There must be a lot of care poured into a Black & Tan here 'cause I could taste the love in two pints all night long. It's no joke; just a spectacle of sheer beer beauty. All five of us got 10 oz. of some of the best burgers the city has to offer, which cost ten or eleven bucks. I got the American cheeseburger cooked medium, but they forgot to bring out my request for a side of barbecue sauce (a buck extra). Our server was an old Irish lady with glasses who was very polite, attentive, and eager to make sure we had a great night. My friend ordered a mozzarella cheeseburger with bacon, but our server couldn't tell if there was bacon in his so she asked him to check. She corrected this when another server came by and handed her an open-faced burger which clearly had bacon in it. She apologized, left for a few minutes, then came back with a dish of eight glorious slices of bacon to make up for it. Bacon makes everything better. The first few bites of mine were delicious, but unfortunately, I inhaled the rest so I couldn't account for the last bites. It's a serious burger that says, "Hey, I'm a quality cheeseburger. I was made just for you and I like to take this time to let you know that many burger joints can't compare." I promptly agreed. After my burger told me that (secretly of course) I thought to myself that I can't wait to come back and try their traditional Irish fare - most especially their Shepherd's Pie. When the check came, I couldn't read the handwriting to see if the extra bacon was really free or if my order for a side of barbecue sauce was recorded. By that time, I could've cared less as I was soaking in all the deliciousness of my food and the full bodied character of my beer. I was becoming one with the sawdust on the floor. read more

My quest for the holy grail (aka the best burger in nyc) is complete! I've been to the burger joint, numerous forgettable establishments around the city(see my review on dj reynolds), and many places big and small. Somehow tucked away in this bar/pub/whatever Irish people call their watering hole, is one of the best burgers in the city. Went there with a group of three friends who all ordered typical bar food, deep fried with a side of fries. My cousin had made an off hand comment about the burger's being good and luckily for me that was just what I was in the mood for. I ordered the buffalo burger medium rare. A lot of times when places list the weight of their burger its before they cook it, so a 10oz burger can become an 8.5oz burger depending on whether or not the customer enjoys eating hockey pucks. Never the less, it was not a problem here. The burgers are big, juicy, and very well cooked. I'm not going to lie, I'm always nervous about ordering a burger in a bar because more times then not, its cooked one way-BURNT, regardless of how you ordered it. Again not an issue here. Also the steak fries they serve it with are nice and big as well. Left this establishment extremely happy and filled. Can't wait to bring more friends back here and let them taste the glory that is the best burger in NYC. read more

Molly, love, you're a bit of a liar. You appeared to have so much potential and then you just left me cold. There, I said it. Based on all of the good Yelp reviews, and in search of an Irish pub in the area, my husband and I stopped in to grab some lunch and a beverage before sight-seeing. At first glance, Molly's seemed perfect. It's not 100% like being in a proper Irish pub, but it's dimly lit, full of regulars, and close enough to authentic, so I was initially charmed (even while I was perplexed and slightly grossed out by the sawdust on the floor). We put in our orders with the Irish bartender, both opting for one of the specials of the day, the Reuben. Food and drinks came out quickly enough, and they even brought over some spicy mustard for us without being asked for any additional condiments. So far, so good. But then I tasted the Reuben. Ugh. Thank god it wasn't my first Reuben or I never would've eaten another. I guess my first clue should've been the lack of rye bread. Whatever the issue was, the sandwich was NOT GOOD. So not good that I considered just leaving it and eating the fries, but as we had a long day ahead of us, I just peeled off the bread and did my best with the rest...which was fatty, tough meat and horribly bland toppings. So bland that I slathered it all with the spicy mustard...maybe that's why they brought it without me asking for it? The fries? Also bland. No taste to them at all - even salt and condiments couldn't help those poor buggers. My husband didn't hate his food, but certainly didn't love it either. Maybe we should've gotten the burgers? The staff were nice, and service was perfectly decent, so I feel bad about hating on the food, but I just can't recommend it unless you're starving and desperate. All in all, I would absolutely go back to Molly's for drinks, but I would absolutely not get food here again. read more

