This place is pretty good. They had a wide selection of both sweet and savory foods. The salad bar had a lot of options as well. There was also a small gift shop, which was nice. The restaurant was very clean and inviting. My family had a good experience here. The prices were pretty reasonable, as well. read more

Good plentiful food, most people opt for the buffet with their good selection: beef, pork, chicken and fish choices. Side dishes are good too. Large and adequate salad bar. They have another section for desserts, mostly pies, included in the price = value. The service is always friendly. We have gone during the week and been able to walk right up to our table. Our last visit was a Saturday and there was a brief 15 minute wait. My only cons are, when they're busy the dessert table looks like a war zone: they didn't pre-cut the pies (mostly crust with little fruit/filling) and the patrons had a hard time serving themselves; and $2.29 for a large glass of ice with a little soft drink seems a little excessive, even if it is all-you-can drink. read more

When I get a hunger for some old fashioned comfort food, this is my go to spot. Their chicken & noodles are just like Mom used to make & the roasted chicken, AND chicken livers are heavenly. They even have fried Green Tomatoes in the summer! Friendly, helpful staff always makes my visit a pleasant experience read more

Went for small lunch. Had soup and sandwich. The waitress let me substitute the soup for their delicious chicken and noodles. Sandwich was good. Everybody was very friendly and quiet atmosphere. Had cherry pie for dessert. Yum! Like to browse in their gift shop. I have ate here before and have always been satisfied. Very relaxing experience! Would go again! l read more

No buffet which is fine. We decided to have the family style which is fine. Family style is all you can eat but don't plan on it because you will have to wait about 25 minutes to get any additional food. Our server was MIA most of the time. We had to ask a young lady cleaning the tables to find her. We waited so long we said just give us our bill and pie which is included with the meal but we were told no because you get nothing to go. I could have ordered a regular meal and had more food for less. Won't be back....EVER!! read more

Enjoying our day in Hocking Hills and could not have made a better lunch choice. We got there at 330, so lunch prices with all the great food. The chicken was the best ever (even better then Frakenmuth), the homemade noodles and pie bar. Delicious read more

Excellent customer service. Good American food. Love their addition of a petting zoo outside the restaurant. They also have a nice gift shop outside the restaurant. Very affordable. Family friendly. read more

Not a fan of buffets but this is the exception. Rolls and chicken were excellent. Jason, waiter, was attentive, personable, and friendly.

Typical buffet food... Fried chicken was good mashed potatoes were good.... my wife enjoyed the the liver and onions.... the rest was OK...., our server was very prompt and courteous..... they kept the buffet pretty well stocked...... good selection of ice cream... Tried the lemon meringue pie and it was ok..... read more

Friendly service and good food! We ordered from the menu but there was a lot of food on that buffet that looked pretty good! The chicken and mashed potatoes were very good. The green beans okay. My husband enjoyed looking out the window to see the goats. I would go back again if we are ever in this area again. read more

Tuesday afternoon in September 2014, young couple ages 21-24 This was a great restaurant. We arrived at 3:48 pm expecting to pay dinner buffet prices, but were surprised to find out that lunch prices were good until 4:00pm. It is a bit pricey for us (lunch $9.99, dinner $13.99) but comparable to other Hocking Hills area restaurants. I really appreciated the atmosphere, main buffet, and massive dessert buffet. Nothing was overly spectacular, but all of the food was good. I was surprised by the selection of pies and ice cream. The dessert bar was a large as the dinner bar. We will definitely be eating here again on our next trip to Hocking Hills. read more

Ok, we knew we weren't going to have as many restaurant choices in Logan as we do in our home in Columbus. We wondered, however, if this restaurant might be something along the lines of Der Dutchman in Plain City. Wrong! The 'buffet' basically consisted of fried chicken, green beans, green bean casserole, stringy beef, box mash taters, and a very small salad bar. This was $11.99! I chose the Rueben platter, and I was amazed how quickly it was brought out! Unfortunately, this showed in the pale uncooked fries. I was also unimpressed with the beef - it was tasteless and quite fatty. I really would not recommend this place to anyone. I wish we'd just grabbed some hamburgers from the Wendy's down the road. read more

The food here is terrible. The buffet choices are terrible and the broasted chicken I ordered was just as bad. I would not recommend this place at all. read more

