This is one of THE best places to eat in Mayport. It's also the BEST Greek restaurant in all of the beaches. I love walking in and seeing all the cookware out on the countertops - knowing the food is all prepared fresh is so refreshing. Everything from the pizzas, wings, and gyros are amazing. Can't recommend Olympia enough! read more

Best gyro EVER! Meaty and juicy with a tzatziki sauce that is the tastiest I've had. I'll be back for more! read more

The place doesn't look the best but that's normally where the good food is. That lunch gyro wins everyday.

Unbelievably rude staff!!! I went in today and ordered a gyro platter. I asked the gentleman taking my order if I could substitute another salad for the fries and he said yes.. when my order came out i got one salad and my gyro but no fries and no other salad .. I asked another gentleman there about my 2nd salad and he said "I know I know I know". Which by the way is rude and not how you speak to customers. They bring out my salad and we pack up my leftovers and leave .. the rude "I know" man came out after me and said you didn't pay for the 2nd salad. I told him it was part of my platter he said he told me he didn't charge you for it. Which I did pay the platter price. He went back in and came out again aggressive towards me and I said let me just give you the salad back. He walked away spattering on his way in. Didn't even have the ability to speak his words to me.. very unfortunate because we liked our food. But they will never treat me like this again. read more

Food was very filling. Pizza was hot and loaded with cheese. Wings were yummy although slightly chewy. I would not recommend the fountain drinks. Very nice staff though, seems family owned. read more

Olympia Cafe - Large 1 Topping Pizza and 10 Wings Special - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Best Gyro Sandwich in town hands down!! This place always delivers the freshest and tastiest food. I drive 30 minutes to just eat their food. Excellent Greek food. Highly recommend. read more

Olympia Cafe - Best Gyro Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I have been 2x and ordered the same thing... Gyro. Best in town and I have to drive a bit for it but worth every mile. read more

Perfect lunch spot to go to with co-workers! The gyros are stuffed to the brim, but fret not - your fork will help you complete your gorge session. You can't go wrong here. read more

I got an outstanding wrap here. It was fresh, big, and loaded. It took a little while but it was well worth the quality it turned out to be. I've ordered both the chicken and the lamb Gyro and they were filled to the brim! Fed me for the day:) read more

I ordered an extra cheese and pepperoni pizza, and I received a already cooked cheese pizza with extra cheese sprinkled on top and pepperoni that was thrown back into the oven and reheated highly do not recommend this place! read more

Olympia Cafe - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Ordered from DoorDash! Food was so tasty. Got the gyro sandwich and a Greek isle salad. The sandwich is huge and the sauce was delicious. I'm craving some more. read more

Olympia Cafe - Greek Isle Salad, Gyros Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I wasn't very happy with my order tonight. I get charged for a sandwich that's supposed to come with fries and there none and the other sandwich I order comes with the smallest amount of fries like it was for a child . And my food wasn't even hot. I'm not very pleased with my experience. read more

This is the best food in Jacksonville! Great service and best Greek food in the area. The staff is so kind and helpful, and the portions are huge. I definitely recommend trying them out! read more

This little hole in the wall was surprisingly very good! The lamb in the gyro was delish-just wish there was a little more tzatziki. So glad to have some Greek food close to home! And they have free delivery! read more

Favorite stop to go for lunch! They give good portions! It's a small mom and pop place but it's clean and they are very welcoming. I literally tell all my coworkers to go here. I hope they're getting the business they deserve. read more

Called To see if so grape leaves were fresh made in house which was reply yes but sure did taste like out of a can you don't serve that to a Greek, Ordered lamb and got processed meat. It was a Monday maybe the owners were off Spent $35 I was very disappointing read more

Hands down the best gyros in and around mayport. Olympia is a hidden gem on mayport road. It's in a plaza and when I talk to people about it they have no clue it is here. GET THE WORD OUT. Their gyros are amazing. The pizza is pretty good as well. They cook the lamb classically right behind the counter and give everything that signature Mediterranean touch. The location is small, seating for about 20 people but I have never had a wait at lunch time. This is a small family owned and operated business. Pricing is average. About $9 for gyro, fries and a soda, but the portions are huge and you certainly won't leave hungry. If you are like so many others and haven't checked out Olympia Cafe, I suggest that you do. read more

