Sandwiches are not normal here but they are fantastic. Had a chance to check out this place and the ambiance was really cool which is what caught my attention at first. Tried the Monte Cristo and it was not heavy with frying oil which is a great! The jam it came with matched the savory of the meat inside perfectly. A very solid sandwich, wish it came with a side of fries or chips though but that was extra it looks like. After wards I saw they had homemade hand dipped ice cream bars and thought I would try one. It was AMAZING and so good. The table next to me as asking about it and hopefully they got one as well later. The ice cream was really smooth and not over sweet, the nuts on the bar that I got were the perfect texture. The size of the bar was pretty hefty as well, almost good for sharing after a meal there. Staff was friendly and attentive so bonus points there. Favorite dish: Chocolate hand-dipped vanilla ice cream bar with peanuts and almonds. Go out and EAT! read more

Walked in on a hot day. I ordered the Italian and a side of fried zucchini and my coworker got the Cubano. Amazing. We asked the gal up front for some recommendations. These were her options. Glad we asked. Both sandwiches were bomb. The zucchini hit the spot. What can I say. I hope I'm in the area to try the rest of the menu. read more

See all

The service was terrible. I ordered a sandwich with a group of people and everyone else got their food and mine never came. I went inside to inquire and out they came with a sandwich that was not what I ordered. They had to remake it and it took forever and it wasn't even very good. I will never return. read more

The service was excellent. The employees were inviting and fast with my order. The sandwich tasted amazing. Looking forward to coming back and trying more read more

Colony Sandwich - Morty - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Nice patio, good açaí bowl, GF bread available for sandwiches and they have happy hour read more

See all

Great for kids! Fully fenced in with yard games area. The food is also good. I really like their turkey sandwich on sourdough with the works. read more

We stopped here for lunch on the drive back to the Bay Area as the sandwiches looked interesting on the menu. The set up is like a backyard picnic kind of vibe- some outdoor seating, corn hole, a semi open air bar/eating area, and a smaller dining room. I got the porchetta sandwich and my wife got the Turkey and Tot sando from the breakfast menu. We also split a bowl of fries. The portions were good- the sandwiches were big! My porchetta sandwich was tasty but very messy to eat with the amount of pesto and lemon caper sauce. In the end, a little too much caper flavor for me, that's one thing I would change. The turkey and tot sando was the better of the two sandwiches. It's like breakfast in a brioche bun! Delicious! Plenty of fries, we didn't even finish it. Would come back to try more of the sandwiches! read more

See all

First time eating here, really enjoyed the variety of the menu. Sandwiches were good & fresh. The corn dip & chips were tasty. Nice beer/wine/cider selection. Large outdoor area to sit at with lots of sun or shade options. Definitely coming back! read more

Colony Sandwich - Chipotle Bullseye (on sourdough), Morty's, Crack Corn Dip & Chips, Regular Side of Fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

My wife and I grab lunch here 2-3times a month. It's conveniently located downtown and next to Ancient Owl. I love the pastrami sandwich on rye bread and we share fries. Burgers are good too and so is the fried chicken sandwich. Decent beer on tap, includes CaliSqeeze, Wild Fields and Figueroa Mtn. Sit outside on a nice day and enjoy the breeze! Service speed depends on how crowded it is, but wait is nothing to worry about. read more

* Visited on a Sunday around brunch with a group of 4 adults & 3 kiddos It was our first time visiting, and this spot is pretty kid friendly for those with kiddos! :) there's an outdoor area where there's a mini play house and toys for kiddos, as well as a corn hole set up. the restaurant itself is quite large, and has plenty of outdoor seating - there is indoor seating, but the majority is outside. The staff is pretty kind, and quick to get your order going as well as drinks. OKAY THE FOOD: * western cheese burger - pretty yummy! It was very filling, especially with tater tots. It's quite large, and honestly perfect for satisfying a good burger. * tater tots - SO CRISPY, I genuinely loved it though it was slightly greasy towards the end of the batch. * duck fat French fries - crispy, and perfect to share with a table. Despite the herbs mixed into the fries, it was a huge hit with the kiddos! * the patty melt - my partner had gotten this, and said it was pretty good too! I was able to have a bite, and might get this for myself next time we visit :) read more

