Just discovered Oliver's Sandwiches in Milton and WOW I tried the lobster sandwich and it was hands down one of the best sandwiches I've ever had--fresh, flavorful, and packed perfectly. It was so good I literally came back the next day to try another one... and it did NOT disappoint! If you're anywhere nearby, it's absolutely worth the drive Highly recommend! read more

Wait time was pretty long for a Thursday around 1pm but the Oliver burger was really tasty- minus mayo, pickles and onions. There was some salty taste I think came from the burger but the rest was very tasty. I was super impressed how unsalted the fries were and they were cooked perfectly. Salty fries can ruin a meal and hours later you're drinking from a fire hose to manage the salty aftermath. Not these fries- they were crispy, golden, crunchy and not salty. My only issue was how long it took to get the food at 1pm on a Thursday- it was over 30 minutes. read more

See all

Bad service Food ok Price high Takes long time Wasting time here hand, food sloppy you never know what you're gonna get read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - No servicio - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

Was driving to visit my son and thought "ohhhh gotta stop at that great sandwich place again". Glad I did, got the Rocket and it was my bad for not inquiring what the horsey sauce was, but now I know it is horseradish sauce and it is not my favorite. The sandwich was great and I got fries too, which were really good. They had a lot of takeout orders and it did take awhile to get food. Staff was friendly and very nice! read more

See all

I drove over 25 minutes each way from Puyallup to Edgewood to try Oliver's sandwiches. I made sure to check the hours online, and it stated it was open! After arriving, the restaurant was closed and there was a sign on the door stating the restaurant would be closed July 26th through August 29th (seen below). Which would be no problem at all, except today is July 6th (20 days prior to advertised closing day) and the website says open! Please update the website so as to not waste peoples time! read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Website advertising open - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

See all

We decided to order from Door dash, the app said an hour which was fine with us. However, the driver waited for almost 90 minutes for them to make two sandwiches. Seriously. My hubs ordered the Gladiator which was huge, tons of filling and on a really thick roll. He said it was good but too much bread. I ordered a turkey, cranberry and cream cheese with tomato. Should have been amazing but there was one small slice of turkey and that was it and way too much bread for the sandwich. The taste was good, but took way too long to make, 90 minutes even on a busy evening when we ordered ahead is just wrong and I felt badly for the driver who just had to stand there. Then mine with minimal filling was disappointing. Way too much bread, they should either make the sandwiches on smaller rolls or give you an option to have bread instead. We won't be going back. read more

I thought I didn't like sandwiches. I have been in here twice and if I could make sandwiches this good I would eat them all the time. Very very good. I had the basic turkey and some kind of combo with a blue cheese / horsey sauce and OMG. They are going to be closed basically for the month of August 2026 for a family vacation. I hope they have a great vacation ! read more

I ordered the Oliver Special sandwich and saw a few reviews mentioning too much bread on their sandwiches, so I opted for sliced wheat instead. Paired it with a cup of chili--both were solid choices! At first, I thought the sandwich was a bit sweet because of the honey mustard, but after a few bites, I realized it balanced perfectly with the onions. The chili was tasty, though I do wish the serving size was a little bigger for the price. Still, no complaints about the flavor! This place was BUSY when I went, which makes sense--it was peak lunch hour. That's always a good sign, though! I placed my order, then walked around the Dollar Tree for about 30 minutes before coming back. Next time, I'll try to avoid the noon rush, but I'll definitely return. read more

See all

no napkins; messy sandwich. why??? seriously like its a 2 go order meaning i need 2GO outside of the the restaurant where thrre is no utensils or napkins. as far as the sandwich goes its pretty okay. just standard sandwiches. i might be really up my ass saying this but i swear this is all gotta be sourced from costco which nothing necessarily wrong with that until u think about how its 22 dollars for one sandwich with fries and a drink. yeah no im good read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

See all

Still pissed about the Attitude and resolution to a simple issue.When the customer say's (Bacon on the side) just what does that mean ? The answer as I stated previously given by the owner,(just take the bacon off ).I won't cross threshold threshold again. Double check your purchase they won't honor with a customer is always right policy. read more

The food and service was great. I had the Oliver Special. Massive amount of meat to bread ratio. My son had the French dip and he was also quite pleased. read more

The sandwich was definitely not the kind of sandwich you get at sandwich shops. It had more substance. The staff was friendly and the place was clean. I would recommend stopping by! read more

