Ordered online for delivery. Changed after the fact to pick-up only and refused to deliver...and then when I couldn't get there to pick it up, refused to offer a refund. Having to fight this through my credit card. Will never order from the Weymouth shop again - hopefully the places in Boston will deliver down to the South Shore. read more

This was my second visit to Otto, my first to this location. I have to say it didn't live up to my first experience at the Harvard Square location which was perfection. I ordered a slice of the meatball pepper and onion and while tasty it wasn't very hot temp/wise and toppings were skimpy. I ordered another slice this time the roasted tomato red onion mozzarella and asked for it to be heated more which it was but again hardly any toppings - I would have loved more onion and the tomatoes didn't seem like they were roasted. And then I was shorted $2 in my change - mistake? So I probably won't try this location again. read more

Really solid place for some good ole pizza!! I've been here a couple of times and the pizza has never failed me. During my last visit I got a margherita slice and a lobster, bacon, and scallion slice (one of their specials for the month)--both were super tasty and the crust has a nice crunch to it. I think my two pizza slices perfectly describes what this place has to offer: your classic pizzas as well as some interesting combos of toppings (come on, lobster + bacon on a pizza?? what a genius idea!!). That means you'll always find something that will tickle your fancy, so you really can't go wrong with coming here. Keep in mind that this place is usually really busy, so do yourself a favor and make a reservation to ensure the smoothest of visits. read more

See all

Disappointing slice of bacon mashed potato and scallion pizza today. Basically no mashed potatoes. When this pizza is good it is amazing, today is not their day. read more

OTTO - Bacon, mashed potatoes and scallion pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Food is always delicious and delivery is always timely. Would recommend for anyone looking for a good meal.

Grabbed some pizza after a movie at the theatre across the street. Ordered a slice of the speciality mashed potato pizza, the Cobb salad, and the large sausage and onion pizza. The mashed potato pizza was interesting but don't think I could have eaten more than a couple bites since it was loaded with scallions. The sausage on the pizza had great flavor and I liked that it was sliced instead of crumbles. Overall all the food was great and it was a pleasant dining experience. read more

See all

Big fan, last time I was here, I didn't get to try their world famous pizza... So this time, you already know what the deal was! My lady and I got a half/half pizza w/ Mushroom & Garlic on one side and Bacon & Greens on the other. When I say you need to come here and get the favorites, that's no joke! Take their recommendations and have your way..! If drinking is your thing, please try their draft beer cause they have come eclectic options that taste wonderful. If you're doing takeout, double check your order with the host cause last time we ordered in person she kinda mess up our order.. pizza was still fire but def wasn't what we asked for Will be back, can't wait for the next visit! read more

When you've got a motley crew like we had on this evening--a group that included a 10-year-old, a developmentally-disabled adult, and a friend with a gluten allergy, and then never mind the wife and me--and no car immediately available, you ought to thank your lucky stars for a place like Otto. It checked all the boxes for our group, at least in pencil. And this location is a pleasant one--comfortable seating, music that's not too loud, decent service, and a location at a relatively interesting commercial corner. But I thought the pizza was only pretty good. The thin-ish crust was a bit pedestrian--not much textural variation or flavor to it, and on this occasion at least, the kitchen was sorta skimpy with the tomato sauce, which was rather spottily dappled about. (I see that folks on Yelp seem to be enthused about Otto's creative topping combinations here, but that stuff doesn't usually interest me all that much unless you get the basic pizza building blocks lined up right.) Not exactly economical, either. Five stars for the very specific purpose of providing a difficult group a suitable dining option on a summer Sunday evening, but I honestly can't get this rating up to four stars for the pizza, which ought to be the dominant criterion here. read more

Went and got the mashed potato pizza... Flavor was delicious! People were there too were super helpful and friendly

Whenever I am in the mood for some pizza, Otto is my go to! I have been getting the Mashed Potato, Bacon and Scallion Pizza every time I come here and it never disappoints. Sometime I would get half a pizza of that type then the other half would be the sriracha chicken and avocado pizza, which is also really delicious and flavorful. This time, I tried the fresh Pineapple, Bacon and Hot Honey Pizza (substituted bacon for pepperoni) and it was amazing! Love the hot honey kick and we wanted to trade the bacon for pepperoni since we like pepperoni too, and there was already bacon on the mashed potato pizza so we wanted something different. It costs 50 cents to change out an ingredient which isn't too bad. We usually bring our friends who are visiting out of town here, and everyone has been thoroughly enjoying. read more

