Surprisingly great space. Food was typical bar food, but the service was very slow. I would go back. read more

See all

Great potential. Yet, this is the 2nd time we have visited (over ~3 years) and each visit we have encountered HUGE cock roaches.. 1st time was at a high top and it was running on the floor. 2nd visit - we were at the bar and it came up from behind the bar and ran close to us. read more

We had wrapped up a class in the area on a Friday at 6 p.m. and wanted to grab dinner in Fayetteville before heading home. We had eaten here before once or twice probably 5 years ago, but we wanted to check it out again. Parking is on-street nearby. There seemed to be plenty of spaces around the courthouse across the street. They normally have parking around back, but the lot is currently being used for construction staging. We were greeted as we entered and advised that we could sit anywhere. They were about 3/4 full, but we saw a table up front so we took that. Our server advised us that this would be where the live band would be setting up about 45 minutes to an hour later, and she asked if we'd mind being moved it our dinner overlapped with the band. We said no. There seemed to be a fair percentage of 'regulars' here, maybe for the music. They space is a standard bar arrangement. The bar takes up much of the right side, with tables down the center and booths along the left wall. The decor seemed to be seasonal, and had changed from Valentine's Day to Mardi Gras when we were there. They got our drink orders. My wife got a Po Boy (catfish). I opted for a burger. They offered fried okra as a side, which I recalled from the last time we ate here. I was glad that had not changed. The food was pretty good. The wine pour seemed small, though. We managed to finish before we got evicted from the table. Prices seemed average. If you are in the area, this place is worth stopping in. read more

Went here for lunch with a small work group. The smell of bleach smacked you in the face as you entered the establishment. Several of us had issues into the night with symptoms of inhaling bleach fumes. Maybe they don't know there's a ratio of water/bleach when cleaning? The Caesar salads were awful. I have never had a salad with minced lettuce. There were a lot of what looked like store-bought croutons, but they had a slightly rancid taste like they were expired. The kicker was the bowl of chili that arrived with the lid to a can in it. The server made a little joke about it. No apologies offered. I'm not sure how this place is still open. read more

I have driven past this place 2 billion times and have never stopped in. This rainy, Saturday night me & my date wandered in. There was a very small crowd enjoying the entertainment of a live band. We found a waitress (Liz) who gave us the lay of the land & pointed us to a table. We came for the food but ended up getting a whole experience. This place reminded me of that show Cheers. I felt like everyone knew everyone & we felt welcomed. The food was excellent. Boom, boom, pow shrimp appetizer was really good & so was my fish & chips. The fish was fried 2 perfection & the batter had to be seasoned. Plus, this place was open late. I think they close at 1:00 a.m. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Mediocre hole in the wall bar food. Nothing special. Server did her best but they were clearly short staffed.

I was in the middle of eating my meal and a cockroach ran off my table up my arm so i went and told the manager and he tried to bribe me not to tell anyone after that as i was walking back to the table another cockroach ran out from in under someone else's table read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

Cristie is the best!!! She is so kind and customer service is fire! Great prices, dope vibe and awesome regulars too. The chef is super kind and food is delicious! Get that Tavern Pretzel! It's amazing! read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - The bar is so laidback and this pretzel are amazing!! - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Had the very best fried boom boom shrimp and jalapeños. We love this tavern and all the folks that work there! Cristie is the absolute best. read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - Boom boom pow shrimp and fried jalapeños. - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Walked here from hotel. Cute inside bar area and music playing. Our server was Christy- very patient and friendly. The blue cheese chips and fried pickles were tasty and we enjoyed. One of our group had the hot dog and said it was really good and the fries were really good. We also tried the Reuben. This was not my favorite- the corn beef was somewhat fatty. We ended with the beignets and they were really yummy. Great selection of beers as well. read more

See all

We are from out of town and we're looking for a fun, local treat. This place had great atmosphere and friendly wait staff. The food was terrific and we enjoyed the drink selection. Would recommend and come back again if we ever come back in the area! I had the corned beef Reuben - delicious! read more

So I'm very picky on who I give five stars to but the tavern is legit, I ate here for months, sometimes multiple times a week, the presentation of the food was spectacular and I wish I had pictures to show it, the environment is very hole in the wall bar with the old locals and worn brick and old wooden bar but the food is nothing short of a restaurant you should need reservations for, the alcohol was always served right along with orders and I can not complain about anything with this place, waiters were perfect and always there if you needed something, if you're in Fayetteville, you MUST check out this place, it doesn't get the respect or recognition it deserves. Steaks were cooked perfectly, sweet potato tots, fried pickles with some special batter I've never tasted like before, NOLA potato salad, Salads packing flavor, this is the place to be if you want good food and drinks in Fayetteville or surrounding areas. read more

If you want a good burger this is the place ! cooked great to order . I hate they changed the french fried they use to had texas cut big fries .... yummy now they have the small crust ones . The service is ok and the pub is just what it is a neighborhood tavern....good if you drink beer also ...it has a bar you can sit at.... read more