Top sandwich place in Washington! Owners are so friendly, everything they use is fresh! I tried many places around the area but non can be compared to this place! MUST TRY! read more

Great place to get a Philly cheesesteak sandwich. They make it fresh while you're there, the bun is soft with a little crisp, and the meat and flavor is super good. read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Classic Philly Steak with lettuce and tomato on half. It normally has no lettuce or tomato - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

Been seeing reviews raving about this place so I ordered their philly cheesesteak for delivery. I got chipotle sauce on the side and I didn't really like it but their philly was very juicy and I loved the mushrooms on it. Super super cheesy! It was very good but I really want to try their other sandwiches... will be updating this review soon read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Philly Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

Excellent sandwiches- good variety. Can get crowded at lunchtime but worth the wait.

This place was recommend to us and we were excited to try it. Very disappointed on the sandwiches. I ordered the Hot Pastrami and my Husband had the Roast Beef with Au jus. First of all there was more bread then meat and the photos show it. The meat had great taste but the bread was very dry and not worth $25 for 2 -8" subs. We would rather go to Subway. We won't be back and we won't recommend Oliver's. read more

See all

I'm not sure how long this place has been here, but I am no stranger to the area. I've been to several of the restaurants on this block as well as shopped at local stores. I heard about Oliver's after doing a local sandwich search. A friend was raving about a place near Auburn, but as it turned out, the place he was recommending ended up being a different spot. That said, Oliver's had an impressive menu, prices also appeared to be reasonable and last, reviews were overwhelmingly positive. This place appeared to be family run, and the proprietor appeared to be Oliver, which is actually the name of the sandwich I selected. Now, this is where the wheels came off the cart for me. Most sandwich shops and certainly the smart ones make the sandwich with you, I like that, because if I want more tomatoes, onion or mayo, I can correct that in real time. Not here, she just asked if everything was ok and I said yes. I like a cold deli sub, so when it came toasted, I wasn't pleased. I didn't see anywhere where that was advertised, but since the place appeared to have possibly been a Quiznos at one time, I should have guessed. No complaints on the amount of toppings, but I would have asked for more mayo, had I actually seen the sandwich been made. Last, and seriously one reason I chose the Oliver, it came with sprouts, and I love sprouts on a sub, however, there wasn't a single sprout on my sandwich, and again, noting was said to explain this. I don't know if this is the case, but I was at a bagel place several years back and asked for sprouts on my sandwich and they told me the health Department banned Sprouts from sandwich shops, I think it had something to do with an E-coli outbreak. Again, this was like 7 years back, so worth case scenario, your menu should be updated, or you should advise sprouts aren't available and allow a vegie substitution. To the point, I'd chose Jersey Mikes over this any day, however if this place was in my neighborhood, I'd try them again. The menu was so rich, it's possible I would have liked another sandwich better. No problem with the people, but the sandwich didn't blow me away. I could have made a better sandwich myself after stopping at any grocers deli counter. read more

Excellent grilled pastrami and swiss on rye. Will buy again and try other sandwiches.

Great service and great sandwiches. Prople really like Oliver's fries. Im just adding this brcause this app requires 85 characters or more. read more

Always on point here! Best sandwiches! Lovely staff and great service. Get you a sandwich at Oliver's! Go feed your You.

Always delicious! Kind owners. Well made with fresh ingredients. Perfect spot for lunch! Good energy and clean space.

If you have not tried this place do yourself a favor. Bring your appetite. Incredible sandwiches. This is a go to place.

Best little sandwich shop around I've been here a few times philly cheese steak are my favorite really fresh ingredients only recommendation I would give is maybe change the bun to one that holds up better to the juices they are so good that I don't mind the mess read more

Amazing Straight to the point Bomb must go Friday vibes! Top notch of great sandwiches and many other options Going back today ok read more

See all

Come here all the time, the sandwiches are huge! My boyfriend loves the gladiator and I always get a cheesesteak, absolutely delicious with the fries. read more

I was out running errands and didn't want fast food but I wanted food fast. Lol I remember seeing Olivers when I would shop at Safeway. I looked up the reviews, liked what I saw and ventured in the establishment. It was busy but the lady that made my Turkey Bacon Avocado was very nice. Took my order and it was ready shortly afterwards. I didn't get to eat it right away but it was AMAZING. I think the honey mustard dressing just made a difference or something. I highly recommend this place and that sandwich. Going back to try others. read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Turkey Bacon Avocado on toasted sour dough - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

