I've given this bakery many chances, but it is a clunker when you consider the many fantastic bakeries in the Pittsburgh area. Service is lacking. I was unimpressed with their workers, but I'll give it a pass considering the holiday. Their baked goods aren't anything special. Everything tastes the same, too sweet, too much vanilla. There's no complexity of flavor here. The nut roll was dry. The cake is bland. Their cookies feel pre-packaged. I've had a better sugar cookie from Giant Eagle. For the prices, I'd recommend spending your money somewhere else in Pittsburgh. read more

My Sweet Lilly is a local bakery that sells baked goods for humans and dogs. During my most recent visit, I saw a large assortment of cookies, biscotti, macaroons, macarons, galettes, tortes, cake slices, and much more. Prices were average. Employees interacted nicely with us. My husband and I both noticed the apple galette, so we bought one of those, as well as peanut-butter blossoms. I rate the apple galette, which is like a pie with a short crust, as 4.5 stars and the cookies, which needed a stronger flavor of peanut butter, as 3 stars. I no longer have a dog (otherwise I would have bought many dog treats here!), so I unfortunately cannot comment on the dog treats. read more

See all

Great find! Good selection and portions. Got some cookies to take back home on my flight. I had a slice of tiramisu which I highly recommend. Where this place shines is customer service. She gave great recommendations and suggestions. She wrapped the cookies so they'll make it back home on the plane. read more

The best place to grab some biscotti or something sweet located in the heart of Pittsburgh. The staff is so sweet and fast serving and always welcome you with a hello when you walk in the door. They are so sweet to my Miss Molly and always give her a cookie when they see her. The pictures speak for themselves! Everyone will find something sweet , including your pet! read more

See all

A boutique bakery in The Strip District.  A bakery specializing in baked goods for both you and your pet!!  They offer homemade delicious and traditional pastries.   I got the Italian assorted cookies and thought they were delicious and a fair price.  The raspberry filled cookie and the thumbprints were my favorites.  The dog baked goods look like human cookies and are so cute and a great quality.  They had homemade pumpkin roll that looked amazing, and I plan to go back to try. read more

See all

In my opinion, this is one of the staples of the Strip District if you have a sweet tooth. The staff have always been friendly during my many visits to this bakery. It is wall to wall sweets and treats! They even have treats for dogs as well! They have holiday themed doggy bones and biscuits that I love to use for stocking stuffers/puppy birthday gifts. They have a little bit of everything. I've been many times, but still have yet to try it all. Cannolis, pies, cheesecakes, macarons, cookies, biscotti.... Need I say more? Everything I have tried has been very good. My personal favorites are the stuffed pizzelles, to-die-for's, tiramisu, and raspberry thumbprint cookies. read more

See all

We absolutely love this pastry business, the best in cookies and unique pastries. They also offer dog treats Service was outstanding and helpful. The decor is unique and open, extremely clean and everything is well presented ! read more

See all

I bought this pack of Lilly's Raspberry Cookies for $12. Now, they don't say Linzer cookies but everyone knows that's the look and shape of a Linzer. They were horrible. The cookie tasted like packed sawdust and the center like a fruit roll up from 1992. The only real thing in here was the powdered sugar which was sparse. We both tried one and I am throwing the rest out. Will def not buy there again. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Brought some Macarons Great But charge me 10 cent for a bag At $3.00 a piece are you kidding about charging a dime for a bag Great Bakery Cheap Management read more

This is a nice bakery with a variety of tasty looking treats. I ordered the peanut butter cookie and another cookie with Reece's peanut butter mixed into it. Both were fresh and flavorful. Another person in my party ordered the pecan treats and said they were okay, (which I agree). There are doggie treats available for sale as well! The location is surprisingly large when you walk in. Everything was clean and orderly, and those providing service were nice. There is probably something here for most people to satisfy their sweet tooth. read more

If you want a sweet treat this is the place! Big variety so something for everyone. I got a strawberry chocolate macaroon it was amazing!!! So fluffy. read more

See all

What cute little shop! Went in while visiting town. Wonderful desserts and such adorable dog treats to bring back to my fur babies.

