I haven't had such a good pizza in a long time and especially the butter chicken one that one tastes so good and makes your mouth so watery overall such a good experience staff was also very nice and helpful. 100% would come back read more

When I order delivery this is where I order from. My favorite is the hot bbq chicken pizza and the "it's Friday" bread. While I do get severe heartburn I still order my favorites and deal with the pain later. I have had most of the menu but these are my go to when I'm feeling delivery pizza. They have many options to choose from whether you want fried ravioli calzones salads wings bread sticks or pizzas you can find it here. Prices are fair for the market rate. read more

Nice little spot to stop at for lunch on the way home from a visit to Pinnacles National Park. Quality pizza with good flavors, well textured dough/crust. Very friendly staff. read more

It changed ownership and is no longer the same pizza. It is good, 3.5/5 It is close to tandorri pizza now. read more

Gluten free options are always helpful. Great cauliflower crust. My pizza was amazing and if that were the only one we got, it would be a 5 star rating. My wife got a veggie that was missing half of the ingredients, which was odd. It was still tasty, but... left us feeling like we didn't quite get what we paid for. read more

Very, very, very good pizza very first time I tried it today. The gentleman was very friendly. I didn't have to ask for peppers or cheese. He asked me. Pizza was crispy as I asked cheesy and very flavorful. Definitely recommended and definitely will go back plus the pricing is on point! On top of that I ordered it weird and I kind of felt like I did online. They gave me a call to verify how I wanted my pizza. Good job Valley pizzeria! read more

Change of ownership had left this place wanting for everything 1) Service 2) Quality of Toppings Basically under new ownership This PIZZA SHOP IS A BUST read more

Delicious! Traveling from out of town and visiting a friend here. I always prefer to support small businesses whenever I can while traveling. I love the pizza options so thought I'd give it a try! We ordered a half hot barbecue chicken (seriously so good and flavorful) and half pineapple and jalapeño it did not disappoint! Satisfies my pizza craving. Helpful, friendly and kind service. 10/10 recommend read more

We went there saturday morning and had the best pizza and cheesy bread also the best service from the restaurant owner. The place is clean and helps make your pizza even more enjoyable. We had the bbq chicken pizza and the combo and they were both amazing, the pizza is flavorful and not greasy and the dough is nice and crunchy! The cheesy bread is full of flavor and not greasy which I love! One of me favorite pizza places and 100% the pizza place with the best service. read more

Valley Pizzeria - Cheesy Bread - Pizza Near Me - Hollister, California

See all

I used to love this place, it was by far the best pizza in town. Under the new ownership, things have gone downhill. I've been there 3 times under the new ownership and each time there was a problem. My first experience, the driver tried to take off without giving me any change back when I gave him a $50 for a $30 pizza and acted surprised when I wanted some of my change back. This time the online ordering wouldn't work, when I picked up the pizza, it wasn't what I ordered so they remade it. When I ate the new one, it tasted like they scraped the toppings off the first one and re-cooked it. Overall, it was flavorless. I asked for extra sauce and there was barely any sauce in it. I won't be going back any time soon! read more

Valley Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hollister, California

Reviewing just the Indian food. Had the chai and the chicken curry for lunch. Chai tasted homemade. It was nice to have chai that didn't taste exactly like a clone of every other one. The chicken curry was very good. It would be too spicy for someone with no spice tolerance but was just right for me. Good mouthfeel from the ground spices; I could tell that the spice mixture was homemade. Not excessively oily. I needed rice (see below). Be careful on a DoorDash order, though, which this was: the "rice included with curries" didn't happen. Also the dessert I wanted didn't arrive. These may have been user error on the part of the person putting in the DoorDash order since I didn't do the order myself. read more

Was not impress, pizza had no favor it was cold. I should have open the box to see,if it was fresh, it look like it was a day old.

