We've been to Old Mill for dinner many many times! This is the first time we enjoyed Sunday brunch! Super busy and super full! There were 12 people waiting for seats while we were leaving! I knew we ordered correctly when the table next to ours all ordered some form of eggs Benedict! We enjoyed our chicken fried steak Benny with white gravy and biscuit and also the California Benny! Yummy! read more

See all

My family and I went up to this area to look at the water and the lights for the holidays. It was a great little historic place. We loved checking out all the photos and decor from the old mill. We got some fish and chips, a burger, and I got a brie and ham sandwich. Staff was very nice with quick service. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

Service was excellent. The ambiance is v very country. Since this was my first time here, I was only able to order breakfast. I had a half order of there country Benedict. The sausage, egg, and English muffin were done perfect. However I felt the gravy was a little runny and lacked flavor. The potatoes were also really good. I'll definitely be back to try there prime rib on Friday and will update then. read more

We had the chance to have a late lunch at the Old Mill yesterday and loved it, including the numerous locals that stopped by our table to meet Pippi as they allow dogs on their deck! We found the staff attentive, food plentiful and tasty and the prices reasonable! The Gobbler and their Cobb Salads were perfect for a slightly warm day!!!! read more

Excellent food great service, we love eating there!!! I love their lunch menu the most because it's hard to find a good place to have lunch!

Cute little spot for a hearty meal in what appears to be a nice neighborhood. Service was good and the food was good.

Amazing, friendly customer service with even more amazing food! Small town family run restaurant. We went back twice in three days. This place is a must! read more

Wanted to try IldMull Cafe, but must have been been a bad day for them, didn't look busy, 45 minutes to get served, small mediocre seafood salad for $28, burger very average. read more

We went for a early dinner at five pm There were only four couples in the restaurant. We ordered one cob salad and a bowl of corn chowder. After thirty minutes, I complained to the waitress. She said we were being taken care of in good time. Food was served five minutes later. Cob salad was ok but the the so called corn chowder was nothing but white bean soup with a few kernels of corn. Who puts beans in a corn chowder? VERY DISAPPOINTED and will not go back. read more

Outside tables were pretty sticky. Had to request a wipe down. Bird poop along railing. Friendly staff and served relatively quick. Wife had the salmon, which was very good. I had prime rib. Meat cooked well and to desired medium rare. However, had a good amount of grizzle. I can understand, with price of beef, that restaurants are struggling to keep up quality while maintaining a fair price, but quality of cut was subpar. (Another patron I spoke to in parking lot had same complaint). We both had excellent desserts, which pulled this review up to 3. read more

The menu and food is so good...that I checked out at the counter and forgot my computer at the patio table where we were also allowed to have our dog - Phineas! Honestly, both of our lunches were exceptional, the server and the service were great. We were on a six week summer vacation visiting many restaurants and arriving from Victoria Canada, at this cool cafe. We drove off to Palm Springs bragging about the food and service and realized three hours later, no computer...But Manager Savanna and her wonderful team went - way out of their way - to arrange for my computer to be sent to my home. Now that's Class and America at its best! Thanks, Savanna! read more

Old Mill Cafe - Dog friendly cool country cafe! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

We had been wanting to stop into this cute little cafe for a while and the timing was never right-'to think of all times o could have had the BEST fish and chips ever! I kick myself. We both ordered the fish and chips (3 generous portions of cod) and it did not disappoint. The fish is dipped into a tempura batter that is light and crispy in a delicate way that does not over power the fish. The waffle cut fries and seasoning was so good! A stand out star was the coleslaw that is dressed for each order so it's crunchy and fresh (anyone who loves coleslaw knows this is a pro move ). We would have loved to order dessert but we were stuffed! Highly recommend! Ambiance is casual and our server Megan was a Delight!! read more

Old Mill Cafe - Fish and chips - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

Old Mill Cafe is a staple in town that I waited forever and a day to try. Sent with a good old fashioned burger loaded with blue cheese and bacon along with some waffle fries. Burger was juicy and fries were crispy. Everyone in our party was satisfied. Service was quick and friendly for a large party of 7. Great place to hold meetings or for family gatherings or outings if you are looking to eat out in the town or on the road if you are heading to Forks or Lake Crescent. Ambiance is small town cozy antique hunting vibes. There are fun things to peek at throughout the restaurant on the walls and along the hallways. I've heard the prime rib is outstanding. Will be back for that one day. read more

