We used to have a Mr. Pickle's in Templeton but the location was challenging and they did not stay there very long. Fortunately, Atascadero has one and although it is farther away, it is worth the trip to get there. They serve up the best selection of sandwiches in the area. The service is consistently good and congenial. read more

Hit the spot. Hangloose for the win. Get it on dutch crunch and no matter what eat it there. You will not regret it. I might ditch the avocado next time, but 5-6 star sandwich and they know how to do it well. Fixings check, meat check, and dutch crunch check. I got the whole.... I am stuffed but it was so good I am going to eat another one tomorrow. Oh yeah the place is so well staffed they churn through sandwiches quickly. So don't worry about lines.... Get the hang-loose. Your mind and soul will thank you. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Hangloose after battle - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Haven't Been Here In A Very Long Time. But I Love It So Me And SANCHITO Stopped In Now Time To Find The Park And Eat..!!! read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - My Listen Linda Sandwich With Chips And Sweet Tea And Of Course The Free Chocolate Chip Cookie. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

I love this place! I'm use to the SLO location this was first time visiting this location! Staff was super friendly and they have a restroom unlike SLO, ha ha. We ordered the BIG Jake and the Goomba. Both sandwiches were so good! All the ingredients are great as always! :) we had one for lunch and one for dinner! We ordered both sandwiches on the Dutch crunch bread which is great!! It's a must!! read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

I had ordered from here on doordash multiple times, and honestly Mr. Pickles never miss! The sandwiches are always super yummy and very filling- considering how much the sandwiches are, I'm glad they're still filling the sandwich as much as they can. I appreciate that each sandwich comes with a cookie (sometimes two cookies!) and is perfect for any meal. My usual order is the Mrs. Pickle on a dutch crunch but tried the Hero and it was SO good! I haven't really ordered at the location, but they've always gotten my orders right and handled it with care- that's enough for me to appreciate the staff's hard work :) read more

See all

I went into this sandwich shop this morning at 10:00. I chose a sandwich to go, it was a pastrami on dutch bread, had some letters that started out the name of the sandwich The sandwich was very good, and this is the first pastrami sandwich I have had in years that did not skimp on the meat. Mine had cheese mustard and pickles and a great deal of pastrami. The sandwich was ready quickly, loke less than five minutes. The staff here seems to appreciate the customer. This place is very narrow from left to right but it is a long restaurant. There are old historic photos, very large one to check out. I am not from the area so they were of interest to me. I get over to this part of SLO county frequently, so I will be back to try other sandwiches. read more

Delicious! Restaurant was very clean and all the staff was very nice. I arrived early and waited for them to finish my order, they sped up the process and gave it to me Early. read more

Food and service is great and the people are very friendly. Everyone i know i tell them to go there.

I ordered a tri-tip salad. Not on the menu anymore, but they will still make it! Love the thin sliced meat! The order was correct and on time! read more

Pretty much every sandwich is amazing. Their Dutch bread is a must. Always quick and friendly. They havnt missed yet. Oh... one thing.... They charge extra for a pickle.... I'm just saying.... If your name is Mr Pickle.... Might wanna just add one to the bag. Very good tho. read more

I had eaten there several years ago & really liked it. This time had the GOAT & was meh. Freshness & flavor were lacking. Expensive for just above Subway quality. I much prefer Jersey Mikes. read more

Love the food and fast service here for a great Italian meat sandwich with the delicious bread. Get the meal deal and it's even better. Quiet spot to eat in or take to go! Will be back again! read more

Good sandwiches, decent price, nice services, nice pictures on cities history hanging on the walls.

The bread and sandwich contents were great. Thank goodness we double checked our online order. They handed over sandwiches but hadn't also packed drinks chips potato salad and pickle we ordered. Dah check the order. read more

Second time here at this location! Excellent service and great staff! I had the hot beef sandwich this time! OMG delish!!! I also love the free cookie!!! I love all the great signs ! Nice inside and out ! Super clean ! Go get ya some! read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Got Beef! - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

I used to live in the bay area and was visiting Atascadero over Thanksgiving, to my surprise stumbled on a Mr. Pickle's! Dutch crunch is in it's own league, if you haven't had it, run don't walk to try it here. I split the Mr. Pickle and the spicy chicken sando with the works, would recommend both. Free cookie is always solid too! read more

Severely lacking in safe food handling practices and terrible attitude towards allergy notices. If you don't respect allergy safety, you put people's lives at risk and contribute to the lack of trust in safe food handling at restaurants. Do not eat here if you have any concerns with cross contamination or allergy exposure. read more

I've been coming to this spot for 4 years, and it's always spot on. I've tried the Italian, Mr. Pickle, and for the kids the pb&j. I've tried more but can't recall the names at the moment. What I know is that it's always good, and the servings are big. The Dutch bread is always my favorite but the other breads are also good. The service is always quick, and the staff is friendly. The vibe is friendly and has always been of the highest caliber. The prices are high, it the quality of the food makes it okay. The last meal I got came with chips and a cookie too. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Fresh baked sour dough bread. Great pickles all around a great lunch spot! Don't forget to try the fresh baked chocolate chip cookies.

I ordered my sandwich via grubhub and it came fairly fast it was delicious. All of the ingredients tasted fresh and it was larger than I expected. read more

Always good. Great bread which really makes the sandwich. Fresh meats. Tried a variety of sandwiches and they all have been delicious.

Great service, fabulous sandwich (Santa Maria tri tip on Dutch bread with horseradish sauce, no garlic sauce). The cookie! Omg the cookie. Clean restaurant and restroom. read more

Fresh, fast and friendly. Meat was piled high, veggies were crunchy and sandwich was out together and wrapped well. Staff were engaging and prompt and asked how my day was going, even though they were clearly slammed. Love the Dutch crunch bread. Place was clean and easy to park. read more

Great food. Great service. I'm so glad I stopped in. I got the hang loose and it was amazing!!!! I'll be back

Second time reviewing these guys but felt compelled because of the excellent customer service the staff gave us. And all of our orders were made correctly and were delicious! Thank you for another great experience. read more

Great service, fresh Dutch crunch bread, loved the free cookie...the sandwich would have been great, but WAY too much pickle. My son rolled his eyes and said, "Duh, mom...it's called Mr. pickles for a reason!" Next time I'll order and hold the pickle. read more

Went there yesterday. I was in a hurry and didn't look at the menu. Ordered a tuna wrap. Nothing else. They charged over $14.00! The tortilla was dry and pieces would actually flake off. Never again! read more

Food was delicious and well made. It's too bad the floors behind the counter were disgusting. Bread, meat and other sandwich fixings were all over the the place . The staff never cleaned it up and were constantly walking through it. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Food: delicious sandwich, I got the Mr. Pickle and enjoyed it. Service: People were very friendly and quick Ambiance: great little sandwich shop Overall: a little pricy, but worth checking out! Expect to pay ~$35 for 2 read more

Food ready on time. Made a quick stop off 101. In a grocery store parking lot. Parking and signage a bit tricky but we figured it out. Sandwiches were exactly as ordered and ready at pickup location. read more

Clean restaurant, efficient and helpful staff. Good bread and fresh fixings. Easy parking near Vons.

I came in here with my husband a little while ago and I have to say, the young man behind the counter named Joel is the reason I'm giving this 5 stars instead of 4. Great sandwiches, fresh ingredients and tasty food, but Joel put things over the top by chatting with us, being friendly and upbeat and just going above and beyond to make us feel welcome. I'll stop here next time we're driving through and feel a little peckish! read more

See all

They have the best sandwiches in A town! Their staff is soo friendly and always goes above and beyond to help their customers!

This was my first time here. I was promptly greeted, the sandwich was was delicious. Great customer service.

Professional and customer friendly, the staff are exceptional and always service orientated

I took a trip up to the Bay Area to see my daughter and she surprised me with a veg sandwich from Mr Pickles. The crunch bread was phenomenal! The meat replacement also did not disappoint. I wish we had Mr Pickles in SoCal, but since we don't I will make sure and grab a sandwich every time I'm up that way. read more

Found two whole peppers, stem and all. The second one had a nice long brown hair attached. Very dissatisfied. They also put chilis on my mothers sandwich even though she asked 2x for no chilis and they repeated it back to her. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Found two whole peppers, stem and all. The second one had a nice long brown hair attached. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

I was slightly disappointed in this shop. The sandwich itself was fine (turkey, cheese, Mayo, mustard- nothing fancy). But, the prices are ridiculous. Half a sandwich was $6. The team members weren't the friendliest. They didn't do anything specific, they just didn't do anything in general. No help, blunt, and in a rush. read more

Mr. Pickles has been my go-to during the pandemic. The online ordering is extremely easy and I love being able to pick what time to pick it up at and paying for my order online. All I have to do is pick my order up from the table at my assigned time and that's it! Very minimal contact and I can keep myself and the employees safe. The sandwiches are always on point. I really like their Big Jake on their sourdough bread, but I highly recommend making any sandwich into a wrap. Their spinach wrap always hits the spot. read more

This place was fantastic. I guess it's a chain in CA but it hasn't gotten so large as to destroy itself. The food was very good. We ordered a Reuben. a hot pastrami and an Italian and every single one was as good as I've ever had at any sandwich shop. Making a proper sandwich is about flavor balance and combination and these guys nailed it. They were friendly and the service was fast. The only option was taken out so we weren't able to dine in. read more

Mr Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California