I used to come here all the time when everybody used to live at home. We could get a big pizza and everybody could get a quarter of it the way they wanted it. But one of my favorite meals from there is their lasagna. It is a meat lasagna and it's jampacked. I never can eat it all at one time. It also comes with the thick breadsticks. The guys that work there are nice to me. I always get good service. They have a large menu and if I don't see something I just ask and they go. We got that. There is seating inside to eat, but I always get the food to go. The inside is your typical pizza joint. read more

New York Pizza - Meat Lasagna with Bread Sticks! - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Was hangout with friends and they order a couple of King Kong size pizzas from here. The Combination & the Mexican Style on thin crust. I felt that the pizzas were a little dried not enough sauce. Compare this to Little Caesars. read more

New York Pizza - King Kong Mexican Style - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Their pepperoni pizza was pretty good. Thin crust and cooked well. Pepperoni had a kick to it and sauce was flavorful. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. Definitely would order again. I forgot this place existed near my home. Pricing isn't too bad either for the amount of slices you get. read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

We used to love this place. They used to be generous. But the prices went up. And you get hardly any meat or cheese on it. Something in the quality has changed, the dough, the sauce, the flavor and seasoning. What used to be good is now mediocre. Unfortunately, because we want to support our Halal community. But its been several orders that we've noticed the quality had decreased. And size as well. The thickness is never consistent either and if we ordered two, of the same or similar pizza, one ALWAYS comes out different than the other. So the employees are not making them the same. One will have hardly no.sauce and light cheese, and the other will have more sauce and more cheese. But hardly any meat on both, now they have gotten stingy while increasing price. Im not sure what is happening we really wamt to continue supporting but if the quality keeps decreasing we will have to go elsewhere. read more

New York Pizza - Hardly any beef sausage and hardly any cheese or sauce. and they used to put more beef pepperoni, - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Your pizza is so amazing it's not only delicious it makes me happy. It never fails me. Thank you and don't ever go out of business! My neighbor is also now hooked I always share with him. Thank you!!! read more

Ordered more than $200 worth of pizza and the guy at the front was being rude and didn't give us our sodas. He also was charging us for ranch when the concord location never does. (Mind this we order from here very often too) What horrible customer service. Not a way to run a business. Do not go here. read more

I have been coming to this location for at least 20 years. Never disappoints. Great service, nice staff and tasty pizza. What more can you ask for. read more

waited over an hour for our pizza to come (usually takes about 15-25 mins) & then we open the box, the crust looks bitten off. we've been coming here for YEARS & now everything is just downgrading & the quality is getting worse. crust isn't even there; it's just straight THIN. UPDATE: one of my brothers friends just found a hair in the pizza as well read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

I ordered breaded chicken and they gave me frozen chicken nuggets. I'm so disappointed. False advertisement. Also pizza was greasy. read more

New York Pizza - The frozen chicken nuggets - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Ordered a pizza for pick up. Got the text it was ready, went in to pick it up and was greeted with every worker eating behind the counter. I ask for the pizza and they tell me they gave my pizza to someone else hahahaha there were literally no other customers. How does that even happen. Made me order again and had to wait in the store for a new pizza. I get it, mistakes happen, but the part that annoyed me is they laughed about it and didn't even apologize or offer anything. Horrible service. read more

Doordashed an xl 18-inch cheese pizza with jalapeños on it. It was done fast, and tasty. Haven't been there in-person. An 18-inch pizza for 24.99 is a really good price. Like I'm a pizza guy and I'm telling u, in 2025 that's a really good value. It'll feed my partner and I for two nights in a row; that's like $6 per night for each of us! read more

Their pizza never disappoints! It's very crispy & tasty! My family and I love ordering pizza from here.

Best pizza shope in the bay area highly recommend try it will never disappoint worth it read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

I love a New York Pizza, especially this one. They have the best halal pepperoni pizza you can find and definitely don't skimp on toppings compared to other locations. Call ahead, place an order on line or in person. They are fast and have the option to dine-in as well. Coupons and pick up specials are available. The Afghani King Kong is great for parties or to a feed large group. It's seasoned ground beef or chicken and veggies on a pizza. Try it out, it may become your favorite. Out of all the NY pizza shops in the area, this one is definitely better than the rest! read more

See all

Very disappointed on how they don't make pizza the same way they advertise it. But because we waited almost 45 minutes for the pizza thinking it had fresh basil, sadly did not. Not what I expected for New York pizza. read more

New York Pizza - 18' Pizza Margherita pizza I thought I order for $24.99 - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Very bad pizza. Not cooked. Not taste good. Too expensive. Bad attitude. Not professional.

We have been coming to this pizza place for over 20 years. But this is the first time we were informed that halal beef will cost extra! We agreed and asked for extra beef on it. They gave us a pizza that had only 1-2 pieces of beef on a slice!! Must have new management because the quality has gone way down. Shame. read more

Mom and Pop's type of restaurant. Plenty of parking. Whole bill came to $17.00 I saw that they had chicken alfredo pasta i added broccoli to it. and it came with plenty of breadsticks and it was good!!! They dont use fettuccine they used penne pasta. The pasta was a little salty but my hubby loved it and he's usually picky too! They had spaghetti with meatballs will try that next. I loved how it was next door to the chinese restaurant that is really good..so i will get that and get my hubby can get this kind of food. read more

See all

Food is really good. Owner is very nice , friendly customer service. I always get pizza from them. My daughter loves extra cheesy pizza , King Kong size and they don't disappoint us ever. Pizza is perfect all the time. Ask for extra cheesy you get extra cheesy. read more

The service is very friendly and the pizza is amazing. If you anywhere else you making a mistake. Try the pasta !!!

Spend over $100 would not give me a Ranch as complimentary! I will never order here again. Service sucks with no smiles not even a thank you! Wanted to charge $1 for a ranch. read more

Came here for second time. Neither time was a good experience. The person taking the order wasn't paying attention and there was zero customer service. No hello or anything. Ambiance was dead, the carpet was clean but looked dirty. I ordered a large and was told it would be ready in 15 mins. The wait was much much longer. I had to pay tip ever though it was not delivered. The first time it was delivered and the guy demanded I tip again even tough I had tipped while paying online. The food itself was horrible. Their margherita pizza didn't have mozzarella or fresh basil. The dried basil they use burns while cooking. Domino's has better pizza! read more

Thanks to COVID we've been eating way more pizza than we should! While with other eateries, the prices are significantly up while the quantity and/or quality has gone down, NY Pizza seems to have gotten better. Prices did go up, The Managers special is now $23 but for 2 medium pizzas with 2 toppings, breadsticks and 2 cans of soda it's still a great deal! read more

See all

They are getting expensive day by day. Very greedy owner. $60 for afghani King Kong, they are charging a lot It used to cost only $25.99 with a large 2 liter soda. Ok I get it every thing is getting expensive but not doubled. I really hate when they are trying to take advantage of people. I think afghan community need to think about opening another competition for halal pizza in Hayward. Surely they make tons of money. read more

I ordered thu d the order was ready after 8 minutes but it was really nasty sh*t, the chicken & beef pizza was raw n it wasn't cooked well at all, even animals can't eat this sh**t. 0 read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

The pizza isn't the same as under previous ownership. There customer service is horrible. Employees are very rude. Size of King Kong pizza has shrunk. They have doubled the prices of the pizzas. They don't take orders correctly, they used to offer free 2 liter soda with any type of king kong pizza and now they are denying it. they are saying we never offered it and yet i used to get a 2 free liter soda every time I ordered a king kong pizza with 2 or more toppings. New owner is not a friendly person. My order is always messed up. read more

COVID is Pizza time; This place is great when it comes to getting a pie fast. They are VERY fast. I'm talking 10 to 20 minutes even during busy times to get your Pizza. My issue is sometimes I order the same thing and the quality of the chicken is different. It's really strange they sometimes make it super spicy and makes the Pizza taste like chicken over the PIE. I guess it's on me for getting Chicken and Pineapple on my Pizza but I like it. Sometimes I'll order the pizza is 4 stars it's good it's priced pretty well they have good coupons or promotions; but other times I find my self throwing the pizza away. It's very inconsistence on the taste for me. Sometimes it's a good pie sometime it's not good; it's strange. I feel like it's gambling to go here. The place is pretty busy and they get the pizzas made pretty fast but it's not the best pizza I have ever had or just average pizza. It's a good value but it has been a super let down on taste the past few times. It's a avoid right now for me; I hope they step up there taste game. read more

New York Pizza - The front covid safe spacing - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Pizza is good however do not get the Margherita Pizza only because they do not have real basil! :( Other Pizza options are pretty tasty at fair prices. read more

I ordered a slice (huge slice!!) of pizza with pepperoni, basil and mushrooms. It was so good! I did not have high expectations for this place as it's a little hole in the wall that's been there for yeaaaaars but wow it was good! I also ordered a Cesar salad that said it came with olives and I was sad to see it didn't come with it. Like most pizza places I basically paid $7 for a bag of croutons, 3 slices of cucumber and 3 slices of tomatoes. The salad and the slice would have been enough for two people to share! We were trying to compare it to a larger pizza chain as we will be ordering several pizzas for a bday dinner and this spot got our order! read more

New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Food is great! Service is great ! Ambiance could be improved. The staff are friendly and helpful. I don't know if they had a customer bathroom to wash hands. That is needed (if they don't have it). read more

Very good. Love the thin crust, great quality. I don't like pizza much, but I like this place.

So my bf and I went to this New York pizza, when we first walked in the the cashier was rude when get my order. They charged separately for the hot sauce and ranch dressing it cost an extra three dollars that they could get give us for free for spending 25 dollars for a medium. "Welcome the world greedy at its finest". Never going to go there again, atleast have good customer service if the food and charging people outrageous prices for some crap pizza and they have to charge extra for the sauces to for the nasty and greasy and tasteless pizza read more

I've ordered from this place for a while and we always order the same thing, today there was some sort of miscommunication and at a workplace where the staff are supposed to act friendly, this man started to argue with us about our order. They kept on telling us that we are wrong when we have witnesses that we have ordered with. They ended up arguing with us, telling us we're wrong and they wanted to teach us how to order. Definitely wouldn't order from this place again, horrible customer service. read more

We've been ordering here for many years, yet as of recently, I'm not sure whether the management has changed or something else but whenever we order, our order is always wrong. We've called to ask the reps to rectify the situation in some way, but they always double down that they do not take our orders incorrectly and the problem is with us. We did not have this problem in the past, yet this new management is screwing our orders every time while refusing to fix the situation in any way or even offer an apology. I do not recommend coming here unless you want bad service and to waste your money. The food quality has also gone down over the years yet the prices are constantly rising. Save your money and get better pizza and customer service elsewhere. read more

Ordered online and everything was perfect. Combination pizza was delicious and my family had no complaints. Delivery driver was pleasant and pizza was delivered hot and intact. read more

See all

ZERO STAR REVIEW HONESTLY I been a customer for a long time and I found this in my food when in to tell them n all they said was they can give me a small pizza like really I would not want a nother pizza after I found this on my pizza I asked for my refund n they said they could not give me my refund ridiculous I am so angry as my daughter could of choke in this never again eating here read more

New York Pizza - Nail on my King Kong 24" Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Afghan pizza is amazing, the slices here are the best been coming here since I was a kid 1995 when we moved from fremont to nasty Hayward, ghetoo d block. Thanks dad for ruining my education and bringing me here. Service is quick, ambience is rough, neighborhood ghetto! read more

I Ordered the LA Super Combo Specialty Pizza through door dash. It's supposed to have salami pepperoni linguisa sausage mushrooms feta. Does this look like it has any of those toppings on it? All it is is mushroom and sausage. Called to let them know & the guy kept arguing with me saying he made the pizza himself and it's correct and that I can't see the other toppings because they put a lot of cheese. I guess I had to post the pic on yelp so he can see for himself since he didn't care to rectify the problem for me. Update: I did call door dash myself & their phones were not working. I explained that to whoever it was I spoke with at the restaurant and for them to contact door dash for me. I work at a restaurant who also uses door dash - I know how this stuff works. read more

Really good Pizza!! Great service and the manager Ahmad is awesome! They have good deals too. read more

my favorite pizza place, the pizza is so good i always order on the phone and they always answer the phone and the wait time is short 10-15 minutes! I once ordered on doordash and they didn't pay attention to my note where i asked for light tomato sauce so from now on i'll only order thru the phone or in person. read more

New York Pizza - menu - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all