Music Sat and Fri What is this Garth w 95,000 peeps Lower that noise please !! The band is okay but 30db Lower we we can hear each other NUFF SAID read more

See all

Food arrived cold. The lettuce on the salad ($10) was wilted and not eatable, so we threw it away. The chicken on the chicken sandwich ($14) was so overcooked it was like a piece of solid rubber, and I ended up throwing it away. So that left 2 "loaded" baked potatoes which were very small and only included a couple of crumbles of bacon, a small amount of cheese (size of a quarter) and a small container of sour cream (each being $10). Also left on our order were 2 "large" (as ordered) sides of mashed potatoes that were a small circular container in the same footprint as a soda can, just not as tall (each side was $6). This was definitely not a meal worth $73, which was our total with Grubhub+. We won't be ordering from here again. read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - Cancellation Reason - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

The food is good the atmosphere is dull, and the owner is a total JERK! After my recent visit which was worth my husband who had done some work for the owner.... We dropped by to pick up a check for the repairs my husband had done. The owner has given us the run around for over a month. I finally printed out the invoice and took it to him placed it directly in his hand. Nothing.... Don't do business with this guy and you'll thank me.... read more

Nice local pub. Lots of activities in the evening like 'regular' bingo. Food was fine but usual pub grub.

Great music with Ray McCafferty and friend on Wednesday nights! If you get these sweet potato fries, you may want their sauce left off or on the side. It's very sweet. The service can be really slow when they're busy, with only one waitress, and one cook. read more

Really good food! Had a chili dog, it was delicious. Drinks were really good. We happened to come to the tavern, when they were having live music, Jazz was rocking the rafters after 8 pm. read more

gumbo was horrible, but what should i expect, for bar food. overall it an ok place, don't think ill try again

If you're every in the Fayetteville, Riverdale area definitely come check this place out. Fun good food and Hella good drinks read more

See all

My sister has been coming to this spot and she decided to invite me, and love the vibe and the live music. I ordered the black and blue burger and I was amazed by the taste and the presentation, the food was lovely and I will come back again. read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - Black and Bleu Burger - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Old style bar... old school for sure. Met some really nice older gentlemen there. I don't live in the area, but if I'm back in this parts.. I'II stop by again... ps.. bartender is a hottie... just sayin'.. read more

Perhaps their food is OK in person, but I wouldn't recommend ordering via Grubhub. We ordered: Fried Green Tomatoes (soggy, inedible) Pow Pow Shrimp (not terrible, ate most of it) Steak Quesadilla (not bad at all) Blue Wedge Salad (good) French Onion Soup (a gross gluey potato soup showed up instead) read more

This is such a neat little place with a good bar, good service, and good food. Highly recommend stopping in, if you're in the area.

We walked in about an Hour before close durning the live music night, we were very calm and walked in and sat at one of the booths. something I've done before, and the old lady, assuming she could have been the manger, was incredibly rude to us. She first looked us all up and down then shook her head at the cash register to her bartender. Her tone was condescending and rude to us. She first yelled at us the we better be 21 or we can leave, we are all 22- 25, then when my friend brought out her passport, as she is in town for work, she rudely asked 'is it valid' then proceeded to tell us all we can only have one drink each in a rude tone. When my friend said yes it is was a uncomfortable laugh she proceeded to yell at her "is that funny? I have one too! I go to France!" Like it is a flex or something. We proceeded to get up and leave and she yelled "Ha Ha Bye!!!" At us, clearly proud of her behavior. Truly a shame as the bar has been in Fayetteville for years and my family has gone on several occasions as I was born and raised here and the owner, bless his heart, is a friend of my moms. Very disappointed in this experience. read more

Let me tell you: this place saved the day! We were riding around trying to find a place that was serving hot food and drinks and we stumbled upon this place. I'm not gone lie: I didn't know how me and my friend would fit in at this business because we were the only black couple there, but as soon as we entered we were greeted by the owner/manager maybe and the beautiful bartender Allie. I instantly felt welcomed and she informed us because we came in 40 minutes prior to them closing that they were only serving wings and fries (which was up my ally) and we ordered a 20 piece with fries. The food arrived shortly after our drinks and man, it was hot and delicious! We were so quiet eating and drinking omg and they also have a sister restaurant/bar across the street which we will try this weekend. And to end the meal, she made a green tea drink which was great! They just don't know they made me a customer for life! Thanks Allie! read more

See all

Worst food ever. Service is only for people drinking at the bar. Absolutely no ambiance. Just being honest. Would not eat here again.

Great local place. Good food. They have an awesome Ruben Sandwich on the menu. Great wings. Great burgers. The Head Bartender ALLY is just a dream. awesome place! read more

If you're visiting the area this is a great spot. My first time in was a HOOT! Mixing it up with other travelers and locals alike. I came back another night and it wasn't the same vibe. Just saying if it's not your thing the first time give it another shot. read more

Wow! This is the worst place I have been to in a while. First off, old, sticky menus with peeling-curling corners given to us. The place was cold inside and very uncomfortable for eating. I ordered a sandwich and it was pathetic. Notice the two thin pieces of corned beef! It was not on rye bread and had American cheese on it! WTH! I sent it back. It was beyond disgusting. The waitress was nice, but the nasty owner had the nerve to come out as we left and glare right at me instead of apologizing and saying he hoped we would give his shitty establishment another try he chose to be as nasty as his pathetic sandwich! YUCK, stay away from this dirty place! Side note, my husbands burger was burnt black! He ordered medium! Shitty food...... shittier owner! It is a watering hole, don't eat there! read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

This place should be shut down. The kitchen is infested with roaches and they serve expired food. I watched with my own eyes a cook serve a burger that was dropped on the kitchen floor. There's no way this place would pass an inspection. By far the worst restaurant in Fayetteville read more

The burgers are great. The fish is also fire. Definitely a goto for some food. The atmosphere is awesome. read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

Good bar food, but not a gourmet meal. Be careful of beer's price, and not cold. On the other hand nice waiter, good environment, awesome music. read more

I really wanted to love, love, love this place, but sadly it fell short. My husband and I went for brunch on Saturday. The setting is lovely, quaint and inviting. We sat outside and they allowed us to bring our dog, which is always very nice. The hostess greeting us was friendly and seated us quickly, the service was excellent, but where the Old Courthouse Tavern fell short was on the food. My sandwich was decent, I had the Seaside Catch on focaccia (instead of hoagie/too much bread). the grouper was tasty and it was warm. The focaccia, however, was cold a bit stiff and dry (it was not the kind of sandwich you sink your teeth into). It really brought the sandwich experience down a few notches. I think they could put some butter on the bread and toast it on the flat top to warm it up and awaken the flavor. My husband and the other couple we sat with ordered the eggs Benedict. Sadly, this is where the brunch fell flat. By the time the eggs got to our table, the eggs, hollandaise sauce and everything underneath were cold. Cold eggs are the worst. My husband and friends ate theirs, but the overall feedback, when we got back in the car was that it was underwhelming and we probably will not do brunch again. The food had a institutional look to the plating, like the plates are sitting on a table and the food gets put on them and not much love to go with it. I guess the amount of food they prepare has to be pre-cooked, so the warming up of items is kind of lost. It just wasn't the kind of experience we were hoping for. Now, having said that, the restaurant is lovely. I think we will try it again and do a dinner next time. Overall, the place is clean, the service was excellent, but the food left us out in the cold. read more

You can always expect good food and friendly service. The few times I had any problems with what I ordered it was very small and they went out of their way to make up for it. The drinks are wonderful if they don't have what you're looking for they can whip something up for you. Everyone's very friendly. The fried jalapeño are AMAZING. The only thing I've ever had issues with is the noise. Gets really loud but as long as you're prepared for that you're good to go read more

Most disgusting place to eat for sure. It's not cleaned properly or ran by health code standards. Barely passed. Has big roaches crawling around. One actually got on me while trying to have dinner. From my understanding it's sinking and sinking fast due to the way it's ran and the lack of care put into it. read more

I am so happy to have a place like this out in Fayetteville. It is such a great bar. They consistently reinvent their drinks for the season and they always have something good up their sleeve. This is a true bar. The seating at the tables has always been a little tight but I guess it fits in with the tavern feel. When its warm out you can eat on a small back patio and they often have live music every time I have stopped in to pick up food for take out. So about the actual food. Their fries are the true thick steak fries. They are so yummy and fried to perfection. They also have sweet potato tots if that's what you prefer. Their fish and chips are good but even more basic on the menu they have a giant hot dog and fries. Its really good. I recommend ordering a side of Mac & Cheese to round out the order. So far I have not tried anything that I don't like. I can only say that one time I went and the Mac & Cheese tasted less fresh. Also...I think u can def take kids between 4-10 here during the day but prob leave them at home once it gets a little later. I haven't been for any of their weekday events in the evening but will share when I do. read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - Peaches on Fire to the left and Peach Martini on the right. - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

If you're gonna be racist maybe try to make up for it with decent food and service. We used to eat lunch in here now and then because it was close to work. Damn near every time something wasn't available on the menu. Or just generally not very good. And on pretty much every visit we were forgotten about or just not a priority. Fine whatever. But the owner of this joint apparently hates freedom of speech and tried to have peaceful protesters arrested for being on the sidewalk. Protesters who were accompanied by the police by the way. I'm guessing he doesn't like the subject of the protest and that "the old courthouse" is civil war old. Take from this what you will. But if you're in the area there's a Twisted Taco and Gremlin Growler where your money would be better spent. read more

I love this place! They are the sweetest and the food is amazing! This was on my to go box. I'm keeping it forever! read more

Old Courthouse Tavern - I love this place! This was drawn on my to go box. If you are lucky enough to find yourself in this place, you will be treated like royalty - New American Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia