The pizza was good -- cheesy, flavorful, and hit the spot. I do think it would've been perfect with the crust a little more crispy, but overall still solid. The wings were delicious and had great flavor. The only miss was the sauce for the mozzarella sticks -- it tasted more like spaghetti sauce than marinara, so I wasn't a fan of that. Overall, good food and friendly staff. read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

Everything went well!My steak n cheese,cheeseburger sub,'& a Willie sub...nothing left but our full bellies..Again their CRAB CAKE sandwich is" watch out "Jimmys Seafood!"delicious Try it!!!! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - The Best Italian Cold Cut in this town!!!you must in large to see what it is!!!$ - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

Ordering is very easy online My order was ready fast both delivery and when I picked it up . Best pizza around -Plenty of sauce to toppings. The chef salad was very fresh and enough for 3 servings . Highly recommend . read more

Love that they have $1 wing Wednesdays!!! It's basically a pizza/sub shop you can order in person or online. There are tables to eat inside. Fountain drinks or bottled drinks are available. I placed an online order and it took about 30 minutes to get it. read more

I'm going to stick with the trend of 4 stars. Mr. Y's is a clean and quiet pizza/sub shop. Gyro is good. Chicken tenders and fries were good for my grandson. Crab Pretzels were only okay. It seemed like the neighborhood likes the takeout and delivery since there was a lot of traffic picking up orders. I will try other Mr. Y's locations too. read more

See all

This place has gone downhill! I recently had a pizza delivered. It tasted to me like something was spoiled, the sauce? the cheese? Either that or they have started using substandard products. I actually threw my pizza in the trash after a few bites. Now the restaurant they have in Street, MD is, and always has been, excellent. This location has had issues from the start. It improves for short periods of time then goes right back to substandard food. I'll be looking for another place to buy my takeout food. Don't waste your money. read more

Pizza was great . Wings were meaty.Convenient location . Staff were friendly . Ordering on line was a plus

we just had MrYs deliever our dinner..3 steak n cheese n one Italian cold cut...When i say they were out of this world..i mean fabulous !!Ny husband with Dementia couldnt find his words to say how much he enjoyed it!!! thank you for offering delivery,not many deliever to Fork Md.!!!! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - y italian cold cut....wow can't open my mouth that wide!!!yum!! - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

Wow wow wow, my favorite cheesesteaks were from Ravage Deli until I had Mr Y's. I got a Chesapeake cheesesteak in a bowl (no bread) which comes with steak, crab dip, cheddar, and fried onions. Literally the best cheesesteak I've ever eaten. The meat was tender, the crab dip was full of flavor, and it was sooooo cheesy! My friend got a mozzarella stick grilled cheese and I wish I wasn't low carb cause it looked amazing. The bread was nice and toasty, and the perfect bread to stand up to the sauce without getting soggy. She said the fries were delicious too; not your standard takeout fries. Thick cut but not soggy. Nice and crisp. I will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Mozzarella stick grilled cheese - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

See all

Delicious pizza, and subs! What more do you need to know? The Mediterranean calzone is wonderful, full of cheeses & just enough spinach to make you think you're eating healthy! read more

It's hit or miss with Mr. Y's. I ordered a cold roast beef sub. I was told it had changed. So, they heat it up (it's on their cold sub menu) and then give me cold roast beef like you'd chunk up from a roast in the oven. Chunky and hard to bite (felt like left over pot roast from home). They don't use a deli style roast beef there its thin and has a nice bite. I will say my German Shepherd enjoyed those beef chunks, but I threw the rest away. When a food requires too much pull to try to chew it then it's not worth the money. It becomes a chore to eat it. read more

Foods been great every time. We like the Bigmac pizza and the wings. Tad pricey but a good treat.

Delicious pizza. Easy to place an order online. I'm glad there's a place making delicious pizza right in fallston. We ordered a large pineapple and onion pizza. Big chunks of pineapple on a nice and crispy crust. read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

We ordered a pizza from Mr. Y's on our way home from a long trip. It was delivered to our house at exactly the time we asked - as soon as we got home. My husband and I like to try al the local pizza to figure out who has the best. Mr. Y's is our new favorite!! The thickness of the crust was perfect and it had the perfect ratio of sauce and cheese. We can't wait to go back for more! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Half pepperoni & bacon, half pineapple & ham - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

Great specialty pizzas for the family. Even though it's a longer drive for me, I make the trip out to get things I can't get elsewhere like a crab dip pizza, big Mac pizza and some great subs and wings. Every visit is on point and my kids are always happy. Definitely worth a try! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

See all

Mr.Y's Is our "Go To" carryout because they have consistently good food, plenty of it and at a good price, and then there was tonight's total strike out. I'll try to make this short and sweet, I got a Lamb Gyro with extra meat and it was the absolute worst Gyro I have ever had in my life, and I've had a lot of Gyros over my 70 years. First, the meat, I'm sure it was good, at one time, but the line cook must have just thrown it in the microwave, hit the button, and over-nuked it because he turned it into shoe leather. Advice: throw out the microwave!, people don't know how to cook with it. Nukes are good for soups and liquids, but not meats and fish, I don't give a wack what the directions say. Second, the "homemade tzatziki sauce topped with tomatoes" - the homemade tzatziki sauce was horrible and not a sauce at all, when I first opened the wrapper I thought somebody had made a mistake and sprinkled feta cheese on the Gyro, it was no where near the runny, sloppy, tasty cucumber sauce I'm used to. Advice: stop making your own - it sucks, go buy it by the gallon from Sysco or US Foods. Third, topped with tomatoes turned out to be one piece of a tomato, same with the onion - one little piece. What'sup with that, even a first day rookie knows better then that. Such a disappointment, Mr Y's, learn how to do a Gyro the right way, or stop selling the thing. Of all the times we have ordered food from Mr Y's this is only the second disappointment we have suffered, the other time was on a Sunday too. Maybe that's the lesson here, don't go to Mr Y's on a Sunday their team is not up to the task. Tonight's adventure is not a deal breaker. We will still go to Mr.Ys - overall they have good food and we love their Pizza's, except on Sunday's. Everybody screws up, tonight was Mr Y's turn, we'll be back. 4 stars is solid! read more

Ordered a large Cheese pizza around 1:39pm on 10-31-23. Brought home and bottom of Pizza crust was not cooked. Mushey. Top was over cooked. would not come back!!!! Very unhappy!!!! Order # 58 read more

This place is very close to home. Love that you can order online and I definitely prefer their pizza to the cardboard from the place across the street from them. So, online orders are usually prepared well for us. They even called me once to clarify something about an order. For kids these days, that's huge! Unfortunately, this time they messed up. Ordered a pizza with mushroom & sausage on half. They completely forgot the sausage. My favorite part! read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Is there any sausage in there? Anybody? Anybody? Bueller? - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

See all

Great pizza and we tried the cheesesteaks today. Best I've had in Bel Air. Love this place

The staff never does what you ask. Cold fries wet soggy subs I just give up‍‍ I really give up I can't order from there anymore

Awful! I read the other reviews and I think those people are nuts. Service is terrible. Imagine a restaurant with a bunch of 16-17 kids running the place. Listening to music, playing and doing everything but working. Then add poor food quality. We recently moved to the area and we're hoping this would be our go to place. Well, after three or four bad experiences, it was time to write a review. Don't say you weren't warned! read more

2nd time no gluten free pizza,and charging 14$ is bit expensive,

I ordered a pan pizza and it had thinner dough than most regular pizza....what is up with that? The ingredients were good but the pizza looked so small and had a very thin crust. Service is not friendly. Wasn't our 1st choice because the service here is fair and they never toast our rolls like we ask. Now the pizza was disappointing. I was looking for a good deep dish pizza. Not here. : ( read more

