Best pizza in Nashville! Crust is bubbly and perfect, sauce is full of flavor. Been here 6 years and it is way better than any other pizza I've had in Nashville read more

NY Pie has become my go-to pizza place in Nashville. I have found it is the closest thing to true New York style pizza in the area.... now if I could only find a genuine Chicago-style pizza in town, I'd be set! Though cheaper than some of the other pizza places in town, my husband and I still walk away paying at least $20-25 each visit, which is pricier than you would expect at a casual joint. However, we like the low-key atmosphere here and the workers are always really nice. Plus, the pizzas are yummo! You can buy pizza by the slice for around $3. I highly recommend anything with sausage on it or the NY White-- delicious! read more

Great pizza and cannoli's. We will definitely be back. Cannoli and New York Pizza were awesome!

Sub par pizza not ny quality. I know because pizza is half my diet and my so won't eat somewhere a second time if he doesn't like it. Will someone make good pizza please!!!! read more

This spot was delicious I order over the phone tough my order wasn't correct the immediately accepted responsibility for the mistake and made me another pizza. Customer service was great and the pizza was tasty. read more

This pizza was quite delicious.. and this is saying a lot from a former NJ/NYC resident! Granted, it wasn't the same as NYC.. but close enough for me. Great toppings, good prices, and the staff was super friendly. I had the Greek one.. my bf had their supreme-type one and also a slice that was spinach and chicken I think. All were yummy. I will definitely go back whenever I visit Nashville again! read more

This place was pretty good. I came here to grab a pizza for a friend. She said she'd been craving chicken pesto pizza, against my better judgement I went with it. I'm actually so glad I did. It was awesome. I've actually never made it to west nashville, so I'm glad I did. I love the area this is located in. Staff was super friendly. I would say the only thing that kind of threw me off was, they had signs and prices in the pizza case, the pizza I wanted to try had a sign laid out, but the pizza wasn't available. Normally I'm a visual person and go by how the pizza looks, but they stole my heart at sriracha, only to be let down because it wasn't available. The crust was actually perfect. I've tried a lot of ways to do it wrong, they can definitely so it right here. Even leftovers were on point. This isn't my number one pizza place in Nashville but definitely really, really delicious! read more

NY Pie - Chicken pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Best NY style pizza in Nashville. It's a bit greasy so bring your own napkins, but when you're craving a thin crust slice of cheesy goodness, this is your spot. read more

Best Pizza in West Nashville! 10/10! Located in Nashville West shopping center so very convenient.

The pizza is actually good however I'm from Chicago so I like my pizza Chicago style. Also, I love thin crust but I like it crispy. This pizza was only crispy on the outer crust and real saggy from the bottom crust. I do like that they have a good selection for pizza by the slice. Today I tried the meat and Hawaiian slices and they were good in flavor but again, the crust didn't do it for me. The location was good and service is great. They were quick to clean up all the tables as people left. I would try them again but maybe the next time will be earlier as I did come later so the oil may have gotten the crust soft. All in all definitely a place I'd consider for lunch since I am in the area a lot. read more

NY Pie - Hawaiian and NY meats slices - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

I'm ashamed it's taken me this long to review NY Pie since I've been enjoying lunches there on a weekly basis for many months now. A slice of delicious pie + a drink for under $5 = a perfect lunch in my opinion. I've never been to New York, so I can't comment on the authenticity of their name. However, what I do know is that their pizza is very tasty. My personal favorite is a "slice of Grandma" -- mainly because it's (morbidly) fun to order a slice of granny. The crust on Grandma's pizza is just right and topped with minimal sauce, fresh basil and a blend of cheeses. I've also tried their meaty pizzas and loved them too. On top of their yummy food, they also have great service -- it's always nice to be greeted here with a friendly hello and a smile. I also love the transparency of their food preparation -- it's really fun to watch them prepare the dough and to have the oven on full display. read more

