Mr Pickle&#x27;s Sandwich Shop

10

234

159

9 months ago

I love this place! I'm use to the SLO location this was first time visiting this location! Staff was super friendly and they have a restroom unlike SLO, ha ha. We ordered the BIG Jake and the Goomba. Both sandwiches were so good! All the ingredients are great as always! :) we had one for lunch and one for dinner! We ordered both sandwiches on the Dutch crunch bread which is great!! It's a must!! read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hey Tiffany,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William R.

22

56

11

3 months ago

We used to have a Mr. Pickle's in Templeton but the location was challenging and they did not stay there very long. Fortunately, Atascadero has one and although it is farther away, it is worth the trip to get there. They serve up the best selection of sandwiches in the area. The service is consistently good and congenial. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

We really appreciate you making the drive to support us here in…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dan L.

166

36

0

2 months ago

Very good fast food sandwiches. This is a counter pick up sandwich shop. Normal atmosphere. Service is prompt and courtious.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dan, we are so glad to hear you had a wonderful experience ,with some…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paula W.

0

17

0

2 months ago

Used app to order food an hour early with requested time: sandwiches were delicious, but I did have to park with my dogs and wait 10 mins past due read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for the fantastic feedback Paula, we are so happy to hear…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tiffany L.

269

194

692

2 years ago

I had ordered from here on doordash multiple times, and honestly Mr. Pickles never miss! The sandwiches are always super yummy and very filling- considering how much the sandwiches are, I'm glad they're still filling the sandwich as much as they can. I appreciate that each sandwich comes with a cookie (sometimes two cookies!) and is perfect for any meal. My usual order is the Mrs. Pickle on a dutch crunch but tried the Hero and it was SO good! I haven't really ordered at the location, but they've always gotten my orders right and handled it with care- that's enough for me to appreciate the staff's hard work :) read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Kickin' Chicken in a gluten free wrap :) - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - The Hero on a dutch crunch roll (no tomatoes) - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Free cookies!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for your glowing review, Tiffany! We're delighted to hear…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Frank H.

18

1250

0

10 months ago

I went into this sandwich shop this morning at 10:00. I chose a sandwich to go, it was a pastrami on dutch bread, had some letters that started out the name of the sandwich The sandwich was very good, and this is the first pastrami sandwich I have had in years that did not skimp on the meat. Mine had cheese mustard and pickles and a great deal of pastrami. The sandwich was ready quickly, loke less than five minutes. The staff here seems to appreciate the customer. This place is very narrow from left to right but it is a long restaurant. There are old historic photos, very large one to check out. I am not from the area so they were of interest to me. I get over to this part of SLO county frequently, so I will be back to try other sandwiches. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Frank, thanks for visiting Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop this…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cassie W.

61

1

0

1 year ago

Delicious! Restaurant was very clean and all the staff was very nice. I arrived early and waited for them to finish my order, they sped up the process and gave it to me Early. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hey Cassie,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael B.

0

7

0

8 months ago

Food and service is great and the people are very friendly. Everyone i know i tell them to go there.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hey Michael,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jenell B.

54

29

0

1 year ago

I ordered a tri-tip salad. Not on the menu anymore, but they will still make it! Love the thin sliced meat! The order was correct and on time! read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for your fantastic review, Jenell! We're delighted to hear…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael G.

2

71

53

1 year ago

Pretty much every sandwich is amazing. Their Dutch bread is a must. Always quick and friendly. They havnt missed yet. Oh... one thing.... They charge extra for a pickle.... I'm just saying.... If your name is Mr Pickle.... Might wanna just add one to the bag. Very good tho. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you, Michael! We're delighted to hear that you love our…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Leo B.

11

276

214

2 years ago

Love the food and fast service here for a great Italian meat sandwich with the delicious bread. Get the meal deal and it's even better. Quiet spot to eat in or take to go! Will be back again! read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Leo, thank you for your 5-star review of Mr. Pickle's Sandwich…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Sally S.

49

568

0

3 years ago

The bread and sandwich contents were great. Thank goodness we double checked our online order. They handed over sandwiches but hadn't also packed drinks chips potato salad and pickle we ordered. Dah check the order. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Sally, thank you for sharing your feedback on your recent visit to…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Raquel M.

0

50

9

2 years ago

I had eaten there several years ago & really liked it. This time had the GOAT & was meh. Freshness & flavor were lacking. Expensive for just above Subway quality. I much prefer Jersey Mikes. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Raquel,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Oliver S.

4

16

0

2 years ago

Good sandwiches, decent price, nice services, nice pictures on cities history hanging on the walls.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Oliver,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

J. Brenton W.

77

88

11

2 years ago

Second time here at this location! Excellent service and great staff! I had the hot beef sandwich this time! OMG delish!!! I also love the free cookie!!! I love all the great signs ! Nice inside and out ! Super clean ! Go get ya some! read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Got Beef! - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dear J. Brenton W., thank you for recommending Mr. Pickle's Sandwich…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steve L.

2

135

26

3 years ago

I used to live in the bay area and was visiting Atascadero over Thanksgiving, to my surprise stumbled on a Mr. Pickle's! Dutch crunch is in it's own league, if you haven't had it, run don't walk to try it here. I split the Mr. Pickle and the spicy chicken sando with the works, would recommend both. Free cookie is always solid too! read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Steve,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William R.

1

44

68

3 years ago

I've been coming to this spot for 4 years, and it's always spot on. I've tried the Italian, Mr. Pickle, and for the kids the pb&j. I've tried more but can't recall the names at the moment. What I know is that it's always good, and the servings are big. The Dutch bread is always my favorite but the other breads are also good. The service is always quick, and the staff is friendly. The vibe is friendly and has always been of the highest caliber. The prices are high, it the quality of the food makes it okay. The last meal I got came with chips and a cookie too. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dear William, thank you for being a loyal customer of Mr. Pickle's…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Francesca Z.

Elite 24

167

96

50

2 years ago

Severely lacking in safe food handling practices and terrible attitude towards allergy notices. If you don't respect allergy safety, you put people's lives at risk and contribute to the lack of trust in safe food handling at restaurants. Do not eat here if you have any concerns with cross contamination or allergy exposure. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dear Francesca,…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Veronica C.

138

72

24

2 years ago

Great service, fabulous sandwich (Santa Maria tri tip on Dutch bread with horseradish sauce, no garlic sauce). The cookie! Omg the cookie. Clean restaurant and restroom. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Veronica, thank you for your fantastic review of Mr. Pickle's…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Don M.

Elite 24

6

65

21

3 years ago

Fresh, fast and friendly. Meat was piled high, veggies were crunchy and sandwich was out together and wrapped well. Staff were engaging and prompt and asked how my day was going, even though they were clearly slammed. Love the Dutch crunch bread. Place was clean and easy to park. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Don, thank you for your 5-star review of Mr. Pickle's Sandwich…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Chad C.

202

85

26

2 years ago

Fresh baked sour dough bread. Great pickles all around a great lunch spot! Don't forget to try the fresh baked chocolate chip cookies.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for your wonderful review, Chad! We're so glad to hear that…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

T. Deaun E.

0

60

97

2 years ago

I ordered my sandwich via grubhub and it came fairly fast it was delicious. All of the ingredients tasted fresh and it was larger than I expected. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for your amazing review, T! We're delighted to hear that…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John H.

55

97

105

2 years ago

Great food. Great service. I'm so glad I stopped in. I got the hang loose and it was amazing!!!! I'll be back

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi John, thank you for the fantastic review of Mr. Pickle's Sandwich…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Chris V.

43

27

0

2 years ago

Always good. Great bread which really makes the sandwich. Fresh meats. Tried a variety of sandwiches and they all have been delicious.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Chris,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

William L.

0

16

1

3 years ago

Second time reviewing these guys but felt compelled because of the excellent customer service the staff gave us. And all of our orders were made correctly and were delicious! Thank you for another great experience. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for the kind words, William! We are thrilled to hear that…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cyndi D.

11

75

68

3 years ago

Great service, fresh Dutch crunch bread, loved the free cookie...the sandwich would have been great, but WAY too much pickle. My son rolled his eyes and said, "Duh, mom...it's called Mr. pickles for a reason!" Next time I'll order and hold the pickle. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Cyndi, thank you for sharing your feedback on your recent visit to…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Donna J.

39

31

0

3 years ago

Went there yesterday. I was in a hurry and didn't look at the menu. Ordered a tuna wrap. Nothing else. They charged over $14.00! The tortilla was dry and pieces would actually flake off. Never again! read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dear Donna, we apologize for your disappointing experience at Mr.…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lou R.

4

3

1

3 years ago

Food was delicious and well made. It's too bad the floors behind the counter were disgusting. Bread, meat and other sandwich fixings were all over the the place . The staff never cleaned it up and were constantly walking through it. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Dear Lou, thanks for taking the time to leave a review about your…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shayne C.

3

9

3

2 years ago

Food: delicious sandwich, I got the Mr. Pickle and enjoyed it. Service: People were very friendly and quick Ambiance: great little sandwich shop Overall: a little pricy, but worth checking out! Expect to pay ~$35 for 2 read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Shayne, thank you for the glowing review of Mr. Pickle's Sandwich…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laura V.

0

78

1

3 years ago

Food ready on time. Made a quick stop off 101. In a grocery store parking lot. Parking and signage a bit tricky but we figured it out. Sandwiches were exactly as ordered and ready at pickup location. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Laura, thank you for your review! We're glad to hear that your…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erin K.

397

2073

14349

7 years ago

I came in here with my husband a little while ago and I have to say, the young man behind the counter named Joel is the reason I'm giving this 5 stars instead of 4. Great sandwiches, fresh ingredients and tasty food, but Joel put things over the top by chatting with us, being friendly and upbeat and just going above and beyond to make us feel welcome. I'll stop here next time we're driving through and feel a little peckish! read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Mary W.

55

1045

233

3 years ago

Clean restaurant, efficient and helpful staff. Good bread and fresh fixings. Easy parking near Vons.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thanks Mary, we're glad it was easy to get to our delicious…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Larry H.

99

17

1

3 years ago

They have the best sandwiches in A town! Their staff is soo friendly and always goes above and beyond to help their customers!

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for your high praise and compliments, Larry! We look…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John S.

3

70

1

3 years ago

This was my first time here. I was promptly greeted, the sandwich was was delicious. Great customer service.

Business owner information

Christy H.

Thank you for the 5 star review John!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Edward S.

0

18

0

3 years ago

Professional and customer friendly, the staff are exceptional and always service orientated

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Cheri I.

400

20

2

3 years ago

I took a trip up to the Bay Area to see my daughter and she surprised me with a veg sandwich from Mr Pickles. The crunch bread was phenomenal! The meat replacement also did not disappoint. I wish we had Mr Pickles in SoCal, but since we don't I will make sure and grab a sandwich every time I'm up that way. read more

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Cheri, Thank you so much for your kind words! We are humbled! We…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sam F.

0

2

1

3 years ago

Found two whole peppers, stem and all. The second one had a nice long brown hair attached. Very dissatisfied. They also put chilis on my mothers sandwich even though she asked 2x for no chilis and they repeated it back to her. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Found two whole peppers, stem and all. The second one had a nice long brown hair attached. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Business owner information

Christy H.

Hi Sam, thank you for sharing your experience at Mr. Pickle's…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kylie W.

Elite 23

219

231

336

5 years ago

I was slightly disappointed in this shop. The sandwich itself was fine (turkey, cheese, Mayo, mustard- nothing fancy). But, the prices are ridiculous. Half a sandwich was $6. The team members weren't the friendliest. They didn't do anything specific, they just didn't do anything in general. No help, blunt, and in a rush. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 4

See more reviews

More info about Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop

7177 El Camino Real
Atascadero, CA 93422
Directions
(805) 538-5112
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://www.mrpickles.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop open?

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop opens at 10:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.

What time does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop close?

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop closes at 8:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop is closed on Sunday.

Mon-Sat 10:00 AM - 8:00 PMSun Closed

Payment methods

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop take credit cards?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have catering options?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop does have catering options.

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop serve alcohol?

No, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop allow dogs?

No, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop does not allow dogs.

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have TVs?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have bike parking?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop has bike parking.

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have outdoor seating?

No, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop does not have outdoor seating options.

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have parking?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop is wheelchair accessible.

Does Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop have free WiFi?

No, Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop does not have free WiFi.

More Info

Special Hours

You might also consider

Colony Sandwich

4.0(262 reviews)

Sandwiches are not normal here but they are fantastic. Had a chance to check out this place and…read morethe ambiance was really cool which is what caught my attention at first. Tried the Monte Cristo and it was not heavy with frying oil which is a great! The jam it came with matched the savory of the meat inside perfectly. A very solid sandwich, wish it came with a side of fries or chips though but that was extra it looks like. After wards I saw they had homemade hand dipped ice cream bars and thought I would try one. It was AMAZING and so good. The table next to me as asking about it and hopefully they got one as well later. The ice cream was really smooth and not over sweet, the nuts on the bar that I got were the perfect texture. The size of the bar was pretty hefty as well, almost good for sharing after a meal there. Staff was friendly and attentive so bonus points there. Favorite dish: Chocolate hand-dipped vanilla ice cream bar with peanuts and almonds. Go out and EAT!

Love the outdoor seating here and the sandwiches are loaded up pretty good! It can take a little…read morewhile for the food to come out but all around the service and food was good.

Tater Tots

See all

Jonnyboy’s Bagelry & Jewish Delicatessen

4.4(125 reviews)

As a kid I grew up in L.A. in the 1970's fortunate enough to eat at one of the great Jewish Deli…read moreabout every 2 weeks. Wherever you lived in L.A, you likely were partial to the delis nearest to you. For me I was partial to Nate n' Als, Label's Tables, and Langers. Each place had their own style. So it goes without saying that I have my own opinion of what I like in a corned beef sandwich. Get together with a person from New York, and get ready for an argument ;-) It's not always easy to find deli's that serve the kind of corned beet I grew up eating. It's got to be made there, stacked high enough, tender, just the right amount of fat, warm, moist and brined just right. Johnny Boy's nailed it. I got a Reuben, without the cheese. The rye was toasted and buttered or oiled just right, the sauerkraut spot on, and the corned beef delicious and ample. There was some extra spiciness that I liked, which almost made me think it was pastrami. I don't know if it was in the corned beef or in the sauerkraut or Russian dressing. Boy was it tasty. I was delighted they had chopped liver, not something you find everywhere. Nate n' Als used to make the best chopped liver. Light and sweet in both flavor and its appearance. Johnnyboys' was darker in appearance, creamy, and creative in its presentation. They placed cut up pickled cucumbers and onions on top of it. Delicious. Again, I felt it was generous in it's serving size along with some rye bread. And I must say, their prices were much lower compared to many of the better deli's I've been to in bigger cities. We ate outside, and because of the way it faces, we were nicely shaded. For those unfamiliar with Atascadero, it can get pretty hot. I liked that it was off the main drag, and it faced an office machinery store which took me back to my childhood. It's a quaint street with some cute stores and small eateries, a pie place next door, and some coffeehouse. Pull over if you're traveling on 101 and you're ready to eat or want to bring home dinner or lunch. I was on my way North to see my brother and he said, "We don't have a good deli here. Next time bring me a corned beef sandwhich". I will :-)

Jewish Deli, I'm headed straight for it everytime (BTW - also true for an Italian Deli, Armenian…read moreDeli, Persian Deli, Greek Deli, etc). Of course, whenever I think of a Jewish one, Pastrami, Corned Beef, pickles, bagels, are top of mind. Cute outside seating, a few deli refrigerators filled with amazing delights, bagels atop, and a busy busy ordering kitchen. At 11am, all the magic was complete in the back baking kitchen. Note: Closed Monday's and Tuesday's, dang it. It has a small menu, but it's mighty. I ordered a couple of bagels "to go", $3 each, and the next day, I had one and it was amazing with a great chewy texture. But the main item was a Corned Beef Reuben [$extra meat$ -- which I did]...wow. One of the best I've had. The meat was almost shaved, not sliced, and I loved the softness with each bite. [Significant update] I was a little disgusted at what I saw. The cashier dude had the dirtiest cap I've ever seen with old sweat stains. The cook had massive hair and no hair net or hat. Yucka.

Inside counter

Avocado Tartine

See all

Entrance

Atascadero Bistro

4.4(204 reviews)

0.3 mi

One of the best breakfasts I've had in a looong time! Seasoned, simple, delicious and absolutely…read morewill be going back as much as possible!

We just had Atascadero Bistro it was so delicious. We loved the cowboy sandwiches the bread was so…read moresoft and tasty . We will definitely be coming back.

Atascadero Scramble

See all

Nice and smooth coffee

Back Porch Bakery

4.4(324 reviews)

5 stars for food and service. 2 stars for the display case and presentation. Suggest a painter for…read morethe inside of the case. Also the items were in the dark. Possibly an electrician could have suggestions. LED strips ? Also images of breakfast and lunch choices displayed would be very nice. We will return.

Came in early on a Wednesday morning and thought the storefront and inside the bakery was very…read morecute. Maybe it was too early, but I did notice that it was a bit dim inside. I could barely see the pastries in the case. No worries though, I saw what I came in for. Purchased a French baguette for $3.70. Beyond amazed at the price. Excited to have some with my coffee, I ripped off a piece almost immediately and noticed the nice crust on the outside. 5 stars for the crust!! As for the flavor, it seemed a little flat. It was lacking some of the wheaty-tangy flavor you would get from a longer prove/fermentation. The inside of it was also missing all those nice deep pockets you see in a French baguette. Overall, not a bad baguette, but not one that you yearn for. I'd like to mention the young lady Annabel I had the privilege of meeting outside of the bakery. She was on a delivery run, but told me about their IG page, and we had a wonderful chat about cookies. Thank you for your time, Annabel, you are awesome!

Morning Bun, Chocolate Croissant and muffin

See all

Mediterranean Spice

4.4(27 reviews)

0.1 mi

Hidden gem during our visit to the area. Large portions, fair price and cooked well…read more We had the mixed grill platter with the kofta being our favorite.

Clean basic restaurants set up with limited staff but fast service . Food was amazing and fresh …read more Everything was made from scratch. Plates , wrap and pizzas were amazing. Chicken shawarma platter , buffalo chicken pizza, veg wrap were our favorites, we tried a lot of other items too . Definitely recommend.

Mediterranean Spice interior

Sampler Platter

See all

Self-serve cutlery

Jersey Mike's Subs

2.7(15 reviews)

0.8 mi

I had one of the worst experiences I've ever had at Jersey Mike's Subs, and it came directly from…read morethe manager, Maria. She was taking multiple orders at once and asked three customers what they wanted--I was the third. I clearly ordered an Italian with double meat. She repeated it back correctly, so there was no confusion on my end. When the sandwich was made, it was obvious it did not have double meat. I calmly pointed it out, and instead of correcting it, she argued with me--saying "that's extra meat." I clarified again: I ordered double meat and understand the difference. Her response? A dismissive tone and "well then it will be a double charge," as if I wasn't already aware of that. That's literally what I ordered. From there, her attitude completely deteriorated--eye rolling, snapping back, and accusing me of being rude for simply asking to receive what I paid for. When I asked for a manager, she said she was the manager. That's the real issue here. If this is how management handles basic customer interactions--arguing, dismissing, and deflecting instead of correcting a simple mistake--there's a serious leadership problem at this location. I don't mind paying for quality. I do mind being talked down to and treated like I'm the problem for expecting my order to be right. I've been coming in pretty regularly, but that ends today, I'll never come back to this location Do better.

I ordered online and was waiting at the counter, the cashier completely ignored me and took a…read morecustomer who had come in to order. My order took over 25 minutes from the time I ordered until ready. I order online for convenience and speed, still waiting. Tables not clean. Food on the floor. I like their food. I don't like their service. I finally see my sandwich sitting over there. No one is wrapping it. If I can figure out how to cancel my order since I've already paid for it I will. To top it all off, after waiting over 30 minutes the employee tells me that they are going to start my order! Seriously? You take every walk up and don't make online orders? I worked fast food, you make the orders in order received, so simple isn't it? The chick asked if I wanted to cancel, asked me very smugly. Yes, yes I do and I'm not sure I'm ever going back. Horrible service.

See all

The Nest

4.5(430 reviews)

1.6 mi

We love going to the Nest. The food is fresh and consistent…read more The toast is always buttered perfectly and the syrup is always warm! The service might even be better than the food.

This is a place to return to. Food, service and atmosphere were enjoyed. Menu was inviting…read more Everything was fresh. Service prompt. What we thought about our specific choices. The turkey wrap seemed too dense and needed to be constructed incorporating air or moisture into the layers of ingredients. The salad was served with the dressing on the side. There was an abundance of baby spinach under a mound of flavorful ingredients. Tossing the salad with the dressing was more than I was looking forward to. It was a great salad otherwise, although if I was to make this at home, I would trim the spinach stems off. They hang out every which way on the fork. They could be reincorporated into the salad by dicing them.

Entry area

Chicken Strip Salad w/Fries

See all

Enclosed Dining

Tea Trolley

4.9(12 reviews)

We had a wonderful visit to the Tea Trolley and decided to enjoy the High Tea. Reservations are a…read moremust! They also offer a Queen's Tea served in the charming backyard, which looked absolutely adorable and made for some wonderful photos. The outdoor seating has a cozy garden feel, with an Alice in Wonderland vibe, while the High Tea room inside is intimate, with just four tables. One table seats four guests, and the other three seat two each. During our visit, it seemed like nearly every table was celebrating a birthday, which added to the festive atmosphere. Atmosphere and decorations are off the chart. We started by choosing our tea from a full page of loose-leaf tea selections. Each tea arrived in an adorable little teapot with a beautiful china teacup. Shortly afterward, we were served a small coleslaw, followed by the classic three-tiered tea tray. The tray included a lovely assortment of finger sandwiches, fresh scones with clotted cream and jam, crumpets with additional preserves, and a top tier filled with miniature pastries and macarons. The portions were just right, leaving you with a sweet finish without feeling overly full. High Tea was $50 per person, which we felt was well worth it for the experience. I'm not sure of the current price for the Queen's Tea. Be sure to leave a little time to browse the gift shop before you go. It's filled with everything tea lovers could want, including beautiful loose-leaf teas, charming teaware, and the cutest fascinator hats. There are also plenty of picture-perfect spots throughout the property, and don't skip the restroom...it's worth a peek! Every detail of the Tea Trolley is thoughtfully decorated, making the entire visit feel like a special occasion. The service was also spot on. Not rushed but thoughtful and kind.

