Slow service and this is NOT wood fired pizza. I know because my order that was to be ready for pick-up in 20 minutes wasn't done until 35 minutes after the order was placed so I was standing there and watched the cook pull both pizzas from the traditional oven, cut them and put them in the box. The Aloha was a disappointment. Very uneven sauce application - heavy on some slices, almost absent on others. Canned pineapple pieces with no cook/char on them at all. Crust edges were thin and crispy, BUT the edges only. Middle of pizza was NOT fully baked which left it soft/soggy. The Rustica had potential. Good flavor profile, but the soft barely cooked middle and barely melted cheese in the middle were big detractions. Servers seemed very disorganized yet only five tables (out of 14 total) had customers so they were not very busy. DISAPPOINTING! Will not be back. read more

Their pizza, pasta and prices impressed me very well and deliciously. warm, familiar place and very clean, their customer service very good. read more

Arte Pizza - Su menú - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The food was delicious but they put too much tomato sauce on the margarita pizza. The service amazing they let us stay 3 mins after hours. Basic pizzeria. read more

Ordered from Artie's and was deeply disappointed in service quality cost an overall experience. Pizza was fine nothing to write home about a little too expensive The staff from the hostess till the checking out could not have cared less about us having dinner. Long, wait for food with only two other customers in the restaurant slow poor service Sure, there's several other places around much better and watch your tourist read more

Friendly staff, GREAT lunch specials ($), enjoyed sitting outside under shade. The personal size pizza with a side salad was plenty to share and yummy. read more

overpriced and average. service was good but how do you fail at wood fired pizza??? seriously read more

Arte Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We were seated promptly, the restaurant was not busy at 5:30 pm. Ordered a half margarita and half pepperoni and sausage pizza, $24. Two soft drinks, $8 with refills offered. Total bill $34. Up charge if you're paying with a credit card. The pizza had an odd tomato base. The "fire cooked " pizza, well, they had a mock fire oven but it was just for show. Traditional oven used to bake the pizza. My wife did not enjoy her half. Mine was soggy. A disappointing one and done experience read more

There are a growing number of Italian options for NE Florida diners. Arte remains a steadfast location great for casual atmosphere and lots of tasty options. Lasagna is a specialty of mine and Arte's deconstructed version is tasty, interesting and plentiful! You'll never walk away hungry. We had the place to ourselves on this visit. Our server was attentive, even when she remembered she'd forgotten to bring our sangria. Location is great for an Amelia Island shopping outing or for a fun night in with tasty take-away. read more

See all

Arte Pizza has amazing food though they're pepperoni pizza is it the best the rest of their food are outstanding, including the meatballs of the Caesar salad and the spaghetti and meatballs my parents loved their specially pie highly recommend but don't expect out of this world pizza. read more

I used to love this place but recently the music inside is loud and obnoxious. This kind of ruins the dining experience. My waitress was really good. She has only been here a week or so. The food is still good. read more

Phenomenal pizza- one of the best pizza places I've ever been to! Highly recommend! The hot honey pepperoni pizza was out of this world! read more

Arte Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We stopped by Arte's for some pizza, and we had a wonderful experience. The host and server were very nice and quick. We ordered garlic knots, and the caprese appetizers and the garlic knots were so good. They were super fluffy on the inside and crispy on the outside. We also ordered the honey hot pizza and the Bianca Rosa pizza. Both were hot and delicious. There were 4 of us, and we were very hungry and still had leftovers. Inside, you can see the wood fire oven, which is really cool and the wine decor as well. read more

See all

We've lived here for a while and noticed it was rarely busy. Finally tried it the other night and we were really disappointed with the pizza. We ordered with three toppings, which they recited to us when they delivered the pizza to the table. Two ingredients were missing and the third hardly had any. How could the waiter recite the toppings and not see any on the pie??? The crust was burned and not good. We like thin crust but this was like a burned pita. Salads were very good and beer was cold but there are way better pies on the island. We may go back for the salad but not the pizza which BTW was expensive. read more

Great cheese, pizza, great white pizza really pleasant service... we will be back soon

We have been here twice during the week. Have only ever observed one server. Tables remained uncleaned our entire visit. Ordered a large Ceasar salad which cost $17. The salad was a bag of lettuce dumped in a bowl. Much of the lettuce was brown and gross. I should have complained but alas I did not. Mozzarella sticks were clearly frozen and had no taste whatsoever. Pizza was ok but definitely not worth the lack of cleanliness and poor sides. Sadly we won't return. read more

We had the shrimp scampi pizza and a traditional pepperoni pizza. These were some of the best pizzas we've had in a long time. The atmosphere was warm and inviting (especially on a cold, rainy night) and our waiter was friendly and attentive. We're glad we made the choice to stop in. read more

