Find out for yourself why this place has had great success with their marinated steaks since 1956! Dark wood inside, fireplace always crackling, comfy booths, and an old school bar. Service is always attentive & informative. Every item on the menu hits the mark for everything you hope it to be. I can never get over their Old Bay Fries or their perfect burger. I dream about this place. (Please bring back the Banana Old Fashioned!!) Parking next to the railroad. read more

Old Fields - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

Went here for my boyfriend's birthday dinner. Ambience is so cozy and well designed. We had shrimp cocktail and arancini to start- both delicious, the Cacio e Pepe sauce for the arancini was new and very good but it definitely is not a light app. For dinner I had the beef and goat cheese salad- not super filling but lots of beets and pecans which I enjoyed a lot. My boyfriend loves the skirt steak here and the mashed potatoes were amazing so 10/10 there. The food came out quickly and our waitress was pretty prompt with service. Overall great dinner and excited to try other dishes next time read more

See all

I love this hidden gem in port Jefferson. It is wheel chair accessible with bathrooms too! The food is amazing and the staff went above and beyond to make our night special!! I love the cozy fireplace on cold damp nights. The bar is fun and lively! read more

Local spot that is cozy, warm, and always a good meal. I came here with my book club and they were gracious enough to give us individual checks, which I know is such a pain for places to do, and it was much appreciated. I had a clam and chorizo appetizer which was very tasty, then the fish and chips for my entree. I've had the fish and chips here before, but this time was a miss. The breading was still wet and not fried through, so that was disappointing, but everyone else enjoyed their meals. For dessert I had a brownie sundae which was super delicious. Definitely will be back soon! read more

Old Fields - Reach for the beach - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Great atmosphere. Cozy setting. Good service. Tasty burgers and fish n chips! Portions were generous and hot!

Perfect stop for a cozy winter dinner. We sat in the bar area. Nice fireplace, friendly service, great food, great music. Can't go wrong. Caesar salad is a must. read more

See all

Good old neighborhood meeting place with fine dining to cozy comfort food by the fire. Great place into spend with our family and friends on a cold rainy night. Cocktails and dinner were awesome, as always over the years! read more

See all

Stopped in here one day. Loved the ambiance, the friendly wait staff. My waitress was extremely knowledgeable and knew all the specials and details of the specials off the top of her head. Good was great. I would definitely recommend the Bulgogi Popcorn Chicken. It had nice kick to it and was extra crispy. It is an appetizer but the portion size is for a full meal. If I am ever in the area again I would definitely revisit. read more

Old Fields - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Good food! Service for is always good. We shared the buttermilk battered calamari- wuich was excellent. Then we split and order of fish and chips that wss perfectly done. Fries had coating so they were extra crunchy. Drinks were very good, house white wine and an old fashioned that my husband said was perfect. We will be back, this is one of my favorites.z ill need a marinated steak before too long. If you havent tried one- make sure you do. read more

We got a booth table and just soaked inthe vintage decor, think 1959. We loved it and we felt right at home. Our server was attentive and we had the special that night which were really good. Plated beauty and tasted delicious. They let us take our time it's a busy place. We will be back soon . read more

See all

If you're looking for the quintessential 1970s-style steakhouse with a roaring fireplace (it's gas but looks wood-burning), Old Fields will make you happy. To be clear, as one would suspect, you won't be thrilled with the food if you are a vegetarian. Yes, there's an option and it's a housemade burger but it's not to my liking. Apparently they used to have a really good cauliflower steak but it's no longer on the menu. It's disappointing, however, my time spent in the bar portion of the restaurant made up for it in droves! After we finished dinner (while the back room is slightly less atmospheric, it has cozy booths), we moved up to the bar and fireplace area. In front of the fireplace is a long table and we were lucky to grab seats and enjoy drinks for the rest of the night. This is all I ever want in a bar, honestly. I'll definitely come back for the bar after eating elsewhere. But if you do eat steak or seafood, you will be happy here because my friends all loved their food. read more

Been here many times for both lunch and dinner and have never been disappointed. Portions are large and well cooked, service is attentive, atmosphere is cozy and the restaurant is very well kept and clean. My only negative comment is that it is a bit pricey for what it is but if you do not mind shelling out $22.95 for a burger at lunchtime you'll love it here read more

See all

This place committed the mortal sin of sitting us down, ignoring us for 15 minutes, then taking care of a people who came in after us. We walked right out. Good thing - they're overpriced anyway. Got served immediately right down the street at a better establishment. Don't bother with this place. read more

I cannot heap enough praise on their marinated skirt steak! It's tender, flavorful, and is served with a fantastic creamy horseradish sauce. I'm also a big fan of their wedge salad. I will admit that I was thrown off at first by seeing BBQ sauce as part of the salad but it works brilliantly. read more

Best restaurant in greenlawn. Yall are the best...but variety is the spice of life and it's been over a year since you've added new items to the menu. It used to change with the season but not any more. Also, yall need to try some actual korean food and reevaluate your bulgogi popcorn chicken. Still love yall. Best oysters on the island. read more

