If you're heading to the mountains for the weekend or planning a camping trip, make sure to stop by…read moreand grab breakfast or lunch here! Not only is the food absolutely delicious, but they use premium-quality ingredients that really set them apart. The bread on their sandwiches is fantastic, and they've recently started using beef tallow for their French fries, chicken sandwiches, and wings which takes the flavor to another level. They also offer gluten-free options, making it a great choice for everyone. It's a smaller establishment, so be patient if there's a wait it's 100% worth it. The customer service is beyond what I've experienced at some high-end restaurants. While waiting for my food, I got to witness the teamwork and communication between the kitchen staff and front counter crew. These guys were hustling, working efficiently, and clearly taking pride in what they do. It was genuinely impressive to watch. Whether you're stopping in with friends and family or grabbing a meal solo, the atmosphere is welcoming, the music is great, and the overall vibe is positive and upbeat. Do yourself a favor and stop by, you can thank me later! And whatever you do, don't leave without trying one of their homemade ice cream sandwiches!

My friend and I were heading towards the mountains and we were hungry. The first…read moreinteresting-looking place we stopped at had closed (it was an odd time on a Sunday afternoon), so we decided to stop at the next interesting place. Otto's was it! The place is small and seemed perpetually busy, so it took a while to get our food. But, there are also lots of interesting things to look at, so it wasn't bad. And the staff was very friendly I ordered the South Carolina BBQ sandwich, and we split an enormous basket of sweet potato fries. We liked that there was frosting to dip them in. My sandwich was good and generous; I only ate half, which meant that I got to enjoy the other half at another time. At first, we were not very impressed with the fries, but we managed to eat them all, so I guess they actually were good!

Great food! I love soup and sandwiches so this is a favorite for lunch to either eat in or get it…read moreto go!

This place is a hidden gem! We eat here every time we are in town. There are several soups…read moreoffered daily and they are all delicious. The bread is some of the best bread I've ever eaten. This time I tried the chicken salad and it was really good too! A+

So cute!! We were passing through town and its was a perfect quick stop! Delicious croissant…read moresandwich + breakfast burrito.

Loved this place! We were visiting FairPlay for the week and this was definitely the best place in…read morethe area. The staff was very kind, efficient, and the food was good! We definitely loved the atmosphere.

The service was excellent, very friendly and inviting. The IPA flight was good, but they were out…read moreof the 6th one. The potato salad had a great flavor, texture but was a smidgen dry, coupled with the jalapeños, picked onion and pickles yuumm. Anyway get the 1/2 rack of ribs. The meat was not fall off the bone. It had to make contact with my teeth. Ohhh!!! the rub on it didn't need bbq sauce. The full lunch was exceptionally prepared.

What a delightful surprise inside Highside Brewing! My partner and I hung out here for a few hours…read morewaiting for our friends to get to the Airbnb (they were bringing all the food) so it was perfect that we got to enjoy some craft brews and freshly smoked BBQ. I got brisket, he got salmon. We shared some sides. It was a perfect date. Plus it was fun hanging out with the guy working the smoker as well as the Highside bartender.

Pastries and coffee too! Looking for a great pastry and a latte come here ! The cinnamon rolls…read moreare wonderful. We ended up having to buy a day old cinnamon roll but they heated it and it tasted fresh and delicious! The chocolate croissants are so flaky. I had them 3 days in a row. The employees are all so friendly. The baker is so nice and I enjoyed talking to her about FairPlay and taking time off in winter to go somewhere warm like South Padre, Texas or Hawaii. They also make great sandwiches. We grabbed some for a day out and about. Loaded with meat and made fresh. And of course we had the ice cream one afternoon. Creamy and smooth- full of flavor. Stop by here you will not be disappointed! (Skip the other coffee place and come here ) Cute old fashioned ice cream decor. Indoor and outdoor seating.

Quaint, charming ice cream shop. The quality of the ice cream is delicious, the cookies are…read moreamazing. The staff are super friendly. The patio outside is comfortable and spacious. Would definitely come back!

Good food and great service. My husband left his hat on the table and the waiter ran out and…read morebrought it to our car.

the food and staff are great. Juat don't do the Burrito challenge, it's a scam. The burrito is more…read morelike 6 pounds and is mostly rice. hardly any actual meat inside which is a shame because the regular burrito is very tasty. we'll definitely eat there again just stick to the regular menu

Service was awesome, very laid back place with outside seating. This is the BEST meal we had…read morevisiting the Denver area. Absolutely worth the trip. The BBQ was tender and delicious. I have never had green chili before and it was so good. The beer with it was spectacular!

This place is amazing. For a small town up in Fairplay, Colorado. This town really needed a…read moredelicious brewery with scrumptious smoked food. We ordered smoked chicken wings, a turkey smoked club with avocado sandwich, barbecued nachos, with smoked chicken, added on top, macaroni and cheese, potato salad and coleslaw. I know this seems like a lot of food, but there were 5 of us, we all shard. The macaroni and cheese was very cheesy, the turkey club had lettuce tomato gouda cheese on Texas toast. The nachos had a little bit of everything. Beans, cheese, sour cream, black olives, it was very good. The waitress was amazing very attentive. She was also the bartender, and they have 8 different beer on tap. And several non alcoholic drinks to choose from as well. When you pull in, you can smell the smokers, one of the best smells in the world. Because this is also a bar.They had several big screen TV. Several arcade games and a shuffleboard. Huge patio outside and it's pet friendly. Where can you go wrong if you're up in Fairplay Co. This is a must see. Check it out. If you like my review's follow me.

Bartender was rude but at least the fries made up for it somewhat. Side salad was good as well and…read moreseemed fresh

Amazing Bison and traditional burgers! So peaceful to sit on back deck and watch fishermen and…read moreMountain View.

Was stuck in Fairplay yesterday during total white out conditions with all the roads in and out of…read moreFairplay shut down. The staff were super friendly, helpful and let us bunker down in the store for a few hours in the hopes that the windstorm would die down. The storm did not let up and we ended up spending the night with about 350 people at the high school which was set up as an emergency shelter. Really appreciate the team's hospitality and support during a very stressful time. We live in Chicago and are relocating out to Bailey and would come back again to show our support!

Out of almost all pizza toppings. Tried to order a sandwich, but they were out of almost…read moreeverything. Food prep person was out on a break enjoying the herb when we were trying to get our sandwich order placed.

Start to finish a great experience…read more Met the owners, Bill and Robbin and understood why it was so good!!

the food has gone downhill in the past year. I use to recommend this place to people. I tell them…read moreto go to the Java Moose for great sandwiches instead. Colton