I've been to this establishment a few times and tonight was my first time in a long time since COVID hit. The female bartender with the black hair was having a loud conversation with a couple at the bar and being very disrespectful and racist towards me and making other patrons turn around to look at me while I was having dinner with my fiancé. I'm disgusted and won't be back. My fiancé had a conversation with the manager whom I feel sorry for because he wasn't around when she started spewing her hateful words. I refuse to stoop to her level tonight because she's not worth a minute of my time. We are not on the same level! The food was great though was considering celebrating my birthday here but after tonight absolutely not. read more

GREAT food and GREAT drinks!!! Me and the gals ‍ went in Thursday night for some cocktails , burgers , and pizza and wow!!!! SOO GOOD!! It was only our first time there but we will DEFINITELY be returning ;))) read more

Pizza was super good. Service was alright, but there were 12 of us and they should have tackled the situation a little bit better. Other than that, I liked the place and would definitely go back to try some other things on the menu. They had this cranberry cider that I had to order two of...I'm curious about the cocktails, they looked intriguing and probably taste the same. They have outdoor seating and when the sun is setting, the lighting is amazing. And it was a church once, so PREACH. read more

Love the decor. Sat outside on a beautiful nite. Service was prompt and courteous. Portobello burger and meatloaf wrapped in bacon were delish. Will definitely be back. read more

We were a party of 5 adults first time visit. Seated right away. Order taken and drinks came out fast. My wife and granddaughters pizza and Mac n Cheese balls came out first. Two out of the five were still frozen inside. Thirty mins later 2 more dishes (Catfish $20 ok, Chicken Alfredo w linguini $20 was dried out from sitting under heat lamp for 30 mins) came out. I had to ask about my overpriced chicken parm hero ($18) which finally came out. Discombobulated kitchen service for sure. Food was ok but the only thing that is a bang for your buck is the pizza. Everything else on the menu is ridiculously overpriced for the dining atmosphere and the poor kitchen delivery. Outside has the unique church look but inside and outside tables are like sitting at a boardwalk eatery. Won't be back. read more

Rustic decorations? Yes, please!! Their pizza is one of the best in town. From the moment you step in you feel relaxed. They have entertainers during the week and the dim lighting outside makes it more relaxing. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

The menu has many choices on it but I noticed that the food is very bland. It seems like they don't use seasoning which makes the food ultimately tasteless. I had to ask for side sauces for my meatloaf, mash potato and chicken and even with the sauce it lacked any real flavor. I was very disappointed considering the meal appeared to be a nice portion. Also, I feel they should advertise their happy hour and drink specials. I asked the waiter if they had anything special and he just handed me the menu when really there was some special on the beer and pies. Kind of annoying read more

This is usually a great spot to go out to eat.I don't know what happened to this place but on our most recent visit there was bird poop on the outside seats and tables.The inside tables were all sticky and the beers all came warm.Had to leave read more

Inattentive waiter. Ribs were undercooked. Had to ask another staff member to bring them back to the kitchen because our waiter never came to check on us. read more

We had a good time at Old Glory. The food and service were good and we enjoyed the vibe.

Okay been here a few times now my buddy and my self passed it on a fluke on ours motorcycles and stopped in and fell in love with it. From the decor to the kegs as urnals which is pretty rad by the way!!! We have been making it almost a weekly thing to come by for a beer ! Great selection. Also the wings are awesome, that's my favorite on the menu. Love also how it has a huge out door and second floor outdoor... all in all great waitstaff and bartender and good food !!! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Great food & service a few blocks from the water!! The outside bar is the perfect setting a few steps from the water!

Wow. I wasn't sure how the food was going to be. I am pleased. The arugula salad is crazy good. The braised short ribs are tasty too.

