Parking lot was overflowing but we thought we would try anyway and was surprised that we were seated right away. The chicken and greens were very good. The blue cheese chopped salad with steak tips was delicious as well. The steak was well seasoned and cooked perfectly. For dessert we ordered the biggest, richest piece of chocolate cake I have had in YEARS. We couldn't finish. It was relaxing and comfortable and Cole did a great job as our server. read more

See all

This place is worth the drive! I've heard so many good things from people all around Northeast Ohio and finally could make it here! The mussels were probably the best we've ever had, the sauce was amazing. Everything was so flavorful, great portions, and you can't beat the prices. We will definitely be back and will recommend this place to others who have also not tried it! read more

See all

What a awesome surprise! My wife had been given a GC for her birthday and we finally got around to using it. We heard fantastic things about Nicolinni's and everything was true! Great Friendly Service, Great Menu Selection and Daily Specials. We started off with the California Calamari for dinner my wife got their Chicken Marsala and it was probably the best I've had to date. I got their seasonal Chicken Apple Jack with butternut squash ravioli and it was great! To finishing off the evening we shared a pumpkin cheesecake and it was delicious. We can't wait to go back, two thumbs up for Nicolinni's Chophouse! BOOM!!!! read more

See all

The deserts are so good sometimes I just get one for dinner. But tonight I went with the Grilled Chicken Salad. A bowl filled high with crisp mixed greens, seasoned and grilled chicken, and French fries. So good and in theory good for me. read more

Nicolinni's Chophouse - Grilled Chicken Salad - Italian Near Me - Canfield, Ohio

Outstanding restaurant with an Italian flair. Charming atmosphere, with excellent food and service. Our party of three thoroughly enjoyed the dining experience here. Upon being seated, we were immediately greeted by our server Ashlyn. She brought us our drinks and a basket of bread and butter, and a plate of dipping sauce. All of our dinners came with a salad and a unique house dressing. For dinner, my wife ordered the Chicken and Greens, which she loved. It came with a side of vegetables. I had Veal Parmigiana over penne, and our nephew enjoyed the pork chop. Our meals were prepared well, and the portion sizes were generous. Recommended! read more

See all

Pasta Giada is the best thing in the worldddd. The name is great, and it just tastes sooooo good. Take your family here.

Wow the food was fantastic! Half off appetizers in the bar is the way to go!! My husband is a type 1 warrior and he was well accommodated for! Staff was pleasant and welcoming! No complaints only complements to the chef! read more

Love it all the way around! Great service great food! Have to say they have the best pace around for some great Italian food and some great wine read more

Looks like a standard strip mall Italian place, but they are a cut above that. Service and atmosphere were top notch. Food was simply outstanding. Everyone in our party of 16 left very full and very happy. read more

Excellent service. Wanted something that was off menu. No problem! Starting with the bread and olive oil and herb dip. Then came a very unique delicious salad with house made dressing. Very fresh and delicious tasting. I had seared shrimp and scallop pasta with broccoli in an Alfredo sauce. The dish was plentiful and amazing. I brought half of it home. Hubby had a rib eye steak, cooked perfectly to the temperature he requested. We ordered dessert to go. We were too full to enjoy it there. The restaurant is clean decorated beautifully and the mood is happy. We enjoyed it very much! read more

Nicolinni's Chophouse - Rib eye steak - Italian Near Me - Canfield, Ohio

See all

Some of the hardest working people in the business, with the most consistent food in the area. No managers here, only the two owners who work every station, every day. The bar staff are great, personable and knowledgeable. They will make whatever drink you'd like, as long as they have the ingredients to do so. The restaurant staff are wonderful as well, and make sure everyone is satisfied . The food is always flavorful and plentiful. Best happy hour in town. Half off apps Tuesday-Friday from 4-6, including any app on the daily specials menu! (At the bar or the high top tables on the bar side only) The owner makes homemade desserts daily which are to die for! Stop in and try it for yourself! read more

See all

Had a fantastic dinner. Greens with sausage was my starter. This was so tasty. Definitely my favorite. I would come back just for this. House salad was solid. Entrée was the veal francese - good portion. Excellent flavor. Veal was well prepared. Just a bit too saucy. Came with a side of penne with marinara sauce. Really pleased with dinner. I recommend this place. read more

Nicolinni's Chophouse - Greens with sausage - Italian Near Me - Canfield, Ohio

See all

Terrific people and great food. A great variety on the menu and many daily specials. The desserts are made in house, taste great, and are very large. We frequent the bar area due to the workday discount and love the service! The owners a very loyal to their employeesj. read more

Ambiance is like an old school steak house with Italian vibe of that makes sense. Menu items are large to look forward to leftovers. The salad dressing was unique with a. Old school French taste with chunks of tomatoes. Roland parm was more like eggplant lasagna with thick layers of ricotta cheese and delicious tomatoes sauce... not heavy sauce. Manhattan martini was perfect!! read more

Great food.Best chicken and greens in the area. Only thing that I would recommend is to sit at a table instead of a booth.6 people was way too crowded read more

My husband and I shared a romantic dinner in a beautiful wrap around booth. Service and food were both 10/10. I had the chicken and Italian greens and he had the whitefish with clam sauce. The house salad dressing was very unique and tasty, more like a French than the Italian it's described as, but all the same loved it. Bread service was plentiful with a lovely dipping oil to accompany. Definetely will be returning as I think this is my new favorite Italian dish. We finished off with a caramel apple cheesecake to share and it was also very good. read more

See all

Recommend the food is 10 star one plate can easily feed 2 and the are poured heavy the atmosphere is can be romantic at the bar area by the fireplace and last but not least the service is impeccable word for you call at 3:00pm for reservations hope this helped ....Caio read more

Best in Youngstown! Menu has something for everyone. Cioppino is best I've ever experienced anywhere. Great service, reasonable prices and tastiest food. read more

Big disappointment. All of our side dishes arrived cold or luke warm. Italian Greens unnecessarily spicy. Not 'the best in town' as bragged on menu. My father enjoyed his filet minon, although thought seasoning overdone. My porterhouse steak was awful. Strip side tough and full of gristle and sinew. Filet side overcooked and therefore also tough. Service was non-existent after food served. read more

The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Liked the booths and ambiance too.

So impressed with this place. Every aspect of our dinner was amazing. The chicken and greens is a must try item. The chicken is so tender that you can cut it with a spoon. The greens are extremely flavorful and creamy. Add these two items over a bed of pasta and you got yourself a delicious dinner. Salad - delicious Bread and oil dip - even more delicious Slice of hot butter cake with ice cream...... I'm drooling just thinking about taking a bite right now. Waitress was a nice gal too. Overall 10/10 best dinner I've had in awhile read more

Stuffed Hungarian peppers were amazing. Pizza was fresh. Steak was overcooked so I can't comment. Service was really good, we sat in the bar. Price was fair. read more

The main dishes were good, my wife's pasta was cooked well and the sauce was very good, the chicken was way overcooked tho. My pizza was altogether very good. The bad was our appetizer came out after our main dishes and was stone cold, my wife never received her salad. It just seemed they were overwhelmed. For the price it was ok read more

This food is unmatched! The quality of the food is amazing, the atmosphere is gorgeous! Cant wait to go back!

My favorite restaurant whenever I'm in town. There are a ton of great Italian restaurants locally but Nicolinni's takes it to the next level. I always get the seafood medley in red sauce and ask them to make it spicy for me. It is loaded with seafood and perfect every time. This family puts tons of love into all the food they serve and it shows. Amanda was our server for the last visit and she was cheerful and knew the menu well and was able to answer any questions. 5* every visit! read more

Nicolinni's Chophouse - Seafood Medley with red sauce - Italian Near Me - Canfield, Ohio

Always wonderful food. Service was not great but we've had great experiences in the past.