We were only in NYC for 8 days, but i drank a lot of Guinness, and this was the best I've had. Just the perfect temperature. Great selection of other beers on tap, if Guinness isn't your cup of stout. We've been here both times we visited NYC, and I think I actually got the same meal both times, the Irish pub standard "bangers and mash." They are incredible. Sausage, potatoes, gravy...all of it. The wife got fish and chips which were really good as well. I love the atmosphere, small, dark, wood all around. Flatscreens up in a few places with baseball on if you're interested, although they're easily ignored. A great low key, laid back kind of place that always seems busy but manages to have a seat for you. read more

Stopped in on Sunday and had a great Shepherds Pie, old school authentic Irish pub atmosphere, also had an excellent fried mozzarella appetizer, bartender and staff very friendly, nice experience. read more

Good food for decent prices! Drinks are little expensive but would definitely come again!

I've walked by Molly's for ages and given the fate of many of this neighborhood's long-time gems I decided to give Molly's a go. This pub is rich with history and is adorned with antiques that tell a story spanning 100+ years. This is exactly the kind of ambiance that takes me back to when I lived in the UK and reminds me of how much I love rustic pubs. I ordered a deluxe burger with cheddar, bacon and mushrooms. I got it with half fries and half onion rings, too. The burger was meaty and the fries were clearly hand cut. The only thing was that the burger was a little over cooked (I asked for medium but it came closer to medium-well/well done). It was still good, but next time I will emphasize medium. Service was incredibly pleasant. I waited a short while before the waitress came to my table, but she made sure to apologize for the wait and had a lovely disposition and came around a few times to ask me how I was doing. The gentleman who I'm assuming is the owner also came around the greet patrons. This is exactly the kind of customer service that makes me want to become a regular. I'll be back to try the fish & chips. read more

Opening the door to this place is like going back in time 20 years to when things were slower and simpler. There's only one small TV, and it feels like cell phones haven't been invented yet. Small wooden booths, and an old fashioned bar make the people you're with more important than surroundings. The burgers are amazing, and the prices won't break the bank. If this place delivered I'd order from them constantly. The only reason I don't go more often is that I know anytime I go in there I end up staying for hours. read more

I've been here a few times the past few years and the quality of the burgers is as consistent as Britney Spears lip-syncing to a computer vocal track. We are talking 10 ounces of the juiciest, well flavored burger patties in NYC, and yes I have tried Shake Shack, Minetta Tavern, Burger Joint, Royale, Island Burger, and on and on. The atmosphere is authentic Ireland and the floor is straight sawdust, legend has it that the floor hasn't been swept for over 20 years. There may be several small species of undiscovered creatures living down there, but the "A" rating on the door is reassuring. We each had a burger on a Sunday at around 2PM and didn't eat the rest of the day, it is that filling. The meat sweats were so powerful, during our short walk home we had to gravitate towards areas in the street with shade to avoid drowning in our own juices. In terms of the menu, there is no excuse to order anything aside from the burger as your entree. Thank me later for the tip. read more

Come for the burgers, they tell me. Come for the sawdust on the floor. Come for the bartenders and waitresses with authentic Irish accents! And, sure, those are plenty of good reasons to attend this traditional Irish pub with the "authentic" low lighting.* The burger (with cheese, natch) will be sufficiently tasty, even if the chicken fingers were lacking in any sort of flavor. ** But the most important reason to come here is the super-friendly bartender whose name I did not get and be nice to him. He will probably listen to your incredibly detailed questions about different types of pint glasses (the ones I like are called 'tulip' style***) and, if you are really nice (and tip well, one presumes), he might even give you a couple since the only other way to get them is to buy 144 at a time. Not even I drink that much. * - Even if you've walked by four or five other similarly-setup bars between the 3rd Ave. 'L' stop. ** - And they don't have ranch dressing. Gah! *** - And, fortunately, not the dreaded Hamster style. I swore years ago I'd never do Hamster style again; don't ask me to now. read more