Where do I even begin with all the things that went wrong with our Easter Dinner. To start with I do not live in Logan so it is an hour drive to get there and an hour drive to get back. I usually enjoy going to this restaurant five or six times a year. But after the events yesterday it will be a good while before I go back. First off, I know they were busy. But when you have to continuously ask your waitress for drinks you are never off to the good start. Especially when you have watched her leaning against the wall going into the kitchen doing nothing and talking with her co-workers. Second , leaving plates on our table for the majority of the meal. Third, back to the drinks, every waitress around us asked their table if they would like something to drink to go, our waitress never even bothered checking back at our table. I was sat with a group of eight, and it was two separate checks one with three and the other with five and a 15% gratuity was automatically added to the check. I prefer to leave my own tip. When we approached the cashier to pay she started to give the other person we sat with a hassle about removing it from the bill because she wanted to leave a cash tip and not put it on the credit card. So the manager was called. I wish I would have gotten her name but I did not. She was wearing a red blouse and had blonde hair. So I proceeded to her register where we asked to have the gratuity removed. So the manager then proceeded to throw a pen and the receipt at me to sign. I am sorry but I expect better manners from a manager. Because of her attitude I only left a small tip. Had they acted with better class the waitress would have received a $20 tip total from both parties that sat at the table. I'm sorry but I am not going to reward horrible service both from a waitress and from a manager. It was about 3:15 pm when we were leaving The last time I checked a tip was not something automatic, especially for a buffet. If she had cleared the table in a prompt manner, and kept our glasses full I would have tipped more than I did, but do not expect a $8 tip when your only duty is to do the two things listed above. read more

Biggest rip off this whole trip! $20.15 for a drink and crappy salt leaden food on buffet. I ate very little, unless I wanted to swell up like a tic! 15 min wait for pure junk! Would not recommend this place at all! They say homemade, I don't believe it for a second,everything tasted canned or out of a bag. Go somewhere else!!!! read more

My family ate here about 2 months ago & loved it. Their rolls were so good. We went back last night & were very disappointed. The waitress said they were out of & wouldn't have rolls for at least one hour. I asked if we would receive a discount on our bill since 3 of our meals were to include rolls. She said yes. When we received our almost $70 bill there was no discount. I just deducted it from her tip. My husband ordered cabbage rolls & said the sauce was Campbell's tomato soup & they were horrible. The only good thing I can say about our second experience is that the broasted chicken was delicious. Next time we are planning to try Bush's (in Logan also) because from my understanding they also serve broasted chicken. read more

Not impressed with the food service selection. Nothing is made there. We went there for the buffet, it all came from boxes.

Nice buffet. Food was good and everything was clean. I'm just not a buffet person. But I say this is much better than the chain stores. I would come here again. read more

Decent food, nice, family atmosphere. Our daughter loves to visit the petting zoo area after we eat. Their pie is awesome... Be sure to save room! read more

The food is much better under the new management. Service is very good. Nice party rooms and gift shop. They also cater

I was so happy when my husband finally agreed to stop here during our 2nd trip to Hocking Hills. The buffet food was really food. The dessert table had so many pie options. I was in our paradise (get the apple pie by the way. It's worth breaking your diet for). Our waitress was great. Stayed on top of refills and removing dirty dishes. Their gift shop was wonderful too. I spent a long time in there. Everything was affordable. read more

Was hesitant when seeing an Amish themed restaurant away from Amish country. We live in the middle of Amish country so I have been to plenty good and not so good ones. This place gets a thumbs up from me. Buffet was enormous. Fish, roast beef, turkey , chicken , liver and onions, ham, tons of sides (all fresh too) and to top it off had a full pie bar and self serve hand dipped ice cream. Great deal, we eill be back nect time we visit Hocking hills read more

Simply put, it's good. Not great. Not spectacular. Just plain ol' good. No one in our party could really find any fault with the food or drinks. There are some items, of course, that are better than others (the chicken dishes were our personal favorites). The price is pretty decent (around $8-$10 per entree) and the wait staff is friendly. Some people may find it to be better than I did which could be, in part, to the fact that I grew up on great homestyle food and have a pretty high standard for my chicken livers. Nevertheless, if you're in the area and looking for some good, country style food, it's definitely worth a stop. read more

If you want great food and great service. The buffet is filling just on 1 pass through and very well priced

Great food, great service. Cute gift shop too. Got the broasted chicken, mashed potatoes, and green beans with salad bar. Delicious!

Large variety, including many protein options. Nice selection of pies for dessert. Service was good. Highly recommend this place. Not sure why the lower overall rating on Yelp. Makes us second guess those other 3.5 star restaurants we have passed up other times. read more

