Let's see, where to start...? Not with a photo, because the pizza is gone. I ate it. Let's do this. I love pizza. It's a food that brings me joy. Mountain Mike's was a weekly haunt when I was growing up in Morgan Hill, so when I decided to give the one here in town a try, I poured all of that sweet sweet nostalgia into my expectations. You know how that usually goes... disappointing remake movies and general failures to rise to the original. But tonight was not the case. I ordered a childhood favorite custom: pepperoni, mushrooms, olives, and bacon. Combined with their wonderfully spicy red sauce, it shattered the nostalgia ceiling and forged some new memories all its own. My friends, this is some mighty fine pizza. My wife ordered something with chicken and bacon on a garlic sauce and it was great. Not as good as mine of course, because all of my food choices are inherently more awesome, but delicious nonetheless. We wasted no time devouring both, and I can definitively say I have found a new favorite pizza place in town. My son got a personal Hawaiian. He ate it so fast I'm not sure he tasted it. He said it was his new favorite pizza though, so there's that. That's not to say it's all sunshine and rainbows. I would categorize it as definitely sunshine, and maybe one of those cool half rainbows you see from time to time. The pizza certainly isn't what I'd classify as "cheap". $51 for two smalls and a personal isn't bad, and definitely blows Round Table prices out of the water, but it is a little spendier than your Valley's and Domino's sorts of pies. You can taste the price difference too though. You're definitely eating better food for your $51. To close I'd like to toss a big high five in the direction of the staff. I echo the other sentiments I read in some reviews that they're pretty great. I arrived on time, but at the end of the night, so my pizza wasn't quite done. The ladies manning the restaurant were very friendly, pleasant, and even sent a sucker home for my son from their Halloween candy stash. A+ service in my opinion. TL;DR - The pizza is dope. Buy some and thank me later. read more

Simply Gross..Today, I thought I would order pizza..Went to Mountain Mikes..Ordered a Snowy Alps..and a Dessert Pizza which was nothing like the guy described..First off , not a soul on site..No one was there..I had ordered these pizzas togo.. The Snowy Alps was salted so much.. I had to rinse my mouth out on first bite.. It was gross..Cheap products, overly priced and I tossed it in the trash..I was still think we'll at least I have my dessert pizza..I took a bite of this crap and wanted to vomite.. Butter, powder sugar and mozzarella..The guy told me cinnamon and sugar with butter..He said it was good..Once I tasted this crap, it was like what planet was he from..If you want crappy pizza at a High price.. This place is perfect..$50.00 for crap in a box..That I had to trash can..Buy the way..Well, I was waiting..a $10.00 coupon came across my app. SO, I went to the counter to see if I could spy it..I was told No! not today! Don't waste your hard earned money on this place.. Below average pizza..I would give them minus 5 stars if I could.. read more

After a long day with the kids on summer break, we arrived around 8:20pm for dinner. My autistic son had a brief meltdown, so I took a moment to calm him while also keeping an eye on my other children. Once I was ready to order, I was told I couldn't get a salad because "they already closed salads"--even though the restaurant doesn't close until 10:30pm. This was really disappointing. I don't eat bread, so salad was my only option--and there was still two full hours until closing. I wasn't asking for anything complicated, just a simple salad. I understand closing prep areas near the end of the night, but this felt unnecessarily rigid and inconsiderate. The situation wasn't handled with any empathy or flexibility. After an already challenging evening, it left me hungry and frustrated. A little compassion would have gone a long way. read more

The pizza was amazing. I think this might be the best pizza in San Jose! Will definitely be going back to this pizza parlor!

Called in an order earlier today around 6pm while driving home from work for pick up at 7pm. I called the phone number that appears when you Google this specific location and mentioned that I had the HOLLISTER HIGH SCHOOL football fundraiser discount card to confirm that I could use the coupon which is only valid at THIS location. I was told I could. I placed my order and thought it was weird they didn't ask for a name. I figured they could just look me up through the phone number on their caller ID. I arrived at about 7:05 to pick up my order and I was told there was no order on file under my number, and no order matching what I had ordered. I showed the cashier (who actually sounded like the person on the phone I had spoken with) the phone number on my phone that I called to confirm I spoke to the right location and she claimed that the phone number takes you to a call center and that they probably didn't confirm my location and sent my order to the wrong restaurant? I don't understand why, after stating I had the Hollister high school baler card, that I would be ordering somewhere else? I was advised I could reorder but that my order would take another 30-40 minutes to be ready and nothing was offered to make it right. I unfortunately could not wait that long and left :( read more

Super friendly employees food is always fresh. Good environment super clean thank you mountain Mike.

