This past Sunday my girlfriend and I visited Montana Mike's for the first time in years for either of us. She wanted a steak to celebrate snagging a new job!! As always in our reviews we started with an appetizer and we chose the Cheesy Bacon House Tots. They were delicious!! The spicy ketchup while nothing fancy added a great variety to oppose the ranch our wonderful server Joe recommended without hesitation. You can also add the warm soft rolls to the app experience. They were even more tasty. Could eat a ton of those alone and be happy! For our mains she got steak and shrimp and chose grilled shrimp as opposed to fried. She absolutely loved the steak and said it was exactly what she needed! The shrimp sadly, was not, she took a bite and had a reaction I haven't seen before. We believe the seasoning was just not to her taste. Our server Joe again was right on the spot and offered the solution to swap for the fried shrimp and they were so much better in her opinion. We cannot thank Joe enough for being so friendly and professional. She had mashed potatoes for her side and was not blown away but that is perfectly okay. The meal came with a salad, however it was okay at best. The uncut veg while visually appealing takes away from the eating experience. As for my main I ordered Messy Mike's Burger without the fresh red onion to medium well temp. The temp was overdone, but truthfully is no big deal to me. It was still tasty and very flavorful. An item I would order again for sure!!! The French fries were crispy and well seasoned and the green beans were also a great addition to the meal. Overall the food was great and alone is a 4 star given the remedy. The big driving force for the 5 star was the fantastic service provided by Joe. It isn't often I mention the server, but he was attentive, kept our drinks full, was polite and the true home run was the quick remedy of the issue with the shrimp. We hope the tip we left was enough to show him that we appreciated him and thought he did well!! We will return and hope to have him as a server again. read more

See all

Ordered the NY Strip with Ancho butter, steamed veggies and a Caesar salad. It says something about a steakhouse when the best part of your meal is the salad -- and the Caesar really was excellent. Perfect portion, great dressing, well-balanced. Unfortunately, that's where the highlights end. The steak and veggies arrived shortly after I finished the salad, but the vegetables were cold and clearly undercooked. The bigger disappointment was the NY Strip itself. I ordered it medium rare and it came out medium well -- and I'm not exaggerating when I say the cut was barely a half-inch thick. Grey throughout, with zero sear on either side. To be fair to the kitchen, it's nearly impossible to hit medium rare on a steak that thin, so the real issue isn't the cooking -- it's the quality of the meat being sourced. The ancho butter was $1.99 extra and absolutely flavorless. Didn't even taste like real butter much less any seasoning in it. For a restaurant billing itself as a steakhouse, the cut and quality of the beef has to be the priority. This one missed the mark. read more

This is a great place to eat. We had the nicest waitress ever. Her name was Amanda. She kept our drinks coming, checked on us every little bit and made sure we were taken care of. The food was excellent and a great value . Great atmosphere .It's close to the outlet mall. We will definitely be back . read more

See all

After a day of shopping in Edinburgh, we stopped at Montana Mike's for dinner. The restaurant was super clean, they were even wiping down the doors when we walked in. We got seated right away and our server was great! The rolls came out warm with cinnamon butter, and my daughter said they were the best ever. We ordered the garden salad with grilled chicken, teriyaki chicken, and chicken tenders with a loaded baked potato. Everything was great and the service was just as good. Bill stopped by after we finished to check on us. He was so friendly and fun to talk to! Definitely a great guy to have on the team. We'll for sure be back next time we're in town! read more

See all

Where do I start? The service! Amanda, our server, exceeded any expectations of a great server. My 12-year-old grandson, said. "She's great!" She gave us enough space to talk with each other and she engaged with us. (That's always a delicate balance.) It was the best catfish I've had in a while. It was seasoned and breaded lightly. It tasted delicious. We shared an ice cream sundae. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Grandson enjoying a brownie sundae for his birthday! - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all

I was staying at the hotel next door so thought I would walk over for dinner. I was seated immediately and ordered a half rack of ribs and a salad. The food didn't take long and was pretty good. I would definitely return if in the area. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Wedge salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

Overall, I enjoyed this. We decided to go here while traveling since it isn't a place we have back home. The staff were nice. The food came out fairly quick. Everyone seemed to enjoy their meals. Decor was different and unique. read more

When we first entered this restaurant we weren't sure what to expect. It gives off a feel similar to Texas Roadhouse. The dinner rolls were good and the service was excellent. The atmosphere is very relaxed as well. We started off with the fried zucchini as an appetizer and wow, not only was it delicious but there was also a large amount for the money. My son ordered the 10 oz sirloin, medium, with a double order of fries. Again, the portion of fries for each order was very large (honestly could have fed two people if they had their own steaks. My daughter ordered the boneless buffalo wings with fries and said it was good. My husband ordered the 12 oz New York strip with a salad and baked sweet potato. His steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly, and his sweet potato was perfectly soft and tender. My husband said it was the best sweet potato that he has ever had with how it was cooked. I ordered the ribeye sandwich with rice pilaf and it was all tasty. Though it had the Texas Roadhouse vibe, the food was cooked evenly and seasoned perfectly (unlike every Texas Roadhouse we have been to). Overall, I would highly recommend this restaurant as the food was delicious and Jessica W (I think) did an amazing job! read more