Moving back to New York to find Cedar's closed, I was beginning to fear that there were only two kinds of bars left in NY: (1) the hip trendy thumping with loud music $12 for gin and tonic sort of place. Great if you are 21 and can afford it. I am not 21 any more and think $12 for gin and tonic is silly. (2) The generic Irish bar with new wood paneling and green fixtures to be seen anywhere in midtown NY. Some of those places have decent food, but not the greatest hangouts. Molly's seems to be a holdover from older days (hm, the 80s & 90s) of NY. It seems to have grown organically on the East Side, sawdust and all. Atmosphere is low key despite the Christmas lights all over the ceiling. I went with a friend who is from New Hampshire who shared his state motto "Live Free or Die" with a happily inebriated co-drinker which resulted in the co-drinker shouting Live Free or Die one time too many loudly for the bartender's happiness. The fish and chips were pretty good, particularly the fish which was fresh with a nice light batter. If you are over 30, tired of the trendy bars, sad that White Horse is now a tourist hangout, and just want drinks, a good conversation, and reasonable bar food, this is worth checking out. read more

Irish Lamb Stew - not great. It's over priced. Service is crappy. Enough said. I understand it can get busy at night during dinner time, but common! Highly disappointing. House Shrimp Cocktail - good, but kind of standard in flavor and execution...and I've had better. It was a little expensive but there are better deals if you're not in a hurry. Service: Somewhat slow, at times it was very very slow. We received a menu and the guy seemed to disappear. Food took for ever to come out. Upwards to 43 minutes for Irish Lamb Stew in half empty restaurant with no explanation. VERDICT? Blech. Most flavorless highly priced food I've had in a long time. Hence it is my opinion that for the price and the quality this place offers, one would be better off avoiding this establishment if at all possible. It's in a convenient location to meet up for a group, but otherwise I'd go somewhere else. I have definitely had better! read more

Molly's is that rare little Irish pub where you find real English food. It's amazing....but expect to get what you pay for. My boyfriend and I ordered the Fish and Chips and the Bangers and Mash. Now I am a rather large Fish and Chips connoisseur. You could say that the English in me makes me a tad obsessed with finding Great F&Cs. Molly's has got it. Fresh white fish, fried to order, not too heavy and crisp, not soggy. Chips are crisp and good. The bangers and mash were comparable to a German restaurant back in SF, Suppenkuche, which is a HUGE compliment. VERY, very good. When you walk in, don't expect friendly, American service. This is an Irish Pub....you get good food, entertaining characters and locals, and a bartender that will speak his mind and not give an eff. This is why I love this place hahaha.... The decor is just as hilarious as the staff. Wood shavings all over the floor, stringed lights around the walls, and in the winter they have a cozy fire place! Very cool, love Molly's. read more

I was meeting my friends for some drinks after work. She had some guests in from out of town and wanted to show them how bars in NYC do Christmas. While our first choice was Rolf's, then line there was out the door and around the corner. So instead we hit up Molly's around the corner. Cozy, warm, inviting - all words I'd use to describe Molly's. I loved the sawdust on the floor (although I wasn't expecting it!) It was also decked out with festive Christmas decorations and lights (Not NEARLY as crazy as Rolf's but still very festive). While Molly's was PACKED it was still a perfect spot to get some relief from the cold December night. We pushed our way to the back of the bar where the hostess was so we could put our name down for a table. It was still relatively early (7:00ish) the estimated wait for a table for 4 was 30 minutes. Unfortunately there were actually 6 people in our party (whoops) so we took our name off the list and just had drinks. Word to the wise, the standing space around the bar is very limited so get there early. Because there are booths across from the bar, if you don't manage to get a seat at the bar you are forced to stand very close behind the people sitting at the bar. Uncomfortable at times, especially when servers and runners are bringing trays of food back and forth. It was a bit annoying and but then again it was a Friday night...you're going to get jostled and pushed a bit. If you can't handle it then go to a bar in the burbs. If you have backpacks or shopping bags or worse yet...suitcases, please be considerate. Better yet, don't bring them. There is really that little space to stand. Subway etiquette please. read more

