No frills pizza. Decent pie, better than the chains. Other than the convenience of being close by not sure I would recommend to anyone who has to to drive more than 2 miles. read more

This place has pretty good pizza, but I think that there is something strange going on with the 'tax' that they are charging. I got a slice of pizza and it was $2.95 before tax. After tax, the bill came to over 4 dollars. When I had inquired about this, I was told that there was a small charge for using a credit card, but that just this once it would be waived. After it was waived, my total came to $3.86. Now I'm not a mathematician, but Florida sales tax (6%) on $2.95 should be around 20 cents. Where the other 71 cents comes from...I have no clue, but didn't argue. I would be careful and do the math yourself when ordering and I hope an employee isn't skimming. read more

Amazing service , amazing people , family owned business ! The food here is amazing !! Always on point and delicious! My boyfriend and I travel to Altamonte to see my dad and we always stop at nicks ! West palm needs a pizza joint like this one ! Everything is homemade and will make your mouth water ! Make sure you stop by check out the specials they have 10/10 worth it read more

Nick's Pizzeria - Gyro - Pizza Near Me - Altamonte Springs, Florida

See all

This restaurant has the best New York pizza in the area. Nick's hospitality and love for his customers is always on point. Thanks for the amazing slices and conversations go birds!!! read more

I always looked at this pizza place when going to the gas station on my break and said I'll stop by one day. Well today was the day. I wanted pizza and that's where i went. Soooooooooo good! Great prices and many choices. Such nice people too! I'll def be coming by more often. read more

Ordered pizza online. Forgot to ask for it well done so partially my fault but still very doughy and overall very mediocre. As far as NY style pizza goes this is one of the worst I've had in the area. I regret not ordering from one of my usual go to's. Certainly not going to try this place again. read more

Nice and comfy place. It is located at a gas station and there is only two tables outside but that's fine by me. Service was great and fast. I love pizza so I will definitely recommend it. I will definitely come back. read more

This is one of the best pizza's I have ever had. The extra cheese was heavenly delicious. I am a little confused, because last time I went to the location is no longer called Nick's pizza and the pizza tasted different. I am not sure if they sold the location and moved somewhere else or if they are under new administration... I need to know because I was craving that extra cheese pie and last time under the different name it did not taste the same. Disappointing. If nicks moved. I want to know their new location read more

I'm from New Jersey and this was by far the best pizza I've ever had outside of New York/New Jersey. The crust, the sauce and the cheese were perfect! I got a pepperoni pizza for delivery. I can't wait to go back and try some other things. read more

If I could give them a zero, I would My pizza had two hairs in the crust and the "bacon" calzone had several pieces of pig snout with hairs on it. I will be going back tomorrow for a refund. Ridiculous! read more

This little gem has amazing food you need to look for it in a small building at the gas station, I have had their pizzas meatball sub and that's all delicious. Cannot beat the pick up Monday deal of $7.95 large cheese. read more

Amazing service and great pizza . This is the real deal. If you like NYC pizza u will love this. My number one pizza place ! read more

I don't claim to be the all knowing pizza guru, however I have had the pleasure of enjoying pizza around the world. I've been in the business myself from dishwasher to ownership, and frankly I would venture to say there are a very few people that know the history of this delicious food the way I do. That being said, THIS PLACE IS IT!!! Pizza is about fresh. Pizza is about comfort, but most important, it is about family. Nick and his family are passionate about their craft and their customers and it shows from "hello". This place is no gimmick, just the real deal. Amazing ingredients. Amazing food. Amazing service. I've eaten here a dozen times, but I just had the Grandma's Pie today and I can't help but feel like the food critic from Disney's Ratatouille. You brought me to a happy place my friend! I would wish you luck, but when you are this good, luck is just not necessary! Spettacolare! From the Food Fam read more

The spot is choice! Aside from high quality and taste, this hole on the place has a some amazing prices. Unlike other spots, this place has fantastic and respectful employees. The garlic knots weren't exactly what I thought from the pictures, slightly drowning in oil and short on garlic, the taste didn't disappoint. Great place once you find it. read more

Nick's has to be considered among the best Pizza shops in Central Florida. Classic New York thin, crispy, excellent sauce, herbs and covered with the right ratio of cheese and toppings. New to the area, but you can easily tell that this Italian owned and operated restaurant has Grandma's secret recipe on their menu read more

What a great hole in the wall place. Everything is made fresh owner Nick is also the pizza man. Funny guy to talk to while the pizza is being made. The pizza was great. Not to thick not to thin. Delicious new York style pizza. The beef patty was great in Coco bread. They even have zeppole for that old school feel. It's a great little place and I will be coming back. I recommend it. read more

Hands down best pizza joint in the area. Everything about this spot is great. The food, the people, the prices. You can feel the love that goes into this place. If you're looking for a new spot, go here, you won't be disappointed. read more

This place has such a good family vibe! Everyone was so sweet. First off, it's in the same plaza as the Citgo; so don't pass it. We ordered a tossed salad, personal Bianca pizza and personal mushroom pizza. They tossed in some zeppoles too. Those reminded me of a funnel cake. Salad was great, perfect amount of toppings and I loved the dressing. Very fresh. Pizzas were good but a little on the doughy side and not cooked to a crisp so if you're into that be sure to specify. If I ordered the Bianca pizza again, I would probably add some garlic. On the other pizza, I wish the mushrooms were fresh, you could tell they were from a can (maybe bc of covid). Overall, it was good! I'll definitely order again, I want to try the calzone! read more

See all

This is the best pizza I have had ever. New York Italian style. Nick is my go to for pizza time and time again he does not let me down. I have been eating pizza here for years. The Wings and everything that is prepared in the kitchen goes above and beyond expectation every time. read more

My wife and I are visiting from Massachusetts and ordered the cheese pie from Nick's twice during our stay. We also ordered garlic knots and buffalo wings. The pizza is extremely delicious. The sauce is perfect and the cheese is darn near perfect as well. The crust is really good maybe just a touch on the doughy side as I prefer a bit more crisp. Regardless this pizza is fantastic. The wings were also delicious and very well done. The garlic knots also are very tasty. Would definitely recommend. read more

I moved to Orlando about 3 yrs ago & have been looking for good pizza. I am originally from NY. I was lucky enough to stumble on this pizzeria. This pizza makes me home sick! This is authentic NY pizza What a great find! This is my "go to" for pizza! read more

I had never been there before but seen it on YELP before and I noted that pizza was purchased by the slice which is rare. I was in the area picking up a honeybaked ham so I walked up to the window counter and just started chatting with the two gentlemen in there and they kindly told me what they had available or what else they could do for me. Then offered me a drink to accompany my 2 slices and even read the labels to me and told me what was in it because they had specialty drinks that sounded ethnic which I love. Next time I will definitely bring my husband so he can get one of those fun island type drinks with his slices of pizza as well. We may make it over as soon as this weekend. Happy to new year to the Nicks Pizzeria employees and old owner who was there helping by the way. read more

This is a great little pizza spot! Some of the best pizza you can get in the area. If you like NY style pizza, don't sleep on Nick's.

This is a little hidden gem in the altamonte area. Best pizza in a 20 mile radius. It is a walk up counter in a building that sits in a gas station parking lot. There are a few tables outside if you just want to grab a slice or a sub. But they offer delivery and it's always faster than expected. The dough is just the right kind of chewy and just the right amount of a good homemade sauce. They also do an amazing Grandma's pizza. If you're going for a slice those run out early so call ahead. If you're in the area stop by. You won't regret it. Also the burger spot next door is amazing as well. read more

I went here the other day for the first time and got the bruschetta pizza. It was phenomenal!! This pizza made it to my top three, so I will definitely be back. read more

My girlfriend and I decided to try Nicks Pizzeria and we really enjoyed the pizza it was definitely a place we will be going again!!

So glad we found this place! We ordered 4 pizzas and a Greek Salad for a family birthday. Everything was perfect. Great food....great owner! read more

OMG....if you dont stop here for a slice or a beef patty YOU ARE MISSING OUT MAJORLY!! Today the hubs and I drove up for their special 2 slice and a drink special w/ a beef patty on the side. First, the lady that came to the window to take my order was wearing a mask...yes!!! Nick (owner) was making the pies and he too was wearing a mask. They have a nice seating area where you can eat outside or you can park your car in a parking spot and eat right in your car. Now....the pizza. Lord have mercy for local pizza shops that get it right!!!! Nick's got it right! Crispy not soggy, dough is thin and the crust is doughy and perfectly cooked. We ordered 2 more slices and we also tried the cannoli which was perfect! Made fresh!!! Ooh and the beef patty..that was crispy and perfect!! To-GO was had the zeppoles which we highly recommend also. They never made it home. Perfection in a bag! We are definitely coming back to Nick's probably in a few days!! Yummy!! Good luck Nick's you will do great! read more

I'm a DoorDash driver and have made many pickups at Nick's Pizza in Altamonte Springs. Finally, I decided to try them out. Wow!!! I haven't had Pizza this good since I lived in New Jersey!!! read more