Great pizza and good prices! I've been buying this pizza for years now and am satisfied every time. I always get pepperoni pizza. Their sauce is on the sweeter side and the bread is perfect. Great place to try and would recommend to get away from those big chain pizza places! read more

Love Neighbors! It does take awhile for delivery, but in PL, that's to be expected. Great customer service every time, and the Pizza is delish. Georgia is my favorite. They deliver ice cream as well :) read more

By far one of the best crust I had for a pizza. It was crispy on the outside and soft an chewy on the inside, but there was not too much dough. Amazing state theme flavor pizza with a warm welcoming staff. I never thought mashed potatoes could work on a pizza, but the Idaho was amazing. I also loved the Georgia (perfect balance of cream and garlic sauce with chicken and cheese) and the New Yorker (tons of toppings but not feeling like I am only eating toppings). If you are ever in the area, take a drive to Neighbors Pizza. read more

For the prices the food really isn't good at all. A bit of advice if you're going to charge an arm and a leg at least make sure your drivers bring their condiments that were ordered. Especially when I'm pre paying a 10 dollar tip. read more

Love getting pizza from here! This place is absolutely money every time! Prices are definitely fair as well! I might call for some now!

I ordered a XL New York pizza and cheesy bread sticks to go..The pizza was embarrassing. Everything fell apart. The crust was soggy and when you lifted a slice everything fell off. From the sauce to the topping there was no flavor all bland. The cheesy bread sticks tasted like a slice of bread with cheese on it. Im not sure if this service and quality i received was due to the fact that i arrived about 45 min to there closing. Disheartening that i could have received a better quality pizza for half of what i spent on a Walmart take n bake! read more

I was so impressed with our meal today. The food was delicious. came out exactly the way we ordered it and the staff was so pleasant. They came by our table twice to ask how things were and brought my daughter the gummy pizza at the end of her meal. places like this are a rare find. read more

Neighbors Pizza - The Alaska challenge. Way too much pizza for me. - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

The pizza isn't that good.They also charged my credit card more than my total. I even went in to pick it up. Took almost a week to get the difference back. read more

I was really disappointed! After hearing so many amazing reviews, most of which were from family members, I have wanted to try Neighbors Pizza for months! Finally, Tuesday my husband and I went and ordered a large half Hawaiian; half New York pizza with mozzarella cheese sticks. The crust.... this may be their signature crust, or something, but mine was incredibly dry and flavorless. It was not appealing at all. I had to dip my crust in marinara when I got home. They didn't add much sauce, which I usually am one to complain of too much sauce so this complaint came as a shock to me. I felt like the pizza was nothing to brag about and truthfully would rather go to Papa Murphys or Dominos. The mozzarella sticks were okay, but again, nothing special. Overall, $30 for a large pizza and cheese sticks was way over priced for a mediocre taste. read more

My fiancé and I really love this spot. We are new to the area and while we were moving we saw this place and decided to try. We tried the bbq chicken pizza and the combination pizza. I LOVED the combo one. Super tasty and great flavor. the bbq was my fiancé's favorite. He said the sauce had great flavor. I wonder if they make it themselves... But anyways not badly priced. It's a mom and pop shop so I would expect to pay $20 for a large pizza. They also give you a chip for every pizza you order and after 10 (I think) you get a free pizza! We will be back!!!! read more

We ordered a pizza last night and while eating leftovers today my mother bit down on a paperclip!! The owner did call back right away and apologized, offering a credit on our account. Right after we hung up I sent him a text with a picture of the pizza and paperclip and requested a refund rather than the store credit. The owner never responded so we went in the store to meet face to face. We met with the owner (Bryan) who was argumentative and implied we put the paperclip on the pizza ourselves. When we told him we're both police officers he implied we weren't honest officer because "not all cops are good ones." All we asked for was the refund and spend 15 minutes arguing with this guy who could have just made things right by refunding immediately! He was mad when we said we we're not interested in their pizza anymore. I mean who would order from a place after biting down on a paperclip pizza!!? We don't doubt the paperclip was put their on accident, but it still got in our pizza and someone bit down on it! Make it right and treat customers like you really care! read more

Neighbors Pizza - Found this paperclip in our pizza last night! - Pizza Near Me - Olivehurst, California

Just got a personal chicken garlic pizza and it was real good!! The pizza I ordered came with fresh tomatoes originally i asked for sun dried as a sub and boy did it come with sun dried a bunch and they were yummy. Only negative was that I am a huge fountain drink fan and there machine was down/flat. but they did accommodate me with a can of cold soda! overall good experience! read more

Neighbor's pizza is by far the best pizza place I've been to here in the yuba/sutter area. My favorite would have to be their Pennsylvania pizza which is basically their cheese steak pizza. A lot of other pizza places out there use red sauce for this same pizza but neighbor's uses cream sauce instead. It is heaven. I was never a big pizza eater until I came across neighbor's. I only give it 4 stars because their cheezy bread is just ok and they're not open late at night, so when hankering for a late night pizza, I'd have to go elsewhere. They also offer pasta which has great meatballs but the pasta they use is a little overcooked, not mushy, but it's not al dente. They also offer a military discount which is always great. read more

I used to love to order from these guys,stop for a while.well today I decided to order.....my order took an hr and a half to deliver,I live about five blocks away....really.i was very upset and disappointed.....all they said was,well we are busy......hire more people more delivery drives.....I done with,no wonder they went out of business in Yuma city read more

Pizza sux dont waste your money. Crust. Hard , not a lot of sauce or toppings, waste of 25 bux, next time ill make the drive to round table, not good in the hood! read more

Rude staff and not so good pizza. I do not recommend this place!!!! Better off going to little Cesar's for 5 bucks.

I've been here twice since moving to the area about a month ago and I don't know what it is about the pepperoni.... but it's the best pepperoni pizza I've ever had! read more

Great pizza! Best pizza around here. Good customer service. The only negative is that lately( last two years ) they take an hour + to deliver. read more

I was at my daughters for fathers day and she suggested a Pizza, sounds good. I enjoy trying different foods and asked my daughter to get me as odd a flavor as they had, well the "Idaho" flavor sure met that desire, it's basically a baked potato! I have to say, first pizza in a while that really knocked me out, REALLY good pizza. The delivery to Plumus lake was fast, the delivery lady was sweet as can be, five stars from me! read more

They have the worst delivery times and the food is awful and overpriced

We were visiting my brother we ordered pizza from here. Gabby went above and beyond for our order. She has excellent customer service skills and is very friendly! Today that's hard to find. The pizza was pretty good also! The only thing was the cinnamon balls were a little tough. Overall great experience and taste! read more

Great pizza!!! Trying the Idaho is a must, but each pizza I tried was amazing. Service was friendly and fast, the restaurant had such a family feel I had fun hanging out there with friends. Definetly best pizza I've had in awhile, especially that crust! read more

My love affair with pizza has landed me in pizza joints all up and down California from LA to Visalia to the SF Bay area, Santa Cruz and Redding. This one is up there with some of my favorites. I'd have to say it's the crust. Not too thick not too thin and pleasantly light. Wonderfully unique twists on familiar toppings. Great experience. Will swing by again if I'm in the area! read more

We went here two times and we will not be back ever!!!!!! The pizza was under cooked both times !!!! Dough was raw!!!!!' Can you say yuck!!!

Pizza is ok, but prices are too high for the quality. We eat their on a rare occasion since it is close to home, but would rather drive a little further for better pizza. read more

Ok this is great! I absolutely love the Texas pizza! Yeah its really hot and hard to eat sometimes but all you gotta do is blow! ;-) and alright I am not a racist woman but the black lady that works there omg! She is so beautiful! And the legs on her like damn! Not to mention her customer service is superb and is so polite! I hope I get her every time I go in and order! I had stopped by today hoping I would see her but she wasn't there. Sad face! I will definitely be going back to this place with the little checkered paper in the pizza boxes! read more

The New York Pizza is Awesome!!!!!!! My husband & I love it. Sorry no other pizza place is better then this

Love there pizza always hot fresh and amazing. My favorite is the salads, and stuffed sandwiches.

Great customer service, unique and delicious pizzas! As the Health and Safety Administrator for a small business in Plumas Lake, I occasionally get to reward our hard working guys for good safety practices with a pizza party. I called Neighbors Pizza this time around because of their quality and unique pizzas, but was worried if they could accommodate my guys' lunch time (11am). But, Julie made it happen! The pizzas were delivered to the shop right on time, the guys loved them, and we had a very full and happy crew the rest of the day. Thank you, Julie, for coming in early to make my meeting such a success! Everyone is looking forward to the next time they reach their safety goal :) read more