I woke up Sunday wanting a popsicle. Luckily, Nicey is nearby. I wasn't sure which popsicle to purchase, so I asked the lady working. Her name was Kaelee. She was super patient and knowledgeable about popsicles. Because of Kaelee, I got two awesome popsicles. Thanks, Kaelee! read more

Are you looking for somewhere to get a nice cold treat from? If so look no further get a delicious ice cream bar from here. Customer service was great and the price of the ice cream popsicle was not bad at all. They charge $4.50 per popsicle. I love how they have multiple flavors to choose from. They have a reward system where you can earn points on each purchase. If you are in Broad-ripple area for sure check this ice cream store out. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

I wouldn't choose a popsicle over ice cream... unless it's Nicey Treat!! Their treats are delicious and made with natural ingredients. I first tried a "Not So Hot Chocolate" pop at an event years ago and went to find the store the very next day. I was hooked! I also love their fruit flavored pops - blackberry lemonade, key lime, and mango ginger. I love that they have vegan options for those that are dairy free or vegan. One thing to note- the shop is a grab and go, walk up counter style where it's best suited to get a treat for a walk on the monon or sit on one of the benches outside. Recently they added a little tray that stays at the bottom of the popsicle to catch drips - a brilliant addition! Thank you! read more

Nicey Treat - Blackberry Lemonade Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Oh my! Not just a popsicle shop but popsicles with vegan and diary options. Walk in and you are greeted by a very sweet attendant and a walk full of unique popsicle flavors. We tried vegan and just fell in love with Pina colada, mango ginger and POG - passion fruit, orange, guava. POG was a taste that instantly transported you to a tropical beach with sun and breeze on a warm summer day. I couldn't get myself to stop enjoying POG, it was SO good! The popsicles are priced at $4 which is slightly expensive but so so worth the experience and smile (their punchline is don't wipe that smile on your face) - on a napkin box!!! Locally handcrafted- highly rec read more

See all

This place feels like the best kept secret in Broad Ripple that people don't talk about enough! It's a sweet and vibrant little shop just off the canal and the Monon. The treats there are ALWAYS delicious. Personally, Key Lime is my favorite but you really can't go wrong with any of them. The employees are kind and are ready with a suggestion. Definitely worth a stop. read more

Nicey Treat is the perfect ice cream date spot for you and the kiddos , partner or friends . They have a huge selection of flavors so everyone is able to find something they love on the menu . The service is fast and efficient ! I highly reccomend Nicey Treat read more

Nicey Treat - Pink Lemonade - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

They are closed! No signs, nothing on website - the place is locked up and very empty. They had a good product. RIP. read more

Nicey Treat - Former location of Nicey in Broad Ripple :-( - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love Nicey but have mixed feelings. I wish they would extend their hours. I normally get cookie butter flavor and it's always so amazing. Today, I drove to get a cookie butter popsicle and it was about 5:45 pm (during business hours) and the door was locked. No one was there. I waited around for a few minutes and called.. no answer. I kept calling and finally got an answer. The lady said she took a quick break and is back now. I think it's very weird and unprofessional to take a break during business hours when you have no one to cover for you. read more

One of my favorites spots to get a nice(y) treat! Natural popsicles is the way to go! Conveniently located in the Fishers district, and in Broad Ripple. My go to in the banana cream, s'mores, or watermelon in the summer! They have disposable chocolate, and plenty of toppings to make it your own!! The shops are quite small, but it doesn't take 20 mins to eat a popsicle so you shouldn't have any trouble there In Broad Ripple, I enjoy grabbing one and walking the monon! My family and I love Nicey! I had more pictures, but yelp only gives me 10 spots, if you wanna see more I guess you'll just have to try them for yourself! Some of their pops do have dairy, BUT they have plenty of delicious, delicious non dairy options! read more

See all

So many yummy flavors. Many gluten free. And vegan. I've had so many and all delicious. Today was Kitchen Sink... only $1 and you get what you get! No official flavor identifier, but today tasted like a creamy citrus #yum. #R read more

See all

I've tried the key lime and the strawberries and cream popsicles from Nicey Treat. They were so good! Very simple, yet refreshing and cooling on a hot day. It's a simple concept - popsicles, but with traditional flavors and newer flavors. Located in Broad Ripple they have other locations throughout Indianapolis. One location that some might not know is that they sell them inside the White River State Park Visitors Center located close to the new TCU Amphitheater. The only problem is trying to decide on which flavor to choose from. read more