The best thing about this place is the atmosphere -- warm and inviting. The sawdust floor is a nice touch. Based on the other reviews, I thought it would be nice to try a casual dinner here with the boyfriend. All the tables were full when we walked in at 7:30, and we were told it would be a 15 to 20 minute wait. Okay, not bad, I thought. The hostess took our name, and we meandered over to the bar for a few drinks. The bartender was overly aggressive/unhappy when taking our drink order, but hey, that's not completely unusual. The murphy's was fresh. After about 25 minutes, my boyfriend and I were able to snag some seats at the bar when another couple was offered a table. At this point, we were starting to get antsy (not to mention hungry). The hostess came over and assured us it would not be too much longer. Okay, I don't mind waiting another few minutes for some good grub. But our seats at the bar were very close to the front door, and with the comings and goings of a multitude of people, i started to get freezing and shivery. Luckily, a few tables were opening up! BUT instead of seating us, even though we had been waiting over 45 minutes at this point, the hostess seats a group of 3 that had walked in half an hour after we did! Then the hostess seats another group of 4 that walked in even later!!! At this point, we are both pretty annoyed. We waited another 10 minutes for a table -- that's right, a total of 55 minutes for a table that originally should have taken 15 or 20 minutes. I'm not sure if the hostess forgot about us or just decided that (slightly) larger groups should have priority. Either way, it's not very good restaurant practice and was pretty insulting. We left and ordered italian takeout. I guess dinner at Molly's is just not meant to be. I would not return here. read more

I am ashamed to say that although I have lived in the area for many years, Molly's was never a place I frequented. That has since changed with one bite of a Molly Burger and a sip of a pint. This burger is huge and good. The sawdust on the floor and various irish mainstays on the menu make this a must at least on a weekly basis. The regulars with whom I have drank a pint or two with now consider me black irish that was after I showed the a childhood picture of me with natural red hair. This Pub is great. read more

I was torn about whether to give this place 4 or 5 stars. Let's get the bad over with: the wings were downright gross. Fries not much better. But okay, done and done, nobody really comes to an Irish pub for the wings, do they? I came here after work one unassuming weeknight for "a drink" with a coworker and ended up having to leave work early the next day because for the first time in years, I woke up drunk (and the day didn't get any better from there). My coworker called in sick. Why? Not only were the bartenders congenial as all hell, they gave us at least a couple rounds of free drinks ( we were the only girls at the bar...might have been a factor). We met some other interesting people at the bar too. I've been meaning to go back but I can't afford to miss any more days of work so I'm going to have to watch it this time. I would recommend this place if you're in the mood to DRINK. read more

Came with some friends the Sunday afternoon following a big night out, and Molly's gave us what we needed. The front door has got to be the smallest door I have ever walked through in the tri-state area... The booths are also kind of cramped. People taller than 5'1" who weigh over 90 lbs might find the seating uncomfortable, but I'm not over those measurements so I was OK. Otherwise, the interior is very cozy, dimly lit, and even features the classic sawdust-covered floor. We had two brunch items and a French onion soup. Service seemed a bit slow, surprising as the place was only half full (food seemed to take a little long, and we had to ask for water a few times before getting it). Friend who got the soup only thought it was alright, but I enjoyed my Eggs Florentine and it seemed the friend with the full breakfast enjoyed that as well. Eggs were poached to perfection and the hollandaise was too yummy! Home fries were good too, but I wouldn't say this dish is worth $16 without the free drink it comes with (although that's typical at brunches). My Bloody Mary looked very transparent, I usually prefer them nice and opaque and tomatoey, but this one tasted good so no complaints! I also wasn't carded which is weird because I look 16 or under even though I'm 22, so I usually get scrutinized pretty heavily... However, when the bill came out, a mistake was made and our free drinks were actually charged. Luckily, we noticed the oddly high total price, figured out what was wrong, and told the waitress, who fixed the issue, so no biggie, but I'd suggest being vigilant with the bill here when you order brunches-- Not saying they purposefully try to trick you into paying, but maybe this mistake is often made, especially if they're particularly busy, because the brunch is only a small part of their menu. Overall, the place is nothing incredible, but it's quaint and exactly what you want for Sunday brunch recovery. I'd want to give it 3.5 stars. read more

Molly's - Eggs Florentine and The Irish Breakfast in the back. - Irish Pub Near Me - New York, New York

I really enjoyed it here. Dim lighting, fire place, good beer selection and I came in December so there were Christmas light everywhere which I loved. The bar is very homey...we were there around 4pm and it was a bit crowded but we were able to get a table. I had the turkey club and my girlfriend had the chicken sandwich and both were very good, but after reading the reviews it is evident that I should have ordered a burger...next time. The waitress was kind of blah but I was fine with it. Anyway definitely a nice place to hit up around the holiday or really any time. read more