See all

My wife went with the chicken sandwich with fries while I went with the boneless buffalo wings. They bring out some yummy buns and butter. This is a Military friendly restaurant. read more

See all

I'd give it 3.5 if I could. A few changes would make it 5 stars. Short version: Price to value and flavor + service. If you're in the area looking for a sit down meal and maybe an adult beverage.... totally worth it. Service was exceptional. Also all the staff really looked like they were enjoying themselves. Not unprofessionally, just seemed to have a nice laid back style with each other, lots of smiles, but focused on doing a good job. It gets 5 stars for vibe and service. I had a veteran and a trainee and thought the vet did a great job explaining and teaching as we interacted. GM/leadership came around and checked on me. Saw him later making drinks to help out bar tender. Awesome! Easy to get a seat Saturday at 7:30p. Buffalo Trace Manhattan was great. I wasn't expecting much but it was well balanced. There were some local beers I should have tried, but wasn't feeling up to it. I think about 4 different styles of local. I ordered the NY strip medium, garden salad with homemade blue cheese dressing and mashed potatoes. Got a comp roll and cinna butter. Roll: Pretty tasty. Just a tad undercooked for me, but it was still really good. Salad: Everything was fresh and crisp! However, it was probably the most underwhelming of the meal. Too watery. iceburg lettuce pieces were HUGE, onion were in rings, like 2 crutons and I swear 3 little strings of cheese. Now, the PORTION size overall of the lettuce was huge. I had high hopes for the BC dressing. one- there wasn't enough for the dressing to lettuce ratio, and two, it was pretty bland. I think they could take the salad up a notch without much effort and zero cost. The basics are there to make it really good. Steak: It was medium - totally impressed! It was also tender and juicy. NY strips are pretty lean and they did a good job. I don't like hardly any fat so I use surgeon like precision to remove fat but a few bites where I got some of the trim it was well rendered and flavorful. So super kudos there! They could take this to 5 stars by doing two things. Seasoning my friends. Seasoning! There was zero seasoning I could tell. You got the hard part right!! LOL. Do the easy part and season it with S&P+G some melted butter, etc. Like pennies to take a 3 star steak to 5 stars! Second - Sear it. It came out with grill marks, but if you could give that steak a good crust.....man with the medium perfection and tenderness that would be a freaking amazing steak at a great price. Given this is a steakhouse, I'm critical on this one. You nail this part and I'd totally say 4-5 stars. Bonus- I think steak sauce is a crime. However since there was no seasoning I did use some minimally. Wow, the house sauce is amazing. Thick, good flavor, not over powering. Reccomend. Mashed potatoes: OMG. I have no idea if those are made in-house but if they are----give that cook a raise! They are rough mashed so they have some chewy texture. But whatever lesson they learned on seasoning potatoes they need to apply to the steak. I'll go out on a limb and say top 5 mashed taters I've ever had. read more

We stopped in to give Montana Mike's a try. First off Ali L gave us great service throughout our dinning service. The restaurant had a great atmosphere. We both had a salad that was crisp and fresh. I ordered the 6 oz Sirloin & grilled shrimp combo. I would rate my Sirloin as average and the shrimp was delicious. My side was mashed potatoes with gravy and it was very good. My better half ordered the Mountain Topper Chicken with mashed potatoes. She shared that she enjoyed it! We will be back. read more

See all

Service here at this location is amazing!! Food was gooď it did not disappoint. But the mother daughter servers at this restaurant are so patient and attentive. I would come back just for their service. read more

Had the ribs for the first time at Montana Mikes. 1/2 rack was plenty. Very flavorful and fell off the bone. My wife had catfish and said it was excellent. Our waitress, Taylor, was very personable and did a great job. Highly recommend them for ribs or steaks. read more

Clean environment very spacious. The trainer server did an outstanding job, she'll do great here. Good had good flavor very filling and overall fresh tasting! A good spot to stop right before you hit the mall! read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

Sometimes a billboard on the freeway works. We were traveling through the area and looked up the address of MM. It was a great lunch. The steaks were done perfectly and the sides were good. We enjoyed the decor and the staff was very friendly. read more

See all

If you have never been to a Montana Mikes, it is similar to any steakhouse/roadhouse out there. Outdoor decor, staple dishes, and lots of tvs playing sports. Montana Mike's offers a dependable dining with generous portions. I had the fried catfish, which was well-cooked, battered nicely, and flavorful, though not exceptional. My boyfriend enjoyed his steak, which was cooked to his liking . The portions are notably large, ensuring you won't leave hungry. Not pictured, onion rings as our appetizer. While nothing was outstanding about our visit we enjoyed our food. Our server was less than enthusiastic to be working. The manager did stop at our table to personally check in, however this may be due to the table next to ours complaining about their meal. Overall, Montana Mike's is a reliable spot for those looking for decent food and ample servings. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all

Food was good, steak was cooked perfect. The server was fantastic just a great attitude and checked back 4-5 times. 3 other people stopped by to see how the food was. Great job. read more

We ordered to go but I will say the service over the phone was exceptional. Everything we ordered was ahhhh-mazing!

Awesome food and service. Saw a billboard. Decided to take a chance. Seated right away. Restaurant was very busy. We ordered chicken fried steak. It was delicious. Service was excellent. Only complaint would be it's kinda warm in here. But we are in a heat wave. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Chicken fried sirloin - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

Ribeye a bit tough, not bad, but very tasty. The apples were good but not special. The baked sweet potato was wonderful. Outstanding. The rib slab was fantastic, per my wife. The steamed veggies ranked high too. The apples, so so. Very good service too. April was on top of things. They have a decent beer selection too. Upland brewery has some really good . read more

This was my first experience dining at the restaurant. We ordered stuffed mushrooms, fried onion rings, and for the main course, steak and shrimp accompanied by a side of green beans and steamed vegetables. The service was efficient, and our server was courteous. However, I observed that the green beans were overcooked, resulting in a lack of flavor. The ambiance of the establishment is welcoming and suitable for families. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

It has been long time since we had been here. It was nice to see consistency in our previous experience. Overall service, food, and experience were great. We arrived before rush hour. We will definitely return. Everything was perfect. Great steak, baked potato, rolls, salad. Recommend mushroom and zucchini appetizer. The restaurant was quiet, staff were all great too. read more

I've been to Montana Mike's before but this is my first review, just because it was so good. It's always good, but this was different. I wish I could remember my servers name because she was awesome and got a massive tip because of her service. I had the ribeye sandwich, medium rare. It's on a toasted hamburger bun with lettuce, tomato and horseradish sauce on the side. It is actually a ribeye steak, cooked medium rare, on a bun. Incredible! Tender with amazing flavor. I don't eat like I did when I was younger so I don't finish many meals, but nothing was left of this sandwich. I also had the house salad with ranch, and their ranch is very good. I don't do cucumbers or raw onions, but they are easily removed. The roll with cinnamon butter is a nice starter. Highly recommended. read more

See all

I was staying at a hotel off base from Camp Atterbury and my co worker suggested Montana Mike's for dinner. Things started off good here- we were seated right away and our food arrived relatively quickly, however it went quickly downhill. Once we got our food our server was either no where to be found or when she passed by our table she didn't stop. I had to stop her to ask for another drink and stop her again for the check. I felt like I was inconveniencing her to ask. Also, somehow they kept messing up our drink orders. I asked for a short beer and they brought me a tall, and my co worker asked for a tall at first and they brought him a short. I ordered the 6 oz sirloin with baked potato and side salad. The food was ok but nothing spectacular to write home about. I don't know that I would come back given the service. We were there for almost three hours for two people to get dinner and then constantly trying to flag down our server. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all

Found this by accident-what a gem of a find! Great service, great steaks and an interesting-but friendly-lunch vibe! Our steaks were grilled perfectly (medium rare) and the sides were nice too! All this for an unusually inexpensive cost! Thank you MM! read more

See all

Great restaurant. The atmosphere was laid back and welcoming. They had a great selection of local brews along with other domestics. The bar was loaded with options for beverages. The food came out hot and fresh just like the descriptions. The bbq chicken sandwich was great, it had a sweet bbq glaze with cheese and an onion ring that topped it off. It was a very large portion. The home chips were good, could tell they weren't fresh cut but they were a solid complement to the sandwich. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Bar area - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all

The food was amazing right up there with the customer service. The restaurant was very clean and not that loud either. My steak was cooked to perfection and the baked potato was hot and steamy which allowed everything to melt together which made the perfect bite every time. If you goto the Outlet mall in Edinburgh, stop in for dinner, you won't regret it.. read more

Food, Service & Ambience all A+. We will be return customers. Do not hesitate go and enjoy this place. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Breaded Tenderloin Excellent !! - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

