Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Mill Cafe

    4.0 (4 reviews)
    Closed 8:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Old Mill Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Old Mill Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 day ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Edgar A.
    54
    33
    30

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Food is really good, fresh and quality ingredients. Good variety of snacks and drinks. New management and staff are very nice and welcoming.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Old Mill Cafe

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 3,564 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Porcupine Pub & Grille

    Porcupine Pub & Grille

    4.0
    (982 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    $$

    I have been coming to Porcupine since I moved here in 2016. How am I just now finding out about $2…read morebeer on Tuesdays?! Every Tuesday, they do $2 draft beer - ALL draft beer. They have something like 10 taps, lots of it is pretty nice craft beer. On Tuesdays, it's only $2! Apparently they have been offering this deal for decades! What's the catch? They are operating as a restaurant so in Utah, you are required to order food with your drinks. They do have some cheaper food options and the servers are very cool with you sharing food. I recommend getting a pizza to share! As far as the food is concerned, it's your pretty standard bar/pub food but a little bit more upscale. So, it's a good spot if you're looking for something that everyone will enjoy. Their pizzas are popular and very reasonably priced. Porcupine is also a great location for post mountain activities and right along multiple trail routes. I frequently find myself here after an intense outdoor activity, looking for air conditioning and good food. The nice thing about them operating as a restaurant is that it's kid friendly! They also have a really nice patio with a beautiful view! See you there on Tuesday!

    Great dining experience here. We had to wait a short time for a table so fortunately there were…read moreenough seats open at bar for us to be able to order a drink. (This Utah and one has to be seated in order to drink) We had just barely got drinks when our table was ready. I enjoyed my house salad with shrimp added. Friends loved the tacos and the ravioli. Then to finish our meal we ordered the chocolate porcupine. It was tasty. Bottom layer of cake topped with mousse surrounded by hard chocolate shell made to look like a porcupine! So cute.

    Photos
    Interior
    Interior
    Cajun Chicken Alfredo
    Cajun Chicken Alfredo
    Ice tea

    See all

    Ice tea
    Eight Settlers Distillery

    Eight Settlers Distillery

    3.7
    (302 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    The venue itself is huge, with plenty of comfortable seating and a really unique atmosphere. One of…read morethe coolest features is that they even have old jail cells converted into dining areas. The furniture is comfortable, making it easy to settle in and enjoy your meal. The menu strikes a nice balance. There are enough options that everyone in our group found something they liked, but it's not so extensive that it becomes overwhelming. If you enjoy spirits, definitely try some of their house-distilled offerings. The gin stood out as particularly good and was a highlight of the visit. We visited for a birthday celebration with a group of eight and had no issues being accommodated. We were seated at a comfortable table, and service handled our larger group just fine. Overall, it was an enjoyable experience, and I would definitely go back.

    Mother's Day Brunch was at Eight Settlers Distillery and it didn't start out the greatest…read more Our reservation was at 10:30 and they do not even open their doors until 10:30, ok no big deal although I do wonder why they make reservations right at opening vs open slightly earlier or slightly later reservations. We got seated and to start the chairs were dirty (first people of the day sitting here), my water had something in it, and the silverware was dirty. We ordered the bread appetizer, but no plates to put the bread and oil on. We ordered the shrimp and grits, which was very bland it needed salt. Ham and cheese omelet, which my mom also thought was bland, French toast, my son enjoyed. The Benedict, my step dad enjoyed as well. Finally chicken and waffles, which was as expected. On the plus side the service was great and the price was reasonable for the portions. Overall I was not impressed and more than likely would not recommend, at least not for brunch.

    Photos
    Bar upstairs
    Bar upstairs
    Cool Ranch elote dip. Almost gone. We couldn't wait
    Cool Ranch elote dip. Almost gone. We couldn't wait
    Après ski cocktail

    See all

    Après ski cocktail
    Prohibition

    Prohibition

    4.0
    (931 reviews)
    4.6 mi
    $$

    This was such a fun place for date night with my hubby! The venue is so fun, the entertainment…read moreexciting albeit I wish it was longer than 25 minutes as I really enjoyed it! I want to come work here! The food was really good, and really expensive! Our bill was $145 for the two of us. Our server Jaxson was really knowledgeable on the menu, and really friendly. I don't think there's a bad seat in the house as all the burlesque dancers move around the space. Be prepared with some ones to tip them, but they also take Venmo. I'd love to come back!