My wife and I were there last evening, 5/17/24. For an actual sit down meal instead of our usual potatoes and greens pizza, which is fantastic! I ordered the chicken and chicken and greens which is usually fantastic as well. However this time it was way to salty and I was only able to eat roughly a third of it. Don't get me wrong, it's a wonderful place with great food and atmosphere, it's just we were disappointed this time. read more

Overall, it was just okay. We had a larger group (12) on a Saturday night. The bread and salad were excellent. Some pitfalls: my mule wasn't filled to the top and tasted very watered down. I got the eggplant parm. It was good but nothing life-changing. The waitress brought us our checks and said that we could "hangout" but there was another party waiting and she would eventually need to "kick us out" (her words, not mine) in 10 minutes. Mind you, this was only 1.5 hours since our reservation started. We also were never asked if we wanted to dessert. I think that the waitress knew it would take us longer than 10 minutes to eat it so she didn't ask. Overall, I was disappointed. read more

We hosted a dinner for 8 customers and employees at Nicolinni's on June 15, 2023. We had reservations, but arrived early and sat at the bar for a bit. The service and knowledge of the bartenders were outstanding as well as the drink options available. Dinner was fantastic. The appetizers were plentiful and very tasty, the Italian greens with sausage, Calamari, and lamb chop lollipops were superb. Dinner was also wonderful. The table order an assortment of entree's and from steak, to seafood to Italian the portions were great and the taste was superb. Our waiter was a young man who is part of the family that owns the restaurant and he made sure the table never lacked in anything we needed. We went back to the bar after dinner and I had the opportunity to speak with one of the owners. She was a delight to talk to and we thanked her for the great experience. Definitely will be back the next time we are in the area. I highly recommend Nicolinni's Chophouse! read more

The food here is always delicious. You can get a wide variety of items too. Pastas, greens, fish, meatballs, Eggplant parmigiana and so much more. I have tried each of these things over the past few visits. The service is knowledgeable, polite and always willing to answer questions and help in any way. Best wedding soup around and they sell it in quarts to go! Yum! read more

I absolutely LOVE the food at Nicolinni's! I get the chicken and greens but substitute the chicken for salmon. Their House Italian is AMAZING!!!!!! read more

It was wonderful... had my birthday dinner with my friends from Akron, Ohio. They couldn't believe how good it was, they will definitely be back. I loved that you didn't have loud music playing so we could have a conversation without screaming at each other. Looking forward to our next visit. read more

I had the shrimp and clam Diablo...it was excellent. Definitely will be back. We sat outside, didn't have reservations on a Saturday and didn't have any problems getting a table outside. We did call an ask best time to come though. 7:30. read more

We were in town for a funeral and stayed at the Hampton Inn. This restaurant was next to the Hotel so went there for dinner. It was really nice and busy so that's a good sign. My husband ordered a ribeye which is always his choice everyone else ordered some kind of pasta which was amazing. But my husband's steak was so tough and had a lot of fat and gristle running through it. I guess the old saying is true don't order a steak at an Italian restaurant. ( the salad dressing is amazing I wish they sold that because I definitely would have bought some.) If I'm ever back there I would go back just not for the steak. read more

Service A+ Food A+ Atmosphere A+ Portions enormous!! Drinks A+ Highly recommend!! can't go wrong! read more

The food is amazing and on point. High end ! The ambience is a little crowded unless sitting in back room. Food is plentiful in portions and priced very well. Service is decent, could use more help, can be a little slow. But all in all awesome place. read more

Excellent place to Dine. The food is great and so is the ambience. Great portion size too. But the Bread!!! Just go and find out for yourself!! We love this place. read more

I had the white fish Nicolinni and it was so good! We loved it so much we ordered it again that following time we went.

Loved Nicolinni's at their former location and was pleased when they reopened in this new space. Since I'm increasingly less and less tolerant of crowds and noise when I eat, my wife and I have chosen to get takeout from here a few times. It never disappoints. Like everywhere else prices are higher than the Before Times, but the portions are always more than enough to justify the cost. Our favorite dish--pasta Giada, swap out angel hair for penne, thank me later--is monstrously huge and is enough for dinner plus a full meal as leftovers the next day. Food's always good, service is not a net negative (which is a victory anymore), and it's worth the price they charge. Overall I would recommend this place. Hope they have continued success and are around for years to come. read more

Food is really good, no complaints at all! The chicken calabrese is my favorite. The service is getting really bad though, prepare to be there a minimum of 2 hrs even with just a party of two. Takes at least 20mins to see a waitress just for drinks, we both ordered the wedding soup, it got to our table and we finished it and still waited another 20mins to even place our order for dinner. By the time the food came we just needed boxes because we were just tired of sitting there for two hours. read more