Food is ok. Clean dinning room. Service could use some attention, I used on line ordering it was a fiasco. I ordered but business was closed and waited til get confirmation but never got it. Called 5 times in a 30min spand no answer. Went to business but it was closed. My bank account was charged. Not happy with charging when they are not open. Never will go or order from there. read more

Valley pizzeria I'm not sure if it's still there, but when I was there, I had the best wings, buffalo wings and the pizza place and a salad. I'm there. I'm not sure what it is today but the Indian man that made my buffalo wings. what is the best buffalo wing maker on the West Coast and believe me I've been up and down in a few time is it more than I can tell you please come please tip please clean up after yourself read more

they changed the recipes on mostly everything with a cheaper option, even though they posted that they didn't change anything on the menu? I ordered a sandwich and I remember it always had a homemade creamy ranch sauce now it had freaking 1000 island?! Not to mention the price update...... they say bc price goes up but they have tomatoes paste as the marinara for the raveolies? Another thing to add I'm looking at the reviews rn and all I see is the owner trying to prove his point without hearing the customers? DO BETTER don't lie saying you didn't change the recipes. read more

Looks like they've changed their menu, fewer Indian food options now. I've ordered both Indian food and pizza from here. Twice through DoorDash (butter chicken and pizza) and another time by phone (dal makhani). I would say they both came out really good, especially since there aren't any other Indian restaurants in Hollister. read more

they changed there recipe for the sandwiches for a cheaper option totally different. even though they posted they never changed the menu? I miss the old owners these people dont care about customers or quality not to mention rude on the phone! read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch--first time under the new ownership. Had a nice chat w/the proprietor, and ordered the butter chicken pizza. Excellent! Chicken tender and tasty, spiced just right--and the crust was perfect: crisp without being burnt. Good luck to these folks. I was the only one there during the noon hour. Hollister so lacks ethnic cuisine, and I really hope they make it. I'll be back for the Indian specialties, served F-SAT-SUN. read more

The curry pizza is sooooooo good!!! The staff was so friendly and helpful with our big group!

This place is amazing hands down , had dinner with family today 10/10 . The pizza is best and the owners are very gentle and nice chat with them about an hour very generous people . must try the butter chicken pizza and Italian job . Would recommend to All in Hollister we have hidden gem go try it . read more

Tried to order for pickup and was calling from private/restricted number from my work phone. They didn't ask for a contact number and refused to take my order unless I called from an identifiable number. I've never had an issue ordering from here before, or any other place in town, nor have my colleagues. Come to find out, this place is under new ownership. Sadly, this experience was enough for us to choose to go elsewhere for pizza from now on. Edit: ended up calling Mountain Mike's and made a seamless order and pickup. To the owner and your response: customer service is obviously lacking. You could've asked for a number and called to confirm. No other business has ever set these ridiculous standards for ordering. As a private business, you can do what you want and give whatever reasoning. As a customer, I have the ability to take my business elsewhere. And you should always remember, bad news travels faster than good news. And patrons are more likely to share their bad experiences than good ones. And since this has never happened in the past, and we've been patrons since it originally opened....the only change is the new ownership. Which is relevant to this new policy. Well, that and our lack of support for this business moving forward. Good luck. read more

This place has gone down hill. The new owner SK S is a real gem. He makes a scene in the local posts about his business then deletes his comments and blocks the customers. Nothing they do is their issue and the customer is never right. The food quality has gone down. The ingredients are not what they use to be and the food size/quantity has also changed. I'll never be a customer again just based on this owners business approach and attitude. You sir have done yourself in. You can't act like this in a small town and think people won't talk. We miss the previous owners. But change is inevitable and unfortunately the new owners don't make the cut. read more

Service and quality have dropped tremendously. Honestly sad being that the pizza was amazing as well as the customer service before the change of ownership. I feel like it has gotten cheap and just trying to make a dollar. I get it's tough times now but this was an immediate change as soon it changed ownership. I had a calzone before the change and it was amazing!!! A month later went back and ordered exact same thing and it was so different. Not cooked well and barely any cheese. I will no longer come here. This use to be my go to spot. Oh well read more

10/10 yummy pizza. Great service from staff. Very good pizza and highly recommended fried ravs. They have thick or thin pizza - I went with the thick pizza. Really cool inside, games and such. Lots of seating read more

our favorite pizza in town besides mountain Mikes, the marhgarita is my favorie sooo good also my favorite thing is how sweet the employees always are when we do go in to eat or pick up but its usually always delivery read more

I ordered a combo to go and a beer while it was cooking. Finished my beer and still had to wait quite a while. No problem, quality takes time. When I got to my hotel and opened the box, the pizza was way more than well done, borderline burnt. read more