See all

I was expecting more than what I experience. First of all , I didn't knew that I had to make reservations to dine in (which was not on their website). I came from 3 hours away and by the time I got there they told me I have to wait 30 minutes because I didn't call to reserve a table. After 30 minutes of waiting the lady told me I had to wait another 30 minutes because there was no space, after waiting for almost 1 hour I approached the person in charge pointing that there was several empty booths, which she replied by saying that they were reserved . I have to mention that no one sat in those booths for a couple hours.. I pretty much wait for an hour and a half. Don't get me started on the food, I order steak, mash, broccoli and that meal was the smallest meal I had for the amount of $60. Can you believe it for the small steak. Steak has flavor but just really dry. Mash potatoes is really bland and also was the broccoli. Don't waste your time going here, it isn't worth it. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Steak, mash, broccoli - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

From the family-like service to the food.... AMAZING! We were suggested to go to Oak Table from family and friends after we raved about Old Mill.... NO, THANK YOU!!!! The food and ambience was Waaaaaay.... Better!!! Will ALWAYS go back when in town. Thanks for the amazing food and service! read more

Salt! Lots and lots of salt. Way too much salt. Which is strange, as there were salt shakers on the table. Maybe the chef hasn't been told we have been provided with salt shakers? And most of us know how to use them. Our entire table is Googling "how to get sodium out of your system quickly ", since we are all suffering in our own way. I would loved to have enjoyed the flavor of my $23.00 hamburger, but couldn't tell what it tasted like because of the overdose of salt. We would love to go back and give their hamburger another try, without the salt, and see what they taste like. read more

amazing food and amazing staff. Ate here during our honeymoon and loved it. :) the staff gave us places to go and information on the town and location. so fun. read more

Great food, great service, and reasonable prices, this place is a home run. The onion rings are worth the trip.

This place is nasty. Last time I went my table was so sticky and had sugar ants crawling all over my table and food plate. Will not be back.

We hoped to go here for dinner yet due to time constraints and scheduling, we went for breakfast as either way we wanted to ensure a visit. The interior is fun, with lots of nods to a former logging mill and the logging culture of the area. The food is homestyle cooking with menu items like biscuits and gravy. There was some confusion over what one of us ordered, as two menu items are slightly similar - the chicken fried steak and the chicken fried cubed steak sandwich. We had order one but got the other. That was fine. Everyone enjoyed their food - the breakfast potatoes in particular were crisp and yummy. Service with a smile. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

Great food, excellent service. Lovely atmosphere they were very accommodating of my very very busy young children!

Had the BLTCA ( bacon lettuce tomato cheddar avocado ) it was amazing!! For dessert I had the gluten free chocolate torte & it was delicious. I'm definitely coming back, thankyou! read more

Old Mill Cafe - BLTCA sandwich & torte - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

Great place to have breakfast. Large portions are nice, you won't go away still hungry. The service was very friendly. Ambiance was great, lot of history in the place. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Biscuit and gravy, poached egg and breakfast potatoes. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

See all

We went there on Thursday because it was highly recommended and so close to home, with my sisters from out of town, my daughter burger was rare, and so was the kids burger, the fish was not done, and the same fish was put back in the fryer, , crab sandwich tasted old, 2 of them, could that finish them, really disappointing read more

Stopped through I. Town for the weekend. Food was good and the ambiance was good as well. Small town eats are usually satisfying and this didn't disappoint. We ordered Chicken tenders and the Philly Dip. I'd recommend this place to anyone. read more

We loved this place, we have tried really hard to support them. They just seem to keep making things worse. They can't seem to get out of their own way. The owner Savannah needs to actually start working there and perhaps with some outside consulting help, new menu, cut prices significantly. This place should be booked whenever there open, unfortunately they have alienated most of there customer base. Prime Rib is there Friday and Saturday special. A little over priced but convenient. So I was going to meet a buddy of mine down there for dinner. We both wanted Prime Rib. Apparently he got there before I did and calls me and says let's meet at Traylor's half way to PA didn't really want to drive that far but okay. So here is where the rubber hits the road. So apparently Old Mill had a message on there specials board that they were already sold out of Prime Rib, really? at 4:30PM? On Friday? Turns out they sold all the Prime Rib to a party, well so much for loyalty to their clients, in both directions they apparently don't care about their regular customers. Now Traylors has a very generous 12oz Prime Rib or $30.99 this includes salad, loaded potatoes, vegetables. Old Mill you get less and it's $6.00 more. Traylors would never ganyk there customers for some party. I like the people at Old Mill but pricing for what you get is ridiculous. There Seafood Linguine which is noodles crème and some seafood is ridiculously priced. Unfortunately, it feels like they will either fold or sell to someone else. They truly need to drop prices by 25% to 40% provide more food, expand their menu and start having more consistent service and quality. Personally I know how hard it is to run a restaurant but for their pricing you would expect more than Denny's level cooking. Sometimes they do a better than basic, but no consistency. I'm sorry, we are done with Old Mill they have slid downhill and you have no idea what you will get. Traylor's offer A family environment. Black Bear kinda Denny's like but better menu, and unfortunately better and more consistent service. Mariner and Elk not exotic menus all have all over better service. I apologize for the lengthy diatribe. Just so disappointed in Old Mill they have hot pretty much the bottom of the list read more

