This place is a gem! The staff were friendly and helpful. The cheese bread was fantastic and the pizza was really good too. I think it was wood fired and cooked really well. The homemade ranch is so good but does cost a little extra. The store is very open and clean. I was excited to see the dessert selection also and will need to try some next time. read more

See all

Food was amazing. It was just the right amount of crowded with plenty of smiling staff, and the food smelled great from the parking lot. read more

Old World Pizza - Pizza Yum - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Best pizza in BA and I am very picky about pizza. Also, THE BEST Caesar salad. Hands down.

Well, been coming here since they opened. Ate lunch here today and it was amazing. Over the top! To help narrow down what to eat, I would have to say everything. They have the Greek salad, wings, pizza, pasta. Bread sticks and all of it is excellent. Their wings have a lava sauce which tastes great. If you like spicy, they are awesome. Had their Greek salad for the first time today. It is now my favorite. Fresh, large, tasty, and homemade dressing. If you all leave here hungry, it is your fault. After that meal, I am heading home for a nap! read more

Old World Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Everything is made fresh! The ranch dressing is the best!! The gluten free is like no other!!

Unassuming looking pizzeria in a strip mall. That's where some of the best gems are found! The staff is great and owner did (as others have said) make everyone feel welcome. Our server was fantastic. The space is huge! We tried two 10 inch pizzas, the pepperoni loaded one and a build-your-own with regular sausage, roasted red pepper, mushrooms and red onion. The pepperoni was the best. Just note that if you build your own, most of the ingredients are piled on top (not under the cheese like some places). We both wished we had added jalapenos to both pies. They just needed a kick. I would return to try some of their signature pizzas, most of which you can only get starting with the 16". This is a ways for us to travel for just pizza so if we're in the area we would try them again. But, having said that, if we had an Old World Pizza in our town we would definitely be frequent flyers and bypass Hideaway and Andolini's. :) read more

Old World Pizza - Pepperoni and a build-your-own. - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Great pizza and service. Tried it for the first time tonight and will definitely be back. The tomatoes on the salad weren't great but pizza was outstanding. The homemade ranch actually tastes like creamy dill and is fantastic. I would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Excellent service by waitress Emily. Owner is wonderfully friendly and helpful. Clean restaurant and delicious pizza, wings and fantastic Tiramisu, (which is generally available on Friday and weekends). you have to try the tiramisu. It is the best in the entire area I can't find my photos, sorry. read more

Wow!! I am so thankfull to have a pizza place THIS GOOD so close to home. 100% our family's new pizza place. I walked in for a carryout order and it was shockingly fast. The amount of toppings on our pizza was way better than I could have imagined. I think I paid 26 for a 2 topping XL, which seems expensive but when you compare what we got with what you would get from ANY OTHER pizza joint it was a great deal. Huge pizza, lots of toppings that were perfectly spaced (all the way to the crust) the crust was top tier, the cheese looked like double the amount anywhere else has, and the ingredients tasted so fresh! I can't say enough good things about this place! Just try it and I dont think you'll ever go anywhere else! read more

Old World Pizza - XL pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Woodfire pizza. If that's your thing you'll probably like it. I would go again. Owner is very nice. Just wish the salad was cheaper.

The food here is really good. The service is good. The owner is great! Wood fire pizza. Notables : appetizer-pepperoni bread. House made ranch! Pizza-pepperoni lovers, Canadian bacon, Morrison. Other stuff-build your own calzone. Desserts- Tiramisu, German chocolate cake, gelato, and espresso!!!! Seriously, get the chocolate gelato and double espresso. Spoon the espresso on your gelato and enjoy an affogato! Yum!! read more

You know what's cool? Old World Pizza!!!! Not only do they have some of the best customer service skills, they make amazing food!!! They recently added a Greek salad, HOT WINGS and a collaboration was done with yours truly to build a pizza named after me to be added to the menu!!!! ZOMG it's so exciting!!! Not only is it fun to see that on the menu, this pizza is striking to look at!!! The color combinations will bedazzle your rods and cones while simultaneously your stomach and other digestive organs will be singing Gregorian chants in blissful awe after each bite that harmoniously traverses down your esophagus!!! I mean, how could it not!?! With a house made creamy Buffalo sauce to start with cheese, grilled chicken, pepperoni, Canadian bacon accompanied by fresh basil, jalapeños and toasted red peppers! Woah what an explosion of flavor!!!! The Greek salad was so fresh and presented well. Very simple and traditional, it was a total pallet activator and laid a nice bed in my belly for everything else to lay down on when it came time. I'm a big fan of these hot wings too! They are not as crunchy as many others as they aren't deep fried but rather prepared in a more health conscious way as they are cooked in the 600 degree pizza oven!! They deliver the same great flavor but without all the grease!!! How cool is that!!!! This is a legitimate 4D eating experience and we get to have this right here in BA right at New Orleans Square!!!! No lunch or dinner plans yet? Well let me make a suggestion......... head down to Old World Pizza and get you a Big Ray in BA pizza and tell 'em well, that Big Ray sent you!!!! read more

