Love this place and keep coming back. The wait staff is super accommodating without being overbearing (special shout out to Jessica from last Saturday night). The food is great. There isn't anything I wouldn't recommend. Definitely a place to check out if you are in Montauk. read more

Laid back vibe with great food. Had the lamb meatball to start which was very tasty. For dinner I had the vegetarian which was really good although I'm glad I had an appetizer because the portion wasn't too big. My fiancee had the pork chop which he enjoyed a lot. Overall really good and I would definitely come back. read more

Just delicious. From the bread to appetizers and main dish. We took the tuna and peppers for appetizers and the scallop and stick for main. All recommended read more

What a great last dinner in Montauk. My friends are hard to please when it comes to dining out and we were all thoroughly impressed. Boyfriend got the lamb chops and almost kicked the plate clean. I did the same for the jerk striped bass and our friend guzzled down a good 25-30 mussels. The service was great and the ambiance is impeccable. 6 Minute walk from the born free. I have literally Nothing bad to say about Muse . read more

Great service. Waitress was friendly and hospitable as were the other staffers. I had the blt salad and it was as good a salad as I've ever had. The salad, as well as the entrees had unique and interesting presentations. But mainly the salad (and entrees for that matter) tasted great (and thats really the point, isnt it?). I also had the jerk striped bass and it was presented beautifully and again, tasted great. My wife got the grilled salmon and she raved about it, I took a taste and immediately agreed. This time in Montauk has been a bit disappointing food wise, but Muse saved the day. read more

This place is definitely worth a visit if you are staying in Montauk. The Muse is located near the Plaza, so while you don't get a view of the water, you do get easy access to the nightlife near Town after your meal. My wife and I ate outside on the sidewalk patio, the servers were generally attentive and they easily accommodated us given that we had a baby stroller. The food was solid. I had the lamb meatball to start. It was juicy, flavorful, and was a good portion for a starter. She had the tuna poke, which was the right combination of sweet and savory. For dinner, my dish was definitely better than hers. I had the seafood paella and it was phenomenal. The rice was moist and it was full of seafood. It was an expensive dish, but worth the price in my opinion. She had the pork chop. We found it to be bland. But, the dish came with these truffle polenta fries, which were amazing. The fries save the dish. If you come here, I think you are better off ordering seafood than meat. read more

Nice deco and ambience but a little noisy due to a wedding celebration which the server was nice enough to apologize for. The food quality is poor. Not even average in my view, especially for the price you have to pay. I'm surprised this is a 4 star restaurant on yelp (perhaps due to limited choices in Montauk). In Manhattan, it would have been a 3 star or 3.5 stars. read more

Overpriced, subpar food. We ordered the lamp meatball, pork chop, cod and Brussels sprouts. Lamp meatball came out almost immediately and was cold. Pork chop ($30) and cod ($40) were average but definitely overpriced for the quality. Brussels sprouts was bad and we barely touched it. Feedback to the wait stuff but she just shrugged her shoulders and we had to still pay for it. No apology given either. The two course and three course sets are only available at the bar. Pay full price at the restaurant for the same food. read more

Went for some wine and apps. Ended up meeting and chatting with locals. A very nice bar with a fun crowd. Tread lightly and you will be rewarded. Will be back! read more

Amazing and by far the best restaurant in Montauk. Excellent food, generous portions, presented beautifully and friendly staff. And all the little things were great; nice decor and ambience, great bar area, and excellent bread and unique spreads to go with them. Can't wait to come back read more

If your in Montauk or Sag Harbor it's a beautiful dining experience. In a 48 hour period, I ate three meals. The salmon dinner as well as the the osso bucco was simply delicious. The service at both places was impeccable and my compliments to both managers Jill and Kevin. I wish you would open a restaurant in Long Beach. read more

Excellent food and service. We will definitely come back. Cant beat happy hour at the bar with live music!

Jill who was our host was absolutely incredible and accommodating! I rushed out to montauk and met my friends at Muse after they had already sat. Jill was able to accommodate us and move our group to a larger table! Our server Liz was hilarious, fun and knowledgeable! We had an amazing dinner and a fantastic experience! This was our first time dining here and I can't wait to come back already! Thank you again Jill and Liz! read more

My husband and I went to the Muse Sept 5. We had the beet salad, pork chops and ahi tuna. Very nice presentation and the food was delicious. We will definitely be back again. read more

Went on a Tuesday evening in the summer and it was easy to get a reservation. Service was friendly and the food was tasty and original. Especially recommend the Indian spiced sea bass and lamb meatball. read more

Food is tolerable at best. Service is ok. Maitre d is a complete asshole especially when customers are completely unsatisfied with their meal. read more

One of my new favorite restaurants! From the manager to hostess, to the server, and, of course the food! Oh yeh, and the watermelon mojito! Indoors or out, the swordfish, and the Indian spiced sea bass are fabulous! A great wine list and always wonderful vibes! read more

My husband and I went to Muse last night. It was one of the best meals we've ever had. We sat at the bar and the bartender Chris was very nice and answered all our questions. I had the mussels appetizer with artichoke hearts. All I can say is DELICIOUS. Crusty bread to soak in the juice, plump mussels, sweet artichoke hearts, scallions. I didn't even finish it and had to take it back to our hotel y husband loves lobster mac and cheese so he tried the scallop mac and cheese. He said it was the best thing he has ever had. He even ran his finger in the empty bowl to get a last taste of the sauce. Then he has the shrimp and grits. That was creamy, cheesy grits with perfectly grilled spicy shrimp. Need I say more? Whatever you do, leave room for dessert. We shared the cheese cake chimicharo and the beignets with three sauces. The vanilla sauce was the best. We are definitely going back. read more

Food was delicious. We got the shishito peppers and tuna apps, I got the steak and she got the scallop Mac and cheese. The donuts were great and the staff was attentive and polite. Also helped us pick places to go drink after. Pricey, but it's Montauk. A 'fancy' place for Montauk, but it still felt casual and easy. I would definitely return. read more

Their food is sensational, the service is exceptional, warm and friendly and their dessert is just beyond! I highly recommend visiting Muse whenever you're in the area... read more

I came on a Thursday night for drinks the place was absolutely dead. $15 cocktails .... to be honest this place doesn't warrant $15 cocktails there are plenty of places you can get cheaper cocktails. read more

I had the pork chops and my husband had the burger. Both were excellent. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable and professional. Will definitely be back! read more

This was our third visit to this wonderful Montauk restaurant and we were delighted once again. The service is friendly and excellent. The food is well-prepared and delicious. Very highly recommended! read more

The service, food, and atmosphere were fantastic! Definitely recommend this place. I went here as a celebration dinner with my boyfriend and his family and shared the shashito peppers, bacon, and pot pie soup. All were really flavorful and delicious, particularly the bacon dish. My boyfriend and I split the scallops and butternut squash ravioli and the steak. They were both perfect. I highly recommend the steak. I also was able to have a bite of the sashimi and the cod dishes and will be ordering the sashimi next time! The service was kind and great and the restaurant itself has pretty lighting and fun art. Check it out! read more

After hearing so much about this place, I have to say I was disappointed. Service was great but I feel prices are a little over the top for entrees that are really just a little bigger than small plates. I had the scallops (4), served over puréed peas, $42. I didn't think the flavor combo worked at all. read more

We just went last night and it was wonderful for so many reasons. The food was excellent- each dish was simply delicious. The musician kept our daughter dancing the whole night long. But what really stood out over everything was how incredible the staff was from beginning to end! We had our 2 young children with us and everyone was so warm, friendly, attentive and just fabulous. My husband and I have not stopped saying how incredible everyone was. We will definitely be back! read more

Liked the food. Liked the atmosphere. Liked that I could dine in shorts and flipflops. Liked our waiter.

We've been coming to Muse for years and happy to see they expanded to Montauk this summer. The vibe is comfortable and Ben was great to us. The tuna 3 ways has always been our favorite app! read more

Went here this past weekend and had a great time! From the great wait staff, to the delicious food this; restaurant doesn't settle in the off season. Although they were out of a few drinks me and my fiancé had selected the waitress and bartender made it a point to accompany us. The food was out of this world. A lot of the restaurants in town aren't up to par as they maybe in the summer months but muse's food was mouth watering. My fiancé and I have been talking about it for the past 3 days. If you want a great atmosphere paired with great food and exceptional service this place is the right choice for you! read more

What a great find. Server was so nice and accommodating! All 4 of us loved everything we ate: Mac n Cheese with Scallops, Salad, Burger, Pork Chops and Paella with black rice. Delicious! We all agreed, we'd go back in a second. Allergy friendly! read more

Had another wonderful dinner at the Muse. Was able to sit outside on a beautiful evening in Montauk. Food excellent and service (Abby) was great. Attentive but not rushed. Great place for date night. Highly recommend. read more

This was a fantastic find. The staff was genuine, pleasant, and laser focused on making sure we were taken care of. The food was beyond first rate; have not been spirited away by a meal like this in years. This is an amazing, funky-cool restaurant that everyone should experience. Sooooooo good. I only wish I could have taken them up on the offer to work there so I could experience it every night. read more