The baked goods are reasonably priced and the have a pretty decent variety. They have attractive displays throughout the store that are timelessly cute. The staff is always helpful, pleasant and they appear to take pride in their work. They're also dog friendly and have little baked dog treats in addition to their human snacks, though I cannot comment on their quality. Overall, a great place to stop when you're in The Strip regardless of your age. read more

See all

Stopped in this shop for the first time yesterday and was not disappointed! The service was friendly and quick. They had a great selection of baked goods available (for both humans and dogs!) I wish I had a dog to buy for! all of the treats looked so good. I left with a bag of goodies and can say that they taste as good as they look. The tuxedo cake will satisfy any chocolate craving you have :) Will definitely be back! read more

My Sweet Lilly - Tuxedo cake slice - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This is a lovely bake shop that has a variety of cakes, sweet, cookies, and all kinds of great stuff. I would have gone for one of the refrigerated cakes, but I was walking, and it would not be easy to eat, so I had to settle for the. Most delicious slice of Apple struedel. If a location like this was closer to my home, I would gain 10 pounds in a month. Check it out. You won't be disappointed. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped here again whilst visiting family. They are still the best. Love love looove the biscotti dipped in Belgian chocolate. I've gone to Belgium and this really is Belgian chocolate. Very good, creamy not waxy. I only like white chocolate if it's Belgian. Also had a lady lock and a lemon cookie. Lock was full of creamy goodness. The lemon cookie was chewy and tasted lemony but I prefer some tartness which it didn't have. So if you like lemon without tart, you'll like these. I wish they had a place in Phoenix AZ area. We don't have anything like it here. I miss Pittsburgh but hate the weather. Lol! I wish I had purchased the assortment box too. Also bought some dog treats but these are made by Canine Confections in Greensburg. So far, Dobby likes them. It's a sampler so he's only tried a few so far. We like supporting local businesses so if in the area, I recommend stopping at Lilly's to try some yummy pastries. You can buy singles to try with a coffee you can purchase nearby. I can't leave there without a bunch of stuff to take home. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Dobby likes it so far! - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

We came here on a food tour and got to sample their macarons. I tried the raspberry lemonade. The flavor was great, but maybe because it was gluten free, it was more flakey than I'm used to. The store itself was a neat experience to walk through. They have rotating display shelves of their pastries! I love that the store was named after the owner's dog Lilly! They had all kinds of dog treats as well. It was a bit pricey, but it was fun seeing all the colorful pastries. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Macarons - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent little bakery in the strip district ! Short trip but will return. Cakes and cookies are excellent. The lady locks are wonderful. I recommend the assortment!! The 2 die for cookies are full of cinnamon flavors that melt in your mouth. Highly recommend!!! read more

This place is amazing. All of their pastries are delicious and you also have to get the tiramisu if you come here! 11/10 recommend. Bonus is the staff are always friendly! read more

My Sweet Lilly - Cookie display - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Lots of bakery goodies here! Everyone super friendly. Dozen of cookies 12.00. This is s great sweet find. read more

See all

Lilly's is an absolute must in the strip! They have so many different goodies to choose from. I haven't gotten something from here that I was disappointed in, and there's been more than a few trips! During the latest trip there we got a caramel chocolate cheesecake for Christmas and it was a hit. Our whole family loved it and said it was the best cheesecake that they've ever had. You just can't beat this place! Between the decor, the friendly employees, and the delicious baked goods it deserves more than 5 stars. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We've been here a couple of times while walking in the Strip District and have been pleased each time! They have a wide array of cookies, cakes and sweets, including dog biscuits! The apple strudel is my favorite, a generous portion and quite tasty. The staff is very helpful in answering any questions you may have. We will definitely return! read more