Stopped by to visit from out of town, and this is literally the cutest tea shop that serves…read moreafternoon tea on certain days! Super charming gift shop as well. The owner was super nice and although I barely made it in with about 10 minute before closing she was super welcoming! I bought a few shortbread cookies for gifts and they were cute and delicious! They also have a cute back patio.

See all

Take a pot of tea to the back patio and relax in the most tranquil space with a book,-

Chef Gregory's BBQ Smokehouse Emporium

4.4(45 reviews)

0.4 mi

Excellent food, nice people. This is a local business with a hard working owner making the best bbq…read morein the area. Come and support them!! Online ordering from their website is super easy and convenient also. Highly recommend!!

Lovely people in this establishment! So glad we stopped by to try some tasty bbq. All the plates…read morecome with coleslaw and beans which are tasty, but nothing compared to the meat. Tri-tip - so tender with great flavor. Baby back ribs - deep flavor, tender, and beautiful smoke ring. Ribs came with sauce on the side but I thought they didn't need sauce. Pork belly was tender. Had never had pork belly smoked before but glad we tried a sampling. Only thing I was missing was a slice of white bread. Chef Gregory also shared a sample of the Mac and cheese. He has his own spice blends, and bbq sauce too I believe. You can buy them there as well. Both he and his lady were so friendly to chat with. I wish them all the success, and with food this good, they can't miss!

Just a picture of the front counter area

Pork rib

See all

Front entrance

Sylvester's Burgers

3.8(591 reviews)

0.4 mi

I was hungry... I had just driven about 3 hours to get into town, checked into my hotel (which is…read morealso amazing) and started to try and find food. Several places were closed for the day already and I saw this little corner place that still had the Open sign on. Burgers? Sure, why not, that should fill me up and it sure did! I ordered the regular Old Fashioned (no cheese), side of fries and a drink. Everyone was very friendly and helpful as I've never been to this place to eat before let alone this part of the state! The burger was perfectly cooked at medium and very juicy and delicious! Fried were good, not great but the burger was the star of the meal anyway. But I will say the fries were good once I dipped them in the dripping juices and sauce from the burger. But it was a very hearty burger and after a long drive, really hit the spot! If I'm ever in this area again or see another Sylvester's I will definitely make it a point to visit and try a different burger. Favorite dish: Old Fashioned with no cheese. Go out and EAT!

Cute little restaurant with a very nice outdoor dining area in the back…read more They're special was Local caught black cod with chips. I love fish and chips so I thought it would be very fresh because it was Local caught. French fries or delicious! My husband, I took one bite of the cod and left the rest. It was so fishy it was unpalatable. So it was a little bummed about that. Service was great. You walk up to the front and order your food and pick it up when ready. Probably try burger next time. Because the fresh fish was not so fresh.

Tons of birthday pics on the walls and ceiling

The $5.50 chili fries were small, chili good. But, I could skip next time--frozen fries!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kevin F.

0

6

2

2 years ago

Jersey mikes. subway. firehouse subs. ehhh‍ Then there's Mr. Pickles! C'mon guys, open locations in Bakersfield and LA! You are legit!

Evan R.

122

274

736

7 years ago

No cookies! Very disappointed. I even asked if they were in there. ......................mmmmmmmmmmmhhhhhhhhhhhaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!

Jeff B.

5

122

17

8 years ago

Great sandwich. Thought bread was outstanding and the meats and cheeses were great as well. Very friendly staff

Mike S.

1

45

5

9 years ago

Always a good go to for lunch. The staff is happy and respectful. The sandwiches are super tasty. Win, win.

Mr. S.

10

42

3

2 years ago

Sandwich was good, prices are just dumb. Almost $20 for a sandwich? REALLY!?!?!?!?!?!?

Robert M.

0

5

1

6 years ago

Loved this place, great sandwich great service. Will definitely come back when in town.

