Wife and I just moved to the area and have been meaning to try Olive Cove. We called ahead to see if they offered table reservations. However, they do not. We came in on a Saturday at 6:00pm and we were able to get the only table available. The waitresses greeted us right away. The restaurant is a lot more cozy than I thought it would be. Very clean area and friendly staff. I ordered a beer and she ordered a sangria. They offer a 2-4-1 on drinks so I ended up receiving two beers and her sangria was in a double glass. They brought bread to the table with a nice garlic butter spread. It had very good flavor and the bread was good as well. Our entrees came out. I ordered the Chicken Parmesan and she got the Fettuccine Alfredo and added blackened chicken. They both were excellent. Definitely made from fresh ingredients, not commercial quality. We both have hefty leftovers for a second meal. We will absolutely be coming back on special occasions. read more

See all

This place is living on a past rep. The (almost non English speaking) waiter waited on us and we didn't see much of him. He was rude and didn't want to be there. Food seemed to be cafeteria style and not the greatest! read more

Still a great experience and still has that amazing sauce! Today I tried the manicotti and it was wonderful! I also tried a side of meatballs, but not as impressed. I just may be a snob with meatballs, but these made me feel like store bought and I wouldn't order again, but at least that sauce is on them that I really enjoy. Our server was nice, but she was all over the place taking care of everyone. We didn't have any problems or anything. Music was good at a nice level and comfortable temperature. read more

See all

One of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to, the food is authentic and delicious!

This is not only the worst Italian restaurant I have been to but it is one of the worst restaurants period. I have never been to an Italian restaurant that doesn't have salad on the menu. This place was never top tier but it was passable. Now, it's like they just stopped trying. I had the Penne Bolognese, the pasta was over cooked and the sauce had no flavor. The best thing about the meal was the bread. read more

Sadly I don't have really any positive feedback. To start... seating is dreadfully uncomfortable.... the meatballs are SAMS frozen meatballs 100%. Fine for feeding a crowd at potluck .. but no! The manicotti was meh .... Seemed to be plain ricotta and no spices buried under 7 pounds of mozzarella. My husband said the chicken parm was "fine". They don't offer a side salad or any salad for that matter. The only positive was that the server was friendly. Won't be back. read more

Everything went fantastic. I had one of the best meals ever. The service was great and had some good laughs with waitress. The place was spotless inside and smelled very clean. Would highly recommend what I got. read more

Olive Cove - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

See all

Usually it's hard to know where to start with a review, but Olive Cove really does Osso Bucco well. Perfectly tender and seasoned, there's no doubt this will please any carnivore. Picked the Rosato and it was divine! The flavor marries well to the pork. No need to add anything! Another at the table ordered it with the Alfredo. Delicious! Both plates had leftovers for the next day. Teen ordered the Linguini Marsala and quite liked their meal. Plenty for noshing on tomorrow. The Chicken Parmesan was classically prepared and wonderfully dressed. Everything was received with great satisfaction. The bread! Do not skip the garlic butter with it. This carboholic was very enthused with the unlimited refills. As to the service, I have to specify that this particular visit was on Mother's Day and there were some issues prior to our arrival that caused a chain reaction. With a cook out and a rush for the holiday, there was a temporary closing that had us wait about 45 minutes to be allowed in for seating. The closure was understandable and none of us were bothered. In fact, all of us said it was worth the wait! Our server was super on it, despite the place filling up pretty much instantaneously upon the doors opening again. The food came out quickly and to eager mouths. This place was hopping and deserves the stars for how well they handled the rushes. On other visits, the wait times were respectable. There is a large parking lot, with wheelchair access in the front of the plaza. This restaurant is romantic for dates and an upgrade for groups. Drink specials are abundant and generous. read more

See all

This place used to be great. They had a huge Stromboli and a large menu. They narrowed it down to a 1 page menu. Usually that means everything on the menu will be spectacular. This is not the case here. The bread: sliced half way through. The part that was sliced was soft but the bottom was hard and crunchy. It was served with garlic butter that was more salt than garlic. If you want a salad with your meal you pay extra for it. It was the highlight of the meal. Crisp lettuce, large slices of cheese and a Ceasar dressing that must be made in house. It was very good. I had chicken parmesan. It came with a side of spaghetti. The chicken was really hot when it was served, burn your pallet hot. Food is not cooked this hot so i am thinking maybe it was microwaved. The breading had no spices. The sauce was just crushed tomatoes. Not cooked down to thicken, no spice, just tomatoes and juice. Our server was pretty OK. I think she is the only reason for 2 stars. She was friendly and knowledgeable but I got the idea she isn't happy with the food either. This place has gone way down hill. read more

Olive Cove - Chicken Parmigian - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