    Sad to say, I'm not quite sure what all the hype is about…read more We had to sit outside because the indoor dining room was fully booked for the show. The night actually started off great. Our server was funny, personable, and attentive, especially when it came to drinks and refills. Things started going downhill when I received my entree, the Poor Man's Truffle. Unfortunately, the only way this dish lived up to its name was in how little the supposedly high-quality ingredients seemed to come through. The dish itself is fairly simple, which normally isn't a bad thing when the ingredients are meant to speak for themselves. With Belper Knolle, truffle oil, pistachio pesto, tomato, fennel, and arugula, I expected something flavorful and well balanced. Instead, the entire dish tasted incredibly mild. Belper Knolle is typically a bold, salty, peppery cheese, and I could visibly see the black pepper around the edges of the thin shavings, but the flavor barely registered. I also couldn't taste the truffle oil at all. There was visible oil pooling at the bottom of the plate, but no noticeable truffle flavor. I understand pistachio pesto tends to be more subtle than a traditional basil pesto, but altogether, this dish just fell completely flat for me. The presentation didn't help either. It looked more like something that had been scooped from a pan and dropped onto the plate than a thoughtfully plated entree. When a dish misses both on flavor and presentation, that's when it becomes a real disappointment for me. I will say the gnocchi itself was cooked well, which was one of the few positives. I also tried the burger, and it was significantly better than my pasta. However, the very small sprinkle of bacon was a little baffling considering it was an additional upcharge. Where the night really went downhill was at the end of the meal. I had been excited to try the beignets because that isn't a dessert I see on menus very often. Our entree plates were cleared, and then we waited about 20 minutes before our server returned and asked whether we were ready for the check. Dessert wasn't mentioned, and by that point our table was tired of waiting, so we decided to skip it and asked for our checks. Then our server disappeared for another 30 minutes. We eventually had to flag down a hostess who was seating another table and let her know that we were still waiting for the check. About five minutes later, our server finally returned and casually explained how "crazy" the night had gotten because of the show. I understand restaurants get busy, but the apology felt very dismissive after we had waited nearly an hour from finishing our entrees to finally receiving the check. It genuinely felt like our table had simply been forgotten. I also want to add that I tend to hold restaurants like this to a higher standard. I'm a big believer in "you get what you pay for." If I'm eating at a fast-food spot or somewhere inexpensive and casual, there's only so much room to complain. But when a restaurant has prices like this, highlights premium ingredients on the menu, and presents itself as a more elevated dining experience, I think that naturally opens the food and service up to more criticism. At that price point, I expect the quality, presentation, and overall experience to reflect what I'm paying for. My final takeaway is that maybe I ordered the wrong dish. Pesto is one of my favorite things, so I almost always want to give a pesto-based dish a try. Unfortunately, Prohibition's pesto gnocchi was not it for me. I also saw that they describe themselves as a scratch kitchen using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, which I don't necessarily doubt. What confused me was how so many ingredients that should have distinct flavors somehow tasted like almost nothing. If your goal is interesting drinks and a fun show, this is probably still a place worth considering. Since we sat outside, I can't speak on the show part, but it seems to be a big hit. Food-wise, though, it missed the mark for me.

    Photos
    Bourbon & Blues - Tuesday
    Bourbon & Blues - Tuesday
    The Patsy Burger
    The Patsy Burger
    Cool Decor

    See all

    Cool Decor
    The Hog Wallow Pub

    The Hog Wallow Pub

    3.5
    (264 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$

    We love Hog Wallow. From the ambiance inside to the retreat that is their patio…read more This is a small pub. Plenty of on tap brews, and they make some really good mixed drinks too. The food is really good for this style of pub. I personally go back for the smoked wings (fried are great too). I have tried a number of different items from their menu, I can't recall ever being disappointed by a meal or a brew that I've had. This place gets BUSY. They know how to pack it in. Live music, friendly atmosphere. The staff does a really good job bouncing around to make sure things are taken care of. Service times can run a little long. And parking can be the biggest hurdle as it fills up. But I wouldn't let either of those deter you from trying this place, you won't be disappointed.

    This is a fantastic pub in the rough. We were looking for something new, so I thought we would…read morecheck it out not looking at any of the other reviews. We just went for it. The service is fantastic! The seating area outback is phenomenal. It's quaint, wonderful surroundings of nature. We ordered the fried wings with citrus habanero sauce and definitely a 10 out of 10! And the Macho Nachos were a little less delicious, but still tasty. Under the first layer none of the cheeses melted. The atmosphere was exactly what we were looking for, someplace to chill and just have a drink with a side of food. On a sidenote, cleanest bathrooms in a pub I've ever seen, my wife agrees.