Clutch they were a little late but im happy they made it. They gave me free breadsticks as well.

So disappointed! Pizza showed up 50 mins after my delivery time. Finally decided to call the restaurant and ask about my pizza, they said the driver had 4 deliveries that were all being delivered at the same time. I know the economy makes it difficult to staff, but that's also why I'm writing this. Pizza is expensive, I know that, it's a luxury for me. I decided to treat myself and was disappointed to receive a lukewarm soggy pizza. Do better. Submitted the form as requested the same day I was asked to, but still haven't heard a response. read more

Ok, I know we only had delivery to our hotel room, but the person taking our order was very sweet & engaging, then when the pizza pie & wings arrived they were hot, quite tasty and the order was correctly made as requested! read more

See all

Ordered from a hotel for delivery of a salad. Had to add mozarella sticks simply because they insist on a minimum. The order took 2 1/2 HOURS for delivery, and it was missing marinara sauce for the add-on, even though it was clearly noted. They do not answer the phone. The food was unremarkable - a "chef's salad" was nothing more than a garden side salad with a couple of slices of pizza topping meat thrown in. All in all a terrible experience and I would never choose them again. read more

I want to express on how grateful I am for the amazing customer service I received from the Hollister store manager Claudia. She was very attentive to our order and very sweet. Thank you Mountain Mike's & Thank you Claudia read more

Beyond rude experience. Julia didn't want to help whatsoever with my order. Called 30 seconds after ordering through Uber eats to just ask for half red and white sauce, and she said there was nothing they could do and the pizza has already been made. A complete lie, and just plain horrible customer service. Very disappointed. read more

Mountain Mike's kicking butt on Round Table pizza. Hands down better especially with the Everest pizza. Kudos to Mountain Mike's

Not bad. This is like a mini Dave N Busters. The pizza is pretty good being crispy hot and flavorful. There are signs that the business has been going down hill (none of the 8 TVs were working). But, at least the food was good. read more

I just love this Mountain Mike's! Claudia and her team always go above and beyond every visit! Clean restaurant and the food is always fresh! When I visit the area this is always my go to place! I just recently visited family and picked this spot for that very reason! Hawaiian pizza read more

Great pizza and great customer service! The ambiance is family friendly and gets you in the mode for pizza! Overall my visits to mountain mikes are met with a smile from Yannet! She's very helpful and attentive to my orders. I always have an idea when my pizzas are ready to pick up read more

I just want to thank Claudia at Mountain Mikes, I was having a really bad day and she asked me how I was doing, I replied with a long list of problems I had all morning and she listened not cutting me off, she made sure our service was fast and even made sure I laughed on my way out... read more

Claudia is the best! Although we had so many special request in terms of food restrictions. Claudia was very patient and accommodating.

We usually order from Round Table but thought we would give Mountain Mike's a try. We ordered a large and the pizza tasted stale. The crust and pie itself tasted undercooked or like they premade the crust /pie and added the toppings today and warmed it up. Very disappointed. Won't be ordering again. read more

Pizza is great! I like to order online and pizza is always hot and fresh when I get there to pick it up!

All, Heads up! Super Bowl Day 2 hour wait for your pizza!! Normally a great place though, I'm sure this is just because of Super Bowl. But they should be giving folks a heads up before they wait in line 30 mins to order before letting them know it will be a two hour wait for their pizza to be ready. Wow! Little common courtesy. Today look for somewhere else!! read more

our families favorite! they never disappoint with the food quality and great customer service!

Usually, this is our "go-to" spot for free choice weekly dinner. The pizza was not extra crispy as requested. The order took 50 minutes instead of the quoted 30. The sandwich had one thin slice of ham! $10 bucks for a piece of bread full of lettuce?! I could've made that at home. Thank goodness the garlic bread is good with melted cheese or not because my cheese was pretty solid. Probably the last time we come to this pizza spot. read more

See all

Called to order a pizza at 7:30 on a Friday night. No one answered the phone. Tried to order online. Closed at 7:45 pm per the online ordering system, really???? read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - Hours - Pizza Near Me - Hollister, California

In Store Pick Up and the Quality of Pizza is Great ! Staff was Courteous and Attentive. Will be making Hollister Mountain Mike's My Go to Pizza Stop ! Yet Another Excellent Pizza Experience. No Doubt one of Mountain Mikes better Franchise's Quality Pizza, and Hard working Courteous Staff. read more

The food quality has been consistent. Something you can count on, yummy! Roundtable's true competitor.

My favorite place to have pizza, never disappointed on quality of toppings and flavor. My go to for pizza

Best pizza in town!!! Great customer service. Every time we come Yanneth makes us feel welcomed not to mention Claudia they are always willing to help and manage to get our order out on time!! Great arcade for the kids. We always have a great time and enjoy our food great family ambiance!!! read more

I recently had my daughters birthday party here . Family friendly food was great not to mention the brand new games kept the kiddos happy and entertained . The service was awesome thanks to the manager Claudia she made sure our pizzas were done in a timely manor and kept checking on us to see if we needed anything else. read more

Our family loves this place to grab and pizza and go. They are always so nice. They offer coupons and always try to save us some money. Pizza tastes great and we love the spice on the pepperoni. Mountain size is a great value. We have never had a problem. read more

The worst pizza parlor in Hollister. Ordering through the app is a joke. The people who answer the phone, IF you can get anyone on the phone, are not competent to be speaking to customers. I had to repeat and spell out my street name multiple times to more than one person. More order took more than two hours to deliver on a Sunday. I'm just going to take my business to the other places in town. Never again. read more

So ordered a medium pizza to be delivered. I received an email asking to come pick it up so I called and said I wanted it delivered. Called at 4:45 and pizza didn't get delivered until 6:30!!! And on top of all that it was cold!! They really need to pay attention to when someone calls in an order. So I will NEVER order from this place again and especially since I paid over $30 just for a cold medium size pizza!!!! read more

Excellent service the girl went the extra mile Michelle and Claudia were very friendly and kind. The pizza, salad bar, wings were all great.! read more

By Far the worst mountain mikes pizza in the tri County area ...not because of the pizza but for their service. I am a delivery driver I've been to all the mountain mike's around.. Twice I called in an order & showed up to pick it up & they forgot to make it. Today I ordered online & I show up to pick it up 15 min after promise time & it's still needs 10 more minutes in the oven. Shame on me for going there .. read more

Grabbed a couple of pizzas here on friday. A large sausage, onion, mushroom and a large vegetarian. Total came to over $55. For pizza like Little Ceasar's $6. The veggie pizza had lots of toppings but the crust was really soggy. I think they just waved it at the oven as they walked by it. Almost $24 for this. The sausage etc was atleast cooked all the way but they were seriously stingy with the toppings. About 2 little nubbin s of sausage (about the size of the tip of my pinkie finger) per slice, very little tiny finely sliced mushrooms and almost no very finely sliced onions. For this I paid almost $30?! I'm giving it 2 stars instead of one because the young lady behind the counter was really nice. But no, I won't be back and I certainly won't recommend this place to friends. read more

Worst service ever. Waited over an hour for a pizza that was apparently just sitting in the back getting cold. Employees were rude and careless. Never received an apology about it all. They also forgot the sauce. read more

Tonight we ordered a medium The Everest pizza which was pepperoni, salami, ground beef, olives and mushrooms (we left off the onions and green peppers). Since I eat a very low carb diet, I only ate the toppings off 2 slices so I can't comment on the crust. The toppings and sauce were pretty tasty but it's pretty obvious that sauce is coming from a can, it had a very strong tomato paste taste. I had an all you can eat salad bar which I only wanted one trip to the bar after seeing how unappetizing it all looked. The lettuce looked decent, the olives looked like olives, fresh jack cheese sprinkled on top, cucumber slices, broccoli and fresh mushrooms. However; everything else looked disgusting, the potato salad, macaroni salad, kidney beans and garbanzo beans looked like they had been sitting out all day and lost their luster. The dressings looked unappetizing, watered down and thinned out with milk. I also ordered 12 hot wings. They probably had the best tasting out of everything ordered. But oh man were they really hot. I don't mean spicy hot, I mean burned my fingers twice hot. The place itself looked pretty clean. The bathroom was decent looking and smelled pleasant. We went on a Thursday evening about 7:00 and it was pretty busy with only a few tables open. Lots of little kids running around and being; well...kids. I don't think I would bother making another trip here in the future. I think there are other pizzas I would rather try out like Mangia's. read more

Mountain Mike's Pizza - A medium The Everest and an order of 12 Buffalo hot wings. - Pizza Near Me - Hollister, California

Mountain Mike's kicking butt on Round Table pizza. Hands down better especially with the Everest pizza. Kudos to Mountain Mike's

It's a good pizza. I have not had anything else there. The Mikes in San Jose had good cocktails.

So 1st of all the service for pizza is a long time for a pizza but the good thing is that they are nice to you the pizza is great and ya but the service tho This why I give it a 2star read more