See all

We love Nicey. I haven't had a bad popsicle from there. It's easy to order from, you can buy in bulk and the staff is always nice-y. Our household favorite is Watermelon. Taste like real watermelon, not the candy flavor like most water melon treats taste like. If you love Hawaii like my husband. You need to get the POG. Also cookie butter or any or their creamy flavors (my daughter loves strawberry) are super satisfying. We first tried them 6ish years ago at the earth festival downtown and our lives have never been the same :p read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We returned 6 years later and it is still amazing!!! Great selection and lovely people work there!!! read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

FINALLY got to try this gem- it's tucked into a small shop in broad ripple, and even though I've lived here for four months, it's taken me forever!! Photo doesn't do it justice! I was struggling between fruity vs icecream-y so I went for peaches and cream. It's a seasonal flavor and the perfect combo of what I was looking for. This place is simple and straight forward with their flavors on the wall and labeled in their freezer. This is definitely a spot I'll be coming to a lot more often for a fast sweet treat that's just the perfect amount. read more

Nicey Treat - Peaches and cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

It was my first time checking out this popsicle place in Broad Ripple and a warm sunny evening. I really enjoyed all the creative flavors they had. There were 2 main categories, vegan and creamy. Each was appropriately labeled on the board inside. The person working there said that they sourced the ingredients locally when ever possible. We picked up the cajeta flavor and the passion fruit flavor. It was recommended to dip the cajeta in some chocolate to add to the creaminess from the goat cheese. It was an excellent combo! The passion fruit flavor was also delicious. It was extremely fresh and refreshing! Would definitely recommend this place. read more

See all

I've heard SO much about Nicey Treat since returning to Indiana. As a disclaimer, I'm really not an ice cream/popsicle fanatic. I grew up indulging in Fla-Vor-Ice during the summers so, evidently, I've never really had a housemade popsicle, and the only gourmet version that I've indulged in would be kulfi (stick ice cream) in India. Participating largely in social media has many perks, of course, one of which is winning some Nicey Treat popsicles at the Farmers Market, which I was lucky enough to do! I sidled up to the stall and took the opportunity to grab a few pops: strawberry-mint, blackberry lemonade, and peach! Each one was a winner with one notable aspect: the flavor that's told to you is EXACTLY what the pop exudes. The strawberry-mint was a tad too mint-forward for me (personal preference) but I found the blackberry-lemonade to be exactly the refreshment I needed for a sunny Saturday morning. I can't wait to go back to the storefront and try some of the other pops that the joint has to offer! read more

See all

It's okay, adults, you can indulge in a delicious popsicle too. Every now and then, I get the craving for a delicious frozen bar treat from Nicey and the craving must be taken care of in a timely manner. Most recently, I was biking from downtown to 86th Street via Monon. I stopped by to check in and see if Nicey was open during the coronavirus, and they were taking orders/paying outside on the sidewalk. One of the best things about this place: the range of flavors. Forget your normal grape, strawberry, lime flavors filled with artificial flavors and colors. This places takes flavor combinations to the next level. Goat cheese and caramel. Herbs + fruits. Vegan options. I was craving something with herbs (what's new) so I went with the pineapple basil. It was a delicious treat on the 80-degree, sunny day. It wasn't overly sweet and it wasn't full of pineapple pulp that usually leaves sores in my mouth from the overly acidic textures. The prices are definitely the thing that stops me from treating myself to them frequently, but they're a nice treat from time to time. read more

Nicey Treat - Pineapple basil - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love love love this place!!! Lots of flavors to choose from. Today I had one that tasted just like banana pudding!! I love that they are so many options. My kids love this place as well! Today was the first time I've noticed "the kitchen sink" flavor. It's only $1 and it's basically whatever flavors they have left they throw together. It was perfect for my 2 year old toddler. It was going to melt faster than he could eat it so it's perfect!!! Great place to stop in for a quick treat on a hot summer day!! read more

Great frozen treats! They have a great variety of flavors. They even have no sugar added and vegan. They use monk fruit and a retrie all in there no sugar added stuff so it's not loaded with bad carbohydrates, for the most part without considering the fruit, of course and that is minimal. Inviting place and the bars taste great. read more

If you want the best popsicles in Indy, you should no doubt head to the bripp location of this little popsicle stand. There are so many flavors, ranging from coconut to chocolate to avocado to blackberry lemonade. All so delicious in their own ways! In addition you can get it dipped in either milk or dark chocolate for only an extra dollar charge. My favorites are by far the fruity ones, but I hear the coconut it really good! Definitely go check it out on a warm summer day, or a cold winter day-whichever you prefer. read more

See all

Y'all, do yourself a favor. Support Nicey Treats because we want these treats all day every day before COVID and post COVID. But here's where you can really change your life. Get the pie. The cookie butter pie. It's just like a giant pop but it's a pie. I "accidentally" ordered 2 and my self worth has improved dramatically. TL;DR - go to Nicey. Order pie. Eat pie. Repeat. read more

Nicey Treat - Cookie Butter Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I love Nicey Treat and tonight was the perfect night for it! I was excited to try the pistachio and it did not disappoint! I hope they keep this flavor on their regular menu. It has a smooth creamy sweet flavor and the addition of 4 salt pistachios on the bottom. Just perfect!! read more

Nicey Treat - Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Yesss!!!! This place is a treat indeed! So many unique flavors and if you're brave you can try the "kitchen sink": a mixture of all the flavors that are left. Another add-on is chocolate dipping you popsicle! Strawberry Cream is a popular pick for this slam dunk! It's a perfect stop from a walk on the Monon. Save you sticks for the customer loyalty program. Be sure to get your picture taken to put on the wall! (Ask to use the Polaroid camera. They keep it behind the counter) The only downside are the bees that tend to hover around the trash cans just outside the doors! So keep walking when you leave the store! read more

Currently eating a cookie butter Nicey treat. It is absolutely perfect. Can't wait to get the other 3 I got!!!!!

My favorite after lunch/dinner spot, however today was the second time I've come to the new location and it's closed- during listed open hours with no sign or explanation why? I walked around the block hoping someone was taking a lunch or bathroom break themselves, but returned to still closed. Super disappointing! Not sure what's up, but it seems like if you're closed during hours listed as open on the door, you'd leave an explanation. read more

Like the taste nice seating lots of options loved would go back they were quick seating was outside

Love love these popsicles! I found out about them at a food truck fest from their truck and I got hooked! They also have 2 locations one in fountain square and the other in broadripple. The broadripple store is located right in-between the coffee shop and a salon, and they have such a cute store interior! It's clean with fun pictures, and the menu is on a chalkboard with all the different flavors. The flavors always seem to keep rotating which is great so you can always have something fresh! I recommend the lemon buttercream. Avocado, and lemon basil, they are all amazing. You have to visit for yourself so you can check out all of your options, the broadripple location is great to just grab a seat and enjoy, big windows as well which allow for people watching as well. read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It you want a treat after dinner, this is a place to go. Gourmet freezer pops. It's just the right size. I had the toasted coconut dipped in dark chocolate... to die for. read more

Maybe walking in the rain along the river walk was not the greatest plan but the popsicles were definitely worth it! The store had just open when we got there but they were ready. Since I had never been I was a little overwhelmed with the choices but I was glad to have options between more fruit or more dessert like options. Once I saw the cookie butter though I knew what I was getting. It tasted just like speculoos cookies! The inside of the shop was super cute although chilly but when all the food is frozen it is understandable! I would definitely come back again to try more flavors maybe something a little more adventurous next time! read more

Nicey Treat - Cookie Butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I recently hired Nicey Treat to cater dessert for my daughter's graduation open house. Everyone I worked with at Nicey was helpful and kind. Their catering request form is easy to fill out and follow up was quick and efficient. A freezer cart was delivered to my house, filled with popsicles. They were a HUGE hit at the party, and every flavor we chose was absolutely delicious. I wouldn't hesitate to bring them back when my younger daughter graduates in a few years! Thanks, Nicey! read more

Nicey Treat - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I don't know why I've never reviewed Nicey Treat before now, but it's one of my favorite Indy eats. I love the rotating flavors, especially any fruit flavor dipped in milk chocolate. As someone who needs to eat gluten free, I never worry about what's in my Nicey Treats, and they always taste fresh and free of chemicals. We picked up a whole box of pops several times during the pandemic, as well as a Nicey Pie for Easter. The whole family loves them, and I even gifted a box of pops to my mom for Mother's Day. There's nothing better on a hot day than stopping by for a Nicey Treat. (Also, peep the super cute popsicle mask I bought this summer from NT!) read more

Nicey Treat - Nicey pops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

There is a super chill vibe emanating from Nicey Treat. As there should be, I suppose -- this IS a popsicle shop. You walk in and a nice person materializes from the back and helps you decide what kind of frozen treat you might want. Milk based or vegan? Yes, they have vegan popsicles. Of course they have vegan popsicles. There is also a gigantic sign on the wall with the names of all of the popsicles. Choose your own adventure. Nicey Treat pops ARE little frozen culinary adventures. Avocado! Cilantro lime! No, you're not eating guacamole -- this is a popsicle, and it is sublime. Yes, they offer more conventional flavors like strawberry and lemon. But if you're going to visit Nicey, I suggest you throw caution to the wind just once and choose a flavor that sounds outrageous. You might just fall in love with it. (I certainly did!) read more

See all

Delicious frozen treats! We were walking around Broad Ripple when we spotted this little place and decided to try it. I got a mint strawberry and it was so refreshing. Lots of flavors, including vegan options, to choose from. read more

Nicey is one of my favorite local spots and a great place to take friends who are visiting. My husband and I even had a fun outing to Nicey with our wedding guests the weekend of our wedding. I always appreciate the employees kind demeanor and good recommendations on flavors (I can never decide!). The OG is my personal favorite (orange and guava). read more

Nested in the heart of Broad Ripple, you will find "Nicey Treat." It is just that - it is nice - Real Nice! And, it is a treat! I had the Key Lime Pie, my kids each had the "No So Hot Chocolate" and my wife had the Strawberry Cream. They were all very delicious. Personally, I liked my Key Lime Pie the best! (I chose wisely!). There are so many flavors - I will be trying more this summer. (I had another flavor once at the Broad Ripple farmer's. I don't remember the flavor, but I do remember it being very good.) At the store, there is car parking in the back - I imagine it fills quickly. Still, it is close enough to the action, that it is not a bad walk from other parking spots. There is also a bike rack in the front and it is just a few paces west of the monon trail. For the treat, I have heard the opinion that it is a little pricey. But, I keep in mind it is a treat, the ingredients in these are very good - not full of junk or chemicals. And, on a hot summer night, when the beach is burning, and the fog is crawling over the sand, I like to cool down with a Nicey Treat! (While you were licking your Nicey Treat and it was oh so shining And I was dying just to ask for a taste...) read more

See all

We love Nicey Treat! They make wonderful popsicles and you can always feel great about eating them.

When I think back to my youth, the once thing that always satisfied on a hot summer day was a popsicle. So what helps beat the heat on a hot summer day as an adult? A Nicey Treat popsicle. These are not your childhood popsicles. Nicey Treat offers an array of sophisticated hand crafted popsicle to satisfy any discerning pallet. I went with the peanut butter dipped in dark chocolate, my wife with with the Thai coffee whole my daughters enjoyed the strawberry mint and the watermelon. We have been to Nicey probably 2 dozen times and have never had a bad experience. My only complaint is there are so many amazing flavors that I can never decide what to try yet. This is a great place to visit with your family or take your date for a little treat. You are never too old for a popsicle. read more

The perfect treat on a hot summer day! I've had Nicey before but this was my first time at their store front location. They have a TON of options to choose from, including vegan options which I know a lot of people appreciate. I tried the cookie butter and it was delicious! There's an option to dip the popsicle in chocolate so I think I'll try that next time. Check this place out if you're in the area! read more

I LOVE this place! I came across this place about a year ago after a doctor's appointment in the area. I'd always thought cool popsicle places were only found in bigger cities, but man I was wrong. Honestly, the flavor wall is daunting. They all sounds so good and at this point I've tried most of their flavors and can confirm they are great. My go to is Cookie Butter dipped in dark chocolate, but the POG, Pineapple Basil and Not So Hot Chocolate are very good. I also appreciate that no matter how busy their Broad Ripple location gets, the employees never freak out or rush you to make a decision. It's much appreciated. My only complaint is that I wish they had some type of small cardboard catch-all for melting popsicles. Sometimes they melt really quickly and it'd be great to have something to put at the bottom of the popsicle to catch the drips. Napkins don't quite do the trick. read more

Nicey Treat - Our first time time at Nicey! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It's hot out Jeff, oh Popmaster. It's a toss up between the toasted coconut and the chili dark chocolate - you decide, well, better yet, surprise me. Toasted coconut it is! I've been eyeing Nicey for quite some time - today was the day - and lets just say, I'm never looking back. Holy popamoly. Before we even get to the pop, let me dive in to their beautiful marketing. Yes, I know your here to hear about their product, but I'm telling you the marketing is part of the whole package. Brilliant branding with a beautiful website and charming-meets-edgy wooden sticks. Do yourself a favor and check out their site sometime. Back to the toasted coconut pop. My ta-tas were sweating it was so hot out. Yeah, you had to know that to truly comprehend the level of heat I was working with. It wasn't like I just wanted Nicey Treat - I Needed Nicey Treat. Now. The toasted coconut was crazy-delicious - milky with nice big chunks of coconut. I must admit I was this (somewhere around one centimeter) close to going back to get a second. Good news is, I'll be seeing Nicey at all of my favorite farmers markets. read more