Kinda disappointed..first the 2 hostesses are rude. Guess they don't like they're jobs. Once seated things were good. Our table was by the bar so the bartender was our waiter. He was very nice. They were out of every choice I wanted so I had to settle on a dish lol. It was good but not what I was craving. We sat outside and it was a nice atmosphere. read more

Decent prices. Food was good. It is tough to mess up a hamburger and fries. Their milkshake was a really good size. Although it suffers an identity crisis. It is in what appears to be an old church converted into a restaurant. While the theme of the restaurant is based off of the 13 colonies and other United States history. Overall, decent American food and decent atmosphere. Would recommend. read more

Cool restaurant, set in an old church. Rustic feel with modern touches. And community sitting at 6 top tables downstairs. Upstairs was closed, so can't say about that. Plus, it looks like they have a fairly large outside set up for the warmer weather. Food was really good. The bread they start you off with is probably the best I have ever tried. Then the crab dip as a starter. Solid, but didnt blow my mind. Served in a bread bowl, so big plus. And staying with our carb theme, we ordered a pizza as a main course, which we split. Got the buffalo chicken. Really good! And it has diced celery on it, which I enjoyed. We initially wanted to do half and half, but they can't do it for the specialty pies. No worries. We'll be back for more. read more

See all

Overpriced, food is kind of bland, the service is no customer friend and it tends to be more like a bar/meat market.

"Old Glory has been our go to spot since we moved to the area two and a half years ago. They have an amazing staff that treats you like family and the food and drinks are always on point. We want to personally thank Jaclyn for an absolutely amazing job on helping us set up a 50th birthday party. We couldn't have asked for any better. Every one of our friends had a great time. I'm sure you just got many new customers. Food and drinks were perfect!" Also our bartenders Ryan & Liz were amazing as always!! read more

See all

Old Glory doesn't disappoint. I love the meatloaf and my wife loves the shrimp kabobs.

Clueless management. Made a reservation 1 week in advance for 6 at 6:30pm on a Thursday night, not Friday, not Saturday, and when we showed up not only did they have our table ready but we were told there was an hour wait. We finally got notified that our table was ready at a few minutes before 8pm. So unorganized. Why do you keep giving walk ins tables right away while people that made reservations in advance are made to wait hours? read more

This is a nice place that the service is always great. The comfort of dining is why I knocked off a few stars: the last few times I've been here it is very warm (they have ceiling fans but it is still hot -garage doors were closed). It is also bench seating, so you can never lean back. Again, as long as you know this then you're good to go with comfort. Food wise: definitely try the crab sandwich, buffalo wings, and the pizzas. Very good! We tried the crab dip recently and it was overwhelmingly seasoned with Old Bay. I think our friend liked it but she may have been being polite. read more

Nice atmosphere and the food is awesome! The jalapeño dip and the cheese burger egg rolls are a fav!!

First time- great ambience. Great specials, easy to understand why they are popular. Good size menu, I had the fish & chips- large portion of fish- He had the burger. Both were wonderful- read more

They accommodated our party of 9 and we were so pleased with the service and the food. Try the buffalo wings- excellent. We had the crab cakes, short ribs, baby back ribs, meatloaf and pizza. All were very good. Fun atmosphere- Definitely coming back. read more

Amazing food and excellent service. Love this place! They were packed as usual but nothing suffered. We had an event there the night before that was awesome. I can't say enough good things about this restaurant. read more

See all

If I could give this place a 0 I would. Such a shame that the management is so terrible. Enjoyed the food but never again. Clearly the manager is on some type of power trip. Decides to kick someone out because they do not like them personally. I witnessed the whole thing. Owners should be ashamed and embarrassed to have hired someone like this. Manager REFUSED to speak to the individuals. Do not give this place your time or hard earned money. Such a shame. read more