11/10 for their service 6/10 for the macaroons and cannoli I found them to be really sweet and creamy . Its could be because I've tried better ones! I also bought some biscotti and I can't wait to try those . They have an entire wall dedicated to doggy treats. This shop is in Strip district so finding parking on a weekend could be a nightmare. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Biscotti - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This bakery is Outstanding. The pastries are absolutely to die for. The bakery inside is so cute. It is very clean and there are so many different pastries to pick from. They also have homemade treats for dogs and cats. The staff is friendly and helpful. I highly recommend stopping there when you visit the Strip District. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Their delicious thumbprint cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The staff was very pleasant. I am sorry to say that the pastries and candy were not. The ladylocks were so stale they were hard. The almonds on the burnt almond tart were soggy. The "turtles" have some sort of toffee base rather than the traditional soft caramel. Their flavor isn't bad, but not at all what we expected, more like a chocolate covered toffee brittle. It would have been good to know that. I hope the dog I bought the treats for likes them. Given all the great reviews, perhaps we just came on a bad day, but won't be going back to try again. read more

Located in the Strip District, this bakery has a bunch of different items to choose from. Unfortunately I think my choices were the wrong ones. The macarons looked amazing so I decided to try the tiramisu one. It didn't taste anything like tiramisu. In fact I didn't taste any coffee flavor whatsoever. It did have a sprinkling of cocoa powder on top giving it the look of tiramisu but without the flavor. The cookie part was amazing! Very flaky but the flavor wasn't all that great. The filling was a very sugary buttercream with no flavor. I think next time I'll try the chocolate one. I haven't given up on this place yet. I also bought a package of Lady Locks. They were flaky and not too sweet. There's filling in it but not enough in my opinion. I think I'll pass on these next time also. I will be back to try other items because there's so much to choose from and I can't imagine they are all just mediocre. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Not enough filling. Very flaky - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Desserts are ok, definitely over priced. $6 for a small slice of cake. Go to butterwood for better quality and larger slices

The customer service is the best I've ever seen. They are so welcoming and helping even when you are looking around. We bought mini cakes and a cannoli and everything tasted amazing. We are definitely going to go back! We didn't have any pictures because we are our desserts so fast! read more

I absolutely love this place. Since moving to the Strip, this has become one of my routine spots I hit on my Saturday stroll. The only criticism I have is that there isn't really any structure to order which can make it hard to be served without kinda butting your way through. I wish they had pull numbers. Not worth taking even a half star though. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Tiramisu - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Stopped in here randomly on Sunday while adventuring in the Strip District. I got 6 macarons - black cherry, birthday cake, salted caramel, vanilla, and pistachio. The macarons are a nice size, very delicious, and priced reasonably. The employees that were working are very friendly as well. If you're ever in the Strip District make sure to give this place a try. I will definitely be a repeat customer from now on! read more

My Sweet Lilly - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Ordered a few slices of their cake, tiramisu, lemon chiffon and strawberry shortcake. The Tiramisu and Lemon chiffon are delicious! Great flavor! Haven't had the strawberry shortcake yet. Great find and am looking forward to trying other items! read more

Wife and I just came from Deluca's which was next door. I saw all the pastries and biscottis and the store just pulled me in. All the pastries looked totally delicious and would definitely go back too try some other items. I got a biscotti sample pack which was $7 and had about 12 in the package. The staff where super friendly and extremely helpful. The selection was pretty good and I will definitely be going back for more I got home and ate about 4 of them before I even knew it. The biscotti's where totally delicious and would definitely recommend My Sweet Lilly. You can be sure I will be a regular here read more

See all

When visiting the strip district, If you like a good cannoli, cake, cookie , or any form of sweets to satisfy your sweet tooth, MY SWEET LILLY is the place for you! I had their Lemon Chiffon Cake! So moist, fulfilling and decadent. If you're into Lemon, do not hesitate, buy it. The sugar doesn't overide the actual lemon. Hard to find bakeries that have lemon goodies where the lemon is packed with tons of sugar ! It's just the right amount of sweet and the right amount of tart. Only costs $4.50. For more peeks at my travels, food gallery, and cooking content, find me on FB, YouTube, Instagram and Cravve @zillathegrubgod. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Lemon Chiffon Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