I have to agree with the other reviewers about the service. Be sure to be clear when you order and check it when it arrives. When I can't hear what the cashier is asking me because of the background noise (TVs & fun being had in the back), it wears thin. Several times they've messed up my order, but that's what I'd expect at a place being run by high school kids more worried about what the others are doing in the food prep area. Food is okay, when it's right. Pizza is pretty hard to mess up unless you get something totally different that what you requested. The Steak/Cheese sub is nothing to write home about. Stromboli is good. It'll be a place we'll go if we can't find or decide on anything else. read more

The freaken Best of the Best !!!! Good Cheesesteaks Excellent Burgers ( My Favorite fresh n Tasty) Delicious tasting Pizza i prefer thin crust Customer Service 5 Fresh oil at all times for fries n more Fast delivery and have done it several times to where nothing was missing from my order . read more

It was okay. Pizza was better than average. Fries were average. Staff was friendly but seemed preoccupied with cell phones, each other, etc. Nothing that would stop me from giving them another try. read more

Close but on the pricey side for delivery. Subs seem to on almost baguette size bread. Husband didn't even finish his cheeseburger sub. I had a Turkey sub but it was okay read more

Favorite well-done, New York style pepperoni pan pizza in the area!

It seems the ownership has changed - sanitation of the dining area has gone down hill and staff seem indifferent to the customer. Hope this changes - food is good . read more

Absolutely the worst can't get orders right more than once.... sometimes you order food and it never shows up unbelievable service the worst service ever and then when you call and you say my food never came I ordered it last night they ask you so you want to place another order you've got to be kidding me and I've spent a lot of money at that place cause they're not the cheapest place in town so take my advice and skip this one it's TRASH.JUST LIKE A LOT OF PLACES UP IN THIS AREA TRASH FOOD HIGH PRICES THATS WHY SOME ARE SLOWLY LOSING IT ALLLLLL ..... you want good food go to the VP ON 40 or Strapasta in jarrettsville. That's about alll you got read more

First of all, I go in to pick up the food I ordered and the girl at the front, the face of Mr. Y's has a face mask that says "If you can read this back the fuck up". I wish I were wrong. Unreal. Then they got the order wrong yet again. Tonight took the cake. I'm done with Mr. Y's - I hope you are too. read more

It was meh. Cheese pizza was so- so but the pepperoni was an absolute mess. If a person cannot pick up a piece of pizza without it completely falling apart then somethings wrong. It was basically half soup. Probably will not eat there again. read more

We had it delivered and they were earlier than their estimated time. The pizzas were a great deal for the size and flavor. Super nic delivery driver and will definitely Re order read more

Very good. Pizza was good and the price was good. The outside of this place looks a little run down but the inside is clean and modern. We ordered online and the food was hot and ready in under 15min. Will return read more

You NEED to go here. Great coupons, great pizza, great everything. For real, GO HERE lol

I love the food. Especially the wings with blue cheese. Sriracha is my favorite. The best part about this place is the manager at the front counter Jenny. She is always doing something productive and really seems to enjoy her job. It's hard to find that in people these days. read more

Talk about some great pizza. This place has some great food. I've tried pizza from many different Places around the area and I can honestly say that I prefer My y's pizza over the competition. Prices are great as well. Service is excellent. Would definitely recommend to everyone. read more

Was excited to try this place for the first time based on the positive reviews. Ingredients seemed decent but pizza was unfortunately over cooked which ruined the experience. Maybe will try again in the future read more

Mr. Y's Pizza N Fries - Pizza Near Me - Fallston, Maryland

This is our go to pizza place (and we've tried a lot of them!). The pizza is always fresh and arrives hot. Same with the other items on their menu but we usually stick with the pizza because it's so good. The best part of this place though is the people that work there. The staff answering the phones are always so friendly and super nice. Same with the delivery drivers. read more

We've ordered from Mr. Y's several times over the last few months. We always order online, and although we're on the further end of their delivery area, we always receive our food pretty quickly (or pick it up). We've ordered cheesesteak subs, grilled cheese (kid's meal), pizza, fries and onion rings. Everything has been really good. No complaints, so we'll continue ordering from here. read more