I don't know what happened to this place used to be great. Now the service is terrible. The prices have increased and the delivery times have nearly doubled. read more

This review is based on my first visit to this pizza joint. I'm not from the area and wanted to be able to feed several hungry mouths. This place just happened to be nearby, so I called and placed my order. Pizza was ready within 25 minutes. I ordered an XL combo. Pick up was easy since there wasn't a line. The pizza had plenty of toppings, good flavors and freshness, and a nice crust. I thought the price was pretty good too, around $30. Good to know there's a place to get great pizza in town. I'll keep them bookmarked, so I don't forget their name. read more

No where in my review did I state I wanted the crust thinner the crust is not the same as before way to thin and the flavor is no longer the same As far as how many hours it took me to call is due to me having a sandwich prior to eating the pizza if you want to be technical about it so I ate sandwich first then had the pizza after Stating I have placed one order in one year is not a true statement maybe one order I placed for delivery it does not count the many times I would walk in and place an order to go you do not ask for my number when I walk in The only thing I will miss at your business will be the delivery driver she delivered many meals to me either when my husband called or myself It is all in how you talk to people and your response speaks volumes when I called to order when I called to talk about the pizza and your response below read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service. I ordered a cheese pizza with black olives. Pizza could not have been more fresh. Tasted great. Service was fast and friendly. Dining room quite clean. Convenient parking right outside the door. Relatively clean men's room. read more

All of the food was so good! We got a half cheese half garden pizza, a chicken pizza, and a combo pizza. My favorite was definitely the chicken alfredo pizza, it tasted so good dipped in ranch! We also got the beer battered fries and the garlic cheesy bread. They were having a special where the garlic cheesy bread was $2 per box! My family got a massive amount of food for just $100 which felt like great value and we enjoyed everything. My only complaint is that the person handing us our order was not wearing a mask. read more

See all

The pizza was ok , my only complaint is that the pizza I ordered was supposed to have chicken, I even paid extra. And it did not have any chicken. Also the crust wasn't my favorite. I am willing to try them again because I do want to try the butter chicken pizza . read more

Solid pizza!! If I'm in Hollister and craving pizza this place hits the spot. The crust is cooked similar to how Round Table does their pizza, which I love. This is definitelyy the "go to" pizza for me. read more

This review is strictly on tonight's order. Normally, we have great experiences and I realize this most likely was the company in which they purchased the mozzarella sticks from. After waiting over an hour for our food, out of our order of mozzarella cheese sticks, only one had cheese! It was all crust, not even melted cheese in the container it was delivered in. My husband called immediately and all we were told was, "oh will write a note for a discount next time"! No offer to remake, or replace with another item, just a quick, "thanks for the heads up, bye"! read more

Valley Pizzeria - Mozzarella cheese sticks, minus the cheese! Lol - Pizza Near Me - Hollister, California

Carnivore Pizza FTW! The Islander is great too and I add jalapeños. Consistently good product and service! read more

Fast friendly service. I phone order ahead of time from San Jose , to pick up on my way. Pizza is always ready . Fair enough prices. And excellent pizza , Rather your dining in or take out , It's a clean nice place . It's my favorite go to place for a fast dinner after work . There's a lot of construction going on right now by the business , so it's important that we help keep the business going. I ordered on line It's a easy to use and understand website And i can order ahead of time and pick a time slot to pick up the pizza. read more

Favorite pizza spot in all of Hollister! Pizza is always super good. Their wings are BOMB! We love them, they are spicy without being overly so. Their jalapeno poppers are also AMAZING. My only complaint is their servings of individual ranch are too small and they charge for them. If I pay for them, then at least give me a large serving for it! However, we still keep coming. Love supporting a local spot. read more

Holister is lucky to have this gem of a pizzeria in their town! Thank you to SK (nicest owner ever!) for your commitment to highest quality and handmade ingredients. Definitely plan to come back next time driving through! read more

Good food. Pizza is really good. The wings could be bigger for the price. Service with a smile. Family friendly environment. I like the pizza and wings read more

Service is good. Found a small dark hair on the pizza and even besides that, food was just alright. It used to be much better before the ownership changed. The regular crust, which used to be amazing, is more like a crispy thin crust now and the pizzas seem to have gotten smaller. This used to be our go to but we're going to find a new spot. read more