What a cute sweet shop in the strip.. so much personality in the shops decor. Cookies to cakes to chocolate covered turtles! ! Me and girlfriend visited on a Sunday and there was really cool music playing .. as you browse all the sweets!!! I purchased a pumpkin pie cheese cake.. which was so divine with every bite!!! Decent prices too. I look forward to stopping the next time I am down the strip. read more

See all

Such a fun bakery right in the middle of the strip. They have some Pennsylvania classic cookies which are always a big hit. They had a large variety of sweets which will make it hard for you to choose! The macrons were delicious as well as the large cookies. The cheesecake was thick and and looked very appetizing. They also had a large selection of dog cookies and home made dog treats. The prices are more $$ but a delicious experience nonetheless. Worth a pop in if you are strolling the strip. They also have killer music playing and you can follow their Spotify playlists. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

We have been in this bakery many times and have never actually tried anything. Just gawked at all the delicious baked goods and then had to leave because we couldn't make a decision with so many choices. Haha! Today we finally broke that cycle and got a few Buckeyes, a macaroon, and some kolaches. Some of our favorite things! It was just as good as expected. We will be back next time we come to the Strip. There are many more things for us to try. read more

Nothing throws you for a loop like a calling for a sweet. And when you are walking around in the Strip District it's a delight to find a place like this that can curb your need. I, like most people, aimlessly roam around the Strip District from time to time. Sometimes it has a purpose, but most times I just end up somewhere without thinking about it. That's basically what happened with My Sweet Lilly. I just wandered in here, or maybe I was guided by an unseen force. Kind of like that gag they did in the old cartoons where a scent just magically guided me here. Once inside it was a difficult time. Difficult in the sense that I now had to make a choice of what I wanted. It's not easy to figure out what you want when you are in a sweets shop, but you kind of just go with what your gut tells you. Bit of advice, don't come in here hungry or you will be making many more decisions than you should. I browsed for a bit, but already kind of knew what I wanted. I got myself and my other half one of each of the following: lady locks and gobs. Yes people, it is called a gob, it's not a whoopie pie, it is a gob in this neck of the woods. I will fight you over this. We waited until after we had dinner and made our way home for the night to enjoy our treats. Each were amazing, perfect sweetness to both. Left us wanting more, but that is until we have our next Strip District wandering. read more

Really ... you set up a huge display of pasteries, cookies, cannolis, enormous apple tarts, ladylocks, pizzelles, etc. and expect me to walk by them in the main lobby of a hospital ... I caved. Buckeyes the size of golf balls just melt in your mouth. The apple tart had a crisy crust with perfectly baked apples with just the right amount of cinammon and sugar goop. Um no pictures for this review because everything was savored/gobbled up in a matter of minutes. The gentlemen who were selling the products were very well versed in the products. So if you have an allergy, they know all about the ingredients. Highly recommend. Support small businesses. read more

If you are in the Strip District you NEED to stop at My Sweet Lilly! It's just a little pastry shop, but their baklava is to die for! Their macaroons are very good as well, but are kind of small for the $2 price tag. In addition to all of the wonderful human pastries, My Sweet Lilly also has gourmet dog treats! They are beautifully created and my dog always loves when I bring her one home! read more

Cute little bakery we found while in town. I must have walked pass this place tons of times before. They have a wide selection of cookies, pastries, cakes and other delicious delights. They are all reasonably priced and very tasty. They even have dog treats which both of my dogs love (one is a picky eater and chows down on them). We got cake, cookies and macaroons to go as we were shopping as wanted something sweet later and we were pleasantly surprised on the taste and texture of everything. I can't wait to be back in town and at the strip district to revisit this place. The woman behind the counter was so nice and welcoming. I think she was kind of shocked when I ordered half a cake on display by the slice. If your looking for some sweets definitely go here. read more

My Sweet Lilly - Delicious - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania