this is a very small place. i took my wife and our two kids and we ordered a Sicilian Pepperoni pizza $18 +$3 for toppings) we went around lunch time on a Monday and the place was fairly busy due to their offering of pizza by the slice. the service was pretty good, and so was the pizza! our pizza was probably 2.5 inches thick and i could only eat two slices before i was STUFFED. they are not stingy at all with the cheese. each slice was trailed by tightropes of stringy cheese. the sauce was sweet and had a nice amount of pop. i really enjoyed it and so did my family. we will definitely return. read more

NY Pie - Sicilian Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

If you've read any of my other reviews, you know I'm a proponent of three things: Consistency, Quality and conscientious service. I'll drive out of my way, pay extra and fawn over any business that can give me the triad of excellence. NY Pie is just such a place. I've eaten here once a week for two years. Consider me an expert. Served by the slice, you can mix and match your version of heaven. The pizza is delicious every time! Sriracha chicken!!! Garlic chicken!! NY White! Too good to pass up. The shingles are generous... one slice is filling, two is just gluttonous!! You will see me ordering one in the company of friends, but being naughty when alone... so very naughty! I've taken a personal liking to the employees. Their hands are rarely idle, they seem interested in their customers and proud of their product. Bravo! In a world where top of the bell curve seems to be everywhere, these folks are A listers! Where do I put my money, invest my passion and plant my big old booty? In NY Pie! They have what it takes to be excellent! read more

Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!! As a native New Yorker who's been in Nashville for 10 years, I'm so grateful that a fellow New Yorker brought me here. This is how I grew up on pizza. I was transported back to the days of non-pretentious slices of pizza, served in a causal atmosphere with signs reading "ravioli" on the wall. This pizza is as good as any slice in the Tri-State area. How about you guys open up a location in East Nashville? The only thing missing was Taylor Dayne or Stacey Q jams on the radio. read more

I'm a New Yorker. I love my pizza. This place is my favorite in all of Nashville. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Decent pizza in Nashville. Wouldn't say it was my favorite pizza I've ever had but for a quick and easy takeout option it's good

Covid-19 update: they're open for take out. Go and support 'em if you can.

Best pizza in Nashville. If you're from the Northeast and looking for real pizza - you've found it. Relocating here has a lot of perks. Good pizza on every corner isn't one of them. Never thought I'd drive 20+ min for a good pie yet here I am. Worth it every time!! read more

We had dinner at NY Pie last night and it could not have been better. The service was outstanding. The pizza was delicious and the crust cooked perfectly. The ambiance was nice...dim lights and the music not too loud. I would highly recommend NY Pie to anyone. I've never had a bad pizza from them!! Also, if you're a veteran, they give a discount! read more

Very good pie joint! Ordered takeout and sat on their outdoor patio as I am driving through. Fresh sauce with good flavor of tomatoes and garlic. Just all around good flavor and the medium pie serves 8 slices. I would recommend! read more

Garlic knots are great. Pizza very tasteful. Sauce may be a bit spicy to some. I think sauce taste great. Home made dough is great.

This place has one of the best coke fountain machines I've had. The White slice of pizza is fantastic! Great vibe, clean, quick service. Price was great, under $10 for two huge slices of pizza and a drink. read more

NY Pie - White slice and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

Okay, let it be said that I haven't the faintest idea what a New York pizza is. Therefore, I don't know if this is the authentic article. But, what I do know is that this is the closest thing I have had to my favorite pizza style at home in Australia. It's the best pizza I have had in the US during the past four years. They have thinnish, but crispy, crusts. There was a huge amount of topping and it was cooked to perfection. Usually in the US I am provided with pizza which has a single, sparse topping. Today's effort was 'NY Meat'. And it was really meaty. Add to that a generous measure of cheese and tomato paste and I was in heaven. One day I will get to New York to see if it is authentic...but, guess what; I couldn't give a s**t. I reiterate, this was the best pizza I have had in the US, better than the west coast, the mid west and the east coast, anywhere between the Keys and Washington. It more than made up for the disappointment I suffered at finding out that World Foods had run out of Vegemite. read more

Pizza by the slice is a rarity in Nashville, though it's getting more common. NY Pie is the genuine article. Lots of interesting choices ready to sample as slices, but the real winner is letting them make you a pie to order. Cheap? No. Worth it? Absolutely. We ordered an enormous 18" NY Meat specialty pizza with mushrooms and onions, and it was perfection. Crispy edges. Soft, foldable slices. Laden with quality toppings. The sauce was the perfect balance of sweet and tangy. Cheese ratio was perfect. Value wise, it was solid: the pie we ordered was $25, but it was eight big slices, enough for four people. Cheaper than buying individual slices, and fresh out of the oven. The service was fantastic-- quick, attentive and personable. N. and I were there for a working lunch that dragged on for a few hours, and they made us feel entirely welcome. Speedy wifi is a big bonus too. Also: excellent music. I am a native Nashvillian, but I've been to NYC, and this is hands down the best representation of the real deal you can get here in Music City. I fully recommend NY Pie. Delicious pizza, comfortable environment, great staff. read more

NY pie is the real deal! Love their pizza (and their lunch special is awesome). Love being able to get good pizza by the slice and they always have it ready in a short time. read more

Best pizza in Nashville, says this New York resident! The guys behind the counter were polite, friendly, and hard at work! read more

Let's just say the Sriracha Chicken pizza is the best thing in life. It literally will be the best pizza you have ever had. EVER. First born children were given up for it. Wars were fought. Seas were parted. The heavens opened and blessed us with this pizza. Do you hear the angels? Why, yes....yes you do. Now, go and find happiness! read more

Top three best pizza places in Nashville. Number one pizza joint in Bellevue. Pros - Pizzas are huge (very southern of them) and toppings are fresh - They are not stingy with the toppings - Location is great (next to central hub of Bellevue...a target, Costco and a park- all of them in walking distance of the restaurant) - great customer service - they support our armed forces and vets (military discount) - You will never get served a bad pie here - they offer pizza dough you can take home and bake yourself! Cons - none really if you like good quality pizza and good customer service read more

Excellent pizza, my favorite in Nashville. Love the margarita + pepperoni, cheesy bread, and garlic knots. Friendly staff. (Someone commented they don't wear gloves, when in fact they do every time I've visited) Lots of delicious toppings. Casual vibe. You can also order ahead online. Walk up counter with high top and regular seatings available. Clean bathrooms. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

We drove from Lebanon to NY Pie on a Friday because of the reviews. We ordered a 14 inch white pizza with chicken. As a connoisseur of white pizza I was excited. The pizza actually had too much ricotta and not enough of the other toppings. Ricotta cools quickly so the pizza was cold by mid-meal. I also found gristle on the chicken, which was very disappointing. The toppings did not reach the edge of the pizza. In fact, there was over an inch and a half of crust. The crust itself was average. I base a good crust on whether I eat all of it or leave the ends. In this case I left the ends. The setting: it's just a mall location so it has a generic environment that's too tight for anyone besides a size 3. The employees: everyone was quick to help or take our order, or clean. We would have been just as happy with something local. I don't see how this place ranks #2 in Nashville on some websites. Don't believe the hype. read more

NY Pie - White pizza with chicken on 14" pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

Awesome customer service! And very military friendly. And the pizza is great! Highly satisfied! A must try place to eat!

I'm a Nashville transplant, not originally from the Tennessee area. However finding great pizza in this area has been hard. This place never disappoints, any pizza you order from here will be great. They're margarita pizza is phenomenal But may as well get a cookie while you're in there considering they're soft and the size of a dinner plate!! Can't wait to be back. read more

Quite a delicious Pizza experience! I've never had "Real" NY Pizza, so I can't speak to its authenticity, but it was quite good to be sure. This place, however, is HOPPING busy. Clearly a lot of people are enjoying it. Also, the waiter service is not exactly "Full" service. Basically you order at the register, and they call your name. In our case the cashier did bring us our Pizza, but we had to get our own drinks and plate. While this isn't exactly a mark against them, it could make your first time slightly awkward. I fully expect to return for more NY Pie! read more

See all

Ok, if anyone loves Sbarro's pizza at the mall, this is just like that but an upgrade. Me and my husband ordered twice in one week it was so good. Everything is on point and this is a hidden gem! My new favorite pizza place, sorry Jet's! read more

Excellent thin crust pizza! Especially on a quick stop for lunch. Garlic chicken pizza was great. I will dine again.

NYC in BNA. Large, foldable slices. Delicious sauce. Real mozzarella, fresh ingredients. The price a are reasonable. Awesome! read more

Great NYC pizza!!! Perfect taste and texture. Thin crust yum!