NY Pie - Grandma's Pizza - yum! - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Having lived in the northeast my whole life I thought I'd never again get a slice like I used to back home once I moved to Nashville; then I found NY Pie. This is by far the best pizza in town. If you like good ol' New York style pizza then this is your spot. Hand tossed, freshly prepared and always on point. *Side note* I went to a party the other evening and met an unbelievably friendly and hospitable gentleman through a great buddy of mine. After talking for a half hr or so I found out this new acquaintance was in fact the owner of NY Pie. It made a lot of sense. That type of hospitality, respect, and friendliness he treated me with is exactly what you experience when you walk into the shop. Hope you guys enjoy this pizza as much as I do, both with intensity and frequency (I don't eat too much pizza... YOU eat too much pizza). read more

This is by far the best pizza I've found in my fifteen years in Nashville. I'm from South Jersey so that's the kind of pizza I like. In my humble opinion, the very best kind. This place nails it. Thin crust, perfect cheese/sauce ratio. My favorite is the Greek pizza. The plain cheese is also to die for. I've tried nearly all of their specialty pies and have yet to try one I didn't like. The staff is super great too. Highly recommend! read more

Love this place! Best "Pizza by the Slice" in west Nashville! New York Pizza at it's finest.

Delishhhh. Workers are always nice and friendly. I always like to order it and bring it home to a preheated oven to make sure it stays crispy. read more

Best pizza I've had in the US! Coming from an Italian! Everything tasted perfectly good, made me feel at home!

Cool little pizza place tucked away in the corner, good atmosphere and great pizza pies. We sat out on the patio and enjoyed the great weather along with our pie. Also suggest the garlic knots, would definitely eat here again! read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

We've been trying to find true authentic NY style pizza in Nashville/Clarksville and NY pie was the 5th place we tried. NY Pie is it! We absolutely loved the 18in cheese pizza and the staff was incredibly friendly. This is our new Nashville pizza spot and I highly recommend! read more

Hands down the BEST pizza I've had in Nashville! If you are from the Northeast like me, you understand my struggle in the search of an authentic Slice of pizza in Nashville. You know, the kind of pizza they sell by the slice, the kind that is mouth watering with just cheese on it. At last, I FINALLY found an authentic New York style pizza at a reasonable price! Thank you NYPie for finally solving my pizza problems read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Native New Yorker here. I have given up on Pizza south of Mid-New Jersey years ago. I went in here and thought I'd take a look. Semi authentic ambiance. The furniture is dead on, the spice shakers, having a few pies on display to order individual slices, and the place just smelled right. The slices looked right. This is my second time here. The first time I ordered a plain slice and it was dead on. I would have honestly preferred a bag to go instead of a box for my single slice. Thats the best I can do to muster up criticism because it was GREAT. A genuinely authentic NY slice. Now here is the REAL reason for my review. This time I ordered a calzone. Even in New York i've had a hard time finding a good calzone in the last 15 or so years because they have to much mozzarella. NY Pie does it right. A calzone should be ricotta with mozzarella and not the other way around. This was great. Kudos. Thanks NY PIE for inspiring my first review. P.S. Anybody else notice the review by Madelyn A. complaining about the strombolli when she clearly had a calzone? She even has a picture of it! Hilarious. read more

Though I've been to this place many times and enjoy their pizza immensely... I've never written a review. Shame on me! These guys and gals deserve better than that! As a New England girl finding delicious pizza in Nashville can be very tough, our expectations are high. I've experience the best pizza on the planet for most of my life. New York pizza, Chicago pizza, Boston pizza, true Italian pizza - Nashville just doesn't have a hold on this for the most part.... But NY pie is real New York style pizza. It's not just on their sign y'all. This place rocks! It rocks because the pizza is delicious and well crafted; rocks because they use the right amount of seasoning and have a beautiful sauce with thin crust; It rocks because the staff is not only gracious, but they are fun loving and happy! They know they are making and serving excellent product - and I think they love their jobs because of it. At least it seems that way... It is always a pleasure going into this establishment and I will go back again and again. I just stopped by on my lunch break and what a happy moment it was - thanks for the bonus guys! Rock the pie! read more