This is our first time at this restaurant and i was impressed. They have a wide variety of food including some i havent seen at other eateries. Lima beans, fried green tomatoes, brussel sprouts and liver just to name a few. We had the all you can eat buffet for $10.59, lunch price. I was most impressed by their dessert bar. Fresh homemade pies, cakes, brownies and Wells Blue Bunny ice cream. Very tasty. The restaurant as a whole was very clean as were the restrooms. The staff were helpful and friendly. When you are seated you are given a survey to fill out which, to me, is impressive....shows they care about how their customers feel. They also have a large gift store with all sorts of goodies to buy....some made by local artists. We will definitely be back and i highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Are people here really so ignorant that when they see a restaurant sign with a HORSE and BUGGY out in the Ohio COUNTRYSIDE called "OLDE DUTCH" they assume it will be food from the NETHERLANDS? haha really I scoff at you. Olde dutch means AMISH, Mennonite, what have you! If you go to the bulk food store next store you can see an actual Amish girl at the counter. Of course this is just good old country cooking. If you thought otherwise well then, of course, you were FOOLISHLY mistaken. I think of this place as a mix between an Old Country Buffet and a Cracker Barrel. If you like either of those places, you will probably like this. Except, since the Olde Dutch is not a chain you can be assured the food is fresh home cooking every time. I am a vegetarian so there wasn't much to choose from but what I did have from their veggies was great as was their salad bar. My mom assured me their meat dishes were really good. And after a long day hiking in the hocking hills being able to load up at a buffet is great! read more

Family get together..... we were seated in side room. Good server. Plenty of food. Good senior discount too. ;)

Are here for lunch and it was fantastic!! The turkey was better than thanksgiving and mashed potatoes were awesome as well. I was at this place many years ago and it's gone from good to great. Our server was amazing too! If you're in the area and are hungry for a top notch meat and potatoes buffet, you must try this place out! read more

Wife and I went there last Saturday evening (~7:30). Has been a few years since last visit. Food was decent but not as good as I remember in the past. Service was good. While paying the bill (at the gift store counter),the Cook comes storming out from kitchen to inform staff in a loud voice that "My kitchen is closed. IF YOU SEAT ANYONE ELSE, YOU CAN COOK FOR THEM." Then storms back down the hallway to the kitchen, passing by my wife (coming out of the bathroom). She comes out and asked me who that was. Says he slammed open the kitchen door and was dropping F-Bombs the whole way thru. Little disappointed that management would put up with a big mouth hothead like that. Must be short on Cooks in the area. Anyway, left a bad taste in our mouths. read more

Delicious Amish style restaurant. Locally owned, not a chain or franchise. Order from menu or enjoy their buffet. Great salad bar and scrumptious pies. Very clean, well lighted with an attentive staff and strong customer service. A comfort food heaven. Did I mention REAL MASHED POTATOES? read more

This was pretty good homestyle cooking. For those of us who enjoy chicken livers, these are prepared nicely and were a highlight! The fried foods were all good. I was a bit disappointed with the chicken and noodles. The ladies of my southern Ohio church made better and in nearly as large quantity as needed for this restaurant. While the desserts that came with the buffet lacked in eye appeal, they made up for it in taste. They were very flavorful, and worth the calories. All-in-all, this is a place we will go again when we are at our Hideaway Hills cottage. read more

We where traveling home from a race and stopped on a Sunday night. Nice place, you have to walk through the gift shop to get to resturant. We both had the buffet, while selection was not huge it was sufficient. Everything appeared to be home made and tasted good. The chicken was good, I had a couple of different kinds of potatoes too. If you are looking for a gormet meal, probably not your place. Good food for a reasonable price. I had the cake for desert, it was very good. read more

I really like this place. The food is always delicious and I really enjoy the pie buffet!!

went to Hocking Hils for a romantic get away with the wife. hotel told us to try Olde Dutch, so glad we did. delicious home made food, great selection on the buffet. Home made pies, we will be back! read more

Olde Dutch was recommended to us when we asked a local for good food...wow, was she right! We were wanting to grab a large, late lunch to hold us over for the evening and the buffet certainly did the trick. Broasted chicken was delicious, moist meat, crispy outside...salad was fresh and the homemade ranch dressing was very good. Great selection of sides and main dishes, chicken, pork, chicken noodle, fish, mashed potatoes, gravy and on and on and on...Oh yeah, then there is the dessert table, 5 - 6 ice cream flavors and probably 7 - 8 different pie selections, this is in addition to the peach cobbler that was on the buffet. So yeah, this late lunch held us over for the rest of the night. :-) read more

Had dinner Monday night and the buffett was very good. This is not a chain and the food is not over spicey. It is home cooking with a good selection. read more

Went there for Thanksgiving and the food was awesome. Had to wait for over half hour and behind at least 100 people but, it was worth the wait. The food was absolutely delicious and a very wide variety, not just the usual Thanksgiving fare. The turkey and ham were some of the best I have had in a restaurant and the staff was very good and friendly. When we left the restaurant there was still well over 100 people waiting to get in. I would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Me & my wife & daughter just ate here today for the first time and I would have to say that our first experience with the Olde Dutch Restaurant was a very positive one.We all loved the fried chicken and I especially liked the homemade dinner rolls. The mashed potatoes were the bomb, they reminded me of my late mother's mashed potatoes. Our waitress who's name was Anna was very friendly & helpful as was the rest of the wait staff. All in all we had a wonderful experience at this restaurant and we do plan on coming back again & again. read more