The waitress was great, the food hot. The Ceasars salad was okay - hard to mess it up. The ravioli was so bland, the sauce was so flavorless, I added salt and pepper to give it some flavor. The meat inside of the ravioli was also bland. The place is pretty, and played calming music. I am super sad that they don't do the pizza anymore. That was always a hit. read more

See all

Service was great and the entrees were even better. We haven't been here in over a year, and it's even better than I remember. No need to travel over the bridge for a great meal. I had blackened grouper and shrimp with linguine piccata. Dan enjoyed Chicken Marsala. Yum!!! read more

The service was good, but the food was just ok. Not bad, but not great. It wasn't anything to rave about and was kind of bland and lacking seasoning. It's been around 2-3 years since we'd been here and it's definitely not as good as we remembered. We could have cooked much better at home. read more

Olive Cove - Shrimp Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

See all

We ordered two lasagna meals tonight to go. My boyfriend put them in the front seat of his truck and drove them home. As soon as he got home and started inside, the bottom of the bag gave way and both meals hit the pavement. Both containers of lasagna hit the ground. I called and spoke to a manager by the name of Zack. I wanted him to know that either someone had set the bag in something wet or maybe he had a stash of bags that wasn't any good. He was rude and condescending, and even went as far as to tell me that it was my fault that I lost my $44 dinner. It is now sitting in the parking lot at my apartment. Thanks to the way this manager handled the situation. I will never go back to this restaurant again. read more

See all

undercooked pasta, mediocre sauce, and questionable chicken. ew do i need add more? atmosphere nice service absolutely terrible

The sauces are amazing but the food poisoning from being served raw shrimp isn't worth it. I couldn't see it with the sauce last night but this morning it separated. We waited an additional 25 minutes after we were finished eating to get our bill. There wasn't anyone we could flag down because our waitress was in the back. read more

Olive Cove - Raw shrimp - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

After catching a movie nearby it was time for some dinner. My wife typically will navigate while I pilot. She asked," how about Italian?" I was on board as long as it wasn't Olive Garden. As she began to utter her words, I heard olive, and braced for the next word. She then said Cove, I was game. As we pulled up, I know that I had looked at this place while in the area previously. Today was the trial of the many times I've driven by. Walking it we were greeted swiftly and seated equally as fast. This a small place which I was excited about, very pleasant ambiance and attention to detail. We reviewed the menu and the specials that were presented. I have seen Osso Bucco previously on many cooking shows but never ventured into it. Today was that day. My bride also ordered another special dish with chicken. We enjoyed an appetizer before being served that monster meal. See the picture of this dish. This is one of those dishes where you rethink previous choices you have made. Diving into this dish was intimidating until the first bite came in contact with the taste buds. It was a party in my mouth. I highly recommend this place, looking forward to our next visit. read more

Olive Cove - Osso Bucco - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

The food is really delicious. Servers are friendly. Atmosphere lends more toward family style and informal. Yet, can double for a romantic date night. read more

I love this place: The chicken Parmesan is my favorite dish. In my opinion, other places put too much sauce on top. Their pizza was superb but last trip,they had removed it from the. M read more

We've eaten here several times and we'll be enjoying it tonight. . My wife and I have tried several different dishes from the menu and they have all been delicious. The atmosphere is nice, and the service is amazing. The low marks speak for themselves. read more

A really nice restaurant. Very quaint. Not too big and loud. Took my 92 year old parents in laws... and the waiter was so patient. The food was delicious. Got the Chicken Capriso. Dig down to the bottom to get the garlic. The left overs the night after were delicious. One of the better restaurants we've been to in and around Fernandina Beach. Sorry I didn't take any pics of the food bc it smelled so good we just dug in. read more

For being in a strip mall type place in Yulee we were SO IMPRESSED! The marinara sauce and Cesar dressing are 100% homemade, no doubt about it. The food was delectable, made perfectly well, staff was kind and quick, great experience read more

See all

I've been wanting to try Olive Cove for a while now. Waste of time and BIG MONEY. The server had a bad attitude when we came through the door. He pointed his finger to the side seating area and said "anywhere over there." I went to a high top in the middle of the place. He really got an attitude cause I didn't follow the rules. I had Chicken Picatta. It was gooey and most of the pasta noodles were stuck together. The chicken tenders were chewy. It just wasn't good at all. My husband had the lasagna and the sauce was highly acidic. YUK! It's really expensive and is AL-LA-CARTE. I do not recommend OLIVE COVE. Sorry to say but Olive Garden is better. read more

Food had ALOT of garlic so if you don't love garlic make sure you ask them to lower the amount. Also the bread butter is garlic too. Service was good but the wine pours were totally inconsistent. The three tables around us all had different levels with ours being the lowest. I asked my table neighbor if she ordered a double and she said no, so needless to say that irritated me that I had one third of what she had and it was my bday read more

We have eaten here many times over the years. The service has always been great and the food very good. My favorite is the osso buco which is always superb and serving more than ample. read more

My wife and I, eat at The Olive Cove have and have to say we have never been disappointed. Coming from NJ I believe we have experienced some of the best Italian food in the country, and Oliver Cove is right in there with the best of them... food, atmosphere, service, price its all very, very good. tx Tom read more

Food was 10/10 service 10/10, overall great place destiny is great. Food was very quick and fresh tasting very seasoned and ambiance was great loved it over all read more

This is a really good Italian restaurant with really good pizza take out. One day we will eat in and order traditional Italian food read more

Food was very authentic and super tasty! Our waiter was very friendly and interactive with all at our table. Service was spot on, they there when needed. Loved the feeling on the neat setting of the restaurant and it very clean. Very well please read more

Excellent food. Authentic Italian. Plentiful portions. Great service. Definitely a do over again and again.

Their sauce & meatballs were SOooo Yummmmy!!! I just moved to Wildlight will definitely be back. The food was amazing.!!!

Inedible and expensive for what's given. The bread was fine, but there was not enough for a table of 3. The butter accompanying the bread had an overly strong fake garlic flavor. The salads were a joke for the price. The fettuccini Alfredo was average at best - but it was the most edible meal at our table. The shrimp scampi sauce had a horrible fake lemon-juice-from-a-bottle taste and weirdly coated the mouth. The shrimp was crunchy. The chicken Marsala tasted like it was made from a teriyaki sauce powder that was burnt. The chicken was mushy. And to top it off - one glass of (what tasted like barefoot) wine was $12. The service was fine. Don't waste your money here. read more

Olive Cove - Chicken Marsala and shrimp scampi - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida

See all

Went here when we were in town with my husband's parents. Everything was very good. We got the chicken parmesan, manicotti and meatballs, lasagna, and a pasta dish with chicken and goat cheese and sundried tomatoes (can't remember the name). The portions were good sized and had a tons of cheese. My favorite was the pasta with the goat cheese. The meatballs were really good too. We also got red sangria which was great. The only downside is it is a tad pricey. read more

See all

Saw some good reviews on yelp so decided to give it a try. It's hard to find a good Italian restaurant in and around Jax but this place did not disappoint. The place was clean and open. The server was good and very attentive. The tables were wood with a heavy resin coating which made them shine. I had the Chicken Parm and my girl had the Salmon. The Chicken was cooked to perfection and the spaghetti was plentiful. It had the right amount of sauce and I finished the whole thing! The Salmon was flakey and juicy with a good portion. The only thing was they did not have salad. The server said due to health reasons. Over all good. We will return. read more

Delicious! The Olive Cove special dish was beyond my expectation. Visiting from Northeast and had a taste for Italian. Ask about the free dessert after you have your meal. read more

Well, this place is incredible... This little restaurant is a must for Italian food in the area. The food is amazing, the coldest beer in town and the service is a plus one. V our server was amazing and he went out his way to accommodate us. We were passing by on our way to NC, but this place definitely will be on my list. Besos! read more

See all

I went in last night and V was my server. From the beginning he gave exceptional service and made it fun! He's kind, funny and took great care of us! Started with bread and meatballs, they were great and the butter was fantastic! I had the beef ravioli and it was delicious. Very nice atmosphere! Thank you V for the amazing experience! May Jesus bless you! read more

Italian food here in Fernandina Beach is scant in options. Olive Cove is a small, venue. Overall I'd say the food is nothing special, and the service can be good when they're not too busy. They have a tiny in-house wine selection to augment the meal. Dessert was likely the best part of my dining experiences here. They have the most uncomfortable seating with hard wooden benches. They do offer a few pillows. Place seats about 40 people. If you're looking for a basic, no frills experience, that's what you'll find. read more

The service was good. The food is not worth it. I have eaten 2 times both time bad. I will ever going back. Very tasteless food

I have mixed feelings about this place...and would give it 4 stars but my meal was just not good... Also, the hours listed are for takeout. You have to call to ask about dine in seating hours! Its a cute little mom and pop place. The seats arent super comfy but they added foam seat cushions for the hard benches. The server was great! Quick and friendly. When you buy an entree they bring out free bread and a yummy whipped garlic butter. You also get a free salad which has fresh parm and was amazing. If i just rated off these 2 things it would be 5 stars. I got the scampi and it was insanely sour...not sure what it was, too much fake garlic or too much lemon...but I literally had 1 bite and didnt finish it. Will probably be back in a few months to give it another shot but definitely trying alfredo since thats hard to mess up haha read more

See all

Lovely place. We stopped by from a drive by or seeing a semi busy parking lot decided to give it a try. Glad we did. Great food with a calming environment. Feels like you're in someone's grandmothers kitvhe read more

Olive Cove - Linguini scampi and fettuccine Alfredo with blackened chicken - Italian Near Me - Yulee, Florida