Back at the best Gourmet Pizza in Tulsa. This time I am checking out a new dessert. Lemon Berry Mascarpone! Wow! read more

Old World Pizza - Lemon Berry Mascarpone. Ooh la la! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

This place has the absolute best calzones in Oklahoma! The staff is friendly and the owners are always there hard at work making sure everything is delicious and hot. read more

Old World Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

My family's favorite pizza place. Friendly customer focused family business. We usually order and pickup, but the dining area is nice too.

Really nice pizza spot in BA. Dine in or takeaway - service is always friendly. Try a calzone! read more

Service couldn't have been better. The pizza is also fantastic. Great wood-fired taste. Best pizza in BA without a doubt. Been several times now and it has been consistently great! read more

Wow! This place is incredible, they did a soft opening around Black Friday 2022. The menu and decor is still under development but the pizza menu is in full swing. Take your family and try it. The owner, an Italian immigrant, takes pride in her business and when you taste the pizza you will understand. The "old world" term is is based on pizzas with the cheese first then sauce all Cooked in a traditional brick oven. They will be adding salads to their menu in the coming weeks, along with more seating decor and other menu items. They have a couple of big screens playing the game and plan to add a bar in the future. The owner is incredible and the staff are friendly and happy to serve you. If I didn't say it already, I am impressed with the pizza. Taste good and didn't give my wife or I indigestion as we usually face when eating this type of meal. Go there and enjoy! read more

See all

I would give zero stars, if that was an option. Let me set the scene. I'm a recent transplant from California. I have been looking for "my go to" pizza place, since I arrived here in Oklahoma. I am looking for a place that serves pizza that features a specific type of sauce. So, I walked in. I was greeted by a young lady, who was kind, and asked if I wanted to eat in or take it to go. I said I wanted to look at the menu first. At that point, the one who I believe was the owner came over and started talking over me and the young lady. I made my way to the counter, with the owner on my heels, pressing for my order. I shared that I was looking for something very specific and asked if she would mind sharing what products she uses. She danced around the answer. I assume she wanted to guard her recipe, which can be understandable. I thanked her for her time and asked if I could use the restroom before I left. At that time, she became quite angry and began yelling at me. "No. You may not use my bathroom. You did not buy anything. I use the money paid for my food to pay my bills. Since you don't pay my bills, no. You can not use my bathroom." I stood there. Shocked and embarrassed, especially since there were other people in the establishment hearing this happen. I replied to her, "It's a bathroom. It's not that serious." I may not have bought anything today, but I promise, after being treated like that, I will NEVER step foot in this business again. I saw another review where someone stated that this person was rude to a disabled person. I find it absolutely wild that the person from this business had the nerve to say, "that person was not disabled." Not all disabilities are visible. You don't know what a person is going through. A little kindness and compassion can go a long way. I can only hope that you are never in a position where you need to be treated with respect and dignity, because karma is real. read more

We got our food to go. The pizza crust is very good. We ordered their supreme and Margherita pizza. Their Caesar is decent size, but recommend getting the dressing on the side. Cannoli was yummy...wish the chocolate sauce had been left off or on the side so I didn't have to eat right away. The staff is friendly and you can tell they care about their food and service. The place is decent size and has a causal feel to it. read more

Excellent pizza & calizone. Quality & quantity of ingredients are absolutely fantastic. Garlic knots are exceptional also. Will try pasta dishes next week. Puts all other pizza joints to shame in Broken Arrow. Fresh never frozen ingredients & everything including sausage & meatballs are made fresh each day. No processed, frozen or pre prepped ingredients. Nice atmosphere, friendly service, great staff & owner is always on hand. Hands down best pizza in green country. read more