Great pizza!! My husband is from New Jersey and this is his FAVORITE pizza in Nashville. The best thing about NY pie is that you can buy pizza by the slice. They have a great lunch special and very friendly staff. I suggest the grandma style pizza- awesome flavor, fresh ingredients! read more

This is practically the only place you can go in Nashville for authentic New York-style pizza. By the slice or whole pies. A little slice of Brooklyn nice! read more

FAIL! As a general rule, I don't care for pizza that is associated with a particular city or region because they tend to represent extremes, too thin and dry or too thick and greasy. I simply want good pizza. I was not interested in ordering anything from this pizza shop but my husband decided that I needed a veggie pizza and ordered it without my knowledge. We took our order to go and later when I looked at the pizza, it looked sad. It had these tiny chopped veggies with a minimal amount of cheese and a very thin crust. It did not look appetizing at all but I decided to give it a try. It was as expected: disappointing. A good pizza starts with a good crust, so this dry, chewy inedible crust was a fail right out of the gate. I looked at my husband's Caesar salad and it was nothing more than lettuce and croutons, so I was not interested. Now for the stromboli! It was absolutely huge but drowning in cheese which was a turn- off. However, as my husband was eating it, I decided to give it a try. I thought it odd that he was only eating random pieces of it but upon further inspection, I noticed that it had totally disintegrated. As I attempted to gather up pieces to taste, I noticed that they had put something that resembled ricotta cheese in their stromboli and that is something I had never seen before. It was not a good idea because it made for a very soggy product that just fell apart on contact to become a pile of ingredients on a plate. The flavor profile was just off and not something I would want to eat again. For me, this was a hot mess and a definite fail. read more

See all

The pizza was good, but the staff was a bit weird. That's all I really gotta say about this place.

Great place. Great people. The pizza is excellent. I wish they were closer to my side of town. But when I want NY style pizza that's the place I go. read more

Favorite pizza in Nashville, hands down. I order at least once every two weeks, if not more, and honestly I could probably eat it every day and never get tired of it! read more

West Nashvillians rejoice...AMAZING pizza has arrived! No more living in the land of chain pizza joints! Ever since I saw the sign go up for NY Pie I was totally excited. I was not disappointed. We went there for lunch (when they have pizza by the slice) and I had a couple slices of white pizza while my husband tried a meat slice and a greek slice(olives,peppers,tomatoes,feta). One bite and I was in love. Huge slices that were perfectly crisp with tons of flavor and only a mild amount of grease. Somehow for dinner we ended up picking up a full pizza and a cheese calzone on our way home. The pizza was just as delicious as earlier and my wonderfully cheesy and crispy calzone came with sauce that was fresh. No canned marinara as a side, yay! If you are out near Nashville West definitely stop by and check this place out. It's a bit small on the inside but whether you sit in or carry out you'll be very very happy. read more

Good pizza and calzones. Also dig the garden salad and homemade balsamic dressing. I recommend the food. Two stars for one simple reason, really poor service. Ever since the owner Greg opened up store #2 in Hendersonville and left the Nashville branch, the service has suffered, getting worse over time. They've messed up my phone order multiple times, trying to excuse themselves with any and all of the following: 1. Are you sure you called this store? (This mixup is probably your fault.) 2. What time did you call us? (Surely this mixup isn't our fault.) 3. Oh we had a computer printer problem, and your order got lost. (This is our fault, but we couldn't help it.) 4. Do you want to wait another 20 minutes for us to make you what you ordered 30 minutes ago? (This is no one's fault, be patient.) 5. We just handed your large cheese pizza to the walk-in order in front of you, although we won't call it that. How about we call this a mystery and provide you with a free pizza for your trouble? (This is our fault.) Basically, they're unreliable. After eating their pizza a couple dozen times, we're fed up and taking our business elsewhere. read more

So normally this would be a 4-star place, but let's face it....we're in Nashville folks and Papa Johns and Pizza Hut are all we have, so I officially give it up for NY Pie. Crust is thin, crunchy without tasting like cardboard (not that I can actually compare having not eaten cardboard). They have a great selection of traditional and eclectic toppings, a lot of pies at the ready for those who want to grab a slice and go and a staff that seems to actually have their shit together (maybe they could go next door to that awful wing place with 3000 TVs and the waitresses with a collective IQ of 100 and lend a hand?). Prices are reasonable, not exactly someplace you want to bring a date since its lacking on ambiance, but if you were the kind of guy who brings a chick out for a slice of pizza, I'm gathering you probably don't get a lot of dates anyway. Try the call ahead for personalized calzones - yum to the max. Oh, and then hit the gym, cuz it is NOT good for you. read more

Absolutely the best NY style pizza in Nashville; we routinely drive past all the other pizza places on Nashville's top ten list to go to NY Pie. We live in 12 South and drive to Nashville West. If your going to indulge in Pizza it should taste great and NY Pie does! read more

Had a chance to grab a pie for lunch here today, was very impressed. Reminds me of pizza joints in Manhattan, you can order by the slice or by the pie. I got their all meats pizza and was very impressed. This particular pie had ham, pepperoni, bacon, sausage(s), salami and probably some additional nummy meats that helped to clog my arteries that I can't recall. They make all of the dough and hand-toss it right there in front of you. The sauce was pretty good, a little bit of a spice to it, I would have liked it to be slightly spicier. Just the right amount of cheese as well. The crust was perfectly crisp at the ends and very thin under the pie, exactly the way it is supposed to be. Be prepared to use a fork and knife if you are a sissy and to fold if you are used to a NY slice. The staff was jovial and engaging, which is always fun. The prices did seem a bit higher than my regular mom & pop haunt, Pizza Perfect, but this is some pretty good pizza, so I'd say it is worth it. read more

Great place to grab some slices on your lunch break or a whole pie for dinner or watching the game. The Caesar salad was crisp and fresh and came with plenty of dressing. The meatball appetizer was really good too. I have enjoyed every slice I've tried. The front counter help is very courteous and efficient. The tall young man Logan greeted me with a smile and let me feel like he cared about my order. And something most businesses drop the ball on, the iced tea, was actually perfect. I will definitely recommend this restaurant read more

I grew up on Tennessee Pizza which is best exemplified by Pizza Hut -- spongy crust and lots of toppings. The first time I had real NY Pizza, I was amazed at how wonderful something so simple could be. I lived in the NYC area for 13 years and then came back to Nashville. In NY, I missed good barbecue. Back in Nashville, I missed good NY Pizza, or "Pie" as they call it. Pizza Perfect has a good reputation, but no matter how good the pie sounds on the menu, when you get it, it seems to be missing something. Joey's in Brentwood is good Pizza. But on slices, you often taste more of the "oven" than you would like. Their stuffed pies are amazing and a personal favorite, but truthfully, they are more like a lasagna than a pizza. Real NY Pizza is a very simple, yet complex thing. Forget pepperoni. Forget mushrooms. Fuggetabout all of the toppings. I am not saying that toppings are inherently bad. However, the real "NY Slice" experience is a slice of plain cheese pizza, perfectly reheated, and sprinkled with a little garlic powder and some oregano at the table. That is the big test. Does the crust "snap?" Do you taste the tomato -- not too raw, not overcooked? How's the cheese? Do you get a nice, creamy bite of cheese that mellows the tomato and contrasts with the snap of the crust? Does it all blend with the garlic and oregano to form a gastronomic delight? Yes. Yes, my friends, that is a real NY Pie experience. Does NY Pie here is Nashville measure up? Absolutely. Is it as good as the best Pizza's NY and Brooklyn have to offer? Probably not. BUT, NY Pie offers Nashvilleans a slice experience on par with many of the very good pizza places in NY. And that, my friends, leaves you with a full belly and a smile on your face. NY Pie is a welcome addition to the neighborhood. read more

This place is the real deal. They serve NY pizza and it's the best I have found in TN!

I've been a customer for about as long as they've been at this location when I moved into the neighborhood in 2012. And the pizza is good. On par with Five Points. But the experience this weekend when I picked my order left me wondering if I'll order from them again, which is unfortunate because of the close proximity to the place. When I came to pick up the order and tip, the staff member processing the transaction asked me about the KY Democrats t-shirt (I was gifted a while ago) I happened to wear that day. When I explained who the person on my shirt was (a US senator from KY) the staff person continued to make me extremely uncomfortable by telling me how crazy and awful Biden was and that by wearing a shirt like that I should expect people questions about it so essentially I better think twice about wearing this type of shirt again and promote the "liberal propaganda". After quickly paying for my order and leaving the tip (I always do since I spent my youth waiting tables) I walked out of the store completely dumbfounded. Did this really just happen? The passive aggressive behavior that quickly turned into berating was so uncalled for I didn't know how to respond. And so I didn't reply with anything back because I had family over who were waiting for the food. But after this experience I don't feel comfortable going into the store again. Very disappointed about this experience and saddened that I was treated in such a disrespectful way. read more

The hardest thing at NY Pie is trying to force myself to order any of the pizzas beside classic cheese or classic pepperoni. They are just so freaking good. Sometimes simple is hard but not here. This is what pizza should be! I won't get into arguments about what New York pie is because I have never been to NY and this isn't even the type of pizza I grew up with. I just know that this is the best pizza I have had in town and one that I truly crave. That being said, I have had several other varieties and they always have a good variety of toppings. If you don't see what you like, ask because there are usually other ones tucked under the main counter or they will make it. They had a stuffed one that had sausage with peppers and onions that was wonderful. I had one that was either the NY Special or the NY Garlic Chicken and it was very good. I've also had the NY White and it was good. The only one I have had that I was crazy about was the NY Grandma's Pie and I think that is because I see thick crust and think Sicilian and very few live up to the ones I had when I was young. So that is more my expection than the pie itself. read more

This pizza is probably the best in Nashville, to be honest, if not then top 3 for sure. Why the two stars? Their staff are incredibly rude. We have been several times just hoping that the people working their are having a bad night because the pizza is so good. We have been there picking up pizza and waited for 30 minutes to get service, watching our pizza get colder and colder. Another time when we were dining in, I have had a staff member "huff" at me when when I asked for a couple plates to eat our pizza off of, as if I inconvenienced her after I had immediately just paid for my pizza at the register. I get it that when your pizza is good you're also going to be super busy. But the girlfriend and I refuse to go back after numerous times of people acting like we were inconveniencing them by picking up our pizza and interrupting their conversation about what pandora station they were gonna pick next. It's not like we were super demanding customers or made a scene, we just walked up and kindly waited for service accordingly. It's a shame too because that pizza is good but the staff ruin it for us. read more

Don't let the haters deter you. I grew up in Boston and lived in NYC. This pizza would sell well up there. It isn't the best I have had in my life, but is by FAR the best place in Nashville that keeps normal hours. I would say it is better than Manny's and Joey's house of pizza by a little bit. They make a great pie as well, but if it isn't daytime during the week you can't go because they are closed. read more

The best pizza in Nashville, and it's not even that close. The place I believe is run by a few folks transplanted from NY (there are a bunch of items referencing the NY Giants, but don't hold me to it) and the Pizza is really good. I'm originally from NY and one of my peeves about Nashville was its horrible pizza. It has to mainly do with the water being different and it alters the flavor of the pizza, so it's hard to replicate NY style pizza or pretty much anything that tastes good as far as pizza apparently. I tried a whole bunch of local places and were disappointed that I was stuck with the national brands for any kind of edible pizza. It's located in a mall area so there is plenty of parking, and the staff seems really nice, although I've never eaten in here, always ordered out. The Pizza itself is a bit thin, and definitely thinner than the ones you usually get in NY, but it's pretty tasty. They have fresh mozzarella as a topping, and I would suggest going for extra cheese because the regular cheese coating can be somewhat on the lite side. I've also tried the stromboli from here, and they are delicious as well, and fulfilling. The only downside is that it is a tad bit expensive for a pizza place especially if you like multiple toppings on your pizza pie, but it's worth it if you love pizza and hate the national brands. They also have online ordering, which makes it much easier to order on their website. I would try this place atleast once if you like pizza, and I'm convinced most people would love to come back. read more