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - sandwiches - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop also viewed

Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

3.6

(97 reviews)

first thing the lady at the front counter was super sweet and professional. I got the classic…read morecheesesteak and it was fabulous. I will definitely come back here price not bad food great that works. Thanks K.R..

This was my first trip into Capriotti's. I decided to grab a sandwich to go during an afternoon of…read moreerrands and so I downloaded the app to take advantage of a free sandwich for my first order. This was actually pretty shameless and all you had to do was order one other site item that totaled two dollars and you got a sandwich for It turns out I was ordering before the store opened so I was automatically given a pick up time of half an hour after they opened for the day. I went with a simple tuna fish sandwich on their small sub. The app did not let me know when my sandwich was ready, but I did arrive a few minutes early, and it was all ready to go. I was met by the smiling face of the single employee in the restaurant. My sandwich was already bagged. My name was on it and my chips and extra napkins were inside already. The store was very clean and organized, and I seemed to be the first customer of the day. The sandwich itself was very good. It had a generous amount of filling and was served as represented on the menu. I will have to try Capriotti's again to try a different type of sandwich as I think it's unfair to judge an entire restaurant by a tuna fish sandwich. However, everything was as advertised and I can confidently give this location a thumbs up.

Sequoia Sandwich Company

3.7

(68 reviews)

Every once in a while you come across a place that you truly weren't expecting. It was late…read moreafternoon on Saturday and the Sequoia Sandwich Company was in the process of closing. Their hours are certainly anemic at 11m-3pm most days. The person taking out order couldn't have been nicer. He answered our inquiries ands even guided us to his favorite sandwiches. We ordered a veggie sandwich and Boston pastrami sandwiches. Wow- A flavor explosion in her mouth, she said. I gave her a look, and when I took my first bite, oh my goodness there's something special about this place. Every bite was enjoyed, each chew savored, it was amazing. When i went to give kudos we were rewarded with a free cookie for each. What a joy, what a treasure to have in SLO and it's somewhere we'll be eating often. The pastrami was not your ordinary store bought meat, it tasted old school in our modern world. Overall Grade: A+

Not having everything on your sandwiches and not telling us !!!…read moreJust leaving it off, not acceptable.

Atascadero Bistro

4.4

(204 reviews)

One of the best breakfasts I've had in a looong time! Seasoned, simple, delicious and absolutely…read morewill be going back as much as possible!

We just had Atascadero Bistro it was so delicious. We loved the cowboy sandwiches the bread was so…read moresoft and tasty . We will definitely be coming back.

Templeton Market & Deli

3.9

(116 reviews)

Always great to service and friendly people !! The store is always clean and well stocked ! And the…read moredeli is the best in town ! My favorite are the chicken strips !

When I lived in the area this was the go to place for quick fried food. We stopped by the other day…read moreas we were headed home to grab some chicken strips and a corn dog. Unfortunately it wasn't as good as I remembered and not worth the stop aanymore. The ranch sauce its soooo water down!!! I have to agree with my fellow Yelper Lisa G. When it comes to customer service. You're not going to get it here. You won't even get a smile!

Smash N Roll

3.1

(17 reviews)

This place was recommended by a local winery and thought it was a good spot to grab some food since…read moreI had not prepared to check out any local restaurants. I ordered the lobster roll. ($26) and the Pad Thai Fries ($14) and my friend ordered the Sweet Potato Fries ($12). For the price of seafood I give it a 7 out of 10. The pad Thai fries were okay, but the winner was the sweet potato fries that my friend had ordered. Ordering is basically going up to the food truck and ordering from the window and waiting about 15 to 20 minutes to get your order and you can go sit down anywhere on the property to have your lunch or get it to go. The location is a part of a brewery and they have most of their beer aren't tap with a very large picnic area for seating and dancing

Smash N Roll absolutely nails it. The fried chicken sandwich is phenomenal -- crispy, juicy,…read moreperfectly seasoned, and honestly up there with some of the best Nashville hot chicken I've had. Big statement, but it earns it. The chicken has real crunch without being greasy, the heat is balanced and flavorful (not just spicy for the sake of it), and everything comes together perfectly on the bun. This is one of those sandwiches you keep thinking about after you leave. If you're in Paso Robles or Tin City and craving something indulgent and done right, Smash N Roll is a must. I'll be back -- and I'm ordering the chicken sandwich again without hesitation.

Ben Franklins Deli 2

4.1

(9 reviews)

yes, they have awesome fried chicken!! they serve krispy krunch fried chicken!!! omg it is totally…read moreawesome‼‼‼‼ it's where twisted and glazed was on spring st.