Owner, please stop updating and lengthening your response. It is spamming me with notifications. The way the pizza tasted has nothing to do with how long it sat. I've had good, authentic NY pizza for 20 years of my life, cold, old, fresh, reheated, carry-out, dine-in, and even some good ones from here like Jimmie's, uncle Vinny's, or even chains like Andoulinis. Your pizza was just not good. That's all. I know you don't like my review but this is a forum for free speech and honest reviews. I don't know anyone who's had good pizza that would have enjoyed your pizza. Funny you are trying to imply my review should be minimized because I'm not a "regular customer" or suggesting I didn't eat your pizza. I bought your pizza at listed price, ate it, and didn't like it. That's it. Freedom of speech, simple as that. If you don't like that maybe you don't love Oklahoma as much as you claim to. Updating to 1 star because I didn't realize the owner was so condescending and rude. read more

After wanting to find a new local pizza place to try, we dined in Old World Pizza for lunch since we were in the area. We arrived shortly after noon and were greeted as we walked inside. We were able to choose a table in the middle of the restaurant. My husband enjoyed a beer in a cold glass as we looked over the menu. We decided to share the house salad and a supreme 10-inch pizza. Both the food and service were great! The prices were reasonable as well. We would return. read more

Pizza was amazing! Crispy crust. Sauce was great. Homemade ranch was delicious! Great customer service. Give them a chance you won't regret it! read more

The garlic knots are fantastic and my wife said the Caesar salad was one of the best she ever had. Apparently they make most of their items on-site, and you can taste the difference. Pizza was good, I'll admit. It was better later that evening as a snack. We will certainly be back to try more pizzas, maybe the calzone. Just please be aware that the menu prices listed are for cash payments and that there will be a 4% surcharge if you pay by credit card. read more

My new favorite pizza place! This is a hidden gem in Broken Arrow. The brick-fired ovens and quality ingredients make for an incredible flavor. After eating here for the first time last week I couldn't wait to return. No up-charge for a gluten free crust, and this one is homemade, not the frozen gluten free crust most places offer. My husband gave the regular crust a thumbs up as well. Delicious all around! read more

Old World Pizza - Gluten free Italian sausage and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Great food, nice atmosphere. Service was top-notch. Had the Chicken, bacon, ranch pizza and loved it!

Their crust is amazing. Service is great. Owner goes the extra mile to make everyone feel welcome. Highly recommend. read more

Old World Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch! - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

The pizza was amazing, and the service was quick, friendly, and attentive! We'll definitely go back! One of our new favorite destinations for pizza! read more

Old World Pizza - 10" Pepperoni Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Great place to eat, great pizza, the sauce is the best it home made . I do recommend the chicken Alfredo for supreme and Margherita pizza. Great customer service, and great environment to eat. read more

Old World Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

The service was great! Pizza had good quality ingredients and excellent flavor! These people care about what they are doing!! Local business!! Great job! read more

Where the best pizza in Broken Arrow meets the best customer service! Can't recommend this place enough. The pizza crust tastes like it relocated from New York. Give it a try and like my review if you agree with my post! read more

See all

The pizza was fantastic, great service, very friendly staff. The dining is nice very big, lots of space. I highly recommend this place to get pizza in Broken Arrow. read more

If you want delicious medium-crust pizza made to order, cooked in a jiffy in a very hot (approx 800 degrees) oven, try Old World Pizza. It's in the same slot where CiCi's used to be, near the 101st & Elm intersection. The pizza dough is well-seasoned, and the sausage, mushrooms, sauce and onions were great. We also tried the lemon-blueberry cream cake, and it was fantastic, although it cost more than I expected ($9). read more

I have tried Old World Pizza on two or three different occasions. I really don't mean any offense to the owners or their business but the pizza is just not good. It doesn't feel like the toppings are cooked well Into the pizza. I had a meat lovers once and the meat just didn't taste like it was well cooked. I will try again in hopes that I will like it at some point. read more

Good pizza. Good salad. We've always done takeout, and every pizza has been good and with plentiful toppings.

Pizza was okay but not worth the $. Tiramisu was not great. Waitress and owners were super friendly.

Absolutely perfect pizza !! Dessert was amazing too. Don't miss out ! 101 and Aspen in BA.

Food is always great, everything is made from scratch. Waitress is friendly and attentive. If you want good Italian food this is the place. read more

Amazing pizza. Love love love. Supreme is my favorite. So far. Crust is the best. Highly recommend.