We Love this place. Great service and great food! Bring you appetite, large portions.

The food was really good, the employees are extremely well versed in all what's on the menu. Plus the restaurant itself is like something out of the past! If I tell you what then it won't be a surprise! read more

Not the same great little place we were used to! We took an out of town guest here for a festive birthday dinner, based on our past stellar dining experiences at this unique restaurant. We were sadly disappointed. The halibut special was mediocre, at best, being overcooked, very small serving, and with tired, limp vegetables. My seafood platter came with very soggy tempura cod and jumbo shrimp (usually my favorite!) There was no lemon, overcooked waffle fries and seemingly no effort on the cook's part for appetizing presentation. The previous lovely pre-dinner delicious bread basket was missing. The wine was a very skimpy $11.00 per glass. Sadly, we will not be using this restaurant as our go-to festive celebration spot in the future. read more

Great staff, delicious food & a relaxed atmosphere!! Always live to see what the chef's special is!!

We have been to the Old Mill Cafe many times over the years, which was always good, but wanted to post a review after the last couple of visits, as it was great! We typically go there for breakfast and have had a variety of their dishes - the cakes are big, light and fluffy, and the link sausage was cooked perfectly. My Wife had the benedict and it looked delicious. This is a fun place to go, with great staff and good food, surrounded by old logging memorabilia and pictures showing how the area grew up. read more

Very homey, Cute kitschy stop known for great breakfasts! We stopped in to try lunch. They have indoor and outdoor seating and plenty of bric a brac and historical photos ect to keep you busy while you wait. It gets busy here even though it appears off the beaten path, located between Sequim and Port Angeles. A good variety of foods are offered. Lunch specials and creative cocktails were a surprise to read on the menu here. Allow time for lunch, it is not fast however, every thing we had was very tasty, homemade and it is a relaxing place for a meal. I look forward to try their berry margarita that I read about someday. Definitely a destination worth the drive over here! read more

Old Mill Cafe - Outside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

See all

Had hamburger with GF bun & sweet potato waffle fries... was amazing. Granddaughter had chicken strips... was real chicken, really appreciated the extra cherries in her Shirley Temple. The homemade pies are amazing... Lemon/lavender cheese cake was a big hit! Heard new owners a year ago... they really are working hard! read more

The best breakfast I have ever had. I have no idea how they took a basic, standard breakfast and made it taste as incredible as they did, but I'm SO sad I visited here while on vacation and it isn't in my hometown so I can go back any time I want. The pancakes had such a robust and rich flavor with a syrup that complemented rather than overwhelmed them. The ham was fantastic, and a large serving. Everything here was amazing and probably our favorite food stop throughout our entire trip! The location was also diligent about COVID precautions, which I loved. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

I found the Old Mill Cafe! I found Carlsborg for that matter. Perched next to a four-room motel and across the street from a Fishermen's Supply store kinda between Sequim and Dungeness is the newly redone and reopened Old Mill Cafe. The front is inviting with outdoor seating under purple flour baskets and the inside manages to be fresh and clean while tipping its hat to the past with a dramatic mural and some horns from elk or deer (hey, I'm new here!) The staff immediately invite you in with warmth and a smile, like the aunt you have that's still nice...not the cranky one. I know what you're thinking. Diner! Guy Fiery eating something deep fried at a counter, etc. Nope! The Old Mill has excellent food that's creative and perhaps even upscale without the snooty part. There is a bona-fide chef, by any standards that you can put up against Gary Danko or Saison in San Francisco...one who would leave Michael Chiarello and Bobby Flay holding each other to reassure themselves everything is going to be okay after tasting the quality of the ingredients and creativity of his food. I asked my server, Heather, to drive for me and she ordered my entree and brought me free soup. Okay, admittedly everyone gets free soup or salad. The soup was a tomato bisque with smoked gouda. Suspended in fresh tomato puree and herbs were chunks of fresh fire-roasted tomatoes and roasted red peppers. So I didn't get an attitude, it came with a packet of Saltines. The entree was fresh seafood fettuccine absolutely drowning in the best of Northwest seafood. Am I talking about leftover salmon from the morning salmon Benedict offering? No! In the bowl with a light sauce I'm pretty sure had white wine, garlic, clam juice and a dash of cream were fresh clams still in their shells, bay shrimp as well as prawns. The taste was fresh and great! But wait! As I dug down, I found a generous amount of lump Dungeness Crab meat! I have no doubt their desserts are great, but I just couldn't do it after eating all that fresh seafood. So, visitors from culinary spots that are perhaps better known, put the attitude aside and enjoy a great meal with friendly people. And eat your Saltines! read more