We just loved it. It's clean, fresh and has a open floor plan. We went earlier (around 6) and that was great. The menu had many choices, and we wanted to try just about everything. We started with the lamb meatball as an appetizer (which was recommended and was delicious) and shared the paella for dinner as our main course. They double plated it and let us share, which was a perfect amount and left enough room for dessert. Glad we did because the rice pudding and the mini zeppolis hit the spot. We noticed they had a price fixed meal choice as well. We look forward to coming back here again!! read more

Keeping it short and simple! Next summer you won't be able to get into this place. Amazing food, atmosphere, and staff. The bartender remembered what we ordered the 2nd time back and the manager Kevin is on top of this place. Whether dinner or brunch, experience this place while you can. Absolutely fantastic!! FYI- I created a Yelp account just to give this place a top review since it was so deserving. Leave room for desert!! See you at the Muse... read more

Very scary! Got a piece of very shape plastic in my French onion soup and they took away right away. It cut my mouth! They said they would offer a 50% off of only my entree. Are you insane? It had already cut my mouth! read more

Had dinner with the family at 6:30 PM this past Sat 2/3/18. Looked crowded at first but we were greeted and seated right away. Most of the people were at the bar although the dining floor was pretty busy. I had the Catch of the Day which was the codfish. The portion size was nice and it was prepared perfectly. I really enjoyed it. The family had the salmon and tuna poke. They enjoyed all the dishes and the service here was spot on! Great beer recommendation as well. This is the second time we have dined at this MUSE location and we have a wonderful experience. We will plan on returning. Nice job! read more

This restaurant is great. We had the osso buco and the scallops. The first one was excellent, good presentation and great taste. The scallops was good too but the quantity was a little low for a $40 plate. We shared a chocolate mousse for dessert that was amazing. The service was also very good and especially fast. I highly recommend this place. read more

Stumbled across this place and made a reservation...two foodies for dinner. Jessica was our server and fantastic in every way. We had several small plates and focused on fish. Mom and I were blown away by every bite that was complex, flavorful, cooked to perfection, gorgeous and just plain fantastic. We were trying to discern the ingredients of each dish on first bite and were suprised at the unique ingredients of each plate. Jessica mentioned the Chef has an organic garden and uses as everything he grows as well as local ingredients. I asked if we could meet the Chef Martin if he had a moment and out he comes 10 minutes later. We chatted about his road to working at Muse, his passion, ingredients etc when he said he had to get back to the kitchen and work on the stuffed zucchini blossoms for next day special. I replied I was bummed we were leaving and would not be able to eat there next day. So, the Chef returns to the kitchen sends out a portion for us! Wow...he whipped the ricotta so it was light as a feather and combined with the other flavors we almost fell off our chairs. A perfect ending to a perfect meal. No need or room for desert. If I lived in Montauk I would eat there every week or more. One of the finest meals Ive had and I've dined in some of the finest restaurants around the globe. Don't miss Muse!!! read more

First, let me say that the service and the décor earned the 5 stars. I did not have a reservation but my guest and I were immediately ushered to one of the last open tables in the newly renovated, perfectly clean, and enchanting dining room. Our server, Virginia, was knowledgeable about the specials and the menu. She also had an effortless serenity about her that made me feel like a welcome guest, which was incredible considering she had a full section. The food was delicious. The bread and spreads were so good that, if it were socially acceptable, I would have demanded more and simply ordered one appetizer. I was able to try the Mussels a la Muse, the Scallop Mac~n~Cheese, and the Pork Chops and Apple Sauce. My dinner date and I agreed that the pork chops were unlike any other--they were so tender and soft that we hardly believed them to be pork chops. The Mac~n~Cheese was heavenly for the first few bites. Unfortunately, it fell into the "too rich" category pretty quickly. I loved the artichoke hearts in the scallops; however, the giganta beans and shaved parmesan felt out of place. I was peaking at other tables' plates as they came out. The presentation of everything was lovely. I am disappointed that I did not get to try the Tuna "Menage A Trois" appetizer. I'll definitely be back for that. Kevin, the general manager, checked in with my guest and me to see how we were doing. I always love when a manager does that. It goes to show that mission of the restaurant is to make sure that everyone feels at home. Kevin clearly embodies this mission and impresses it on his staff. Well done! I can't wait to go back to try other dishes, cocktails, and desserts! read more

Fantastic food and service. COD and seared scallops were super tasty. Lamb meatball and crab cake were wonderful. Kids had chicken fingers which were extremely good. Wonderful decor and well lit inside. Highly recommend. read more