I know this is a new place in town. They are known for great sandwiches at their other location…read more And, I went on their 4th day open. They definitely are not fully set up yet. I will let that slide for now. They will get it dialed in. My experience was good. I only got a sandwich. I made an error in how I ordered it but, no biggie. I was very satisfied with the sandwich and what I paid for it. The one guy that was working at the time was very helpful too. No menu boards are up yet so you have to use a small paper menu. Again, no biggie. There are only a handful of tables to sit at inside too. That's fine for me. I would definitely recommend this place. But, you may want to wait a couple of weeks for them to get everything smoothed out!

Jonnyboy’s Bagelry & Jewish Delicatessen

4.4

(125 reviews)

As a kid I grew up in L.A. in the 1970's fortunate enough to eat at one of the great Jewish Deli…read moreabout every 2 weeks. Wherever you lived in L.A, you likely were partial to the delis nearest to you. For me I was partial to Nate n' Als, Label's Tables, and Langers. Each place had their own style. So it goes without saying that I have my own opinion of what I like in a corned beef sandwich. Get together with a person from New York, and get ready for an argument ;-) It's not always easy to find deli's that serve the kind of corned beet I grew up eating. It's got to be made there, stacked high enough, tender, just the right amount of fat, warm, moist and brined just right. Johnny Boy's nailed it. I got a Reuben, without the cheese. The rye was toasted and buttered or oiled just right, the sauerkraut spot on, and the corned beef delicious and ample. There was some extra spiciness that I liked, which almost made me think it was pastrami. I don't know if it was in the corned beef or in the sauerkraut or Russian dressing. Boy was it tasty. I was delighted they had chopped liver, not something you find everywhere. Nate n' Als used to make the best chopped liver. Light and sweet in both flavor and its appearance. Johnnyboys' was darker in appearance, creamy, and creative in its presentation. They placed cut up pickled cucumbers and onions on top of it. Delicious. Again, I felt it was generous in it's serving size along with some rye bread. And I must say, their prices were much lower compared to many of the better deli's I've been to in bigger cities. We ate outside, and because of the way it faces, we were nicely shaded. For those unfamiliar with Atascadero, it can get pretty hot. I liked that it was off the main drag, and it faced an office machinery store which took me back to my childhood. It's a quaint street with some cute stores and small eateries, a pie place next door, and some coffeehouse. Pull over if you're traveling on 101 and you're ready to eat or want to bring home dinner or lunch. I was on my way North to see my brother and he said, "We don't have a good deli here. Next time bring me a corned beef sandwhich". I will :-)

Jewish Deli, I'm headed straight for it everytime (BTW - also true for an Italian Deli, Armenian…read moreDeli, Persian Deli, Greek Deli, etc). Of course, whenever I think of a Jewish one, Pastrami, Corned Beef, pickles, bagels, are top of mind. Cute outside seating, a few deli refrigerators filled with amazing delights, bagels atop, and a busy busy ordering kitchen. At 11am, all the magic was complete in the back baking kitchen. Note: Closed Monday's and Tuesday's, dang it. It has a small menu, but it's mighty. I ordered a couple of bagels "to go", $3 each, and the next day, I had one and it was amazing with a great chewy texture. But the main item was a Corned Beef Reuben [$extra meat$ -- which I did]...wow. One of the best I've had. The meat was almost shaved, not sliced, and I loved the softness with each bite. [Significant update] I was a little disgusted at what I saw. The cashier dude had the dirtiest cap I've ever seen with old sweat stains. The cook had massive hair and no hair net or hat. Yucka.

The Third Degree

4.1

(70 reviews)

Great burger and service. Came for lunch and tried The Judge burger, it's a traditional California…read morestyle burger topped with pastrami. It was delicious, the potato bun was nice and soft and toasted perfectly. Burger came with a side of chips instead of fries which I enjoyed very much. A bit on the high end for price but anything in Paso will be high. $22 for burger, chips and a drink.

My friend and I decided to split a sandwich from here to go along with salads we had gotten…read moreelsewhere in Paso Market Walk. We were helped by two sisters that look like they were identical twins, but they weren't. They were very polite and helpful. Once we ordered, we were given a food beeper so we could find ourselves a seat we're waiting for our food. It came out quickly and was delicious. All the ingredients were fresh and made from scratch. The grilled cheese was a great compliment to our two salads and we found a lovely seat outside on a gorgeous day to enjoy our lunch. I definitely recommend the third degree if you have a chance to visit the Paso Market Walk!

Templeton Pizza and Greek Food

4.0

(90 reviews)