This has become my family's favorite place for me to order birthday cakes from. Their Polish style cakes are very beautiful and delicate on the pallette. It's a bit pricey but very worth a try. read more

I ordered this heart shaped cake for my daughter's 16th birthday and it exceeded my expectations. It turned out to be stunning and delicious! I sent a design that she wanted and they made it even better than original picture. My daughter loved the added little pink bows and polka dots on the side. I chose vanilla cake with raspberry mouse filling ans it was light and flavorful. Very pleased with this order. Highly recommend this bakery, especially their French macaron cake that I've been ordering for all occasions for many years now. You won't be disappointed with it. read more

See all

They have beautiful desserts, beads, and paczki. If you want something out of the ordinary for your guests, it's a great bakery to try out. I have been to both locations and never disappointed. read more

We just had a cake from there for our daughter's baptism! It was delicious (Forest Fruit); not too overwhelmingly sweet as most things are in the US... even the frosting is good and there was no need to scrape it off! We ordered it online way in advance and there was no issue with pick-up! Highly recommend it! read more

Best Bakery in the area. They have a few locations and we have been ordering from here since I was a child. Their Pear Charlotte cake is to die for, and always a must at any of our family celebrations, from birthday to new babies. read more

Absolutely horrible and disappointing! Came here because Weber's closed earlier than I realized and wanted a Paczki for Fat Tuesday. We ordered what we though were 2 Bavarian cream paczki, 2 cake slices, and 2 cake pops. The total for all 6 items was a little over 22 dollars...ridiculous! My mistake was checking the receipt when I was already on my way home and I see we have 2 gourmet apple somethings and the cost for 2 was 9.98. I'm already annoyed, but figured I'd look at everything better once I got home. The 2 paczki had apple in them inside the ring of cream. So 4.99 per paczki?!? I know inflation is hitting everything, but that is just sinful! We had the paczki on Tuesday and they were just ok...not fresh tasting and certainly NOT worth the price. We had the cake slices tonight and could not even have more than a bite. I don't know how long they were in the display but they just tasted old and weird. The cake pops also had an old taste and are almost 3 dollars each for literally a quarter sized ball on a stick. A complete joke!!! I should have realized when nobody else was in that bakery on Fat Tuesday that was a big sign at how bad this place is! read more

I was surprised with a delish raspberry mousse chocolate cake for my birthday. And it did not disappoint! Fresh and light and not too sweet. Will be getting cakes here from now on. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Raspberry mousse chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Delicious cookies. Extremely pleased with custom graduation cookies. I would highly recommend Oak Mill bakery. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Custom graduation cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

So, my sister and I were heading home yesterday from the south loop and I mentioned that it was the last day to get paczkis. So, we decided to head here to pick some up during a little bit of traffic. We get there about 6pm. We opted for a blueberry, egg liquer and raspberry paczki. The blueberry and raspberry was ok. The egg liquer was too strong of a taste for me. I guess paczkis aren't really my thing. Chocolate Bomb - My sister ordered this and I only got one bite and thought it was good, but my mom ate the rest. read more

See all

This bakery has by far the best tasting pastries! They aren't over sugared like a lot of other cakes and pastries you would purchase in a regular store. I honestly believe this is the best bakery around and I traveled 3 hours just so I could get a cake so I think that says something. read more

My experience at this bakery was unlike any other bakery I've visited - and it wasn't a good one at all, it was absolutely AWFUL!!!! I came in for a wedding cake tasting with my fiancé and mother in law and was expecting a high standard of service, what we got however was less than pleasant. The employees are lifeless and uninterested in serving you, you won't catch them smiling or offering their help and input. They made it seem like it was a burden to serve us, like they were annoyed that we came in. The tasting consisted of 5 stale cake slices and pastries out of the pastry case and three plastic forks for the three of us to share the pieces. The samples did not taste fresh at all and we even overheard an employee telling another customer that most items were made yesterday. When we asked about prices we learned that they charge you separate for everything- literally. The cake flavor, filling, and any and all decorations are at a separate cost- a bling ribbon that goes around the base of each cake layer can be RENTED for $125.... Ridiculous. I don't know if you can get away with a $5-7 cost per person. Not to mention the $80 they charge for delivery. We were charged $25 for the tasting, I'm 100% positive we did not have $25 worth of cake or service for that matter. This bakery is a disgrace and should be ashamed of itself, they don't deserve people's business and people should not pay for them to stay in business. I will never ever come to any oak mill location again and I will discourage all my friends and family from bringing their business there. If anyone is dying for a bad experience and terrible customer service this is definitely the place to go!!! We went to another cake tasting at a different bakery that same day and everyone received their own plate with their OWN 7 samples of cake and 7 fillings to try and we were offered coffee, tea, and water ... Additionally we got a consultant who sat with us and listened to what we wanted and were interested in. She brought out examples to show us how big a 4-5 tier cake would look like. She also asked if we wanted to try any of their other cake flavors or fillings and brought them out with a smile. The tasting did not cost us a penny, nothing at all- the bakery owner said that it was just a part of their service and a part of the wedding cake ordering process. I will recommend them to everyone and I will tell the world about oak mill's TERRIBLE TERRIBLE customer service and rip off of a " cake tasting". Oak mill should be ashamed of their company and their service, they are a disgrace!!! read more

I love this bakery. it does a fine job of straddling the line between good, old fashioned Eastern European tradition and modern innovation. We stop by here a few times a month to get pastries, cakes, and cookies for special occassions, whether that is a birthday, a feast day, or a holiday. This place is known for its mousse-filled cakes and pastries. I highly recommend the passionfruit and mango mousse dark chocolate cake surrounded by a ring of dark chocolate and decorated in edible goldleaf with an imprint of the Chicago skyline. Also tasty is the poached pear and pear mousse cake with lady-fingers. If you are in the mood to sample traditional Polish pastries, Oak Mill Bakery prepares delicious fruit tarts, cheesecakes, apple strudel, paczki, and makowiec (a poppy-seed and dried fruit filling surrounded by a yeasty dough that is rolled into a log and drizzled with lukier (icing) and candied orange peel). A cake that the bakery estimates will feed 8-12 (more like 12-20) because of the cake's richness will run you about $38-45. Also, be prepared, if you have your heart set on a specific pastry or cake, you might need to call ahead during holidays. Oak Mill tends to bake their cakes and pastries in one location and deliver their products to its outlying bakeries. read more

I traversed out this way (after having a very kind handyman shovel my car out of the fence of snow that suddenly appeared around it recently) to get some paczki. I've been to other Oak Mill locations but this one may be my new favorite. They had more varieties of paczki and there were no long lines like last year's trip to the Niles Oak Mill. They had tons of beautiful little Fat (please, more like Hyperobesity) Tuesday treats, that were very fresh. Plus they had pineapple. Hooray for that. They also let me use my credit card even though my purchase was less than $10 so I won't be a huge megabitch about how it's totally illegal to have min. charges. read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Paczki! - Bakeries Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I was regular customer at Oak Mill for special occasions cakes. I ordered cake week prior to birthday party. On the day when I was picking up the cake, they called me at 12pm- (my pick up time) that cake is not done because they had power outage ! They didn't call in the morning or at the time when power when off( if power went off! Or somebody just forgot to make a cake?) they just called when I was almost there to pick it up! They offered me different chocolate cake and told me it will be FROZEN and not ready to eat till 5-6pm!! I didn't get any explanation what really happened with my cake, or real apology :( Now I am not even sure what is fresh in their bakery since they sell frozen cakes for a lot of $$$ :( read more

Weber's Bakery (2 minutes away from this place) is a million time better than this place. Every time I have gone in here, it's pretty much empty with no customers. Every time you go into Weber's Bakery - it's packed, that should say something right there. The white chocolate raspberry cake we order for my dad's birthday was flavorless and the cake part was so soggy from the filling. Yuck! Not to mention it was over $32 for an 8" round cake. I won't be back ever again - I should've just stuck to my Weber's! read more

It is my 2nd time tasting their cake for two separate occasions. Both were purchased by my mother-in-law and I have to say Oak Mill cakes are not good. Overall it is just a really bland and dry cake. Every time a custom made cake which was ordered by her, I only took a few bites and stopped. I'm a little flabbergasted why she loves it so much, but to each their own. Their Paçzki is pretty good though if you'd care to wait every year in February to try them. That's what saves this review from a 1 or 2 star rating. read more

Hands down best wedding cake/sweet table caterer in Chicago-land. My sister used Oak Mill ten years ago for a sweet table and cake at her wedding in Milwaukee. I hired them for my wedding a month ago in Chicago and was BLOWN away by the presentation and the quality of every single pastry. I am posting some pictures. read more

See all

They have artistic beautiful bakery here. You may pay a bit more, but worth it to me. They have exquisite beautiful paczkis here. Due to the terrible snow storm, they're was quite a bit. But I made it out there to purchase some. The texture and filings, just yummy. It was very fresh. read more

I visited this location on 4/14/20. They are still open, but customers in the store is limited to 5 people in the store at a time. You can also get curbside if you know what you want. There was no problem getting in. While I was there a woman picked up a cake. The sales associate was very clear with the woman that the cake was frozen because the store had been closed Sunday and Monday. The associate asked What time was she planning to serve it at? The associate recommended the cake would thaw by then and asked about decorating it for the customer. It seems perhaps they had read the reviews online. I picked up a couple coffee cakes, the associate explained to me what was in each since they had no labels. I like the poppyseed coffee cake, it's not as sweet as Weber's but it's a matter of taste/preference. No complaints here. read more

This was the bakery for our wedding, almost 5 years ago. We stop in every now and again for a special treat. NEVER been disappointed. I've ordered the pastry trays for parties, and get many compliments on them. Great bakery! P.S The Pear Mousse filling is to die for, if you like Pear. read more

We have special ordered cakes from here numerous times, and just walked in and bought pastries. Our experience has been that the cakes are really really good, or just plain and as some reviewers mentioned, tasteless and nothing special. The last cake we ordered we were blown away at how delicious it was, and the presentation.... just amazing. However, a few months ago, on a few occasions when I bought a cake and other miscellaneous slices they were just OK. When I bought the cake, the lady behind the counter forgot to mention that she was giving me a frozen cake, so when I arrived at a birthday party..... well let's just say we couldn't eat it or slice it. Embarrassed, I ended up going to a Jewel to purchase another cake. Overall, they do have tasty cakes and they look amazing. Before ordering, I do recommend that you purchase a slice of that cake and try it. Don't rely on the cashier's suggestion. We've tried the Ambrosia, Opera, and Forest Fruit... there have been others but I just don't recall the names. You can also ask for cakes/pastries that are not that sweet, or don't have cream, they are also very good. They are pretty expensive. But they are unique, beautiful cakes and some are certainly worth it. The 3 stars are for inconsistency. It's really really good, or just mediocre.... We will order from here again. read more

I really wanted to like their pastries because of their (past) reputation. However, if a business owner doesn't care to maintain a positive reputation and takes it for granted, it will only deteriorate. And I have a perfect example of why this place is going down hill. Today, we purchased several paczki. When we brought them home and before even biting into them, it was obvious from touching them they were few days old as they were extremely dry. For the price they charge, which is almost twice as much than other Polish bakeries or grocery stores; and the size of their paczki is half of what others are selling (for example Shop and Save on Archer Ave.), I would expect twice the quality. I am from Poland and my grandma made delicious paczki and I can distinguish fresh from old. Those were old. Never again, will I be spending my money there. read more

The only reason I'm giving this place two stars is because their cakes are decent. Other then that my experience was horrible. I got there right when it opened and had to wait an hour. I don't mind waiting an hour because it is a popular bakery. When it was my turn to order, I received the worst service. I asked for a cake and the order women with blond hair had so much attitude. I asked if she could please write happy birthday on top and she just walked off. Came back 5 minutes later, told me my total, and I left. When I came home, she wrote in horrendous writing where you couldn't even see the day in Birthday. I'm so upset with the service and the product I received that I'm not going back to this location ever again. I would rather go all the way to Des Plains! read more

Oak Mill Bakery - Crappy writing on a beautiful cake - Bakeries Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Cravings not satisfied, panckzi tasted like rose water, Mario badescu inspired I suppose

Recently went in to get a cake and I stood there for a while as employees talked to each other about their party life. I was going to walk out, but I needed a cake. So I got the cake. Paid $24. Worst tasting cake, it wasn't fresh at all. I would have went to a place in Hickory Hills, but at the time I went, they were closed, so this was the other place I could think of that was close by. read more

I've ordered several cakes here and have spent hundreds and hundreds of dollars here but after yesterday's encounter I will not be shopping here again. I asked for a cake from the display (strawberry and banana cake with white and chocolate cake) and asked for a birthday message. A simple generic happy birthday and a name. If this is a birthday cake why would writing on it be an additional fee??? Well this isn't the first time I've had such dry and rude dealings with the individuals working there. One particular girl, Agnes, stands out. She never once smiles or says thank you after any of my purchases. Keep in mind I've bought cakes here a lot for many occasions (son's birthday ($170), husband's birthday ($145), mom's birthday ($160) and just because($26-37). She bags the items and gives me my receipt (lays it on the counter not my hand) as if I have some flesh eating disease. After this I'm done with the place. I rather drive another 2 minutes and stop at Weber's where I know my money is appreciated and I'll be given a thank you! I'm not saying there cakes aren't good but what I'm saying is their customer service sucks! It's not worth my money! read more

I am 100% Polish so I know fresh pączki. I called to pre-order pączki for Fat Tuesday and was told they are no longer taking orders to come in they will have plenty. I asked my manager to pick up pączki for our employees at the Harlem and Archer location. She arrived first thing in the morning at 6:00am and was at the door as the worker turned on the lights and opened the doors. She purchased 30 pączki, spent $62 and they were all stale, tasted old!!!! I was so embarrassed. Never in my life has this happen to me with another bakery and I've been getting my staff pączki for years. They were not fresh and never again will I go to this overpriced bakery. I'm assuming the worker thought since this customer is not Polish she can get away with selling her their old pączki. On a day like Fat Tuesday I'm sure they had fresh ones ready. And to charge more than $2 per one, ridiculous!! I tried calling there to advise the manager but every time I call she isn't there. When they told me the managers name, that was the same name pronged on our receipt. read more

So, it used to be a really good bakery. Their cakes were delicious, full of flavor and unique. Not anymore! They are boring, tasteless and way OVERPRICED!!! I would not recommend this place to anybody! The only reason why they are not getting one star is because their Poznanski cake is still decent. Don't waste your money! Go somewhere else or you'll be very disappointed! read more

Don't be fooled that you can order a wedding cake. Came in to order a cake for 450+ people. They handed me a book of cakes (2-3 wedding cakes in the book) nothing I was interested in. There were sample cakes all over the bakery that were beautiful. While no one was in the store and the staff was coming up with a schedule, I stood at the counter until I got their attention. They don't make cakes at this location but I can drive to Niles or Arlington Heights to see a cake maker..... lost my business very quickly. read more

Now that I'm obsessed with yelp I've made it my mission to try new places instead of just going to the same old. Today on my way to work I stopped in here for something for breakfast. (Normally I have a smoothie in the morning but I swear my blender broke.) I thought it was an ok place when I stopped in. It wasn't exactly to my taste but it seems more European and I just think it was something I'm not used to. I wouldn't cross it off your list just yet! read more

Wow! I felt like a little kid when I walked in and looked at the display cases! The desserts all looked too good to eat! From fresh fruit tarts, to over flowing creme puffs, to miniature bite-size cakes, I felt like I was in heaven. They also offered customized cakes and a variety of torts. Oak Mill Bakery is a staple for catering to weddings and parties, but even for the ordinary get-together, there's a huge assortment to choose from to wow your guests. read more

Very delicious cakes. They were worth the price. Employees really helped me decide what is good.

We used Oak Mill for our wedding last month and loved them! Our cake was absolutely beautiful AND yummy, and the price was really reasonable. They made a 3-tier cake with ivory buttercream frosting in a gorgeous, elegant design. They had a ton of designs to choose from at the shop and the tasting was so much fun. We went with two flavors - almond cake with some sort of nut filling and white cake with rasberry. Both were delicious. Oak Mill was great to work with and makes amazing wedding cakes! read more

AMAZING BAKERY! Just look at the website to see all the pictures! just eye popping creations to suit every sweet tooth. Moist, delicious cakes, tortes and pastries - I have been to many weddings with their sweet tables... nothing is left at the end!!! Their cakes are super moist and come in a variety of flavors... not the usual pick of vanilla or chocolate and one type of butter creme... I'm talking about i.e pear cake with glaze (#1 fave!!), raspberry ganache chocolate fudge cake, black forest cherry cake, cappuccino deliciousness... and so many more. The decorations are stunning and the Polish ladies that take care of everything... phenomenal! They have more than one location as well. I recommend it!!! read more

I have always loved Oak Mill's products, so we used them for our sweet table at our wedding at the Chicago Cultural Center this past June. They worked very well with our caterer...when we arrived everything looked amazing!! This bakery REALLY KNOWS how to do a sweet table. Our wedding cake and all the sweets were delicious and we still get compliments on them. read more

Really loved the wedding cake, groom's cake (fondant corona bottle the size of a small child with red velvet inside), and my dad's birthday cake (brought them a picture; they recreated it flawlessly)! Definitely pleased with the end results!! My only minor gripe would be the communication. E-mail/phone didn't work very well so the only way to get things done was to go into the bakery. Would definitely recommend them in the future. read more

This bakery is wonderful!!The employees were very helpful we ordered our parents 60th wedding anniversay cake and it was beautiful and are guest kept commenting how delish it was read more

I had an amazing experience here with my wedding cake!!! The service was amazing and the cake was delicious!

The cakes there are really good. Really good quality. Came there after my few friends recommendation and I'll definitely come back there again! read more

Beautiful, European style cakes and pastries. Not the least expensive place for fancy cakes, but definitely worth the price...good value for what they provide. Personally, I'm a huge poppyseed cake fan...so if you're not in the mood for an over the top whipped cream cake/torte, try the cakes that are more breakfast/coffee style...very nicely done. read more