Colony Sandwich - Tater Tots - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

Colony has a parking lot in the back of the restaurant, which may be easier to access considering there is construction on El Camino. - If you get there at opening time there typically is not a line but otherwise the line can be rather long. I suggest ordering on the website ahead of time and giving yourself 20 minutes for pick up. It was nice to stroll in and grab my to go order without having to wait in line. There are also many options to choose from when you order online such as type of bread and condiments. It's nice to have such a large selection while ordering. - I was able to fill my reusable yeti at the soda station and my all of my food was wrapped in paper and placed in a paper bag to-go. Thank you for being environmentally friendly and skipping the plastic! read more

See all

Delicious sandwiches and fries. Great outdoor spot. And good fast service. Only beer and wine/cider/seltzers.

I had a great Patty melt there, but my wife asked for a side of pickles for her Cubano and saw through the window the gal who had been handling cash DID NOT wash her hands while handling my wifes side of pickles . Not cool . Food was good but staff needs some basic food handling training . Atmosphere is a spot at a busy intersection and has picnic benches on decomposed granite lot . read more

This place has a number of things going for it, but the first is the guy I kind of assumed was the manager--Justin. It turns out he's NOT the manager, but he's probably a strong reason this little sandwich shop with a great downtown Atascadero location has a great chance at thriving (if they aren't already). I'll come back to Justin in a second, but don't forget him... Layout is simple and obvious, seating has excellent options (unless it's raining, maybe, in which case there are only two tables inside) that are nicely separated, menu is straightforward, not too narrow, not too broad. And the quality was refreshingly good! My "Morty" was what basically an "Italian", but really just a simple, well-balanced, nicely executed and just slightly elevated ham and cheese sandwich (sorry if that offends the menu-maker, but it's a good thing--NO ONE does good basic sandwiches, and I'd far rather get a well-executed simple sandwich than a badly executed attempt that reaches too far!). My wife's tuna salad sandwich was similarly simple, maybe light on the tuna salad, heavy on lettuce--but good! Fries? Simple fries? $4 and the best fries I've had in years. Somebody cares. Is it a sign? And the prices were quite reasonable. The clientele on a Tuesday at about 11:30am was mixed and obviously happy to be there, clearly some new customers, some returning--a great sign. And, Justin. He said hello and welcomed us in the moment we entered the space. He was polite, informative, proactive and friendly. That was different, unexpected, welcome. I often think (as a lot of us do) that customer service is just a memory of the old days when people cared, when businesses, workers and owners/managers alike intuitively understood that true customer service is not an extra, it's not something that can be cut due to costs, something that is second or third string to paying your staff as little as you can get away with. Nope, it's right at the top, whether you know it or not. And those who do know it, the scattered and isolated few, will see results. Customer service is about relationships, about telling people they care--and nothing is more valuable to the customer than that. Justin told me he's always "on", whether at work or not. Someone please recognize that value, if you haven't already, and then apply it--liberally. Someone--including Justin, starting with Justin--needs to KNOW this value is a real and present danger to the mediocrity that has crept into our lives like a layer of cold nacho cheese over potential value in every nook and cranny. All that (potential) value is really there, but it doesn't get fed, recognized, celebrated, leveraged. Eat here, enjoy it, say hi to Justin, thank the cooks for good food and caring, thank your lucky stars you found just a little bit of sunshine. Here's to the Justins of the world--maybe there's hope. (Oh, by the way, if it troubles you that Justin is the star of this review, even though I also said the place is good, you should ask yourself what's wrong with this world that someone who cares made such an impression and then look around and see what a difference there might be if more of us cared.) read more

The good: the overall quality of the sandwich. Available gluten free bread. The not so good: the size of the sandwich -- more like a half of a normal a sandwich size. The $3 up charge for the tiny gluten free roll that the sandwich was built on-- nothing good about punishing people with allergies. The terrible: spending $18 (includes tax, gratuity not included)on a tiny roast beef sandwich on a tiny gluten free bun with 2 slices of beef, a piece of cheese, a tomato slice, greens. The wait... wait... waiting for the order. Overall: While the food was fine, the service was slow and price is what I would call disconnected from reality. No chance I'll be coming back here. read more