Arte Pizza - Shrimp scampi pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Arte's is a good pizzeria, despite staffing shortages when we ate there. Unfortunately, there were only three people on duty in the whole restaurant while we were there. Despite the wait, the food was great. Pizza had very fresh ingredients and was cooked just right. Don't let the wait deter you. The pizza is worth the wait! read more

Pizza overpriced and dripping with oil and lacking taste - not what it was just a few years ago

This use to be my favorite pizza spot. Recently visited there and was sadly surprised when the server broughtmy pizza to the table. It looked uncooked! He noticed the look on my face and began to apologize. He said they cook called in sick and a new kid was making pizza's. He immediately said he'd have him remake it. Definitely didnt touch a wood oven at all... Tasted like a thin crust Degorno from Publix. Next went to use the bathroom and absolutely disgusting. If I would have went to the bathrooms before eating I wouldn't have ordered and just left. Sad this place went downhill, it use to be so good... They need to change the name to NOt WOOd fired!! read more

See all

I ordered online for pickup and my order was ready when I arrived. Service was prompt and friendly. The beet salad was amazing! I was not expecting it to be so large. It was loaded with beets, walnuts and cheese. I would definitely ordered again. read more

Food was very good and Jimmy was what made the experience worth it. He was a great waiter. I think the hostess needs to at least make believe she's happy as she was very annoyed at a large table. Jimmy was engaging, funny and made the experience great He made sure our drinks were filled , orders were correct and we were all happy. read more

Do not go here We sat outside and everything was fine at first. Ordered two dishes- one being gluten free. After about 30 minutes our server came to us apologizing for the wait on our food and that it would be out in 5 minutes, we said all good we understand. While waiting for our food we found there was food stuck on the silverware that was given to us. After nearly an hour we got up to just leave, we went up to one of the servers and showed him the dirty fork and he said "it's fine" and took it away like it was no big deal. He told us the GF pasta can take almost an hour (for real?). We asked for a manager several times and were told there was no manager, the staff was super rude and unhelpful, and didn't care at all that we were waiting a very long time for our food and also were given dirty silverware. I would not recommend this place at all and we won't be coming back read more

OMG this used to be our go to ever time we came to the island. No longer. Somehow a margarita pizza turned into a slop fest of oil, raw garlic ( WAY to much garlic I'm still burping it two hours later. ) the mots was good but it was overwhelmed by GARLIC. and some basil. I wouldn't complain about a $50.00 tab if it was as good as it used to be (a large with a beer and a couple house wines) Took the leftovers but will probably pitch in a day or so. read more

Arte Pizza - Oily leftovers with too much garlic - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Food and service were excellent. My wife and I split a meatball sub with fries and a Cesar salad. Meatballs were delicious and the fries were very tasty. Kids had spaghetti and meatballs and a pizza. I tried the pizza and it was great. Food portions were very generous. Highly recommend. read more

STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE!!!!!! I got food poisoning from this place. Food stuck on silverware and tables were sticky...we had a heavy set waiter in his 40's that was so RUDE when we mentioned it to him. The food was very low budget food and they don't have a real fire oven it's all cooked in the oven.... Just disgusting read more

Thank you so much for having us today for lunch! We loved the pizza and Mac and Cheese was dreamy. Kaeylnn was an excellent waitress. So kind and understanding with our hungry crew! read more

Arte Pizza - Meat lovers pizza. Amazing. - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Sunday 9/13 8:30pm Takeout Fernandina Beach rolls up the sidewalks very early on Sundays, even in the summer. After a busy day exploring the island and shopping, we wanted a pizza to take back to the rental. Some places were closed, one had oven issues, we kept striking out. I hesitantly called Arte Pizza because they were closing in 30 minutes, I was afraid my order would be refused so close to closing. . The waiter who answered the phone said no problem! We ordered the 16" Della Carni ($20), garlic knots ($10) and desserts ($7 each). The waiter said our order would be ready in 15 minutes! I was surprised that it would be so fast! I would have waited hours for this pizza! It was incredible! The crust is nice and thin but it held up to the abundance of meat toppings! The sauce, cheese and toppings were top quality. Garlic knots were fluffy with loads of fresh garlic and butter. Now for the desserts! After a couple pizza slices, we had to hold the desserts for the next day's breakfast. My tiramisu was definitely one of the best I've ever had. The lady fingers were soaked in plenty of coffee and the marscapone cheese/cream was fluffy and flavorful. The cheesecake was not only delicious but decorative too. In addition to the next pizza in FB, Arte's has pasta, paninis and salads. Great Wall of wine to fine your perfect pairing. Indoor and outdoor seating, inviting decor. Arte Pizza is a must stop! read more

See all

Without a doubt the best pizza in Fernandina. I know that's not saying much, but it is good. It is expensive, but still worth it if you want a decent pizza in this town. read more

The food was amazing. We ordered garlic knots and were surprised when we were served fried dough knots with garlic butter drizzle . It was delicious. Pizza crust thin and crispy which is what I like! read more

Love it. Nicest staff/service. The pizza is delicious. Nice atmosphere. Comfortable and pleasant.

First time visiting Arte Pizza, and we weren't disappointed. We ordered a pizza and it was delicious. Even looking at other food that was being served, everything looked very good. Our server, Lisa, was very helpful and checked back with us often to ensure we had everything we needed. We are here for a bit longer and will definitely be back for sure. read more

Arte Pizza - Calabresa pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We decided to skip seafood for our last dinner before returning home from vacation (seafood every day for a week). We decided on pizza and are convinced we made a great decision in choosing Arte Pizza. The fact that it is baked in a wood fired oven suggests it's going to be good! We started with the small Amalfi salad: fresh spinach, walnuts, cranberries, corn, gorgonzola & balsamic vinaigrette--it was different and delicious. We then had the chefs pizza and it was fabulous. Our waiter, Jimmy, had a wonderful personality, was knowledgeable and did a terrific job catering to our requests or needs. We highly recommend this place for when you want a switch from having seafood at the beach. read more

See all

We ate here several years ago and were not happy with our meal, but recently had a great dinner here with our neighbors. We are both from NJ and have high standards for pizza. We ordered 2 different kinds and both were excellent - thin crust and plentiful toppings. We also ordered delicious garlic knots that were served with parmesan cheese and marinara sauce. Our neighbor said he thought they were the best garlic knots he's ever had. Service was friendly and prompt. We are adding Arte Pizza into our regular rotation of restaurants in the future! read more

The Pizza was delicious with fresh ingredients. The ambiance is fair and the waiter was nice.

Our server was so kind and knowledgeable about the food on the menu and the wines. I had a glass of Prosecco and my husband ordered a Malbec. She brought my little lady pizza dough to play with and talked to my older girly about what she was sketching in her sketchbook. We ordered a few things for the table to share. 1. Meatball appetizers. 2. The Amalfi salad with shrimp. 3. Spaghetti and meatballs (I know, more meatballs). 4. Chef's pizza (subbed ricotta for feta). The meatballs were fantastic. The sauce they were served in was the perfect consistency, and seasoned beautifully. They were topped with shreds of fresh basil, which I think makes everything better. The salad was a pleasant surprise. So often you order a salad out, thinking it would be nice to have some greens, and it leaves much to be desired, so when I find a salad that is fulfilling, I get really excited. This salad was so thoughtfully built, complete with Gorgonzola, walnuts, dried cherries, and a balsamic dressing. Perfection. I did not try the spaghetti, but my kids loved it. It was topped with the same meatballs and sauce (and fresh basil) as the appetizer. My five-year-old almost made herself sick on the meatballs, because she couldn't stop. The pizza. Holy wood fired spirits rejoice. Order the 16 inch if you love leftover pizza like I do. I was delighted that they let me swap the feta out and add ricotta. Ricotta on pizza is my love language. The crust was delightfully crisp, but not falling apart. The sauce, which I believe was the same as what was on the meatballs, was the perfect amount of tang to compliment the ricotta. More fresh basil (yes yes yes). I'm not generally into "meat lovers" pizzas, but the pepperoni and crumbly sausage did not disappoint. The only sad part of our experience was that we were too full for dessert. I had my eye on the tiramisu...we will have to stop back in. read more

Arte Pizza - My kid eating a meatball the only way a kid should eat a meatball. And the chefs pizza, minus feta, add ricotta. - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The pizza was really bad...tasted like burned cardboard. It looked good but that first bite was so nasty. The garlic knots were okay, soaked in oil/butter but the mozzarella sticks were gross and plasticy tasting. Better off with a frozen pizza at home. read more

Arte Pizza - Terrible margarita pizza, tasted like burned cardboard - Pizza Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Fabulous pizza & the salads are huge!! Everything is fresh. Service is awesome!! Quick & very pleasant. Can't say enough good about this place. Don't sleep on it if you actually appreciate wood fired pizza. read more

Finally tried Arte. We ordered a pizza, and salad to go. It was way too crowded to eat inside, plus the wait was long to get a table and longer to get food. As I understand it, they are usually very crowded, but with the current Covid issues, the service was impacted. The Della Carni pizza was great, and the Mista salad was large and delicious. read more

We were very happy to find a real wood fired oven pizza shop on Amelia Island. The food was outstanding. Really enjoyed both our pizza and salads. Portion size was nice and big. Our server was wonderful too. It was busy so we expected to wait a little, but we were pleasantly surprised by the service. read more

Don't let the sour smell fool you when you walk in; it may smell funny but the food is amazing! The apps were on point and the main courses were equally amazing. Joey, our host and waiter was awesome! This was honestly one of the best restaurants in Fernandina beach and we will come back every single time we are in town! read more

See all