OTTO - Mashed Potato, Bacon and Scallion Pizza And Fresh Pineapple, Bacon and Hot Honey Pizza (substituted bacon for pepperoni) - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

This specific Otto location is very spacious and it has a fun vibe as well. My favorite pizza is the baked potato/bacon one-so yummy! The spicy pulled pork pizza is yummy but there isn't very much pork on the pizza. I'd suggest paying extra for double pork if you order this specific pizza. The fresh lemonade is very good as well as are the meatballs and Tiramisu. read more

Best and most consistent pizza in the area! Definitely on the more expensive side, but it's a unique treat to get every once in a while. The service is usually pretty good. After waiting for over an hour for our pizza and it coming out wrong multiple times, our entire order was comped without asking. Cater to gluten and dairy allergies with good tasting alternatives. read more

So good! Have been here twice, very good pizza. Love the thin, tasty crust. Best when you eat it right there when it's hot, but it reheats nicely too. Also, really like the restaurant itself. Nice staff, good vibe. read more

Came in for lunch. Service was friendly and attentive and the pizza is so good. I got the mashed potato bacon and my husband got the tortellini. While we didn't need it on a Thursday afternoon it's nice you can make a reservation at this casual spot. read more

Met a couple friends here with their baby kid for lunch and as soon as that's mentioned, you know this place is family and baby friendly. Atmosphere was spacious and our waiter was attentive, although our drinks arrived closer to the time when our pizza arrived (wished the drinks arrived slightly earlier). Can't really go wrong with their pizza selections and combinations of ingredients they have. So we ordered two large - Spicy Pulled Pork, Pepperoni, Bacon & Sausage and the Fresh Mushrooms, Manchego & Herb. I'll have to tell you that the spicy pulled pork had the right amount of spice, meatiness so that the mushrooms, manchego and herb perfectly complemented. The reason being the meat pizza was decadent and the latter was lighter with a cleaner flavor that if you eat the former then the latter and repeat, it just works so well. Have to say the crust was thin and crisp with a nice short chew. Both pizzas were devoured satisfactorily without hesitation. read more

Ordered a pizza for delivery ahead of a delivery time and the restaurant cancelled my order at the last minute and didn't deliver it! Horrible service with Otto and Uber Eats. Don't order through Uber Eats or order from Otto! read more

I got the French onion special and it honestly wasn't as good as I was expecting but the other pies looked pretty good. I liked the ambiance also the server was really nice. read more

OTTO - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Always a great meal with fabulously helpful and engaging staff. Great for both dine in and takeout- either while pies or a quick slice

Honestly when they first opened the pizza was delicious. That is no longer the case. They seem to have changed a lot of their ingredients over the years bringing down the overall quality of the pizza. We ordered a chicken pineapple bacon and honey pizza, which admittedly was better than I was expecting, I just wished that they used actual bacon instead of bacon bits. The margherita pizza was bland and lacking in flavor and they used grated mozzarella instead of fresh chunks which was rather disappointing. And lastly the spicy pulled pork, pepperoni, and sausage pizza was so littered with pepperoni and not enough pulled pork that I may as well just have ordered a pepperoni pizza as that's all I could taste. Staff was pleasant, nice, little spread out but otherwise no issues there. And lastly the table was sticky, most likely either needs to be refinished or simply just needs a new table. read more

OTTO - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

Great pizza and service! We have often come here to eat with our toddler on the earlier side of the evening because the service is quick and they're family friendly. read more

This is by far the best pizza I have had. Always get it when I'm near the main location. Service is always pretty good and never super crowded. Pizza toppings are incredible and pizza cooked perfectly. Pizza also always comes piping hot. Would recommend if you want to eat some of the best food in the world. read more

I really loved the chicken basil pizza.The fresh basil and the chicken were delicious and the thin crust was great! Thin crust is always the winner! read more

We went on a Thursday night and were seated right away. We ordered a 12" Spinach, Olive, and Garlic Pizza and a 16" half Pepperoni & mushroom and half Margherita. The crust was nice and crispy with a good chew. It came out fast and hot! We got some nice cheese pulls from our first bites. The ingredients tasted fresh. Our only complaints were that it was a bit greasy and we had to add extra seasonings for our taste preferences. We don't know really what Portland style pizza is so we can't say if it holds up to the title LOL. Our server, Emily, was really nice and checked in on us + offered suggestions. Overall, we had a good time! It was a step up from the large delivery places and more affordable than North End places. read more