Colony Sandwich - tiny roast beef on gluten free bun. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Stopped at Colony for a to-go Due South BLT, which includes the B-L and T with their great house colony sauce and bourbon bacon tomato jam. Lots and lots of thick applewood bacon. Excellent combo. Kinda wish, though, that the sourdough bread it was served on was thicker and/or more substantial. Great design of the restaurant, play area and seated area. Wish I had more time to hang. read more

See all

Great BLT!!!! Definitely no skimping on the bacon. Loved the zippy sauce and the bourbon bacon tomato jam which added a slight sweetness. Our lunch before wine tasting in Paso. A return trip next time up this way. Great service with friendly staff read more

Came here and got the Get Figgin with it and it was actually very tasty, the Dutch crunch roll was yummy. The whole area is very cute, kid friendly and lots of shade. I wasn't blown away, it was pricey, two sandwiches (no sides) and 2 beers was 50$ with tip. I wish they included a side with the sandwich, the pricing would have made more sense. Might come back for a beer, but definitely won't be the first choice on the list. read more

Great food, worth the wait! Super fresh ingredients, friendly staff. The old gas station vibe is a fun alternative to the normal sandwich joint. Ice cold beer! Huge portions! I took half my sandwich home to have for dinner, but I ate all the fries on the spot! read more

See all

first off, I almost never eat bread but I saw the HOT MESS RUBEN in their menu and decided it was time to give it a try. WOW! This is THE BEST HOT PASTRAMI SANDWICH EVER! I dont like sauerkraut so I leave that off but this is a seriously good big sandwich . I usually have the Portola Salad which is also FABULOUS but the Hot Mess Ruben has been a game changer for me. I also like the facility, family friendly with a nice outdoor children's play area, the staff very friendly and the prices are not too bad. :-) read more

Poor service and quality. It was my first time here and I heard it's a popular local spot. I ordered the fig sandwich and I waited over half an hour before I asked about my order. The buzzer they gave me never turned on, and it turns out it's because they never put my order in. I waited a couple more minutes and then asked for a refund, and somehow my sandwich was magically ready. The sandwich itself wasn't that great. The staff didn't seem like they cared and they weren't apologetic at all. Definitely will be my first and last time here. read more

Wanted to love this place. But the dip wasn't really a dip; thick slices of meat that really should have been in a roast beef sandwich. That's an opinion so ymmv. The salad came out of a bag, which we knew, because the lettuce was old and melted (yes goopy lettuce), which is a health hazard. And the soup was overly salty because we got soup that had been left in a pot too long and was overly reduced. Maybe it was an off day. But it was really not good. When we returned the salad and showed them the lettuce was old and goopy we didn't get an apology or anything. We paid the bill in full and ate what was edible (ie wouldn't make us sick) and left. Won't be returning. Maybe business was slow and we got the leftovers? Still facts: lettuce old and goopy. Soup old and salty. read more

My husband and I have been disappointed in the fries. Every time we go they are burnt to a crisp. Not enjoyable at all. Other than that we really enjoy eating here... but this is like the fourth time getting burnt fries. read more

Colony Sandwich - Burnt fries - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

The food is SO good here! And they just got a really cute makeover so the outside area is gorgeous and full of fun things for kids to play while you hang out. My daughters loved it. This was our second time eating here and everyone was happy with their food. The best part to me was the duck fat fries! So flavorful! Fairly quick service and friendly staff. Great spot to stop for a nice meal. read more

See all

May have just had the best breakfast sandwich ever. The turkey and tot sando on the brunch menu is insanely good . Damn so good. read more

Colony Sandwich - Turkey & Tot Sando - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

They're under construction expanding the front eating area but they are still open. Food is good and and service was fast. It's becoming our go to spot for quick bite and drinks. I like that they open early. It was a little loud since they are expanding but thankfully not too dusty. read more