I have to mention I was in a great mood when I walked into this restaurant. I had just decided on which apartment I would be making a bid for, and nothing could really knock me down, even the pitiful service at this establishment. I walked in and stood there confused. Do I walk to the back, do I sit at a table, or eat at the bar? (I now understand why some places have signs that say "Hostess will seat you") For a late, 3pm lunch on a Friday, I was shocked at how many people were eating here. This may be to their advantage, why would you have more than one waitress at that time? But alas, our service was slow. Our waitress was SO cold, I shivered being near here. Generally an accent bumps you up, but my gosh. My friend ordered the bacon cheeseburger and I ordered the wings. Waitress would not answer how many came in a plate.... When I got them, the "hot sauce" was legitimately Marinara sauce with Franks hot sauce in it. SO WEIRD? It did not taste good, I could barely eat it. I thought, huh, she gave me something wrong. So I asked for some additional hot sauce....5 minutes later (I could HAVE FINISHED my plate in that time...) I get the same crappy marinara sauce smothered in hot sauce. WTF?! AND, where's my blue cheese, she gave me like fake ranch. To top it off, I asked for a box. Where is the box? I don't know, but the bus boy never brought it, so finally 5 minutes later the bad waitress gave it to me. And Lastly, when the bill came the prices on the menu didn't match the bill. I'm not arguing over less than $5, but they kept adding fuel to the fire. Random tidbits: there are wood chips scattering the floor.... Why you may ask? to mask the blood for the brawls that occur here often. note: green street hooligans, much? read more

There are so many Irish bars on this stretch of 3rd Ave and yet Molly stands out from the pack. The floor is covered with sawdust (where it comes from, I've never been able to figure out). The crowd is usually close to 50/50 male/female and is a little less rowdy (better able to handle their drinks) which is rather unique for any drinking establishment around this area. In addition, food here is actually good. Now, it's not a culinary destination but they have a rather extensive menu ranging from Fried Calamari to Sheperds' Pie to their burgers so at least, you don't have to drink on an empty stomach. I don't know what it is about Molly's but all in all, it invites you in to make yourself comfortable and spend the evening getting to know everyone else. And it's always with a little regret that I stepped back into the cold.. read more

This is your standard Irish pub, and if I was a New Yorker, I'd definitely be a regular. Sawdust covers the floor and old-fashioned decorations cover the walls, giving it a divey feel that is very much appreciated. The bartender was friendly and helpful, pouring a delightful Guinness for my friend and a Harp for myself. They have a nice variety of beers on tap, with both the standard Irish-pub selections as well as some local beers in case a Guinness or Harp isn't what you're feeling at the moment. Based on the way the food looked coming out of the kitchen, I was a little bummed that we were going to eat, but I guess there's always next time. There are many positive mentions of the burger, so if you're looking for recommendations, that would be mine. It was a Saturday afternoon and we easily had four seats at the bar, but I can imagine that at night (and on St. Patrick's Day), this place would be hoppin'. read more

Cool little pub-restaurant in Gramercy. Nothing spectacular, but my group-running 7 or 8 deep-managed to snag a decent table, with good access to the restroom. Speaking of the water closet, that is my only significant complaint about this place. They have an accommodating waitstaff and a nice atmosphere, but why on earth do they need those batwing doors. You're not a real saloon! Those are just an unwanted, obnoxious encumbrance to diners that want to enter and exit the bathroom. Do something about that, Molly's. read more

The staff was incredibly, incredibly rude throughout out entire time here. First, they refused to seat us without the 6th member of our party, even though the place was completely empty, and preferred to have us standing by the bar blocking everyone from moving around. After finally seating us, they forced us to move to a tiny table because a 2/6 people did not order food... even though its a pub and we had all ordered drinks AND the place was completely empty. The best part, though, was after they moved us they allowed two guys to sit there by themselves because one of them was some little known TV actor. That makes a lot of sense. Throughout the rest of the meal we got barked at 2 or 3 more times for either sipping out of a water bottle (....then refill my free glass of water?) or simply being in their way (you put 6 people at a table for 4). The food did not even come close to redeeming the attitude (worst being my friend being served an essentially raw piece of meat). Very surprised by the high ratings of this place, maybe just an off day...but I will not be returning. read more