Stopped in for a lunch. Meeting with a colleague. Love that they have a $11 lunch special. There are lots of good options on this menu. I went with the catfish. My only complaint is the picture shows fillets and it's more like bites. However, it tasted, good. The serving size was decent. I got a house salad with homemade in house French dressing. The dressing was phenomenal. My colleague enjoyed the yeast rolls with cinnamon butter. We were not greeted when we walked in the door. As we were there at 11 AM, and the first ones in line when they were unlocking the door. That was kind of odd to unlock and turn around and walk away without opening the door and saying welcome . our server on the other hand was very friendly and the kitchen staff who brought out our food was super friendly. When you walk in kind of remind you of stepping into Montana, and lots of wood! read more

Huge servings and service is amazing! Food is really good! I ordered the teriyaki salmon with mushroom & zucchini appetizer. Yummy

First time at Montana Mikes Steakhouse, we loved it! My wife and I celebrated her birthday there yesterday. Started with the yummy rolls and apple butter, Campfire Shrimp, all excellent! My wife had fillet mignon was cooked to order, juicy and great tasting, baked potato was moist and tasty. I had the creamy Cajun shrimp ribeye also cooked per ordered, great tasting and juicy (even without the sauce), a little more fatty than other restaurants, but still enough meat to enjoy. Baked potato (same as above) and coleslaw also tasty and crisp. My wife had a Pina Colada (she sucked it down before I had a chance to taste it, so it must have been good). Ended it with a complementary rocky mountain mudslide (large chocolate sundae with a brownie) also great. Service was phenomenal, I believe our servers name was Carol. Even the manager went from table to table checking on everyone food and service (haven't seen this done in some time). Ambiance was festive, but not over baring (you didn't have to raise your voice just to have a conversation). No question, we plan to make this restaurant one of our regular eating locations. read more

First time eating at Montana Mike's. Really great food and if you like "roadhouse" atmosphere, you'll love it. We were at the start of a vacation and had no clue where to eat. So...random stop. Looked for lots of local cars. (If the locals don't eat there, keep going!) My husband had a Cheeseburger and green beans (he's trying to make up for 60 years of french fries). I had the broccoli cheese soup and the fried zucchini and mushrooms appetizer. The food was perfect. Stephen was our polite, efficient waiter and he kept our drinks filled and checked on us periodically. He seemed like he enjoyed his work, so either he's a great employee or he's just a great actor. The manager came by to check on us halfway through the meal. It seems like a place that wants to make sure you have a great meal. read more

I just left after my first visit. I ordered ribeye, and it was cold, tough and full of gristle. I could barely cut through half, then just left. I would NEVER step foot there, much less recommend it! Worst Ever! read more

Steak was not cooked right so instead of a new steak They just recooked the same one I had already cut up read more

Last time we were here was almost 4 years ago. Food and service then was meh at best. This time food and service were great. I was afraid around 6pm on Sunday there would be a wait but there wasn't. We were sat in the bar area. Our server came over immediately. We got hot fresh rolls with cinnamon butter. They were delicious. We started with Loaded Cheese Fries with Ranch Dressing. They were pretty good. My glazed salmon was really good. It was glazed with teriyaki and soy. The baked potato was served with lots of butter and sourcream. Husband got Steak and Baked potato. He ate it all so it must have been good. Our server was on with the drink refills. This visit would make us want to cone back in less then 4 years. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Glazed Salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all

My husband and I came here for dinner one night as it was someplace we hadn't tried before. The atmosphere was nice, the food was great, our server was on top of their game and we had an absolutely amazing date night. We will definitely be returning! read more

Awesome atmosphere. Owner Bill is hilariously, good dude. Food is top notch. I got a dinner salad and the Cajun pasta. Swapped the seafood and meats with veggies onions peppers greens . Thank you for the hospitality and good memories. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - House salad - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

Great service and fun ambiance! The cheese fries appetizer portion is huge! Definitely enough to share for multiple folks. The steak appeared a little over temperature, but it was incredibly tender and delicious. The salad also had great flavor and I recommend ordering the dressing on the side so you can control the amount on it. Overall a very good experience. read more

Take Out service after a long day of business travel and work: the order was prompt, text messages received from the Steakhouse and when I arrived, staff were polite and offered me a beverage while i waited, which wasn't a long time. The salad was nicely made, and packaged. The Ahi tuna steak was thick and a bit overcooked and dry. The sweet potato fries were thin and lightly seasoned (my preference), and not oily. I would order next time for dine in, since the atmosphere looked family and business oriented. read more

I gave a 4 star and not a 5 star only because we had a sanitary issue with one of our meals that had to be completely replaced. Joseph our waiter was absolutely wonderful!! He was so polite and nice! Our food was great and we all enjoyed the comfortable atmosphere. We will be going back when we are in the area again. read more

Montana Mike's Steakhouse - Ribs! - Steakhouses Near Me - Edinburgh, Indiana

See all