I ordered a large pepperoni. Should have taken a picture right away but see the attached. Half the pizza and 8 slices of pepperoni. Disappointed as they seem to be cutting corners by a lot. Still delicious but basically a cheese pizza that costs more read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - A bit over half a large pepperoni pan pizza with 8 pieces of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

These days it's hard to get a pizza the way you want it. Old Chicago still consistently gives you pizza they way you want it , with a fresh taste, and great service! If you haven't been in a while go back and rediscover pizza the way you love it! Don't order a pizza delivered, go I. For the experience! read more

The 1 remaining OCP in Colorado Springs is a good one. The grilled chicken Caesar salad is a great starter to share. And we usually get a Chicago 7 pizza with hand tossed crust. Both are always good and the service is good too. read more

No service. Sat down and ate cold food about an hour later. Many people around us had drinks and food before we even had beverages. No apologies or acknowledgement. Piss poor! read more

Came in looking for some good pizza, but left a bit disappointed. The restaurant is open and bright. The service was great, our server as well as the others were very friendly and helpful. The beers we ordered were very good. The pizza itself was a miss. We ordered our pizza with the chicago thick crust as recommended by our server - The flavors were really good, however it was undercooked and quite doughy in the middle. The dessert brownie/ice cream was decent, but nothing to write home about. We do plan to come back in the future to try the pizza again, but perhaps on a different crust and are hopeful it will be much better. read more

How can you screw up a simple personal pizza food order for pickup? "Never entered into the sytem", Are you freakin kidding me? read more

I'm a regular at old Chicago. We order the cauliflower crust pizza consistently, and it's consistently excellent. Service is great, the waitress knows what we like and takes care of us on weeknights. We love this place and appreciate the people that were here. read more

My experience was immaculate. Went around 10:30pm and the service was great. The food was absolutely fire. I got a pizza and it honestly was probably one of the best pizzas I have ever received from anywhere. Music was great, the time was great and the pricing was great! Will definitely be back read more

It's my first time back at this location in 12 1/2 years since I moved away. I was back in town for a week for a funeral so I had to hit up Old C's so my husband and kids could try it. The pizzas were excellent and the leftovers reheated great as always we devoured the pepperoni rolls which are still the absolute best thing ever and we even ordered two more orders of them DoorDash two days later to our Airbnb the night before we left to come home. read more

Just had a luncheon for 30 people . We had one server to take all the orders. Restaurant was notified in advance and did not hire any additional servers. 3 hours later people were finally able to pay their checks. Some orders were mixed up or incomplete. This group goes to lunch monthly. We will cross this off the list. Poor management! Let me emphasize this was not the server's fault and we all still tipped him well. I noticed there were other people not part of our group that the server also had to take care of--poor kid! At one point a woman came out to help. She may have been the manager. Food was okay, not great. read more

We go to Old Chicago because in our opinion they have the best pizza. The service is also good & consistent!

almost every single time I come into the store I ordered the same thing a salad and they mess it up in the back all the time. I don't know if you have little kids running the store and running the front but it's ridiculous and you guys asked for ridiculous prices for nothing and we can't even get what we paid for or extra is it that hard for you guys to make a salad? If so, why do you guys offer it? read more

One of the worst restaurants I've ever been too. Service was slow and inattentive, food was just bad. We got the "Italian nachos" that were advertised as "pasta chips" but were actually wontons and the toppings we sparse and poorly distributed. We also got the "buffalo chicken rolls" but couldn't find any chicken in them at all. We told the bartender we disliked the nachos in particular and she just said "sorry" and charged us for our untouched plate. One visit was enough forever. I'm honestly amazed they have customers at all read more

Light & walls around the booth were super filthy. Food way under par. The coleslaw was super gross visibly & the taste. We will not return to this Old Chicago any time soon. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Lights & the walls in the booth were super filthy. Food was way under par. Will not go back any time soon.. - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

See all

This place used to be the place to go. Sad to see OC has gone downhill so much. Super slow service. No lunch menu. Menu is not what OC used to have. People in charge should get different work. We will NEVER come back. read more

The last three times I've ordered pick up either they completely mess up my order or it's 30 minutes past the pickup window. For instance today they gave me a completely different burger than what I ordered and I didn't know until I got home. The service is very poor. Almost every time I come in, I wait 5-10 minutes until someone helps me. I have on two occasions went to the bar and asked them if they could go get someone to help me. I understand they may be understaffed, but it's always something every single time I order here. read more

old Chicago Pizza on Timberline has reached the bottom. Glacially slow service, cold/rock hard pizza with a tiny amount of bland sauce, a lump of unmelted cheese in the center, very few ingredients and whole olives that rolled off the crust when served. This was Monday night 1/6/25 about 5:30 pm. not terribly busy. I nearly broke my front teeth on the crust. paid $42 for large thin (not) crust 3 ingredient pizza and two light beers. There was no one around to give feedback and ask for refund. Skip this place. read more

This is what the management felt was good enough to feed its customers. Your food will die in the window. It's gross everywhere. The manager James Martin also seeked me out on Facebook messenger and threatened litigation on me. Probably should get that under control, please. read more

See all

Old Chicago has been a local favorite for as long as I can remember. Chicago 7 pizza and calzones, hot wings, burgers and beer. It has been hit or miss the last few years, but I must say, the quality and freshness of the pizza and salad I ordered tonight was really good and reminded me of Old Chicago as it used to be. Our pizza (and salad) tonight tasted so good and fresh! It's the Old C that I remember! Only...remember trying to get a table around 5:30-6 on a Friday night and the wait was crazy? Not so tonight...lots of open tables. Go ahead and give them a try or another chance! read more

better to not eat than eat here Definitely order from this place if you enjoy raw dough. The calzones and pizza rolls have been raw in places every time I've attempted dinner from this place. Raw dough is a food safety hazard, I don't understand how they are allowed to sell this as ready to eat. The pizza in the photo looked so awful I didn't even test to see if it was raw. But this is what you can expect from a double deckeroni add canadian bacon personal size with "tavern thin" crust. Price tag $15.68 on doordash. embarrassing. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - A garbage pizza - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

Absolutely horrible service. We waited for over 30 minutes and our waiter never came to take our order after dropping off waters. We saw him multiple times and he just ignored us. Asked for a manager and when we explained why we were leaving. He just said oh sorry. He didn't care at all. Will never go back. We wrote a complaint to corporate and they never even got back to us. They obviously do not care about their quality of service. Sad because Old Chicago used to be amazing. read more

They did a great job for us. They were able to accommodate 25 people, same day. In addition, I made a last minute change to an hour and a half earlier and they still were able to accommodate our entire large party. Servers were friendly, manager was helping out with orders and drinks, just an overall great experience. Food was good as well. I was really impressed. I hadn't been to an OC in years, but this particular location really came through for my daughter's softball team and parents! Thanks! read more

So it's not great but not horrible. Definitely overpriced. You can get better flavor and same size from a pizza hut. I'm not sure why chicago is in the name. The only Chicago place is giordanos. Luckily there's one in loveland. The chicken wings are a bit overpriced in my opinion too but they tasted pretty good. It looked very good. As my pictures show, but meh in value/flavor. read more

See all

I typically don't leave reviews for establishments but this experience was truly amazing, I came in to get a couple of drinks and some dinner and got seated with Dylan. Dylan gave an absolutely amazing experience. the food was excellent and I will definitely be returning. read more

Cannot get a pizza with the cheese fully cooked! So gross! Even asked for extra crispy because the cooks are so bad! Still under cooked pizza! I'm done read more

Terrible service. Waited an hour for food and only got part of order. Waited another half hour for rest of food. Pizza was not cooked thoroughly not eatable Wait staff walked by several times and even the manager but never approached our table to see if we had been helped or to take our order read more

Old Chicago used to have good pizza. Since Covid, the quality of food has dramatically decreased. I ordered a pizza for pick up. In the order I asked for the pizza to be well done. Not only was it not well done, but the crust so was light it was barely cooked. Also, when I order toppings, I expect them to be spread around the pizza. Not dropped in one spot. Feels like they just don't care any more. Very disappointed. read more

Great place next to Home2! Gluten friendly options! Friendly staff! I see some reviews that confuse me and everyone needs to realize this industry was crushed by the global pandemic. Please don't forget to tip your servers and bartenders! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Huge beer selection! Lots of TVs! - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

Well, another old favorite down the tubes. It's so sad. Been coming for so long, but no more. Party of 6, waited forever and was served cold food. The chicken parm filets were overcooked and were somewhat recognizeable as frozen stuff from the grocery store. Garlic bread was as thin as paper and about the size of a Ritz cracker. Hambuger buns not toasted, hardly, they felt like they were recently taken out of the freezer. Used to be a quality place with reliably good food. We did not complain to the waitstaff, they have no cotrol over a shitty kitchen. Goodbye read more

Excellent choice during our short stay in Fort Collins! Incredible pizza, kids options, garlic bread and spaghetti! Outstanding environment! Staff was super friendly and great with kids! read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Amazing pizza! Great environment and wonderful service! Very kid friendly! - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

I was delivering and I said the name to the host, they repeated the correct name back and still somehow handed me the wrong order. This put my own job jeopardy. read more

Please fix the Air Conditioning! Or give away free cold beer! The food is what it is here but the temp is unbearable. read more

I have gone here for many years but last night we had the large Chicago 7 pizza. $28 !! And hardly any toppings as you can see. I hate to be mean during this tough time. Ladies working hard at the place all nice people etc. pizza not good sorry to say. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

If I could add zero stars, I would I ordered a chicken burger for pick up when I got home. One burger was very crispy and one was very black. I would not recommend coming here. Food was not good. read more

5 stars for the bartenders and the atmosphere they create. We go to Old C's pretty often because it's close to our house and the bartenders always remember us and they take good care of us. The beer selection is good and some of the bartenders even remember what we drink. We were going a lot during football too because the bar is a really good size and they have a lot of big TVs. However, I hate to say I'd give 1 star for the food. Every single time we order food, I get sick 2-12 hours later. My boyfriend has been sick a few times after eating here too. They don't always do the best on their health department inspections and I feel that might have something to do with it after reading the full reports of their inspections. Overall, we will definitely keep going to have some drinks at the bar because that part of the experience is great. But, we won't be ordering food anymore. read more

What happened to Old C's? This place used to be great. Now I can't believe they are still in business. Our food was absolutely disgusting. I'm nauseous thinking about it. The bathroom smelled like it had never been cleaned. I will never go back with all of the other options in the area. I would give zero stars if I could. read more

I got a large pizza and tall wings. It is overpriced and bland, I am very disappointed.

Wow. Went there for take out. Ordered a chicken avocado chicken salad....at $14 you would think I would get more than a upturned King Sooper's bag of mixed greens ....with MAYBE 2 Oz of torn up chicken pieces with 6 nickel size chunks of avocado. Oh, but they DID include a ping pong ball size chunk of romaine lettuce core.....so I guess I should be thankful ‍ ..... what a rip off ! I guess all Old C's is only good for is their long list of beers and pizza. I advise to forego the rest. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Pizza Near Me - FORT COLLINS, Colorado

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooöooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo good In all seriousness though the costumer service was fine and the food was not good read more

Came mid afternoon on Mother's Day. Wasn't busy at all. Server was super friendly. Food, pizza club sandwiches and nachos) were great. I love love the nachos. We stayed a while just enjoying being together. The friendly low keyed atmosphere made it very relaxed and fun. Great place to go read more