I stop into Neil's Pizzeria occasionally during lunch when I'm in the direction of Valley Road running an errand. It's in the strip mall that used to have A&P anchoring it. It's tucked away in the corner. They always have at least 10-15 different kinds of slices available whenever I stop in. I've had the plain cheese, vodka sauce, eggplant parmigiana, and chicken bacon ranch slices among others. Of those, I'd probably say that the vodka sauce and chicken bacon ranch slices were my favorites. Those two kinds were the standouts for me. They are unique and worth trying. For the most part, the pizza is decent, but I've definitely had better. It's not my first choice of pizza place, but you won't be disappointed either. Neil's gets really busy at lunch time as it is located across the street from Wayne Valley High School. The kids will literally fill up the restaurant. So plan your timing accordingly or grab your pizza to go. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

My wife picked up meatballs and grilled vegetables meatball where horrible and vegetables where over cooked and soggy I was shocked we always order from Neil but not anymore read more

Eat Like Being in Naples, Italy!!! My wife and I went to Neil's Pizzeria & Restaurant at the Village Ridge Shopping Center, 588 Valley Rd, Wayne, NJ Last night for the first time but I can guarantee not the last. They were busy with customers eating in and customers picking Up takeout. We got a table and sat down. The owner came over and suggested Several dishes, pasta's, seafood, veal, and chicken which all sounded Exceptionally good and made my decision harder to choose as I wanted to try them all. I ordered the Pescatore which included clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari over linguine. It arrived in a big square platter and looked and smelled amazing. All the shellfish were cooked Perfectly as well as the al dente pasta. It was phenomenally delicious!!! I ate it Like it was my last meal! I could not eat it fast enough it was that good. My wife ordered A bowl of Stracciatella Romana Soup. I tasted a spoonful, and it was the best Stracciatella Soup I ever had in any restaurant. My wife enjoyed it immensely. As servers walked by us bringing pizzas to the tables they all looked incredible and smelled Delicious. We met the owner who is a super nice gentleman. He thanked us for our patronage and wished us a Happy holiday. I highly recommend you try Neil's Pizzeria! You will not be disappointed! read more

The pizza was fantastic, they are one of the best pizzas I had in a while and the service was great.

The pizza here is always great! A nice little spot in Wayne to get some awesome food. Ordered take out the other day from here and everything was fresh right out the oven. Happy to support a small business during these crazy times. read more

I should start this brief review, with a qualification that I've only given it three stars because we've only gotten take out from Neil's. All the items we've gotten have been absolutely wonderful! In particular, my order of mussels. They were plump, tender, and in a tomato sauce that was mostly tomato and very little oil. The bread that was supplied was fresh and crusty and absolutely perfect with an order of mussels. Salads were generous, the wrap that we ordered was perfect, and the two orders of gnocchi could not have been better. We look forward to going there again. read more

A fire place to grab a slice, defiantly worth going out of the way to grab a slice here.

Closes a 9 pm due to the "covid-19" pandemic in the middle of June. Just another business that wants to claim that they fell "victim" of it without even trying to make an effort to succeed. Piss poor read more

RACIST PEOPLE! Are you freaking kidding me?! I cannot believe what happened today! Screw these people. NEVER coming here ever again! There was this sweet Asian girl in front of me asking for french fries and the employee was like, "Herro? What are you trying to say? Chicken Fried Rice? We don't serve CHICKEN FRIED RICE!". I couldn't believe my ears! The girl's face became red and I was truly disgusted! I even told the employee that what he said was messed up! I immediately left without buying anything, same with the girl. I encourage all who read this to boycott this place. There is No Room for racist acts to remain hidden and go unpunished! How can people be so rude and racist?! You lost a loyal customer for good. #SayNotoRacism read more

Dinners were terrible and expensive. Didn't even come with a salad. $19 for 5 shrimp that tasted like cardboard.

Great staff and great food. Everyone who works here is always friendly and smiling. Food is fantastic. Everything from pizza to pasta is great. Spaghetti and meatballs with meat sauce for $8.00 is amazing. Sauce is tasty and meatballs have great flavor. The Neal's special cheesesteak is the best cheesesteak I have ever had. A big fat tasty sandwich. Try it you will like it. From pickup to delivery they are always on time. Love it here and will continue to frequent it. read more

The food here is always amazing and Angelo and his employees use the best and freshest ingredients. As I'm sitting her now enjoying some slices they are sanitizing all the tables and cleaning. Top notch Italian food read more

Great grandma and regular pie. Consistently delicious and our favorite pizza in town! Can't speak for dining in, but delivery is always on time and friendly. read more

I had this tonight. Picked up pizza and it was cold! Pizza was greasy and not cooked very well. I will not go back there. I live in Wayne and would rather travel to Ralph's in Nutley for pie! read more

Wow !! We have been going to Vinnies for years. Tonight we decided to try Neil's - why did we wait so long?? The mussels with hot sauce were sooo good !! The plain Sicilian pie was anything but plain. The crust was so fresh and tasty and the sauce cheese ratio was perfect!! We are never going back to Vinnies. Neil's is the best ever ! Thank you ! read more

Pizza was crunchy and delicious! Service was also quick + the worker was kind. It'll definitely be my go-to pizza place in Wayne.

Was kind of a rush to get lunch and get back to work, so I decided to grab two slices from here...a lot of variety of types of pizzas...I went with the margarita and chicken Cesar ranch....the guys behind the counter were all helpful....I guess I made the right decision I was in and out there ..food was good, maybe I should have baught 3 slices...lol...total was about 6$, not bad read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken Cesar ranch and margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Almost eight dollars for two plain slices and a water bottle? Way too expensive for mediocre pizza

I've been going to Neil's for about 20 years and the pizza, dinners, and salads are amazing! They have the most friendly staff there and many have been there for a long time! It's a casual atmosphere and it's very affordable. I highly recommend pizza from there. I also love the fact that they have so many speciality pizzas which are really good! Lots of options on the menu and I've never had a bad experience ever! read more

When I brought my boyfriend to my hometown (Wayne), Neil's was the only place I took him to eat. A South Jerseyan and pizza connoisseur in his own right, bringing him to Neil's was an integral part of him understanding my adolescence. Neil's Pizzeria is an iconic Wayne pizza spot, located conveniently across the street from Wayne Valley High School, perfect for class-ditching bad asses, hungry athletes and nerds alike. The pizza is terrific. A Jersey slice at it's best! Perfectly greasy, saucy and cheesy- it's pizza heaven on a paper plate. The decor is dingy and the guys behind the counter may make you feel uncomfortable ladies, but it's all part of the experience. read more

I'm really conflicted about this place. For the most part the food is really good but the service needs to step it up a notch. The last three/four times I've ordered from them I've been with my boyfriend and his family and for some unknown reason they've always messed up the order. Either something was missing or details on the order were wrong. It's really disappointing because we really like Neil's but can't keep having to wait for the delivery guy to come back with the right order every time we want pizza. read more

Great service and flavor . Try the grill vegetables salads with chicken or shrimp . Cheese pizza is excellent

The garlic and broccoli was more brothy then what I was expecting, in fact, I didn't even eat. The pizza was eh, but we did get it take out. The folks in our group that got the chicken parm LOVED it. Next time I'll try one of the other "big threes" read more

My friend brought over subs from here, and mine was delicious. I got a ham, capicola, and provolone combo with pretty much everything on it. I really like the bread they use, and the ingredients are fresh. The portions were big and the prices were fair. I would definitely order from here again! read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Ham, capicola, and provolone combo. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Just move in the town firs order I had it was ok I sad all give one more chance From my second order I em there every week at list one time Place is good fast service I recommend the place Enjoy the greatest pizza in town I em Lucky to be living 1block a way from them read more

Pizza was OK, but not a very friendly owner and seem unappreciative of my business. Charged an extra .60 cents on a $16.00 plus tax order. Never informed me of their service charge for using a credit card. read more

Be specific if you order an Italian Hot Dog!! I've never heard of having tomato sauce with it - yuk!! If I I wanted a sausage and pepper sandwich, I've would of ordered one. I don't think they know how to make an Italian Hot Dog. Ruined my evening, especially when you were looking forward to it. read more

What can I say about Neil's? It's not perfect but pretty damn close. Most of their food are my all time favorites, rest are solid choices with great prices. Usually too lazy for reviews but I had to make an exception for Neil's. I have tried most of their specialty slices and a few pasta dishes, here are my thoughts. Hopefully I can try them all one day. All Time Favorites 1. Sicilian with fresh diced tomato Live for this slice. Delicious and so fresh. 2. Sicilian plain Basic but lovely 3. Plain slice Not much to say but great. 4. Ricotta/ white slice with or without toppings Really rich 5. Vodka sauce Chicken vodka or vodka zita slice or any vodka pasta is great. The vodka sauce is killer. 6. Tortellini/ baked Ziti Great on slice or pasta 7. Garlic knots Large and soft, delicious 8. Eggplant Parm or Parm sandwich: my mom is addicted and she is a connoisseur of eggplant. Rollatini seems great too 9. Marinara sauce and Ricotta on Pastas/ slices Perfect classics. Exactly what you expect. Love the manicotti, stuffed shells, cheese ravioli, lasagna, slices 10. Square Bruschetta slice Fresh and great. Solid choices/ popular 1. Buffalo chicken slice with ranch Great classic 2. Salad slices (classic,arugula, etc) or Veggies Slices ( all, mushroom, etc) Any kind, yum and refreshing. 3. Italian hero and California Cheesesteak Perfect size and flavor 4. Chicken and broccoli and chicken ranch( with or w/o lettuce Can't complain love them. 5. Pizza Deliziosa/ Primavera/ Oreganata Great execution in my opinion 6. Small round slice So cute love it. Tastes great 7. Calzone Stromboli Big fan of classic and spinach ricotta sure the other are great. 8. Alfredo sauce The pasta and slices taste great but reheating is hard and sauce separates. But that happens to me everywhere with alfredo sauce and microwaves Only things I can't recommend... unfortunately. 1. Lobster ravioli A gamble anywhere but just not good. Pricey. Maybe an off day but wouldn't get it again. 2. Grandma slice To be honest I might hate grandma slices but didn't love it. I've been going there since I was like 9 so 15 years basically. From walking from Lafayette elementary school, biking from Anthony Wayne, classic lunch spot from Valley, to hometown cravings when home from college, quick dinners after an exhausting workday,to the highlight of weekends and parties: Neil's has always been there. But it's way more than nostalgia that keeps me loyal. Kind and attentive staff that is always friendly, sometimes offering a free pizza slice while waiting or dropping a dollar. They will always go out of their way for you and make delicious food. Fast, convenient, quality and inexpensive food for dine in, take out and delivery. What can I say? Neil's is bae read more

Soooooo Goood! We are here on vacation and the staff is super nice the portion sizes are really big pasta definitely enough to share. If we ever come back to this side of the country we will definitely be coming back. read more

Awesome Pizza best around. Fast delivery Angelo is Awesome as well as the rest of the crew. They have a wide verity of pizza by the slice as well as diner plates. Pick and dine in Service is fast. read more

Best pizza in Wayne by far. Friendly service and great options!! The sandwiches are also amazing! A plain pie is the best tho from here.

Amazing pizza and worth the trip if you are ever in Wayne, NJ. They are part of the big 3 (Tony's, Neil's, and Vinnie's) all of which have great pizza. I prefer the specialty pies at Neil's, but the plain slice at Tony's. Their Chicken Vodka pizza is the best specialty slice in the world! read more

I was very excited about trying Neil's for the first time. A friend of mine mentioned that it had a more substantial crust, which is what I was looking for. I ordered a plain pie for pickup. My son had to drive 36 minutes to ouck it up. Unfortunately, when he got it home the bottom of the pie was burnt black. Such a waste of time and money. read more

Wonderful variety of great Italian food! Personal favorite pizza is the vodka slice and favorite dish might ever the chicken parmigiana

Neil's Pizzeria is hands down one of the best places to go for italian food in Wayne, NJ. Having lived in Wayne for about 8 years and in New Jersey my entire life, I have tasted an obscene amount of pizza all over the state. After I got out of work on St. Patrick's Day, I wanted absolutely nothing to do with corn beef and cabbage (because I work in a deli and was tired of looking at it lol) and decided to grab a pepperoni pie at Neil's. They may have been slow due to the holiday, but that meant I got extra attention on my pizza. I asked for it to be cooked well done, and when I went in, the gentleman behind the counter showed it to me and asked if it was to my liking. It definitely was. I must say that was the best pie I have had from there. In addition to their pizza, I am a huge fan of their subs and calzones. Absolutely delicious. I had also bought some pies and a 3 foot italian sub from them for a Super Bowl party. Being one of the busiest days of the year, they still delivered high quality food. I can't wait to go back. Just writing this review is making me hungry. read more

This is our favorite pizza place for cheese or vodka sauce pizza! Their sandwiches are pretty fantastic too. I do NOT recommend their Ceasar salad, though. read more

AWESOME food! Great pizza, (sauce is the secret), love the linguini in red clam sauce, fecacia, everything is fantastic. The Sicilian pizza is the.best. I can't say enuf positive comments about Meals. Go, you won't be disappointed! MCG read more

You have to love Neil's pizza - they have been there for years and the food is delicious...staff is friendly. My kids grew up here - a great "mom and pop." read more

Decent food. Nothing special. Kind of rude arrogant vibe going on in here. Take a deep breath bro, and humble yourself in the eyes of the Lord. read more

I am a longtime customer, and typically attend Neil's expecting great service and food, but just wanted to stop by and say thank you for helping cater my SuperBowl party this year. The food was hot and ready on-time, and delicious as usual. There's a reason this place has been running like a well oiled machine for so long. They do things the right way, the first time around. THANKS! read more