly-just bad management.

Bathrooms are disgusting. They are never clean, pee everywhere. The trash areas are regularly overflowing with boxes and no one seems to come empty them. read more

This is the best Mod Pizza I've ever been to by far!!! I went in there last Dec on a Sunday night, just before they closed. I called first to see if they would still serve me and they welcomed me in. Everyone who worked there was kind and smiling and no one was upset I was there last minute. I'm gluten-free and so grateful they have crusts I can eat, but they are tough to cook just right. These guys had it down PERFECT. They made me a fantastic pizza, the best I've had at any mod pizza. It was done superfast and REALLY good!!! read more

Absolutely amazing! The food is to die for make your own pizza . Very quick nove efficient service . Nothing to write about ambiance it's like fast food but better totally loved my experience here! read more

Customer service James was very unprofessional in his job at MOD Pizza. He didn't want to assist anyone other than the people that ordered online or from the App. It was around 2:15 pm on a Monday. He stated that he was really busy and couldn't assist anyone until he was finished with his orders. He didn't even greet me and the other customers next to me. I think that's the reason why this place has a bad reputation, employees like James don't care about their job. I decided to go next door to Starbucks. At least they greet you and make you feel great about being a loyal customer. I don't know if I would ever come back to MOD Pizza again with this place having employees like James. read more

Best customer service award for Eli( seems like the manager of the store) super awesome! Best Mod location we have ever been:) read more

MOD Pizza - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Every time I go there is a new adventure!! They taking care of me, offer new suggestions, the pizza is fabulous!! I love the workers, Every one are really friendly!! Newcastle branch is my best, thanks read more

The pizzas are inexpensive and delicious! What more could you want from fast food? Maybe engaging staff? Yep, they've got that, too. Large, clean space? Check. Plenty of parking? Sadly, no. The parking is the only bummer about this place, as there are just not enough spots to accommodate the 3 busy businesses in this area. But if you don't mind parking across the street in the BECU lot and taking a quick stroll, this is a fantastic place for fast, yummy, cheap eats! Pro tip: Try one of the foil wrapped desserts at checkout! They're delicious! read more

Terrible all around. First, the order took half an hour more than stated to be ready. They were very busy, I will give them that, but we ordered 5 pies and they didn't make them the at the same time - so half of our pizzas were cold by the time our entire order was ready. Additionally, their service was awful. I stood there for half an hour and not once did they acknowledge my existence, even when I asked for an estimated time. On top of that, they forgot to add multiple things on our pizzas, and half of them were either burned or undercooked. Will not be going back here again. read more

It's nearly instantaneous service...reliable quality. Any toppings you want for the same price, or choose from their own recipes. Daughter approves of their shakes too. Just opened! Welcome to the neighborhood! read more

MOD Pizza - Vanilla Shake, made by friendly, smiling servers! Extra thick! - Fast Food Near Me - Newcastle, Washington

Was looking forward to testing out their online app feature to save time and to save me from my own indecisiveness. App worked fine however my order was not made correctly- ordered their flash deal pizza and salad both called the same name, salad made correctly but pizza was missing key ingredient of pineapple. Also as other reviewers have pointed out, parking difficult surprisingly for Newcastle surburbia location since shared by Starbucks and a sushi restaurant in a small strip mall. FYI can park across in the BECU lot and just walk over. read more

Disappointed to write this to say the least; I'll try to keep this brief, but to be honest, so much went wrong lol. We're about 2 weeks into this COVID-19 crisis and in an attempt to do our part in supporting small businesses, I've been placing an abnormal amount of take-out orders to try and keep these businesses afloat, and knowing how every transaction makes a difference in these times, it's exponentially disappointing to see how poor of an experience we had with our order. My $50 for dinner for myself and my roommates could have gone to another business that's working so hard to stay afloat, but instead I paid for service that would be considered subpar, regardless of the situation. -Order wasn't ready until +20 mins. after promised time -Ordered 3 pizzas + 1 salad, with only ONE of those orders being made correctly -1 pizza had a sharp metal object left in the middle of it, discovered by my roommate biting into it (thankfully didn't cut him) -Manager and staff were rude in dealing with another customer coming in with a legitimate question about their pick up order, gossiping about the older man IN FRONT of myself and another person waiting for their food I write this as a fan of MOD Pizza and in hopes that things will make a turn for the better ASAP! Plan on revisiting in a couple months to give location a second chance + update review read more