WOW, I'll apologize for failing to take substantial pics…read more The place is small, no seating inside, it's plain, nothing too fancy with a Snapple cooler on the right and a small ice cream cooler on the left. We ordered 2 lobster rolls and a turkey sub. I ordered a Maine lobster - lobster meat and mayo. My daughter got the LBI roll - lobster meat, avocado, tomato and mayo. My wife ordered the west coast turkey - turkey, Swiss, avocado and citrus mayo All sandwiches were loaded w meat. They were fresh and tasty. The amount of meat in the turkey sandwich was ridiculous. Service was quick and friendly. If I have any suggestion, there needs to be a side with the lobster rolls aside from cole slaw. A bag of chips or a side of fries would be nice. Overall we enjoyed the food and I'm a bit concerned that this place is walking distance from my house.

This is probably the 5th or 6th time my husband & I went to Mystic. Initially it was a 5 star…read morereview-- otherwise we wouldn't have gone back. It's pricey for sure, but it was worth the occasional splurge.... Then they changed their menu-- which at first was great. We had liked their subs, but when we saw the change earlier this summer, the guy working the counter said the change was to focus more on lobster creations. That was pretty much their social media tag line. The first time with the new menu it was pretty great & I enjoyed their tacos. My go-to roll was the Deep South. I'm sure you're wondering-- wait, she said it was great so why the 1 star? Well, we went back this afternoon, after not being back since the day after their menu change. So it's been a few weeks. And omg they have gone downhill fast. I ordered a Deep South roll; my husband got the Beach Haven and we figured we were in for the long haul, so we got an order of Costal Tacos to share, along with an order of what were supposed to be the brined yukon gold potatoes. All of these we've ordered before. None of them were the same as when we got them a few weeks ago. The potatoes weren't brined-- or weren't brined to the same level as they were before. When the menu was changed, the potatoes were addictive & really like nothing we've had before. Now? They were a few flaccid potatoes swimming in some oily muck. Before, they were tossed in a seasoning (bay or rosemary herb). Now? The Bay seasoning was clumped to the bottom of the container & there was the aforementioned pool of muck. Yuck. My husband had no complaints about his roll. It looked appetizing. Mine? Which I've had more than a few times-- was overpowering with a mayo that tasted more like Bay seasoning than chipotle. It was NOT what I had before, which was spicy, but not swimming in mayo. You could see and taste the lobster, which came in large chunks-- so good tail & claw meat. Not the shredded garbage that I had today, which was swimming in this bay flavored mayo. And NO CANDIED JALAPENOS!-- which are the maker of this roll. At $20.99 the roll should have been perfect. Not this garbage roll. The final insult-- the Costal Taco. Brown avocado. No Key Lime Jelly. Overwhelming with coarsely chopped red onion-- which I can still taste 6 hours later. Very light on the lobster. Very heavy on the greens, which were wilted. And several pieces of shell. I thought this was my go-to Lobster place. No longer. Changing their menu sounded like a good idea IF they were going to focus on producing the best lobster roll around. Now, with the increased prices what we were served today was just insulting. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY.

We were welcomed and immediately the conversation began. This Jersey Mike's is mere miles away…read morefrom where it all started and the wall murals give you a feel for the Jersey Shore. There is a comfortable simplicity in the small dining area but you get the opportunity to continue to chat with the hard working team behind the counter. However what really matters is the food!! Deli meats, cheese, and veggies cut right before your very eyes! Fresh and delicious. Why in the world does anyone go to Wawa or any place that preslices their meat truly confuses me. Walking out the door we all felt good!

Just picked up a to go order and tried this location as I was with family nearby and my #17 was my…read morenumber 1 and it's a sad fail. Why is this sandwich so sad. Two of the four sandwiches were not perfect. No tomatoes on someone allergic to tomatoes is returnable and inedible. My #17.. I'm playing where's Waldo-peppers n onions. Just sad...

Solid place for food in Bayville area!…read more Heard about this place on social media. Stopped by on an afternoon to try their enormous mozzarella sticks. They did not disappoint! Normally when a food item is made big, the taste suffers. However I can say these ones were great. The breading was great, the marinara sauce was good and the cheese itself was solid. Honestly worth the price and I wasn't hungry for the rest of the day. The restaurant itself was very clean and service was friendly. They had other things like shakes and burgers and I would love to come back to try them!