See all

Friendly staff, small eating area that was very busy. Sandwiches are good, the bread to filling ratio is a little heavy ton the bread side, but price and everything align. Good spot. read more

These reviews are extremely misleading. I went to Oliver's today and I got an over priced sandwich + FOOD POISONING!!! Why has no one mentioned how filthy this business is ?! The walls have thick layers of dust on them, the floors haven't been mopped in who knows how long. They have some deodorizer to cover up the stench (my clothes smelt like it after being there for 10 mins). Nothing was covered on the sandwich bar. Sauces were not refrigerated, and the toppings weren't either. The trash was overflowing. Everything was sooooo filthy!!! Absolutely disgusting. They're lucky they're not in King County. The health department would shut this business down so fast. The owners/employees were so rude and do not appreciate the customer, nor the business. I truly made a mistake by visiting this place today. I should have never ate here, and I wouldn't recommend anyone else doing so either... read more

Great sandwiches. Big menu. Great ingredients. They make a lot of different types of sandwiches

Almost tasted like the day old Bread at Safeway next door and common ingredients from Safeway as well. not busy and not that good for a long wait. read more

They have great fresh sandwiches! Love the reuben and meatball sandwiches . Can get busy and slow but fresh and definitely worth it !

Great food, always very pleased with my order and the taste/quality. Way better than any other Sandwich shop I've tried. Staff is very friendly. It takes a little while for food to be made, but I highly recommend this place! read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Meat Lover Sandwich + bacon, French Fries and blueberry Bubble Tea - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

Have never had a bad experience here. The owners are friendly and make some great sandwiches. The restaurant is clean and although it is small, it works. We usually take ours to go anyway! I highly recommend this sandwich shop! read more

This is the best sandwich shop hands down! We explored a large menu of unique sandwiches, with items for every palette, from meat eater to vegetarian. We had the Harasser on bread and the veggie on a wrap (with mushroom and avocado). The amount of product on the sandwich is enormous and the taste is wonderful. These people KNOW sandwiches and they make Jersey Mike's and Subway look like they are skimping on both product and flavor! When in the Tacoma area go to Oliver's! read more

Winner winner roast beef dinner... well lunch, but still. SO GOOD! I have been craving a really good sandwich and I'm very happy the subway (in the area) was gone.. because I found this little gem! It was busy, because lunch time. But they were fast and friendly, I will be back! MMMMMmmmmm sourdough and roast beef read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Roast beef and cheddar, untoasted on sourdough. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

New found fav place to eat! They can make your sandwich whichever way you want! Place is nice and clean... never empty but always have a spot to eat in. read more

Oliver's Sandwiches - Turkey cranberry and philly cheese... fries is perfectly done! - Sandwiches Near Me - Milton, Washington

Great Food and Great Price. Fast, easy service with friendly staff. Their sandwiches are delicious. Would come back.

This review is for a delivery experience that I had today! Oliver's Sandwiches has been on my radar for a long time - not because of the stellar reviews or the mouthwatering photos... But because my son's name is Oliver. I mean, come on. It was a must try for me! Ordering for delivery was very easy and I was blown away at the selection. Such a large menu with options for everyone! I ended up wanting to try the Spicy Turkey Wrap, sans tomatoes. The food was delivered quickly and the order was correct - I can't tell you how many times I've asked for no tomatoes on something and STILL get them (gross). From first glance I could tell right away how fresh the veggies were - the romaine and avocado were perfect! So good! The spicy sauce was okay, nothing to write home about. But it did add a nice kick in conjunction with the pepperoncinis. I was expecting it to have a bit more depth to it, but it was still good. Another fact worth noting is that Oliver's Sandwiches is incredibly affordable for the quality and quantity of food that you get. Definitely a solid option for lunch or dinner. I'll definitely be giving Oliver's another try - the menu is way too impressive not to, and their grilled cheese sandwiches look out of this world. That's probably next with an in-person visit! read more

I've been going to Oliver's for years. They've never disappointed. They always have a large selection of different sandwiches and whatever I end up ordering, it always taste great. The service is great and they're fast. One of my favorite local sandwich places. read more