This is probably the best value for your dollar in Eureka Springs. The Eureka Omelette was delicious and the service was great. Everyone was very accommodating and there's a cute little gift shop to look around in, too. read more

Found this little place on Yelp. Being in town for wedding and not familiar with the area it is always hit or miss on a good breakfast place. This restaurant is awesome!! Food is good but the service is AMAZING. My server was always quick to refill my coffee and food came faster than I ever expected. If your looking for a great place for breakfast this is a must!! read more

Okay I'm writing a review because I seen this place didn't have 5 stars which it deserves. If it wouldn't have been for this good breakfast I would have literally starved. My biscuits and gravy were da bomb and the omelette was excellent. Coffee was good, hell even my 76 yr old waitress was on point. Your better off paying the few extra bucks here than eating at the other places this town has to offer. read more

So disappointed. Called ahead of time to ask if serving buffet and was told yes but when we arrived there was no buffet. Extremely limited menu and way overpriced. Asked for something besides a side salad with my meal and was told nothing to substitute. Salads were wilted and one had tomato and one didn't. Fried chicken used to be wonderful but this time was overcooked and tasteless. Was offered some kind of muffin. I asked what kind it was and waitress didn't know, she "thought some kind of fruit" . Probably won't ever go back. read more

I loved all the social distancing measures in place. The food was basic breakfast, definitely nothing trendy. Addie was a great server!

Food was gross. Mash potatoes were fake, salad bar was brown, and the food has ridiculous up charges. NO THANKS! 1 and done.

Yaaas! The salad bar is so good and clean ( and cheap!). My buddy hit the full buffet, I'm a vegetarian, we ate til we couldn't eat more, and it was 18 bucks! What a deal! I will put a dent in that salad bar every time I swing thru! read more

Best fried chicken I have ever eaten 5 stars definitely recommend this restaurant we had dinner here 3 times and everything we had was delicious! read more

Decent place to eat. The chicken was amazing but the rest, not so much. Mashed potatoes tasted like chemicals so we didn't eat them. Service was great though, best we had the whole trip. read more

Food was not that good. Best part was our server Mollie who has worked there since 1975.

It was a decent salad bar but my husband and I felt like we time traveled to the restaurant. Not in a good way. It was not as good as Applebees food(which I can't stand). Service was actually great. Nice people! But food quality was low. Seemed like mostly frozen recooked food. read more

I had the chopped sirloin and it was really good! We did take out and it was ready on time as promised. Order was correct and food was hot. Couldn't ask for better. read more

The best old-fashioned Ozarks food in town! Great salad bar, delicious fresh wheat bread, wonderful and fair-priced menu items, and the most delicious cookies and muffins you'll ever find for dessert! We had the fried trout, fried chicken, and country-fried steak in our party, and all were great! Many traditional favorites and healthy options as well. Great family atmosphere. Your best choice in Eureka! read more

Food was amazing, breakfast and lunch equally as good and super good prices! Great service too!

We started our visit in Eureka Springs having lunch here. my husband had the chicken-fried chicken and I had the salad bar and soup. Both of our meals we're very good. Everything on the salad bar was fresh. The staff is extremely nice. read more

Great spot for breakfast. We had the omelette and pancakes. The omelette was so flavorful and can tell they use fresh eggs. Pancake was made with love and definitely had a good crispy edges. Definitely recommend this place for a great breakfast with a view. read more

Very good fried chicken, patty melt, chicken sandwich. Blueberry and nut muffins on salad bar awesome!!

Simply put - I would go back to dine here in a heart beat. From the moment we walked in, to the moment we walked out, everything was perfectly timed. From the greeting to the check. The salad bar, everything you could want. Appetizers, prompt and delicious. Entrees, excellent, which included two steaks and prime rib, all which were cooked exactly as we ordered them and were absolutely delicious. Service was prompt and friendly. I don't have a single complaint about this experience, and will definitely recommend them to my friends. read more

We've been here twice during our stay in Eureka Springs. Breakfast and lunch were both delicious, and the staff is amazingly nice.

It's solid. Gets pretty busy and food was good. Service solid. Place is a little dated but you could do worse for sure (Bubba's BBQ For example). Salad bar is a good bargain and fresh. 3 feels right and I'd go 3.5 if I could read more

Great place to eat! Delish food and service was wonderful! Will be back next time we visit here! read more

Myrtie Mae's - Amazing!!! - American Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

See all

This place is really ok. It's not good but it ain't bad. The coffee was hot water, and the biscuits were microwaved. The gravy is that ridiculous instant crap! There is nothing special about this place. What pissed me off was that half of the men in this place didn't have the decency to remove their hat. I know that is old fashioned but if your a man remove your damn hat when you eat. read more

Been here twice for dinner. I like this place. Large clean dining room and friendly staff. The salad bar is huge. Lots of selections and all good. But, for the second time, I was so full I didn't try the possum pie. Third times a charm. I recommend this place. read more

This place reminds me of a buffet my grandmother would go to. The portions are pretty big and the price is just right. I usually eat here to partake in the all you can eat salad bar. The salad bar is on point with different pasta salads, pimento cheese, muffins, soups, and various types of lettuce. My next visit will be for a Sunday brunch, though every time I've tried the line was out the door. Give this place a shot, your grandma would approve. read more

Food was not great not bad. Are there twice in two days. Both days they messed up the order. The first day we ordered the catfish and it was greasy. Well seasoned and I thought it was ok but not great. My companion thought it was terrible. It came with a scoop of mashed potatoes. They forgot the hush puppies. $13 for two fillets and a scoop of potatoes. The next morning we ordered breakfast. They just butchered the order. I had to walk to pick it up and then had to walk back again to get the rest of the order. They didn't make a new order, just supplied all of the missing items. By then the original order was cold. It was clearly the kitchen messing up. The ticket was correct. What was provided was not. The food was OK and probably would have been better had they remade it so I could have had a hot meal. Bad service really irks me and you can't get much worse than messing up the order. Twice. read more

Handy if you're staying in the hotel, but probably worth a short drive somewhere else.... - When seating I asked for one of the tables near the window with a view of the woods. The hostess said she had just seated some in that waitresses section so she would give me a table with a view of the parking lot. So it's the needs of the staff not the needs, or desire, of the customer...? - Reasonable prices - (Just) OK food - Warm and muggy inside - Flies.... - Slow service Again, there are better places in town that are worth a short drive... read more

During COVID, they had to shut down their signature breakfast buffet, but the food was still delicious! The service has always been amazing when I've come. read more

Delicious Biscuits and Gravy and Hash browns. This is located inside The Inn of the Ozarks. elderly staff but great service and very sweet. Loved going here for breakfast both morning we were in town. read more

This place is in the best western. Totally worth it we had great food and service. I wanted home cookin and got it! Buffet was small but with lots of options and will go back for sure. read more

See all

A cool little hidden gem inside a chain-hotel. We took a tour of Eureka Springs, and our tour guide Ralph suggested of all the food places in town that Myrtie Mae's was the most consistent and best food in town. So we had to give it a try. The GPS said to turn, but all we saw was a Best Western hotel. We thought that maybe it was behind the hotel, but finally we realized it was inside, it was the hotel restaurant. My wife and I were rather skeptical but pressed on. We got the lunch buffet, and man the food was great! They had some roast beef that they hand sliced that was cooked perfectly and seasoned great. Mashed potatoes, rice, fish, everything on the buffet was great. Salad bar was good and fresh as well. We were very surprised at the quality of food from the buffet. Only room for improvement I could see was that the staff were either a little overworked or they were a bit unfriendly & unhelpful at times. The hostess seemed annoyed at my request to put my tip on my credit card, and my wife felt that the waitress didn't have a good tone with her. But both very little things that didn't diminish the whole experience. Thanks Ralph! I don't think we would have ever ventured into a random hotel restaurant for some good food without your suggestion... read more

Food and service were both ok. We had the chicken Eureka and the hot ham and cheese dishes. The muffins were lovely! The main dishes were ok. Over all it was very ok. read more

Went with a group of friends based on one friend's recommendation. It was okay, we all ordered different food and it did all come at once which was a plus. Service was good, parking easy. That said, I probably won't be back. Eureka has several breakfast places and would rather go to them. read more

Stopped for lunch after a long, exhausting drive. Mmmm-mmmm, old-fashioned fried chicken. Yum. Not so fast. It was horrible and mediocre with a scalding hot, hard helmet-like coating that was flavorless. And served with INSTANT mashed potatoes. Really insulting. The only saving grace here was the service, which was provided by gracious, experienced staff. I felt sorry that they were charged with carrying out such drek. The salad bar was OK. Pumpkin bread was studded with hard nuggets of unmixed batter, but MM decided to put it out anyway. Stunningly mediocre place. At least it was cheap. read more

Inside the Best Western Inn of the Ozarks. The BF and I had the FRESH salad bar, it was good. My son had the hamburger, it looked really good and he confirmed it was too. read more

Brunch buffet? Yes. Everything else? Not as much Been here for the breakfast/ brunch buffet and thought it was pretty good. It's a higher than average quality for buffet food as its small and controllable. Even had an omelette chef. So try that if you can. Made the trip for lunch only to find the tiny buffet replaced w menus that were just ok. Food was good and reasonable, everyone very nice - just not great. Kind of ate the whole meal w a "whatever" mindset. There are plenty of other local places that have better food, choices and atmosphere. I'd try those instead. read more

Met a friend at the hotel as we were motorcycling in the area. We decided to go up and have breakfast and coffee. My wife and I split an omelette with home fries as we weren't starved. Great service and really good food. When we are in the area we will go back there for breakfast. read more

The food was good but kinda slow service and saw them setting up a buffet, had we known it was for breakfast that's what we would of ordered but no one said anything we thought it was for lunch since it was after 10:30 but when I asked after we put our Order in (and it had already been over 20 min since it been put in )they said it was brunch , looked very good ! I had pancakes and side hash browns and hubby had two eggs with hash browns and sausage and biscuit and gravy , we both thought it was good ... read more

We had dinner here because it's attached to the Best Western we stayed in. Myrtie Mae's loves to tout their fried chicken as the best around, but we felt that it was just okay. My son had the potato cheese soup and threw most of it away because "it tastes weird." I had the fried catfish filets. The catfish was so hard that it was difficult to eat. All in all it's okay. We probably won't go back unless we stay in the Best Western again. read more

A nice quiet spot to sit down and have a delicious breakfast breakfast. Fast and super friendly service, we couldn't have been more pleased with how nice and quick everything was served read more

This place is cheap. Like, really cheap. It's also not very good. Honestly, it's the kind of place old people go to because they can't taste food so well any more, don't want to cook, and are loathe to spend much on dining. Everyone's friendly, the service is efficient, and it has family restaurant charm. It's also just terribly out of date. Salad bar. Everything was fresh. Iceburg, but fresh. Many options, including a bar of 70s-style potluck mayo salads. I tried some of those and liked none. Fried chicken: Decent for a family restaurant, but not impressive for a signature item. Too salty. BLT: So many chips. Too bad the bacon looked and tasted like salad bar bacon bits, only not ground up. Fiercely salty, like the soylent green of bacon. Otherwise, sandwich okay. Coffee: Standard grade. Standard blend. Not burnt and it tasted like coffee. read more