We had a small sprinkle for our upcoming baby at Old Glory and have to say that it was managed so perfectly! We sat in the upstairs section which comfortably seated 25 of our guests. The brunch package was not only plenty, but so delicious! Everyone raved over the Chicken Milanese. Jaclyn (coordinator) was so easy going to work with - I felt very comfortable nothing was last minute and all organizing was well done. When we arrived, I was greeted by Sheridan who was so sweet and on her game! All of my guests complimented how attentive she was - and we ordered a lot of Mimosas/Bloody Mary's ;) I would recommend OG for a bridal/baby shower or even for a casual lunch to everyone! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Excellent food and atmosphere. Staff is very friendly and attentive. My husband and I had an early lunch at the bar and the food was really good. There were many options on the happy hour menu with food and drinks. The bartender was very nice and had asked us if we ever been there before. We said no it was our first time. She then told us about the happy hour specials they had from 11:30-4p and asked if we wanted some bread. The bread was so good. It was a loaf of bread with parmesan cheese on top and baked in a brick oven. It also came with an oil with fresh rosemary in it for dipping. We ordered the OG buffalo wings. They came with crumbles of bleu cheese plus a bleu cheese dressing that was tasty. We also shared the cheeseburger eggrolls. They were so good! It came with a cheesy sauce with shredded lettuce, red onion and tomatoes on the side of the plate to add. It was everything I liked on a burger in an eggroll. Great appetizer to have with drinks at the bar. The hard cider on tap was very good. Also noticed some gluten free items on the menu. Highly recommend and will definitely be back. read more

See all

Food is great. Vibes are better but WTF is this non-cash adjustment on my receipt. This is absurd. Owner charges a percentage for not using cash. Never seen before read more

Decently priced pub/restaurant. We've never had an issue grabbing a table. I've been a few times, each time on Saturday's where I'm sure they can get very busy but we've always been seated quickly. Servers are friendly and the menu is full of different options. I've gotten bar pies with a side of marinara with no complaints VRBO wings are good as well. Pitchers of sangria are available too if you're in the mood to share, it to keep to yourself. Next time I go, I'd like to visit in the warmer part of the year so I can sit outside. read more

Great pub, food, and service. Love the American flag on the ceiling of the second floor. Oh, and Megan the bartender is awesome!

I am done with this place. I've dined in and picked up dozens of times but the food is always cold and the staff is rude. I've reached the end with them today, when a pickup was 30 minutes longer than their estimate and the girl running the window gave me an attitude. read more

Good drink menu and great food menu! Service is solid and cozy ambiance. Been there several times and will return!

Great food- garden state salad is the best! Most servers are great! Love the inside/outside choice!

Service was very good - friendly and prompt. Food was tasty but very small servings. Had the Cajun Catfish which was tasty but hardly enough to use as bait. Brocolli was okay but, again, not much of it. Rice Pilaf was bland with nothing added (carrots, peas, etc.) and took up most of the plate. read more

Good service!! Great food!! Atmosphere is so awesome... feel like everyone is family!! We love old glory read more

Food and atmosphere are good. However they just started charging $5 for all credit card transactions called a "non-cash adjust." Greedy business practice that will deter me from coming back. read more

Super chill place. We sat outside (when it was nearly 100) and it was fine as it was well shaded. My fiancee and I got the cheeseburger egg rolls were good. I got the buffalo chicken pizza and it was good. She got a crab cake burger and was pretty good as well. Our waiter was attentive without being too over bearing. As for the beers, they have a pretty good selection but make sure you remember what you got...you may be drinking a cream ale when it should be an IPA. read more

Looking for a dog friendly restaurant in Keyport. We had our husky with us and sat outside. There were many other dogs there already. We ordered summer glory and mojito blue as our cocktail. The mojito blue was a little light in my opinion, so I switched to beer for my second drink. We had drunken clams and buffalo chicken wings as appetizer - they were both great! The buffalo wings were spicy though!! For entrees, we had seafood pie pizza and smoke house chicken sandwich. The seafood pizza was just ok, but chicken sandwich was good. For dessert, we had classic shake and chocolate lava cake. The shake is huge!! We like this place and definitely will come back again! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Seafood Pie - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Great atmosphere, great food. This is a wonderful place to explore so many great dishes. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Great experience, im.watching my carbs but the bread....omg! Make sure u come. - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey