As a former Muuurylander (will always represent the state), Old Bay Cafe represents the crab area very well!! So let's start with ambiance - anyone that is looking for a beautiful, beachside dining, this ain't it!! This is a an outdoor, sit yo a$$ down, roll your sleeves up and let's get down to business crab eating, us Marylanders know very well! While you are eating outside, there is a nice shade and wind, with that 80s music rocking in the background, that will give you your "oceanside" feel. Food - so if you want a good judge of character on crab cakes, ask a Marylander. Old Bay Cafe is legit. I got a crab cake sandwich, no bread, and no filling!! Also got a crab cake melt, all of it was slamming! Oh forgot to mention i had the freshest pickle ever!! Service - the people serving this great food is, you guessed it, from Maryland themselves! They are representing the state all over the restaurant (as they should), and just overall, really laid back and nice! Will I come back here again?? Abso-feakin-lutely! If they was closer, i would be chomping down ln their cakes weekly! Try them out! read more

See all

Love love love this place. The owner is very nice, the food is beyond amazing, prices are very agreeable. Not a fancy place but still good for a relaxing meeting or casual get together or just by yourself. Place actually deserves 10 stars. read more

Absolutely delicious seafood. We are from Maryland and swear by the soft crab sandwich and love all the blue crab dishes. Unassuming place with yummy food! read more

Awesome food, great service from the owner. We will definitely be back! Try the crabcakes!

Love the crab cakes from Maryland. This OBC cafe is so authentic and the food is amazing. You've got to try the crab cakes!!!

Old Bay Cafe completely blew us away. We stopped in right after landing in Tampa, just looking for a quick local bite -- and before we even finished our meal, we were already figuring out what day we'd come back. We even joked about returning for dinner the same night. I had the fish tacos, which were fresh and perfectly seasoned. My girlfriend got the crab cake sandwich and loved it -- tons of real crab and seriously flavorful. The vibe is super laid-back with shaded picnic tables, 80s music playing, and a super friendly owner who made us feel right at home. If you're anywhere nearby, do not skip this place. It's casual, local, and absolutely worth it. read more

Old Bay Cafe - Fish tacos and the crab cake sandwich. - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

This place has been on my bucket list forever and I finally had the opportunity to stop by today. Best kept secret in town! There's a reason the crab cakes sell out. I ordered the crispy crap rolls and my husband got the famous crab cake sandwich. The service and owner is amazing! It's BYOB so bring your own alcohol and have a blast! Cool outdoor seating atmosphere. You would pass it over and over again without noticing. Come check it out! Our food was absolutely amazing. They are open Tuesday-Saturday 11:30-6pm and Sunday 11:30-4pm. read more

Old Bay Cafe - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

Had the Chesapeake Fish. Fish was good. Crab cake was great. The sides were fresh and good portions. Unless the weather is nice, get to go. Open air dining only. Friendly staff. read more

Such wonderful customer service here. We were so excited to find a place that makes a "Baltimore snowball". Safe to say that everything exceeded our expectations. A nice relaxed atmosphere with great outdoor seating. Enjoyed an authentic Maryland crab cake with the most delicious old bay kettle chips. Everyone in our group enjoyed their meal and felt pleased with this hidden gem! read more

Old Bay Cafe - Crab Cake Sandwich with kettle chips - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

See all

Small outside hole in the wall spot off the side of the road with mostly picnic bench seating. The menu is pretty limited and probably awesome for people all about seafood and old bay seasoning. I like a lot of seafood but this wasn't up my alley, just wish there were more options. What I had was pretty good- mini crab cake balls and hush puppies, they were good but not the best I've had. Others in my group had fish and chips and I noticed a lot of the batter fell off and seemed kind of messy. The service was friendly but slow, I'm sure this is due to everything being made as ordered which is good. Anything is worth a try at least once so I'd still recommend to people looking for something different. read more

The ambience, Service and food were all beyond our expectations. We will definitely go back again.

We both ordered the soup and slider combo and it was delicious! The service was great and we loved sitting outside by the water.

Love this place, not much on atmosphere but their Crabcakes are outstanding, had the potato salad as a side which was really, really good. Always make it a stop when in Florida. read more

The food was fresh and the service was great. Crab cakes taste like the ones we use to get in Maryland, The burger, shrimp and pulled pork was also a winner. read more

I fell hard for this place when it opened! Tiny shack of a kitchen, outdoor seating, no where location in front of a cow pasture- but they make da best crab cakes! This was a once a week lunch when I used to live here & my boys were addicted to the crab cakes & the crab bisque! Crab cakes- no fillers, no peppers, onions, bread crumbs... Just crab & old bay & whatever they use to hold it all together. I used to chat with the owner all the time I was such a regular! I was thrilled to grab my son and run over for an impromptu lunch! We ordered the crab cake sandwich and a bowl of the crab bisque to share and 2 lemonades- did I mention their lemonade is delicious? And very complimentary to the seafood. Service is always with a smile! And in the years I have been in Jax- they have built a roof to cover the outdoor picnic tables~ making it better to avoid that hot Florida sun. It is a BYOB if you choose. I REALLY miss eating here regularly! Locals- this is a crab cake treasure right here! read more

See all

My wife had the blue crab sandwich although it was very tasty it was also very small. I had a cheeseburger and it was a disappointment. The meat tasted like there was something mixed in with it. I thought maybe some bread to stretch the burger and make it appear larger. I know getting a cheeseburger at a place known for fish is not a good idea, not everyone is a fish lover. The service was great and the view was wonderful, I just wish that the food was better. read more

Great food and service. Best crab cakes in town! Cool theme - outdoor bench seating and a kid pool. Fun spot for lunch or weekends.

The crab cakes brought me back to my Maryland years. Ambiance isn't the best but the service and staff were excellent!

A cute little cafe right on the water in downtown Dunedin. After riding our bikes all over town, we decided to stop for a quick bite and some cold beverages. Great atmosphere, nice staff and great views. read more

See all

Very interesting, a strong "old Florida" vibe. If you like crab cake this is the place to visit, just don't expect fine dining. Seating is outdoors at picnics tables. Price seems a little high, but I'm not a crab cake lover so that may be coloring my review. read more

We enjoyed the crab cake and the price was good. Also, the server was very informative and personable.

Kitchy cute food truck-ish vibe. The crab cake was delish - not quite Maryland lumpy but the flavor was spot on and jam packed with crab meat. Did I get a bit of shell? You bet. I never trust a crab cake without a smidge. The service was excellent, the potato salad and cole slaw were some of the best I've had. The couple who run it are adorable and super attentive. It's all outdoor, picnic table dining. They also offer to go. I will definitely go back for more. Support Local businesses!!! read more

Do you like real Maryland style crab cakes? If yes, this place is a must. Having lived in the Mid-Atlantic for 30 years I can attest to the fact that these are the real deal. They have just enough bread to hold them together and enough crab to satisfy that craving. On a gorgeous spring day it's a great little outdoor eatery. read more

I've passed this place a few times while in town and finally had a chance to try it. Got their crab cake sandwich with kettle chips and was pleasantly surprised! The cake had a decent amount of crab in it while also being moist with a crunchy outside. The breading was great too and the kettle chips (which I was expecting to just be bagged chips) were made there with the right amount of oil and crunchiness you'd expect from kettle chips. Great bang for your buck for a quick lunch stop. Service was great too and the people there are easy to chat with. The location is a bit odd since it seems like it is randomly located but it's clean with plenty of seating. It is outside only with no fans from what I recall which makes it a bit muggy during Florida summers. Would definitely come again! read more

Old Bay Cafe - Softshell Crab Cake Sandwich and kettle chips - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

I grew up in Maryland. When I visit a seafood restaurant that mentions Maryland, 99% of the time I wonder if they even know where Maryland IS. Hubs says 'just don't order it, you'll be disappointed', I don't listen, and I often am. But sometimes, not too often, but sometimes.....they get it right. And THIS is one of those places. I put them to a test, too..... three items, infamous in Maryland and tough to recreate if you are just following a recipe. Crab Soup, Crab Cake, and a Softshell Crab Sandwich. Soup first, brought out first. Absolutely perfect. The right blend of crab and veggies - AND the correct veggies. The consistency of v8 juice, not a broth, not a chowder. Nice BIG pieces of crab. Nailed it. Onto the soft shell - OBC serves it on a roll - I like toast. They accommodated, and got it exactly right. Crispy legs, meaty body, and the size - oh my! Soft shells can be pretty small - this one was a biggie! Lettuce, tomato, Mayo. No weird aioli, chili lime drizzle or other ridiculous accompaniment. Served with their Old Bay handmade potato chips - it was if I was sitting on the edge of the Chesapeake Bay. Finally. the Crabcake. This is a tough one. The best crab cakes are made with backfin crabmeat, cost upwards of $20 (each) - and that's when crabmeat is local. OBC's crab cake is not backfin. And not every restaurants in Baltimore is either. Cost prohibitive! OBC's is very, very good. Crab, and enough 'filler' (meaning almost none). The correct kiss of Old Bay Seasoning - enough for a kick, not enough to overpower the taste of crab. Deep fried to perfection. Again, just served with plain accompaniments. The deal is to taste the crab. And you do. Overall, probably the BEST Maryland seafood I've had outside of Maryland. Ever. In a parking lot in Trinity. Who'd a thunk it? I'll be going back today for a shrimp salad sandwich. Oh, it's a 26 mile drive from my Air BnB. Don't care, it's closer than the 590 miles to Bawl'moor! read more

See all

I really wanted to like this place as the reviews were great . I had the softshell crab sandwich that was soaked in grease . See pics . There's a pool of grease in the container . The crab cake balls were very good . They were served with stale crackers which I didn't understand . The cream of crab soup . Well the girl who works there said both soups were good but she combines them . Which I would recommend as the cream of crab was straight cream of mushroom or whatever with old bay on top . It needs a lot of work . read more

Old Bay Cafe - The greasiest softshell crab sandwich ever . It was inedible. That's a pool of grease in the corner of the tray . - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

It had been awhile since my last update on our tour of Florida. Highly recommend Old Bay Cafe, it is full of character and a total hole in the wall location, complete with an outdoor port-a-potty (don't worry they have running water to wash your hands) lol The crab was amazingly fresh and crab cakes were awesome. Inexpensive and good food! What else can you ask for. read more

Old Bay Cafe - Lovely spot for lunch - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

So good! Outside only. No liquor license. Had the crab cake sandwich with red skin potato salad served with a crunchy dill. The sandwich and service are worthy of the 5 star rating I gave. I am a really tough judge of crab cakes and I have no complaints at all about this sandwich. Ripe tomato slice, lettuce, good bun and you pick your condiment. It was delicious! A lot of choices on the menu including soft shell crabs. Not fancy and I have driven by a lot. No curb appeal but they are deserving of the voted best crab cake sandwich by tbt! read more

Been coming here for 10 years whenever I have an itch for a good crabcake sandwich or soft shell crab sandwich. People working the window are always friendly and the food is always good. Today was a beautiful afternoon sitting out on their picnic benche and enjoying the 70° Florida winter. read more

See all

Great crab cakes, coleslaw, and hush puppies. Outdoor restaurant. Seating under shade. No alcohol sales, but you can bring your own. Friendly staff. Great prices. Child's menu. Don't let their appearance fool you. Well worth the visit. read more

Best crab cakes around, friendly staff. Being from the northeast I appreciate a good Maryland crab cake.