Excellent main courses, excellent service. Very rustic interior that takes you back in time. More approachable than other steakhouses. I will be going back soon read more

first time family ate here. when we walked in there were 3 hostess girls. the one who sat us wearing jeans with pearls on them was great. however the shortest girl who was was black pants with white stripes was not friendly at all. she was looking up and down at my daughter and the other hostess with the pearls on her jeans needed to tell her to stop what she was doing. Short hostess was rude in her body language . food was good. our waitress was pleasant. the ambiance was nice however needs a tad more lighting . make a smidge brighter . even though the food was good we will not ever eat here again for the way my daughter and myself was treated by the short hostess. walking in and dealing with this was very unprofessional. for that alone speaks volume. hire girls that are friendly and not intimidated by another beautiful person. Linda read more

Date night yesterday! My boyfriend got the bacon burger and fries, I got the Filet Mignon. We shared a marshmallow graham cracker brownie sundae. Our server was wonderful! I think her name was Julia R, she said she had been working there for 2 years now. Definitely showed! She was so likable and extremely friendly, even on a Saturday night! Originally wanted to pay with apple pay, she said we couldn't, then she said we actually could. She said she didn't know we could use apple pay. It was no big deal, we all laughed about it. She was sweet and gave my boyfriend and I good service (usually restaurants don't expect us to tip well because we're in high school). Wish we could've tipped Julia more, hopefully the $20 was good! read more

Old Fields is as classic and comfortable as a warm sweater, and the food is impeccable. I love the old-school tavern vibe, and the steaks are out of this world. When I first went this year with my wife and friends, I had the Flatiron steak with original 1956 marinade. I enjoyed a solo dinner recently by the fireplace, and wanted to try one of the other steaks, and the knowledgeable waiter recommended the marinated skirt steak, which was so good I finished every last bite. The fried pickles, mashed potatoes and creamed spinach are amazing too. Cocktails are terrific, I've had a strong and gorgeous Manhattan, and an exemplary bourbon and prosecco cocktail whose name escapes me. Anyway, Old Fields is wonderful. read more

See all

So for years I've driven past Old Fields and never stopped in and that was a mistake!! What a great meal we had to celebrate our 20th Anniversary. From the second we walked in I LOVED the ambiance, the old tavern feel and the cocktails were delicious. Staff was outstanding as was the starter...we entree was delicious and the portions were more then enough on everything. We've been missing out and now we know.... read more

See all

Old Fields is always amazing! I never Have any complaints about this restaurant. The food is always fresh and delicious and the drinks are very good! Definitely try out Old Fields is you love BBQ! read more

Just great food and such a cozy spot. Always ny a good go to spot for burger steak or fish

Customer service at old fields is spot on from the bartender Ron to the hostess at the front desk! Came in on a Saturday evening and was seated immediately! Why the 3 stars it's basically my critical critique on the food. To start off the old fashion made by Ron the bartender was simply Devine would highly recommend it. We ordered 1. Oyster 1/2 doz : was good as expected 2. Beet and goat cheese : The candied pecans or walnuts was the star of the dish - the beets tasted as if they were picked and not roasted fresh (tiny cubes) - odd assembly- combined taste good 3. Porkchop: I really wanted to like this dish but it was not cooked to expectations - the meat was a bit undercooked in some areas and the rest was a bit dry - again the overall taste was good- too much greens on top made the porkchop soggy. 4. Flat iron: now this was made perfectly ! Taste was amazing no sauce needed ! Juicy and cooked to perfection(med-rare) I would highly recommend this dish. We will try this place again with different items on the menu! See you soon read more

See all

What a fantastic night out! Once inside, you get such a cozy feel! Small bar area but plenty of seating in this restaurant. We made our way to a booth and our waitress was awesome! We started off with wine and mango jalapeño margaritas! Sooooo good! My friends and I also started with French onion soup- one is the bests I've ever had!!!! My friend raves about the skirt steak but I went with the buttermilk fried chicken.... it did not disappoint! The breading on the chicken was crispy and flavorful while the chicken was so moist! The street corn is fabulous and the mashed potatoes were devoured! I opted for the mac and cheese instead of coleslaw and I was so happy I did! I have leftovers for tomorrow and I can't wait haha! We ended our meal with a s'mores brownie dessert to share. I cannot wait to go back!!!!! read more

See all

We eat here often. Food is very good. Menu could use some lighter options, almost everything is very heavy, and for those who want to eat a bit lighter you are limited to 1 or 2 appetizers. Service is always great, attentive and frielndly. Ambiance is great. Don't really love the back room, acoustics aren't great and it's a bit bright but the bar area and front room are great! read more