Incomplete. It appears that Big Dogs is gone at this…read morelocation. When I arrived the shop was closed and the windows papered over with advertising for an incoming Korean Fried Chicken rapid food operation. Too bad. While I was hoping for a creative frankfurter, I would have happily made due with some delicious crispy double dipped KFC. If anyone is paying attention, please let everyone know your plans and if there are other locations. I would still like to check you out. Come on, Big Dogs!

On a pretty busy Saturday night, other than taking a bit longer than it should have to get our…read moredrinks-service was great-food was amazing-everything everyone ordered was delicious! Drinks were fabulous!! This was our first visit, won't be our last! Seriously- must try the focaccia fagioli-omg!! I had the veggie burger which was so flavorful-clearly homemade and fresh-delicious! Others in our party enjoyed their meals as well! Great aesthetic-decor is on point! Lightning is great and it's not too loud! Some places are so loud you can't have a conversation-perfect noise level here!! All around it was a great night!

We have wanted to try this place for sometime and finally decided to do this on a Saturday…read moreafternoon, yesterday. I don't know how old the restaurant is, but I believe it's relatively new as it looks very clean, modern, has very high ceilings and a modern rustic type of feel. There are steel beams in the ceiling to the floor. The flooring is a warm laminate wood. They have booths, tables and a nice bar area. The dining room also has windows with natural lighting and also lights that come down to each table. We are greeted by our waiter and sat, he was friendly and attentive. The only thing that was odd, he didn't check to see if our main courses came ok. But overall, we really liked this restaurant. They have a very eclectic menu. We shared the Bavarian pretzel, the mustard and the beer cheese were excellent. I had the Tuscanwich with breaded eggplant. It also comes with broccoli rabe, roasted red peppers and house made mozzarella on Joe Leone's bread. It was awesome. It also comes with housemaid potato chips, which were excellent. My wife had the Smashburger with sweet potato fries. She said it was amazing. I had a Franzeskonner beer, which is very hard to find so I was very happy about that. My wife had a winter tequila cocktail, which looked beautiful and also tasted great. We passed on dessert, but we will definitely be back. They also have other really great entrées. They have a really good wine list and many awesome cocktails.

Our Realtor gave us a generous gift basket that included a gift certificate for Breaking Bread…read moreEatery. An Italian deli with a variety of items that change daily. Salads, sandwiches and delicacies like rice balls and eggplant rollatini. Enjoyed our sandwiches. Like the murals too. Parking on site.

I could never express just how much I love getting a sandwich from this place…read more So you'll walk in and the friendliest people will greet you every time. Even if you're an introvert (which I am) they'll get you talking about anything. The cool vibes you get in there is straight out of an Italian movie. The bread is amazing, the toppings are always fresh, and the fifteen minutes I take to eat the sub is hands down the best feeling I'll have all day, especially if I'm fasting beforehand. 11/10. Best subs in Toms River. Never skip this place on your way to or from seaside heights if you're hungry.

Wonderful food, large portions and an extremely pleasant staff. Highly recommend. Reservations…read morerequired...small dining room.

Just Wonderful!! Service was excellent. Food as always…read moresuperb!! Space is small and seating is limited so suggest planning ahead especially during the summer season

I've said it before & will say it again--BEST sandwich on the Jersey Shore, just over the bridge on…read morethe mainland. DD'd chicken salad sub & Mac salad side to share. The chicken salad is unbelievable & their macaroni salad is one of the best I've had--just like Nonni's!

Can't get enough of Della Cuccina new restaurant right next to their deli. As if the deli wasn't…read moregood enough, now they have this fabulous little diamond in Tom's River. They are so friendly you feel like part of their family walking in the door. The menu is fantastic. The food is fantastic. The decor is fantastic. Did I mention the food is fantastic? Can't say enough about this new wonderful place added to Toms River!

I ordered food and paid for it with my credit card. The pick up time was Sunday between three and…read morefour. I arrived at 3:15 and the place was closed. I will never return and I will be reporting them to the Better Business Bureau.

Big selection! freshly made items. Service very good,friendly informative on questionable items…read more Ambiance, also very good,business clean items located in easy to find areas. Suggestion only, on any new food item a sampling would justify,but as I said the selection is worth the stop in!