Horrible Mac n cheese ball and cheese sauce: cardboard bland waste of calories! Horrible service: I bought crab cake and the Mac n cheese balls. Crab cake is okay, not the best, some shells, be careful. I took one bite of the Mac n cheese ball and knew this was absolutely not worth eating even if I'm starving, I told the owner I did not like it and he tells me "I can't resell the one you tasted but I can refund the second one"! Like seriously! You are not allowed by law to resell it! I had to walk away and didn't even collect my refund.. I don't act out in public but wow I was close to it and it takes a lot to push my little button. He was rude and just disgusting. I will never ever return! Every time I drive by, I flinch. Not worth it. read more

Old Bay Cafe - Horrible Mac n cheese ball: cardboard bland waste of calories! - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Just had lunch at Old Bay Cafe in Trinity, FL & felt like I was back in Maryland with the food. Marty & Channel thanks for an amazing lunch! The food was so incredible I had to get a crab cake & shrimp salad burrito to bring home for dinner! Channel gave us such cheerful and accommodating service while Marty made us one of the best meals I've had while in FL. Crab cake was a massive 5 oz all lump crab cake- broiled perfectly on the outside. And they are right when they say they don't fake the cake! My husband had the old bay tenders with homemade old bay potatoe chips. He was raving after every bite! We are looking forward to this becoming our new Saturday lunch spot! I couldn't believe how cheap the prices were for such quality food! 10/10 must try spot!! If you are a former native Marylander or just a local that loves great food this is a must go! Kudos to Marty & Channel! Thank you, Ashlee & Mike Tennant read more

See all

Okay, today we did our Old Bay Cafe taste test. Oh man this lunch was awesome!! Crab cake sandwich 10/10, kettle chips 10/10, hush puppies 10/10, crab soup 10/10. Old Bay Cafe on Little Road, you will not be disappointed . I highly recommend it. read more

Old Bay Cafe - Today we tried OBC's crab cake sandwich with homemade kettle chips. I also tried the hush puppies and their crab chowder. - Seafood Near Me - New Port Richey, Florida

Are you from Maryland? If not, then just come here and understand that this is the best crab cake that you'll have ever have in your entire life. Not just that, but the rest of their food is really good as well. I came here with my Dad and we ordered the crab bisque soup (excellent), the shrimp (amazing), and a crab cake (outstanding). For sides, we got the kettle chips, cole slaw, and beans. Everything was absolutely outstanding and I can't say enough about their food. The service was friendly, and there wasn't anyone else here so we got served very quickly. Now... if you *ARE* from Maryland... well, this place isn't as good as *your* place. But let's be honest- NO PLACE will *ever* be as good as *YOUR* place. You know the one- the one you always eat at but never tell anyone about because you don't want it getting crowded. The place that makes your favorite cake. Yeah... that place. OBC won't be as good as *THAT* place, but it'll definitely scratch the itch, and that's really as good as you can get. read more

Looking for a quick spot for lunch and found this nice indiscreet restaurant and was very impressed! Excellent fish sandwich...batter on filet was so crispy. Also has seafood quesadillas and fish tacos which we all great. Extremely reasonable prices given the quality of the food so would high recommend! read more

See all

This is a gem of a spot. Great crab cake sandwich, hush puppies spot on. Will be going back many times

Not impressed with the crab cakes. My neighbor said she loved the food but I wasn't impressed with the crab cakes at all. I'm spoiled by the crab cakes at Sam's on the beach in Hudson. I'm going to have to disagree with my neighbors Crab Cake choices. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. We called ahead TWICE (two different days) and heard the message saying they were open certain hours. We drove over there TWICE only to find them closed! Infuriating! At least change your phone message if things change for you. I don't trust you and you've lost a potential customer. I've heard you're moving into the basement area of Widow Fletchers. Good luck. I will not be patronizing you. You can't treat your customers like this and expect to attract new ones. read more

Love the crab cakes and outdoor seating. Also love their Mac n cheese, burrito with crab cake, quesadilla, etc.