Just visited. The buffalo chicken sandwich was dry with what tasted like mayonaise with blue cheese crumbs. The Saz's sandwich had more sauce than meat. The tomatoes were mealy. For desert we got a pineapple sundae but the pineapple topping was flavorless and my 6 year old claimed it tasted like "wine". The much anticipated pumpkin pie shake also did not receive a positive review. Very very disappointing. read more

This is the most amazing custard ever. I grew up not far from here and a lot of my favorite memories as a child involve going here. This custard is out of this world and totally inexpensive as well. The waffle cones are totally delish as are the raspberry malts. I love badger claw and any of the fruity flavors. Oscars I heart you!!! :) read more

Kopp's, Culver's, and all of the other custard places don't have anything on this place. I always make a point to go while I'm in town. My only complaint is that they don't have the chocolate-covered cherry (best flavor ever!) nearly as often as they should. They should make it available at all times, rather than just as a flavor of the day. Oh, and the scrolling marquee sign on Hwy 100 always has way too much info on it and scrolls too slow, so it's hard to see what the flavor of the day is when driving by. Make it scroll faster or else put less information on it. read more

Came for much anticipated flavor of the day Rocky Road, it was NOT Rocky Road! Not one marshmallow! Very disappointed! Saved calories all week for nothing! read more

Oscar's Frozen Custard - I bought a cone with the cup that's why there isn't much in the cup! There were not any marshmallows! This was choc w few nuts! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The Best Custard in Town! I've been to several of the other custard places in Milwaukee and they are good, but this is the best. This is my go to summer "ice-Cream" stop. read more

My favorite go to custard place. My mom who is really picky about everything regularly reuqests to come here whenever she is in town. Not all their flavors are the best (for example drumstick I would pass on as it's literally just chunks of the regular cone crushed into a custard and tastes nothing like a drumstick) but in general their custard tastes great, even the regular flavors. I just wish they cycled the flavors a little better. I almost never get any flavors I like on the weekend when I can actually stop by. I also rarely ever have to wait very long which is nice. read more

Food is good. Lots of immature workers. I went in there and one of the workers kept saying "yaas suh" to his co workers while laughing like he was mocking a slave. Not my first encounter with the rudeness there. A few nice ones but if you're not white you may not enjoy the atmosphere. read more

Yum! I had the Badger Claw frozen custard: Vanilla with hard shelled chocolate with Pecans added in. I think this place is just as good if not, better than Kopps. read more

Yet another of the ubiquitous custard stands of Milwaukee... Honestly, for the most part, I can't tell the various custards apart--except when eating a spoonful from each place one after the other... But then I forget which is which, and end up choosing custard venue based on what else I want to eat there. This particular Oscar's is very old-timey, and has hamburgers, chicken-breast-filet sandwiches, and fries to go along with its sweet goodness, and, according to my gut, is about the best of the fast food you'll get with your unique daily flavor, sundae, or malt (i.e. minimal heartburn). read more

The custard here is great, especially in the chocolate malt! The burgers are better than most fast food chains for about the same price. The inside of the place has sort of an outdated 80's look, but I kind of like it. Overall, a good place to eat for a decent price; and a great place for frozen custard! read more

Drove 34 miles to come here last night and then was told they did not take debit card or any other form but cash which I thought was strange for a business these days. After we went back from gettin cash two of our ordered where messed up and the gentleman did not like the fact of having to redo it. The custard was good but believe there service could be better read more

Standard MKE custard stand. All you'd expect to get is there. As with most of these places the custard is the star, food is secondary and usually nothing special but does the trick. read more

I love, love love, custard. I come here at least 3 times month to satisfy my taste buds.

Very rude staff for a Sunday night. Man at register got my order completely wrong, and added a fruit, something I'm allergic too. The wait was obnoxiously long for a place with over five registers. Everyone seemed antsy for their food and atmosphere was way off for a classical ice cream restaurant. Will not return. read more

Wow, probably the worst hamburgers and food ever. I forgot why I never order food there. I've had bar food better than this joint. Only thing they have going for them is the custard. read more

Best burger in my opinion, I love a good char. Pretty decent onion rings and custard. Usually pretty fast. Love this place just wish it was a drive thru read more

I'm a frequent customer at oscars .. Almost every Sunday throughout the year. I just left there outraged.. I literally wanted to just leave my ice cream on the counter and walk out. My boyfriend ordered a root beer float with a side of cashews. The girl rang it up and we paid .. We then go back up to get our ice cream and a different girl slams the cashews on the counter turns and looks at me and said extranet loud and snotty" next time these are not free of charge " I then looked at the cashier and said do you want the extra money ? She said no and rolled her eyes at the girl that said that to me. I walked away and a customer said she couldn't believe how loud & rude the girl said that comment. I never complain but I just thought it was poor customer service. I didn't ask for free pecans that's all .. Guess I'll go next door to culvers for now on. read more

Disappointed!! Stop in to pick up some quick food during today's football game. Ordered two burgers, two chili dogs, one fish sandwich, one order of fries, two shakes, and a quart of chocolate covered cherry custard. The two chili dogs didn't make the order, the fish came plain without cheese or tarter, and they gave me chocolate custard. The Waukesha location is head and shoulders above the West Allis location. You shouldn't have to open your sandwiches and the custard to make sure they got it right. Sad!! read more

I rarely eat the custard, as I'm usually too stuffed after their great burgers. My typical side with the burger is the onion rings, which are the best I've found. Today, I splurged and had the white cheddar cheese curds. Probably better than the curds at Culver's, and for about a buck cheaper. I don't know if I'd rate the burgers as better than Kopp's or Culver's. All are great, but Oscar's is very reasonably priced. read more

Excellent fish fry, the only cheap one left in Milwaukee. Good frozen custard, but the chocalate is a little weak somtimes. A good alternative to Culvers because its1/2 the price. Fast food should be cheap. read more

Prices are reasonable, but they keep going up! The burgers are ok, sometimes cold or udnercooked and you have a 50% chance of getting what you want on it (cheeseburger missing cheese the other day). Chocolate custard is too light-not chocolately enough and the shakes/malts cant be compared to Kopps or Gilles. Oscars skimps on the custard-their extra-heavy is runnier than a regular anywhere else. No need for a spoon. (lucky to get 1/2 a banana in a banana one). If they improved their chocolate custard and shakes, they'd be our only custard stand! read more

On a Friday or Saturday night while cruising legendary Hwy 100 be sure to stop by Oscars! The frozen custard is actually pretty god for a LOW price. Honestly I asked for one scoop but holy cow it looked like two for the price of one! I absolutely love their chocolate custard and love their chocolate cookies and cream mix up. The scene is pretty cool, lots of high schoolers though. Also, lots of the cruisers park in the lot and chat about their rides which is cool if you're a gearhead. I was a bit put off with some of the staff who really let it show that they didn't want to be there. I asked one of the ladies about the flavor of the day but she could not describe it for the life of her. Granted you aren't goign to remember everything someone asks you, but in most establishments the employees know the menus front to back. At any rate, I've yet to give a burger a try although I hear it tastes almost like a whopper. As far as ice cream, however, it was pretty good. Just expect a bit of a wait on weekends when its crowded. read more

I was on my way to Culver's and as I drove down the street I noticed "Oscar's" and wondered what it was. I got all the way to the Culver's parking lot, and Oscar's was still on my mind so I used my Yelp ap and looked at reviews. Then on my Droid's net to look at their site. I didn't even get out of my car. Off to Oscar's I went and so glad that I did. Yummy burger, yummy chili (very yummy actually), and the custard...so creamy and awesome flavor. Nice team of people helping out. Surprised that you have to go outside to get to the restroom...it is very clean though. Only recommendation is to not have a tv going...it would be better for ambiance. Great job...I live in Chicago so not sure when I will be back so I hope lots of new customers read this review and go. read more

Oscar's is one of the reasons I miss living in West Allis. The custard is some of my favorite in the Milwaukee area and they have some of the best prices around. Occasionally they have 99 cent Oscarburger specials. You will not find a better 1/4lb burger for the price anywhere. I always look forward to October, when Oscars is serving the "Black Cat Sundae" as their Sundae of the Month. It's enough Sundae for 2 people, but you probably wont want to share ;). read more

They just remodeled!!! It looks great inside and the bathrooms are now inside also!!! Love this place even more!

just once..ONCE can I get a hot burger? stick to the ice cream, least thats supposed to be cold

Worst service ever!! Sure, it was busy but I saw everyone that ordered in front of me get their food before me. 25 minutes later, they shove 4 big bags of food in front of me and it is not right. The dumb server then looked into the bags and handed me two of the four bags. Me? I'm an idiot. I didn't check til I got home. They gave me no burgers but double orders of fries and onion rings. And plenty of stupid excuses from not so bright people. Never again!!!! read more

Big fan of the cheeseburgers. Decent quality burgers at a price much lower than Kopps, Culvers or other similar places. Good consistent burgers. read more

Should have went home. I had a craving for a hot dog, and Sammy's was closed. My husband ordered 2 chili dogs, 1 with the works, and 1 cheese dog, (which is a hot dog with a slice of american cheese. He also ordered cheese curds. The order was to go, and he did go inside to order. Upon receiving the order, he asked if everything was there, (which he should not have to, nor should he had believed her). Upon getting home, we have an extra hot dog that we were charged for, and no cheese curds, which we were charged for. My husband immediately called Oscars and spoke with Maddie, who stated your name will be put on a list, and you can come in and get your curds. This really sounds like it is common place, and happens all of the time. It has been a long time since I have been at Oscars, and I will never be going back. It food was sub-par, and certainly not worth $18.49. read more