    Photos
    The Hog Wallow Pub
    The Hog Wallow Pub
    The Hog Wallow Pub

    See all

    Bandits' Grill & Bar

    Bandits' Grill & Bar

    3.7
    (485 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$

    Perfect for a cozy and enjoyable dining experience. Loved that they were open Sundays for service…read more. The decor is warm and the staff are very friendly and attentive. We splurged on the tri tip nachos and platter which offered giant onion rings , bone in chicken wings and fried pickles . The nachos had chili beans in it which had an amazing flavor and makes me curious to try their Chili. The ice tea is brewed daily , possibly hourly . The ribeye had a nice char and buttery taste- you definitely do not need A1 for it. Asparagus had a nice bite to them. I did try the sweet potato casserole and was not overly sweet or had marshmellows. Definitely would return again for a nice dinner amongst friends .

    3 Stars -- Bandits' Grill & Bar Dined: August 12, 2026…read moreLocation: 3176 E. 6200 S., Cottonwood Heights, UT 84121 Price: $$ -- Entrées in our group ranged from about $20-$23.50 This was my first visit to Bandits' Grill & Bar. I was in the Salt Lake City area visiting four colleagues, and they highly recommended the restaurant, so I was looking forward to trying it. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich ($19.99) and added a Caesar salad ($4.99), with beans and coleslaw as my sides. Unfortunately, my meal was pretty underwhelming. The pulled pork wasn't very flavorful and didn't taste particularly fresh. The coleslaw was vinegar-based, which I personally didn't care for at all, and the beans were just mediocre. Overall, I was disappointed with my meal. That said, two of my colleagues ordered the prime rib sandwich ($23.49), which is similar to a French dip, and they both raved about it. They said it was excellent. Another person in our group had the tri-tip sandwich ($20.49), and the chicken plate was $21.99. Our total for five people came to $128.43 including tax, before tip. The service was average--nothing particularly bad, but nothing that stood out either. On the positive side, I really liked the interior and ambiance of the restaurant. It was attractive, comfortable, and very clean. I'm giving Bandits three stars based on my personal experience this time around, but I'm definitely willing to give it another chance. Based on how much my colleagues enjoyed the prime rib sandwich, I'll probably order that on my next visit and see if it's as good as they described. Sometimes the first thing you order just isn't the restaurant's best dish, so I'm not writing this place off yet.

    Photos
    Manager who yelled at the patron ... so poorly handled
    Manager who yelled at the patron ... so poorly handled
    Bandito Taco Salad
    Bandito Taco Salad
    Grilled Pineapple Mint Cooler

    See all

    Grilled Pineapple Mint Cooler
    Bohemian Brewery

    Bohemian Brewery

    4.2
    (1.3k reviews)
    4.8 mi
    $$

    What better way to finish our vacation in the greater Salt Lake City area than to find a quaint…read moreBohemian Brewery in the middle of town. I knew from the parking lot this place was a winner. Once inside, it had a welcoming atmosphere and people inside were all having a good time. This brewery features Lager Beers crafted using traditional Bavarian/European methods...thus I had to try one...two...maybe more. Luckily there was a ton of delicious looking food on the menu from the expected pizzas and wings to the old world treats like beef stroganoff, goulash and schnitzal. Everything is made from scratch and I couldn't help looking at all the neighboring tables to get an idea of what to try. Our waitress Ashley was really helpful and checked if the pesto was made with nuts as we have peanut and tree nut allergies in our family. Luckily there were no pine nuts or other substitutes and we could safely have it! We ended up getting quite a feast of plates and then topped it off with two desserts- the bread pudding and the German chocolate cake (couldn't come to a family agreement so had to get both!). Thanks Bohemian Brewery for the excellent time!

    Really good spot! Some friends introduced me to this place…read more We didn't have any cocktails or beer since we're not good day drinkers, haha. But the food was delicious. We had the pork shank and the chicken schnitzel. The pork shank came with spatzle and red cabbage-excellent dish. The chicken schnitzel was pretty good. It had a fresh taste to it and even a little lemon-y, which didn't make the fried cutlet taste too rich. It came with mashed potatoes, gravy and veggies. The veggies were your basic steamed veggies, but the dish was overall good. Service was great-server was attentive and the manager came around as well to check on us. I think it would be fun to come here for Oktoberfest, since the inside has a good ambiance.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    Bohemian Brewery
    Bohemian Brewery

    See all

    Old Mill Cafe - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...