The menu had a great balance of classic favorites and innovative dishes. We particularly enjoyed the Old Fields Burger, which was a delightful blend of flavors that left our taste buds dancing. The portion sizes were just right, allowing us to savor each bite without feeling overly stuffed. To top off our evening, the dessert menu was a sweet indulgence. Norman and I shared the Irish Coffee, and it was the perfect ending to a perfect meal. The presentation was impeccable, and the flavors were a symphony of sweetness. Overall, our experience at Old Fields was nothing short of exceptional. We appreciate the effort the staff put into creating a welcoming environment for guests of all ages, especially those in their golden years. From the delicious food to the attentive service, every aspect of our visit was deserving of four stars. As one example, my husband really loves trains, and when we got there, right there on our table was a placemat with a train on it!! We'll surely be returning and recommending this gem to our friends looking for a charming dining experience. Cheers to Old Fields for making our night memorable! read more

I have to say since writing the last review they really stepped up there game. The chicken parm was one of the best I ever had . The salmon was perfectly cooked. Wait staff was great. Glad we went back and we will be reg customers with food this good. Would give this trip 6 stars if I could . read more

We were a party of four that wanted a Sunday Dinner. The parking is adequate behind the building. We arrived around two. The brunch crowd was pretty much gone. The menu has a number of dinner dishes besides the brunch menu. The waitress got our drink orders in while we pondered the appetizer. The fried Popcorn Chicken was very good. The fried Calamari was good. Old Field's is a very casual restaurant on a Sunday afternoon. They do not have the entire dinner menu. Mashed potatoes are only available at 5PM. All in all we had a pleasant few hours with friends. read more

I can't say enough good things about the original Old Fields! Owners Christine and Dave have created a great local restaurant with a wonderful and very competent staff that serve polished and sophisticated dishes along with traditional favorites in an atmosphere that draws us back almost weekly. I almost don't want to post this review so as to keep this gem to ourselves - but the word is out and we'll deserved: Old Fields is a special treat! read more

A visit to Old Fields must start with some well spent time at the bar. This is where libations help conversations start spontaneously. I chose the Sweetwater Mosaic Single Hop Hazy IPA, Lisa E. Went with the Voodoo Ranger Topical Paradise from the short but relevant tap menu. At the table, Lisa suggested and I agreed to devour the Pork Osso Buco with spatzle, butternut squash and a nice demi glacé. Burnished and unctuous, fork tender meat melding nicely with the sauced spatzle (alternate version of a Bolognese sauce). Went so harmoniously with a well crafted Negroni. The din in the dining room was at first deafening, but as the night went on mellowed in synch with the mood. read more

See all

A very good foodie pub with a very tasty selection. A bit pricey for the rustic setting but the entrees are very good as is the service. The place is small and they don't take reservations, so it fills to capacity very quickly. We've enjoyed some good times there and I'll definitely continue to visit. read more

I haven't been to Old Fields before but been passing it for years. We went on a Saturday night at around 7:00 PM. We ordered fried calamari to start, and each had steaks. My drinks were the margarita and an espresso martini. We split creme brûlée for dessert. It's a nice place to go on a date, but there were definitely people around with their whole family. The service was nice and friendly. read more

Old Fields - Espresso Martini - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Oldfields is an institution in the town of Greenlawn. Walking into this establishment you feel like you're stepping back into time when things were more simple. The bar was packed so we snagged a table next to the fireplace. If in Greenlawn, you should definitely check out this gem. read more

Old Fields - Special ribeye steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Greenlawn, New York

See all

Quality of food has dropped some especially since it opened. Portions have gotten smaller. Decent if you want something real quick.

Found the menu limited to bar style food at a overpriced value. Service was slow. Ordered French onion soup that was just ok. The fish and chips were also ok nothing special. Hamburger looked ok. The surprise of the meal is that a bug appeared on the wall as we were finishing our meal. Noise level was loud so if you like a quiet place To dine in. Forget about it. Ps wife went to the restroom and reported that the toilets were overflowing and backed up. I'll pass on returning. read more

Tried old field again , disappointed They still charge extra if you get a drink on the rocks , really $17 for ice and a shot If I got soda with my drink. It's not extra The burger was good but not as ordered , I settled Tired of sending food back I go out to eat foods that I can't make at home , don't over cook my order... simple read more

Food, drinks and service were amazing! Loved their bloody Mary's and spicy Margarita! The baked Brie and Mac and cheese were delicious! Would definitely come back! Price is reasonable! read more

See all

The food is good we just had one bad experience the waitress forgot about our food and by the time we got it my husband's salmon was hard on top read more

I had a great meal at Old Fields after a series of disappointing meals. I started with a PERFECT "filthy dirty martini" which was stuffed with blue cheese olives. My husband and I shared the burrata appetizer which was served with tomatoes, basil, and champagne vinaigrette. While we waited for our main courses, we were served a delicous corn chowder in a small teacup. Nice touch! As my entree, I had the short rib risotto which was amazing. The short rib was super tender ane the risotto was packed with mushrooms and truffle flavor. It was a large portino as well. We ended our meal with a brownie sundae. Yum! read more

See all

Located by the train tracks - the inside decor is charming and warm and inviting... Always great cheerful staff and great tasting food! We go back often. read more