A wonderful place with great service, incredible food, and great drinks! Would recommend to everyone!

It was our last day in Florence, we were hungry and didn't have much time to look for restaurants. We saw this restaurant on the way and they had a table available so we thought why not? We ordered the "insalata deux peccatori" which is supposed to have buffla mozzarella and was one of the expensive salads. The portion size was too small, the cheese was ok, a disappointment compared to the delicious food we ate in Florence. My brother joined us a bit later and we asked for the menu, the waitress misunderstood us and brought an extra water bottle, when we told her that we don't want it and just need the extra menu, the waitress got angry and didn't make any comments when my brother ordered food. The food came quick, the taste was good but portions were "snack" samples read more

Had an amazing dinner here my first night in Florence. Staff were so welcoming and gave great recommendations. Try their House pasta, it's amazing! I had the house pasta with wild boar meat sauce. The boar meat was very tender and delicious. The pasta was so fresh and cooked perfectly! I paired it with house red wine. Try the tiramisu if you have room for dessert! read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - House pasta with wild boar meat sauce, so good! - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

See all

We were wandering around starving after going to the Ufizzi and this was the first place we stopped to look at the menu outside. They had lots of options, so we went in. It wasn't until we sat down that I saw "gluten free" on the menu. I asked the waiter if EVERYTHING was gluten free and he said yes. I still feel badly about the face I made at him when he said that. Lol I was a little peeved that we accidentally wandered into a gluten free place. I don't do gluten free. I am a gluten glutton. I love gluten with a passion and, quite frankly, I think gluten free is nonsense. And on Italy, of all places! But we were already sitting and our feet were killing us, so... Alrighty then. I lowered my expectations. And I will admit, for gluten free their pasta was really, really good. (I feel suspicious about its gluten free-ness, quite frankly. How can it be??) What really made it was the sauce - a simple tomato basil sauce that was perfect in every way and the meatballs were DELICIOUS. My mom had a chicken dish that she also enjoyed very much. I don't know if Italians just do "gluten free" better than most because ya know... PASTA. But this place is well worth checking out whether you're a gluten hog like me or not. read more

This place , I think, was the best one I had been to in Florence. Just stumbled into this one in Sunday evening. Most places in the area open only around 7/730 for dinner. We ordered the bruschetta , gnocchi with pesto sauce, tortellini with meat in a pink sauce , fried chicken & fries and the fagioli beans as a side. Every dish was delicious , except the fried chicken ( that ones on me, who orders fried chicken in an Italian place?!! But it was for the little one). These guys had the best fagioli beans dish, I've had anywhere in Florence. And trust me we tried it at so many places! There's only so much pasta & meat u can eat!!! Everywhere else it was just boiled Fagioli, no sauce or seasoning . These guys had it in a tomato sauce seasoned perfectly with salt n pepper. All the dishes tasted really fresh and we wiped our plates clean!! For dessert we tried the cheesecake, we had seen one freshly baked as we were walking in and so that's what we got. YUM!! read more

See all

Fast service, not pushy but definitely Americanized which for most is great since I hate the slow pace of Italian eateries when I'm on vacation. A leisurely meal is one thing, but four courses w/ wine is hard to sit through, especially when there are sights to see and museums to visit! Food was reasonably priced, good and plentiful. Wine was a little overpriced so stick to beer, soda, and water. There's lots of places you can go to have great wine and not pay high prices! The real splurge here is AMAZING dessert! We had the strawberry panna cotta per other recommendations....to die for! Same with the brownie which was more like super decadent chocolate cake....worth every penny! read more

See all

Nice little restaurant within a short walking distance from the Hotel Cavour. The chianti was very good here and I liked the gnocchi al pesto (though no one does pesto like the Cinque Terre region). My husband had the fettucini and said it was good too. Cozy atmosphere. read more

Pretty solid place for pasta in the city. We got tagliatelle with boar bolognese sauce and house made pasta with white pork sauce and both are quite good. They are both the specials of the day. This place does have a dude standing outside and trying to ask you to come in, which makes it a tourist trap looking, but I would recommend this place for the food and reasonable prices. Pastas are just under 10 eu each and the beer and wine are good priced too. Service was not slow for us too at around 7pm as we got our food pretty fast. We did not make reservations and was able to get an inside seating immediately. They do have nice outside seatings and it looked pretty full as we left so I would assume you want to make reservations for outdoor seatings. read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - House made pasta with some white sauce (special of the day) - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

See all

Very friendly servers. Pasta was a bit too al dente. The pizza was okay. Wine was reasonably priced per bottle. Accepts credit cards. Came here twice because my boyfriend liked it a lot (he is Italian, I'm not) read more

Great pizza! Pizza is delish, pretty big and can share between two people. It's pretty cheap too! A/C is always good too :-). Also they have a great selection of desserts including home made cheesecake- which was amazing! read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - Home made strawberry cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

See all

While wandering around Firenze with my friends, hot and famished, we stumbled upon this gem. Three words- best.pizza.ever. I opted for a simple pepperoni pizza, my friends each got a margarita pie. Our pizzas arrived warm and fresh. We each cut a slice of our pies and chowed down. As soon as we each took our first bite, we all looked at each other and said oh my god. i instantly knew it was the best pizza i've ever had. Will definitely return on my next trip to Florence -1 star because the drinks are pretty pricey. read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

Two words... tourist trap. In the Florence centre, this fairly large restaurant sits waiting for unsuspecting tourist for Olive Garden like food at high prices. Service is haphazard and careless and the menu is really geared towards the North American palette. The English menu is a dead give away and so is the french fries ... no one speaks Italian in the entire restaurant. All you hear is English or Japanese. It takes forever to get a waiter to come and serve you or get another glass of water. Food was no better than Olive Garden and to be honest, Olive Garden might be slightly better. All the food was overcooked (tough and dry meats, green yolks from overboiling them to death, pasta as floppy as a shoelace...) and barely had any flavour. Portions are ok, the place is clean, and convenient to the Florence core. That's the select positive thing of this place. read more

Great, delicious and authentic tasting Italian food. We ordered two simple meat and wild boar ragu pastas and loved both. Also the panna cotta was probably the best I've had; made in house! It's in a central location but isn't too touristy feeling. Has a little bit of rustic Italian kitchen feel to it. read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - Panna cotta!!! So fresh and amazing!!! I was basically licking the plate. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

The service was okay, the pizza was not the best and we had to pay inside which is strange since it was a sit down restaurant. Not a great experience and the food was bland. The workers were also all rude to our entire party. read more

This place has pretty good gluten-free pizza. I really liked the taste of the sauce. It's thin with minimal toppings (like true Italian pizza) but the crust was a little over done making it hard to cut. Being from the states, we were so tempted to just pick up our pizza and bite into it because it would have been so much easier than using a fork and knife, but we resisted... We ate here twice because it was really close to our hotel and was reasonably priced. read more

Osteria de' Peccatori is a great place to eat an amazing meal and have a great night. The staff is incredibly friendly and the food is absolutely unbelievable. Great location too! http://youtu.be/D55oWEM-ZhE read more

My wife and I stumbled on this place by accident while walking through Florence and we loved it. We spent four days in the city trying other places we didn't enjoy as but by the last 2 days we decided to just keep coming back here for lunch and dinner because we knew we liked it and got great value for our buck! Food is tasty and very reasonably priced so if you're looking to eat on a budget this is your place! The staff there was very friendly and recognized us every time we came back and made us feel at home like regulars. For lunch they even had a special with Lasagna, Salad, and glass of wine for 8 euro. I'd definitely recommend giving them a shot while in Florence. read more

Some of the best service in Florence. The waiters were extremely generous and attentive. Towards the food, I ordered the lasagna, and it arrived bubbling and DELICIOUS. Possibly on of the best i'd had to date (don't tell my mum) it was polished much too quickly but was a good serving size- enough to satiate but not too much to a point where you can't enjoy some dessert ;) speaking of, the chocolate cheesecake is a dream. Light and rich all at the same time, words cannot explain how much I loved that cheesecake. I'm soon to become a regular there :) read more

Osteria de' Peccatori - Lasagna, oh so good. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, FI

To start with the positive, this place is a great location and a nice ambiance but that was about it. Unfortunately this was not a great experience for us. We got nervous when the 'green salad' was literally entirely white iceberg lettuce with nothing else (wouldn't carrots or tomatoes be an easy addition?)... and to top it off, we were given spray-on oil and balsamic vinegar. We had to spray our dressing into the salad! I've never had to do that before. Then the pizza came, and it was the worst we've had on our trip so far. The crust seemed old and the tomato sauce was not the usual fresh sauce we've gotten around here. Such a disappointment on our last night in Florence. read more

There are a lot of great restaurants in Italy, this is just not one of them. Our dishes did not taste like they contained fresh quality ingredients. Maybe my expectations are too high from all the excellent meals I had before this one. I would not got back or recommend, regardless of price. read more

Delicious food and excellent drinks! You must try their gnocchi- the flavor is rich and creamy. Their other pasta dishes are freshly made and are also good. The ambiance is warm and welcoming and the staff is kind! read more

OH. MY. GOODNESS. I stumbled upon this place, and it was pretty cheap, only 1€ cover charge! So I sat down and asked "pizza or pasta?" My waiter was SO kind and friendly (even to an only English speaking customer) :) He recommended a pasta and said it was the BEST. Trusted him and will now trust him with my life. It was honestly the best food I've had in all of Italy so far. Wow. And I'm not a tiramisu expert, but YUM. read more

As others mention, this is a touristy place, so your experience will depend on when you go. We went for dinner quite late, so it wasn't as packed. The staff was incredibly nice: attentive, funny, and warm. The menu items are very much 'American Italian,' not authentic, but if you're looking for pasta with meatballs/bolognese or fettuccini alfredo (both American inventions), they execute well. My favorite was their panna cotta, which is on the English-language menu as 'cooked milk.' So, food and ambiance were a 4 out of 5, but service and 'feels-like-home' level were 5s. read more

We fell for so many tourist trap restaurants in Italy so I was wary of coming here to eat, but luckily my expectations were blown away! Everything was delicious. We also got the strawberry panna cotta and it was so good! read more

This was probably my favorite pasta dish in Florence- we had the tagliatelle bolognese which was so fresh and satisfying. We also had pizza which was okay. We came to eat around 430 pm so it was very slow as this is not peak time but the server was a bit strange. read more

This was very good gluten free pizza and pasta! We even tried trippa, which was surprisingly good. Reasonable prices, good sized portions, and good service. They do charge a one euro per person cover charge which was a bit odd. Overall though, it was really good. We might go back again within the next 2 days while we are in Florence. read more

Love the restaurant! Great family area with great, fun waiters!!! I really enjoyed the food and environment. I would go back again!

The tagliatelle alla norcina was hands down the BEST pasta dish I've ever had. It had just the right amount of sweet sausage crumbles and a delicate yet bold truffle cream sauce which was not too heavy. My friend got the maccheroni alla parmigiana which was also delicious. The pasta was perfectly cooked. We went back here a few nights later and ordered the same exact dishes. It's in a nice, scenic square. HIGHLY recommend. read more

Luckily this place was open because most resturants close around the time we came which was 10:30. The wasn't many people here, so the service was very quick. My friend order the lasagna, which he enjoyed. I ordered the Tortellini Labbro di Prete which part of the separate pasta section than the primi piatti section. The portions I expected would be much bigger considering it was a separate pasta menu and I only ordered that. It was a small portion suitable to have before a second plate. It was a bit decieving, nonetheless the food was fine. Nothing too special but good for a quick dinner. read more

Nice little restaurant near the market with traditional Tuscan fare. Owner was super friendly and speaks about 4 languages. Beers are supercold. The beef carpaccio wrapped around Gorgonzola over arugula was fantastic. No Pizza! read more

AVOID THIS PLACE. Do not eat here the food if TERRIBLE The only flavor you taste is an excessive amount of salt. We didn't finish any of our food. The waiter was kind enough to take one of our plates back and offer a refund (we didn't ask for it) then then 2 minutes later someone (I think the owner) came out and stated yelling and my wife in public I saying that their food is great and pointed at what seemed to be a local saying that look he loves our food. He said us "tourists" have no idea what good food tastes like. I told him first of all I didn't ask for a refund second your embarrassing me in front of a public crowd and third your food sucks and makes me want to throw up. The man kept yelling and I had to explain again that I didn't ask for a refund, I told him I wanted to pay and leave. I've never been more disgusted eating food in my life! Horrible customer service. My worst experience in Italy!!! read more

My daughter and I stopped here late on night walking back from the Uffizi. We sat outside and enjoyed a wonderful meal. She had the best Calzone. I helped her eat it. It was enough for two and really made for an unforgettable end to a evening! I'm a visitor from California read more

Veal was actually chicken. Service brought out food not ordered. Service indifferent, never checked on us once. Remarkable, considering that was always part of excellent service from other restaurants we enjoyed the last 8 days. read more

Great, price worthy restaurant with Italian flair.

The staff were very polite and cheerful. The food was very reasonable and delicious. By the end of our meal we had eaten pasta, pizza, antipasti, desserts, and had a total of 2 drinks each (four people) plus aperatif. The bill was €118!! It was a very pleasant experience on our first night in Florence. read more

The food here was alright, however, with the 100s of other restaurants in the area, I would pass on this place. The night prior, my wife and I had a night cap and decided we would come back the next night for dinner. We had the same server from the night before who seemed like he just didn't care at all. After 15 minutes of no service, he came by and started to take our order. Another waiter yelled at him and he disappeared again for 5 more minutes. I tried to order a vodka and tonic twice but it never came. Never once after getting our meal did he stop by. I get it, we don't speak Italian and it's not his job to speak English, however, they're are so many other restaurants where they barely speak English and still ensure you are getting the service you deserve. Again I'm not trying to grandstand or thrash this place. This is the first time I ever felt the need to review anything so that may tell you how I felt leaving this place. Florence is awesome and there's so many good spots that offer good service that this place should be a pass. read more

We ate lunch here after a busy morning at the Uffizzi Gallery. Although our pizzas were excellent, our salads were bland and the waiters seemed to forget about us- it took at least 20 min for someone to come to our table and the food took a long time to arrive. Perhaps if we sat on the patio we would have received more attention. We were charged a cover charge per person which was not advertised except for small print on the menu. The experience was fine, but we would not return. read more

I visited Florence with my family and am happy we dined at this wonderful restaurant for lunch. The pasta was delicious and fresh, and the pizza was divine. The desert of strawberries and lemon sorbet was a perfect compliment. The waiter was very accommodating and was quick to bring out our meal. The atmosphere was pleasant and lively, and allowed us to take in the ambiance of Florence while having a great meal. One of the best meals we've had in Italy by far. Just thinking about their food makes me hungry!! read more

Touristy. Very rude waiter sighing with any effort he made to come to your table. We had large salads for lunch. Nothing fresh about any of either salad. Rucola not fresh, not the tomatoes, artichokes, olives...everything tasted canned. Good location and not bad prices, but not worth my time to return. read more

Worst meal in Florence so far. Gnocchi was decent but they looked store bought. The scallopini was way overcooked and the sauce was horrible....some kind of American gravy with corn starch slurry maybe? Salad was pitiful. I took two bites out of the entree and that was it. Very nice staff but the food was below average. 25 Euros for a very poor experience. Avoid this place. read more