Great Greek Food - got takeout due to pandemic. Online ordering went well. Ready earlier than predicted. Everything delicious. Spinach pie - a little soggy, loses its filo dough flakiness w/takeout but taste is good. Greek salad delicious. Lamp gyro meat tender. And taziki sauce Best anywhere! Be prepared - a little steamy & close feeling in this small place. Owners not wearing masks. Still looking pretty busy in there at late lunchtime. One star off for loosening covid restrictions, retirees from out of state - will Not eat inside restaurants in FL! read more

Amazing food and a very friendly staff. The chicken Caesar wrap and hummus was off the charts!!

Today my coworkers and I went for lunch to Olympia Cafe. I was excited since I have gone there once in the past and it was a good experience. Today I asked for a Philly cheese steak. I arrived with an appetite and as I was down to about 3 bites left, almost finished I felt steel wire in my chew. Yuck! Luckily for me I eat fast BUT I do Chew my food. I felt this I spit it in a napkin and There I see Steel Wool Like from a wire brush perhaps used to clean the grill got mixed in the meat when making the Philly sandwich. So, I decide to discreetly inform the gentlemen, in the Counter who appeared to be InCharge or owner. I said Excuse me sir I wanted to show you what I found on my food, luckily, I didn't swallow it. Please tell your cook to be careful when cleaning the grill. I showed him and his response blew me away. No care in the world looked at me as if I had made this all up and instead of apologizing, he went on by saying; oh, I don't know where that came from it wasn't my grill because we don't use wire brushes to clean the grill."! Me being a retired navy and spent tour on the Mess decks I know what I saw! He is so lucky I went to church this past Sunday and reminded myself don't flip out or overreact. God doesn't like ugly. So, I had no other choice than to write this ugly review. Disregarded my complaint and its seriousness. I will NEVER go again! I did not ask for my money back or anything free all I hope was for an apology and that this won't happen again to no one else. read more

my first visit today, i've been wanting to come for awhile now based on the reviews. I wasnt disappointed with the food, service and location. The cafe seats plenty, but we decided to carry out. We placed our order for 2 gyro sandwiches, gyro platter, onion rings and chicken tenders. Everything was fabulous - the portions are more than i expected for all the items - gyro, fries and onion rings! Everything was very good and fresh, i would have to say its the best that I've had so far. The pricing is also very reasonable. We didnt wait long at all for our order and the owner even ran out to my car to give me a few condiments. I will definately recommend and come back to try their pizzas and other sandwiches! read more

Good things come in small packages. This strip mall restaurant is a great find. Pizza was excellent, as was my souvlaki platter. Clean, unpretentious interior fits well with the beach attitude. Shorts and slippers fit right in. The staff was great! My wife is gluten intolerant, the staff were very helpful in choosing dishes for her. She ended up having the dolmades, Greek salad, and hummus (sub cucumber instead of pita), all of which she enjoyed. We'll be back! read more

Delicious!! I ordered the gyro plate, plentiful and very good. The gyro meat was perfect, great tzatziki sauce. They were making a calzone when we left; I'm getting that next. Oh, and the baklava was perfect. read more

Very, very good! The service was professional and prompt. The food was fresh and delicious. I will be back. The Gyro special was tasty and reasonably priced. The grape leaves and tzatziki sauce was some of the best I ever had... Try this little hole in the wall, you won't be disappointed.. read more

Best spot in the area. The fact it's been around so many years should be proof enough. It's always delicious and my favorite thing is to turn new people onto it. It's a hole in the wall so one doesn't know about it unless they know about. read more

Pizza and wings were horrible..$31....wings were so dry they were jerky...pizza overcooked....only starving dogs appreciated it.

Juiciest wings I've had in a long time! And the gyro is amazing too and also their pizza. Good customer service as well. read more

Olympia Cafe - Love these Cajun ranch wings! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Very good cheap New York style pizza! It took a while to come out, made sense as they did have to make a pizza. Very "hole in the wall" feeling, in the best way possible. read more

This is the third time I've ordered from Olympia Cafe. The first time I tried a gyro. Never again as the lamb was so dry. Very disappointed. Then my neighbor told me to only order pizza. So the second time that's what I did and it was good. This time I ordered pizza, Greek salad and baklava. All of which were very tasty. Just don't try the sandwiches and you will be happy read more

Olympia Cafe - Pizza with mushrooms, onions and sausage and Greek salad...tasty! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Excellent quality Greek food. So delicious! Everything we've gotten here is delicious and the owners are very nice! Superb Stromboli, calzone, pizza, salad, and very delicious baklava that is not too sweet and is authentic read more

I cannot say enough good stuff about Olympia Cafe. I cannot tell you much about the menu because ever since they opened, I started eating their calzones and cannot bring myself to order something different. Usually. On the rare occasion over the past 10-15 years I've ordered the Chicken Gyro Platter (very good), the pizza (really great crust and sauce and that is what makes a pizza stand out to me). But their calzones....one calzone is 3 meals for me. I order extra sauce because it's so yummy. I also love their tatziki sauce. So flavorful and loaded with garlic. I usually order pita and tatziki and get extra tatziki to dip carrots, etc. The people there are super friendly also. I never eat in but last night, my meal was delivered within 35 minutes. Amazingly fast for a Saturday night. read more

Ive been eating everywhere to find the best gyro in jacksonville n this by far the best. Located right across from shell gas station on mayport Rd. This place is cheap! Its $5 something for a meal. Comes with a big gyro with fries n a drink. They also serve and deliver pizza. It's close to the navy base and so there's lots of military people that eat lunch here in uniform. Yes u can ask them to take pix with u. There was this one time n one thing that I didn't like..... The ketchup! I tasted the old ketchup mixed with the new ketchup kuz they put it in a squeezable bottle. Ummm. Thats about it. Overall, thumbs up for this place! read more

See all

Fantastic pizza and wonderful service! I'm definitely coming back whenever I'm on this side of town, the mozzarella sticks are to die for!

Always perfect. Anything we order is hot and fresh and tastes amazing. We only order pizza from here anymore!

First time trying their pizza, bought a large pepperoni pizza for $11...amazing thin and large slices. Called ahead and pizza was ready in less then 15 minutes. This will be my pizza spot from now on! read more

Had a great dinner clean friendly environment New owners but to me it is better Great value sure didn't leave hungry Highly recommend will be back for lunch they Have gizzards read more

Good Pizza but something about this place and Papa John's really activates me innerds. The girl at the register is Fun and Quirky and has a great personality for being at the front and making you a regular customer. I Will try something else next time i go. read more

Stopped by thanks to Yelp, my boyfriend loves Gyros and I wanted Pizza so it was perfect. It was a friendly environment, it looks like a family owned restaurant. I got two slices of pepperoni pizza, we sat down, the soccer game was on and they had it on the tv. They brought us our food and like I said, it's delicious! The only downside to the restaurant was the soda fountain machine, it was really dirty on the outside. read more

I had a hankering for gyros and was headed to Arby's for their 2 for $6 gyro special until I remembered about this place. I'm so glad I stopped by. Their gyro value meal is such a bargain for $8.95. It comes with a fluffy pita with your choice of lamb or chicken gyro meat, lettuce, tomato, onion and tzatziki sauce. It was huge! I chose the lamb and thoroughly enjoyed it. While I was there a few people stopped by to pick up pizza orders. I'll be sure to try one of their pies next time. read more

Olympia Cafe - Gyro special for $8.95. It was ginormous! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Food was really good but a little too simple. We got the gyros and they were large and tasty but didn't have any cucumbers, feta and very little tzatziki. We added two extra large sides of tzatziki and it was really good. Service was casual but good. The pizzas that came out of the over while we were there smelled and looked good. We will definitely be back, but might have feta at the house to add to the gyros and feta is awesome on fries. read more