See all

We came here on my birthday a couple weeks ago and not that it was bad, I just really expected more and really really really wanted to love it. Blackened fish sando was okay. Served on a delicious bun and plenty of fixings, but seriously where's the fish? One measly little piece the size of a chicken finger is no where enough. Only half of the bites taken from this sandwich had fish, such a bummer. The jalapeño coleslaw served on the side was odd. It definitely had a jalapeño forward flavor, which I liked, but it just seemed to be missing something. We were very much looking forward to the duck fat fries but these were the most disappointing. These things couldn't have been soggier. It wasn't for the fact of them sitting out before they were brought to our table, because they were piping hot. The flavor was spot on with the orange zest and rosemary but I just couldn't get past the fact they were so limp and soggy. I will say the colony sauce for dipping was very delicious. As for the Reuben, this was the saving grace. Very delicious Pastrami and the pickles were perfect (guessing they are pickled in-house?). Would definitely order this again if we find ourselves back here. On a side note: service wasn't terrible but just weird. Although friendly, we did notice a few things that could use improving. They didn't take our table number when they brought us our food, in fact we left and drove around the front to head back home and noticed that even ten minutes after we left it was still sitting on the table. I can't imagine that anyone would take the initiative of sitting at that table, assuming that someone is already sitting there and waiting for their food. When brought out a menu item that deemed fork worthy, a remark was made from the server that we needed a fork, yet never came back with one. Countless times we watched the servers grab dishes to clear from the bus bins to make room for more, every time they walked by. However, something that was never touched was the trash. This literally had piled so high that nothing else could possibly be added to it. read more

See all

The restaurant is located in a very old small gas station building and there is parking in the alley behind, about 10 spaces It was all full today There's only 1 cash register to order and the line is always about 6 deep They have a pizza oven but it wasn't in use & no pizza menu or idea when you can get pizza Today the person who took are order was a black women who messed up the order twice On the food Dan likes The Boss burger We had 3 orders of fish tacos and comparing them to pier 46 they were not even close These tacos are bland, there's only a drizzle of something over the top so all the cole slaw is dry in the taco & it has no seasoning It needs more sauce snd none was given with the tacos Three of us had the tacos and all agreed Pier 46 fish tacos are way better Iso I ordered a kids meal, Boss burger, and 3 orders of fish tacos to go . While waiting I looked at my receipt and saw it said 1 order fish tacos and 1 extra taco , I went back up and said I had 3 orders of fish tacos not 1 of 3 tacos So she charged me for the other two, but I didn't realize she rang up 3 orders With the register they use you can't tell what is being rung up We were told about the overcharge when our take out food came. she overcharged me but gave me a credit so I'll have to check my visa statement (& the credit was there). But who messes up an order that bad twice! They were supposed to have free wine tasting 11 to 4 but no one was there doing any wine pouring There's about 4 tables inside and a rack of Tshirts for sale was blocking access Outside are patio tables about 8 maybe And a cute area Be careful as you enter & leave the inside restaurant, as there is old gas station curb about 3" high that is a tripping hazard It's painted yellow but when you're carrying a couple large bags of take out you don't see it and my boyfriend tripped and twisted ankle but thankfully he's ok I wouldn't go back It's not very relaxing and there's a lot of people getting takeout It's casual & a nice stop if you want to eat and have a beer or wine and a sandwich burger or salad They had frozen wine in 2 flavors Downtown Atascadero needs more places with shaded outdoor dining and beer wine where people can gather like The Backyard in Paso Robles read more

See all

Looks like the quality is dipping here at colony deli. Hit or miss lately. I guess when the monopoly buys your favorite spot it should be expected. read more

Colony Sandwich - Cesar wrap. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Disappointing. Went in there today for my first time. About 11:30. One girl working behind the counter, a couple in food prep. My order was promptly taken, then the employee went outside to wipe down tables. I heard my order number called from the kitchen, but the employee wasn't there to receive it - she was outside wiping down tables. Another customer came in but since the employee was wiping down tables, no one could take his order. One of the employees from the back came up front and brought me my sandwich, without a word or a smile. I almost got in my car then realized my cookie wasn't in there. Employee gave me my cookie without a word. You get the idea - the silent treatment. It appeared no one was managing the operation and the employees were not friendly. read more

We went back today to what is now called Colony Sandwich Co. and split a "Gettin' Figgy With It" sandwich and the duck fries. Yum yum! Gettin' Figgy is such an awesome sandwich, very gourmet. It has three distinct flavors that marry together perfectly - salty ham and turkey, sweet fig jam spread, and bitter arugula greens to balance everything out. The sandwich was big enough that my wife and I split it with the duck fat fries and filled up nicely. The duck fat fries, what can I say? You gotta try these things. Thin cut, fried to a crunchy snap in the rich duck fat, and seasoned to perfection with rosemary. No, this isn't low calorie or low cost dish, but go ahead and splurge. You'll thank me. Quick, friendly service rounds out what many consider the best sandwich shop in the North County. Highly recommended. read more

Colony Sandwich - Gettin' Figgy and the Duck Fries. Go ahead and drool. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Great sandwiches, but I prefer the menu before the ownership changed. My family enjoys ordering lunch and sitting with our dogs on the outside patio. read more

Have been back a few times since my last review and everything - from sandwich and salad selections to pours to service to pricing - has been consistently spot-on. Easy to see why this place with its cool but casual vibe is a favorite with locals and always bustling. read more

Colony Sandwich - Sadly, bears no resemblance to what we received - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Sandwich was fine. Not great, but fine. I don't even remember which sandwich I got, but I recall that it was fine. Price point was moderate.

Mediocre at best. First time here and it's a cool spot and menu looked amazing. Got the fish sandwich and fish maybe covered half the bun. Flavor was ok. Also had the burger and it was clearly a frozen patty and not great. We didn't even finish it. Would come back for a beer and that's about it. read more

We came on a Saturday afternoon and sat under the shade outside. The cashier was very friendly and agreed we made good food choices. It was relaxing. We are glad we ordered the duck fat fries. They had a scrumptious to them and with the lemon zest and rosemary, they were addicting. The cubano sandwich I got was fire, heavy on the mustard but well worth it. I love the ciabatta roll it was on. The sandwich my girlfriend got was perfect for her. read more

See all

Service was quick and efficient. Sandwiches were good but the duck fat fries was what took the cake. Wow. Couldnt stop eating them! Will be back if I'm in the area read more

Colony Sandwich - Morty's on chiabatta - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California

Stopped here to get a Sammie on my way home from San Francisco and was pleasantly surprised to find this trendy lookin spot. I mean, I didn't expect much in Atascadero. Never even heard of this place but here I was and happy to be here. Food alone is 5 stars but we weren't greeted or acknowledged when we walked in. I know what you're thinking... like what does that matter but it matters sooo much! The cashier was nice and all but I truly believe in manners and welcoming anyone who comes to your place. Now that I'm done with that - the Monte Cristo was like no other! If you're like me and love to satisfy a million tastebuds at once, this sandwich was salty and sweet and don't let me forget to say delicious! Like a Christmas ham with glazed jelly. Like a thanksgiving turkey with sweet raspberry sauce. Easy peasy parking, cool vibes and outdoor seating! Beer for you and games for the kids! read more

See all

52 minutes... how long I waited for a reuben sandwich and duck fat fries. Reuben was okay, but definitely had more sauerkraut than pastrami. Duck fat fries were almost cold, so that was upsetting. If you don't have an hour to wait, then choose another place. Multiple people waited for almost an hour and it just wasn't worth it. I was sitting outside in a woven-ish chair (comfy) and kids were playing tag all around me and almost using me as a shield. I wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt for it being lunch time on a Saturday, but if the food isn't even hot, then it's just not worth it. read more

I stopped here and had a very tasty sandwich, the Monte Cristo, it was made to perfection. The cheese and meats were delicious and set off with a tangy flavor and sweetness read more

Colony Sandwich - A perfect sandwich paired with a delicious draft beer. - Sandwiches Near Me - Atascadero, California