See all

Four stars for vegan black bean burger They make it in-house but they originally told us they did not have it. When we told him we came all the way from Kirkland Washington they found a burger for us. It did have mayo and they told me it was vegan mayo. The vegan cheese they supposedly had turned out they did not have it. :( The vegetarian sandwich was a big disappointment - The bread was completely dry. We had agreed they would put vegan mayo. Obviously mustard but nothing. It was supposed to be toasted sourdough bread I'm not really sure that's what it was. There was only a tiny bit of avocado. I would recommend they put cucumbers in there the small sweet peppers just kept falling out. It was really a big disappointment. It's so easy to make a great vegetarian or vegan sandwich. They need to go back to the kitchen in this one. How about making a vegan chickpea salad and putting that into the sandwich? He would have protein and it would be fantastic. Take a look at what they do at El avocado in La Jolla. Fantastic chickpea Saad sandwich that even non plant eaters like. My husband was going to order the cinnamon apple scone that was to be served warm and was the only dessert they made and house besides the marionberry pie. Don't get your hopes up after we ordered it we were told they did not have it. They have some nice seating outside. Service was hit or miss. Really liked the gal with the sparkly mask. The other server must have been having a bad day. read more

See all

This was my first time at this establishment. The interior is very rustic and historical. This was a mill in its day. We were greeted at once when we entered. We were seated by our very friendly waitress, Meghan. The service throughout our meal was outstanding, professional and courteous. The menu was explained and questions answered. We were there for the Sunday brunch. The food was delivered fast as was outstanding. The portions were nice. The biscuits and gravy was great. This establishment has many dishes to include burgers and more for lunch. They also have an outstanding dinner menu that includes everything from steak, Prime rib and even pasta. The food is freshly prepared. Some might say that the price is a bit pricey. I don't see it that way at all for the quality a d quality that you get. I would recommend this restaurant. read more

Old Mill Cafe - Lumberjack omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington

See all

Been here a few times. Always great food and portions. Today was no exception. Might be the best Rueben on the peninsula. Clam chowder was awesome. Way more clams than potatoes the Carlsborg club was also very good. Both Waitresses we had were great. Smiles and friendly! And honest. We were there slightly before dinner, she let us use lunch or dinner menu. We also had pie. The apple pie was worth the drive! The lemon meringue came with a lemon slice to squeeze over the meringue! Top notch all the way around. read more

Went just after the new owners took over for a late breakfast. May need a revisit. Service was quality. Not a fan of the pink gravy. My potatoes were like chopped up French fries. Lots of stuff around that needs a good cleaning read more

For a small town diner, this place is a pretty neat find. I initially discovered this place on yelp after looking for a cute diner on the way back from hurricane ridge. This place is located near the side of a small street and is pioneer themed. Upon first glance, I appreciated the aesthetics of the exterior and interior of the restaurant. While initially entering the restaurant, the service staff immediately greeted me and was incredibly kind. She seated us at the booth near the window. She started off by giving us our silverware, menus, and drinks. I decided to try their "most popular" reuben sandwich and my friend went with the bbq elk burger. Their customer service was great as the practice proper social distancing and wore masks. Reuben 7/10: The sandwich was pilled with sauerkraut and the meat was a too salty for me. BBQ Elk Burger 5/10: The portions were relatively sizeable but the meat was grossly overcooked. Would not recommend. Ultimately, this place is a cute and neat place to check out with awesome customer service, however, it is a little pricy for a small town diner and I would opt to try different menu items if returning. read more

Old Mill Cafe - BBQ Bison Burger and Reuben Sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlsborg, Washington