After freaking Irving Mill was closed last night (with no sign, no info on their webbie, nada), we came here instead. It's a little divey and grungy (the floor is covered with sawdust, so sandals aren't the best idea), it's really dark, the tables are uneven and a little knobby. But service is friendly, there's no wait, and the burgers are HEEUUUGE. Like, ginormous. I got the bacon cheeseburger ($11) and it was pretty solid. The meat was a little on the tough side, and not quite ground up enough. Onion rings were SUPER greasy and SUPER delicious. Fixings were abundant and fresh: raw onions (sauteed are extra $), tomato, lettuce, pickles. Generous amount of bacon. I could only eat half the burger so got an easy lunch for the next day. Molly's meat is more quantity over quality, but sometimes, you just want yourself a freaking huge chunk of meat. During those times, Molly's is the place to be. read more

Some of the Best Guinness in the City! A great Pub that oozes character as well as being full of characters. read more

Molly's - Irish Pub Near Me - New York, New York

See all

An Irish bar in Murray Hill??? Shut the f*ck up. No way! I had heard about the burgers at this place being great so I decided to come here for lunch one day with my buddy. There's something weird about eating lunch in the dark when there is perfectly good daylight outside. It seems to be the case with a lot of restaurants in this city. I can only imagine that their establishment lacks sources of natural lighting. In any case, I quickly got over the dark dingy feel of the place. We were, after all, in an Irish bar, where anything one normally finds objectionable about a food establishment can be considered here, thematic. Rude waitresses with a heart of gold? Check. Saw dust on the floor along with other nondescript compost? Check. Overrated skills at pouring Guinness from a spout? Check. With all the usual features befitting an Irish drinking establishment of fine repute, we sat down to order. Now, it's been a while since my visit, so I can't tell you what I actually ordered that day. The selection of burgers is extensive, but the permutations of bacon, mushroom, cheese, and onions are nothing that you haven't see before at various other burger joints across the city. What you, my friend, care about, is the meat. You want to know if it's juicy and flavorful and cooked medium, just the way you ordered it. Well, the answer is yes, yes, and yes. This burger was not as big as say, the burgers at Paul's or Jackson Hole, but what it lacked in quantity, it made up for in quality. It was satisfying and delicious, and as with all great burgers, it made me feel like a fat piece of sh*t afterwards for eating the whole thing. The Guinness was about $7 a glass and the burger around $15. Not the cheapest meal you can have around these parts but certainly not the most expensive. If you're looking for a dingy Irish bar to day drink with good company and chow down on some scrumptious beef patties, this is as good a place as any in this city. read more

Zero Star. I ordered foods To Go at the bar. At first, a bartender gave me wrong item,so I waited five more min. Then, I found out that one of Saidera dish was missing. So, I sent e-mailed to them and asked about refound but still no answer. Really bad customer care! read more

This tiny place has a ton of ambiance and charm - fireplace, nook-like tables, Christmas lights - and great beer list with awesome bartenders. We hated it. The major con of Molly's is the service. Let me be frank here--- the waitresses are *rude as hell*. We arrived with a party of five and were gratefully seated at a table. Some minutes later (after we'd fought the crowd, got drinks, and started drinking them), another waitress arrived and told us we "had to get up" and "go elsewhere" because it was a staff table. And she was not polite about it. Uh, then why did your staff tell us to sit here? We had just arrived, we'd barely started our drinks, and we were nicely dressed since we'd gone to a play -- the rudeness was a bit startling. We begrudgingly moved to a table meant for 2 or 3 (though we had five). Then that waitress sat there toying with her phone, alone, at a huge table. We finally sent someone to ask the bartender and he said he'd check. He then got us moved to another more appropriate table. I might note that the gigantic table we were forced to leave was then sitting empty, and the only person who ever sat down there was the waitress. Reading some of the other reviews, the comments are similar - this place has great bartenders but the women who work there are neglectful and not very nice. We are in a city where 'authentic pubs' are plentiful, and it will take more than just a fireplace and some sawdust on the floor to make us come back here. read more

Small, quiet place with a friendly down home feel. The staff are super friendly and the crowd is super chill. Definitely a place where you can have a conversation at normal volume. Great place to toss back a few pints and enjoy great food without feeling rushed or cramped. Prices here are above-average for similar pub fare and drinks, but you cannot beat the vibe or ambiance. I will be back. read more

Molly's - Shepherds Pie. Stellar. - Irish Pub Near Me - New York, New York

I found this in the "Best Bars of New York" book, but .. and it's a big BUT! The place is Irish-looking with the bartender, staff, and half the customers brogueing it up the wazoo! Lots of wood, and nostalgia on the wall. Great-looking from the outside.So I walk in and explain to the waitress that I'm here early to hold a table because I don't know how big the group will be. "You can't just drink at a table. Tables are for eating. Besides, we don't hold tables. When everybody is here, I'll seat you." "I don't know how many people are coming. There are some empty tables. Couldn't I sit at one?" She walks away. Ok, it may be reasonable not to want to give away a table for one person, but the waitress could have used some I'm sorry, I'm afraid, or even Give it ten minutes, we'll see who shows up and I'll be glad to seat you then. After I discovered 3 of us waiting at the bar we got a booth, grudgingly. Another waitress comes for the drink orders. She's as friendly as the first. "You ready? " I order the shepherds pie. One of us is a vegetarian and wants her salad without the cheese listed on the menu? "Can you make a small change to the salad?" " We only got what's on the menu!" And the lovely waitress taps her foot until we finish ordering. There's more, but it hurts in the telling. PLUS the food was pretty bad. The pie was meat, LOTS of salt, potatoes. That's it. I then resolved to make this the only 1-star review from the bars in the best bar book... but... and it's a big BUT. While the others are out for a smoke, I get up to have the bartender sign the Best Bars book. He's great! Chatty, friendly, joking around as if I were a real person. The other folks at the bar were as nice. An older regular with the required accent talks to me about the book. Two girls dressed for a good time, just start chatting out of nowhere. Wow! This place isn't as bad as I thought it was. My advice? Stick to the bar. You'll have a good time. Retreat to a table at your own risk. --Drink Club is a roving group of NYC drinkers read more

Our one and only negative experience during our recent 7 day visit to NYC. Bartender was downright rude and unpleasant. Learned later from another somewhat less rude, but not much, bartender that they were having difficulties with their Murphy's lines and getting no service from Murphy's. Perhaps taking Murphy's and Murphy's Red off the posted list of draft and a simple "sorry" and an explanation would be a good idea for future Murphy's requests. Too bad, it really soured our impression to the point we won't be returning. There are so many other places to choose. Have subsequently learned (and read other negative reviews here) that this does not appear to be an isolated incident. Wonder when management will clue in? read more

*Disclaimer: I live close by Shake Shack!!! Pros: awesome combo of great burger and beer!!! :D actual wood-burning furnace Cons: really casual, dim lights So, before I begin, I live close to both Shake Shack and Molly's and I choose to go to Molly's over Shake Shack for burgers. :D The place itself is really humble and makes u feel like u walked into some old irish pub; the wood dust on the floor and the actual wood-burning furnace definitely add to it. I come here for some cheep beer and burgers most of the times, when I feel lazy to cook and get a hankering for burgers. The burger itself is outstanding!!! The patty is super juicy, thick, and kinda crumbles on the edges with cheese melted perfectly on top! The patty is definitely NOT dense, but super flavorful and just disintegrates in your mouth with that crumbly action. You can just tell from the taste that it's a beefy burger. :) Cold beer with Molly's burger makes my tummy happy. :D read more

I don't come here for the beer, which I know they have plenty of and fans for. I don't come here for the much touted wood burning fireplace. I don't even come here to have the sawdust stick to my shoes or to converse with the friendly staff. What I do come here for is the fish and chips. That is the only thing I order here and the only thing that needs to be ordered. Tender, flaky, fresh fish deep fried in a beer batter with ketchup and malt vinegar. I take a few bites, decide I've had enough batter, scrape off the coating and then savor the fish. Life is indeed divine. Oh, portions are humongous so come hungry or get the fish and chips at brunch. The size is more manageable. You can share the dinner plate but there is a sharing charge. read more

4/5 - Very dimly lit and wooden, Mollys has ample seating for eating. There was sawdust all over the floor which was kind of cool though! Service 3.5/5 - The lady that served us was very nice and polite. She checked on us often and I really appreciated that. Food 4/5 - I got the 10 oz bacon cheeseburger with blue cheese. 10 ozs is a complete lie. It has to be at least a lb of food. Or at least it feels like it! Mollys was very generous with the bacon as well. There were at least 4-5 pieces on mine. The burger was enormous! And tasty! My only complaint was that the patty did seem a little under-seasoned but the rest of the ingredients made up for it. read more

Maybe I have not been in NYC enough to be able to classify a good bar, or a good Irish bar. I have been to a lot of bars, though, and I think Molly's is a good, solid place, but not "the best Irish bar in Manhattan" or anything. I've been to better places, and worse places. On the positive side, Molly's has good character. The bar is in good shape, clean, and has a laid back atmosphere. The food was decent, but I don't think that my burger was all that amazing, though the prices were not that bad, I guess. The Guinness was good, and served at the right temperature, so I can't complain about that. It was a bit crowded, but when you're listed as the best Irish pub in the city, that tends to happen. We just happened to be in the neighborhood and walked in...three of us. All in all, I was pleased with my Molly's experience, but there was just something about the place that did not impress me, overall. I can't say that I would head back here in a hurry - there are a lot more bars around that I like more. Still, you won't be led astray in a place such as this - a good, solid bar/pub. read more

I've never been to Ireland, but I fell in love with an Irish girl once. I like to think that makes qualified in all things Irish. Molly's is a 'real' Irish Pub. Meaning, absent: the shots, the jocks, the bouncers, the televisions on every wall and the electronic jukebox. If you visit on a rainy evening you will have to settle for a low-lit cabin, sawdust on the floor, dusty framed pictures, a fireplace, and a bar where people mull over perfectly poured Guinness and glasses of Bushmills. It gets busy on the weekends, but this is New York, so either expect it or don't come. Your waitress: the short Irish grandmother you've always wished you had. Try out your gab, or just be straight, she won't mind, she's been doing this for a long time. The burger is thick and juicy with good char. The bun leaves a little to be desired but they toast it. Anywhere who doesn't toast the bun doesn't know. Fresh tomato, always red, cheese melted (my goto is swiss), skip the bacon they overcook it. Fries are crispy and a thickish cut, always hot. The sour pickle is always crunchy. The Guinness is the best pour in NY. They let it settle, the right way, meaning you have to wait. It comes creamy and smooth. The perfect temperature. If you don't like waiting for good things, go away. If New York was still populated by people who wanted to live here and were willing to put up with anything to do so, you could imagine Dylan Thomas straddled up on one of the bar stools arguing about poems. Come on a Tuesday night while it is raining, slide into a booth, drink one too many whiskey's and argue, grinning, with a good literary foe. Who would you choose; Pound of Elliott? read more

Molly's Irish brunch = the best hangover food on the planet. Combine this with the perfect pub atmosphere, complete with the Irish waitress, sawdust on the floor, black pudding to satisfy my English boyfriend, a kick a$$ bloody mary, a perfectly poached eggs benedict, laughs about the night before, and the cozy Christmas atmosphere inside while it's cold, grey, and rainy outside and you have the perfect Sunday! Molly's makes this Irish girls eyes (and stomach) smile! Definitely need to try the burger next time though! read more

Nice place right around the corner from my friend Steve's place and when we saw that the place a couple doors down was overly packed, we decided to check this place out. More low key and laid back and a nice old school bar with a serious bartender who pours a nice Guinness. read more

For 12 years living in NYC I never experienced anything like I did couple of days ago. I do understand it's City, Bar is too crowded, too many people, but I'm sorry, you took this job. The waiters staff was very disrespectful and pushing you yelling you can't stand here or there. People just kept apologizing. It was 8 of us and we knew it would be impossible to get a table, so we let the host know we can split. Next think I see she sat another people at the table for 5. When I told the host why would she do that, as we were waiting, she said but it's 8 of you guys. So she ignored that we wanted to take 2 different tables. She saw us waiting the whole time. When I told the host: you literally kicked us out, she smiled and said whatever you say. Very unprofessional! I'm sure they being nice when the place is not crowded and this is all about Christmas time read more