Pretty dang tasty stuff. Good, floury, thin crust pizza. Very clean place with pizza by the slice or whole pie. I'd love to try all their pies, and I might someday. The pizza maker made a great 10 foot dough toss/spin, too. They flour their dough on the marble, wood, and by hand. It's good stuff. The thin crust "Grandmother's" pizza is basically a cheese pizza, but is significantly better. Really nice people here. Employees seem genuinely happy to be here. I saw the owner give a group of well behaved kids a big old cookie at the end of their meal. There was a line at the register and they gave me my pizza to eat and just said to come back and pay when it died down. All in all, best place for pizza in Nashville(?), don't know, you decide, but at least toss this one in the mix. I though just over $9 was sort of a lot for two slices and a drink when I got rung up, but not now that I'm done eating and can't finish it. read more

See all

We just didn't think it was that great. The staff was friendly but the pizza just wasn't very "wow". We sat on the patio and it was nice

Well, it's not NY Pie. It was too thick, but it wasn't bad pizza. I just feel like it's incorrectly named. It should be named TN Pie because it aligns with most pies that I've had here. Thick, doughy, cheesy, lots of toppings, etc. Sound familiar? NY Pie exists right where it should. The establishment is family-friendly and so is their pies. I would recommend either sitting on the patio or bringing your pie home to watch a movie. The inside of the restaurant is a little cramped, but not too bad. Again, NY Pie is A-OK for what it is. Other tidbits: +1 for parking +1 for friendliness +1 for ease and taste read more

This is my all time favorite pizza in Tennessee. I'm part Italian, from Metro NYC and spoiled as can be. I've spent time on tour in Europe and nothing compared to Italy when it comes to pizza. This pizza measures up. The only suggestion I have fir them is to deliver to their biggest and loyal customers! I know I know, they don't need to deliver because their ovens are always full to capacity with walk ins!! I get it but I am a moody music artist who sometimes stays indoors at home for days working at a time and won't go out! Like right now! If something changes and they decide to deliver to us, hopefully this message will be recalled. !! Danny. read more

We tend to take out mostly. Great pizza with good amount of sauce and cheese. Tried the Sicilian last night which didn't disappoint. It has a small eating area but with covid-19 I believe it is take out only. read more

I always order my pizza to-go but I've never had a bad experience. Friendly staff, orders always correct, pizza is AWESOME and great pricing. Haven't ordered Pizza Hut or Dominos since I ran across this place. Thank you, NY PIE! read more

I can not say if I like this place or not. Sometimes the pizza is so good and other times, not the same. I can not explain it but I give it 4 stars because when it is good, it is good and the staff is amazing. Also, they sell by the slice :) read more

Crunchy-crust pizza and delicious, fresh salad. Best pizza I've had in ages. I'll definitely be back.

This place is amazing. AMAZING! If you haven't been there yet then you should stop reading this review and go there now. The price is a little on the high side but trust me when I tell you that you get what you pay for. When I go there I keep things simple and get just a pepperoni pizza and it tastes great every single time. You can also buy it by the slice. The staff is always friendly and helpful and their menu offers almost any pizza you can think of plus more. This is by far my favorite pizza place. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

This little place is one of the best pizza options in Nashville. I've tried many of them and this ranks up there with anyone - I drive far to go here sometimes - I'm originally from the Northeast and I'd to think I know a good slice. Worth the effort imo. read more

So my baby and I went here today and it wasn't as good as the reviewers made it seem! However, we may just not have the same taste in pizza! This pizza was salty to me and that did it for me. Baby didn't like the onions he said it wasn't good and the nice lady gave us the two slices for free, he wasn't a fan either. He said the pizza was falling apart as he was trying to eat it. He is a thin pizza lover so of course this wasn't his style. However, I prefer this style but I think I am going to just stick to my regular pizza spots for now. I always disappoint myself with different pizza spots. Parking is available, I think their outside tables are available, I know we sat inside and workers do wear mask, also, tables are sanitized. They do have lunch specials if you go before three! They have single slices available and have no problem heating it up for you! Hospitality was great! Pizza tasting not so great! I enjoy Marcos & slim and huskys but try it out with a single slice if you want, our taste buds just may be different!! read more

NY Pie - Siracha chicken pizza and garlic chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Nashville, Tennessee

See all

My daughter and I went to the new NY Pie in Franklin. it happened to be a soft opening so we were ready for some issues but we were told the pizza was worth it. First of all, there were no issues and the place was packed. Jessica the owner even took time to stop and talk to us. Quality!! Secondly, the pizza was absolutely amazing. We could not stop talking about how good it was. The large is huge and so good. If you are anywhere close to this new pizza in town, you have to go and you will not be disappointed. read more

Best pizza in Nashville (or anywhere???) hands down. The staff is always friendly and pizza is delish. I literally came here like 4 times a week when I first moved to town. I've tried a lot of their flavors and all are yum, but my favorites are definitely the sriracha chicken and white pizza - so amazing!!! Oh, also - if you're a ranch person the ranch here is AMAZING. Dip the crust and/or garlic knots in it - you won't regret it! read more

Best pizza in Nashville! Crust is bubbly and perfect, sauce is full of flavor. Been here 6 years and it is way better than any other pizza I've had in Nashville read more