OTTO - 16" half Pepperoni and Fresh Mushrooms Pizza and half Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

One of the worst experiences I've had as a customer in a restaurant. The pepperoni pizza was below average but its kind of hard to screw up pizza so 2 stars there. But when we sat down to eat our pizza, they said that we could not eat it inside the restaurant because we order by the slice. Mind you there were maybe 2 tables taken and 10+ unoccupied. Workers were rude and it killed the ambiance in the restaurant. Overall, the shop is cute & all, but in the end the food and service sucked! read more

So let me get this straight: I order at the bar or from a server even though there's a counter person with many pizzas behind him? I can't order a slice without leaving a 20% tip? That's your scheme? Save your money and go elsewhere read more

One of our friends is from Portland, Maine. She was excited to see that we had OTTO's and recommended a Mash potato with bacon and scallion pizza. Food: The pizza was a little dry, but I liked the combination of mash potato with bacon and scallion as it's a really unusual combination on a pizza. Next time I wish I would've added ranch to enhance the pizza. Service: We went mid March before the quarantine. Upon walking in with my group as we were all Asian was so awkward because they made us feel really awkward. Every worker stared at us and made us really uncomfortable. Overall: I think I would like to give OTTO's another try. read more

OTTO - Mash potato, bacon, scallion pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Not sure why this place is rated 3.5 stars, but we certainly had a good experience. We came in later (at around 2p on a Saturday) and were seated right away. We tried to small pizzas- the mushroom/cauliflower and the pineapple/bacon/hot mustard. Crust was thin and crispy and the toppings were just the right amount (I have found that with these thin crust pizzas you can't have too many toppings because it gets too soggy and sags under the weight of the toppings). So we actually found the proportions reasonable. If you're looking for a thick crust though, you will be disappointed. Our server was excellent, great service. I would recommend giving this place a try! read more

OTTO - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

This pizza. It's good if you eat in. For takeout and delivery the only way I could describe it is 'lazy'. This is a damn shame because the ingredients are top tier. Check out this slice to see what I'm talking about. 2.5" of crust because f*** it. Undercooked. Really disappointing stuff. So much potential but not willing to put in the extra 25 seconds to make the za sing. Bummer. read more

OTTO - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

When in Boston means making a trip to one of my fav pizza joints! Tried Otto's for the first time in 2016 and have not forgotten about her since. Today I tried the Ricotta & Basil along with perhaps my fav pizza EVER; the Mashed Potato Bacon Scallion pizza!! The Ricotta & Basil pizza was good - the tomato sauce was tangy and the basil was fresh, but wish it had more ricotta. However, the absolute star of the show was the Mashed Potato Scallion pizza - yummy lil chunks of bacon, perfect bites of scallion, and heavenly little pockets of creamy mashed potatoes, sooo yummy. Def come here for a casual night out or for a quick slice of deliciousness cuz you can never go wrong with pizza and beer :P read more

OTTO - Mashed Potato, Bacon and Scallion Pizza (a MUST get) - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

See all

I'm usually not a pizza fan but the pizza we got was really good! I don't know why this place was rated so low. We didn't have to wait for a seat and our waitress was very nice ! Environment was chill. Will come back read more

OTTO - Siracha chicken and avocado and Spicy Pulled Pork with Scallion (Large 16") - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Otto's in Brookline is within easy walking distance. It was super convenient to order what we wanted online and get there 2 minutes after the time that the website said it would be ready and pick up our Pizza. Besides convenience, the Pizza was EXCELLENT!!! We've been there several times and have never been disappointed. read more

I went in for a late dinner last night. I wasn't really feeling like having pizza but something told me to go in there and there wasn't much open at this time besides this and Taco Bell. It was the best decision I've made this year! The pizza was phenomenal you can taste the delicious smoked flavors so fresh out of the oven, the salad was out of this world and the cookie was freshly baked and warm. But the food wasn't the best thing. The waitress LYDIA had the most infectious disposition. She was amazingly personable. So hospitable i felt like i was chatting and hanging with an old friend. Please come here if you want good food, a good time and great personnel. You will see me again next time I'm in town. Thanks again Lydia. read more

Honestly was our favorite pizza in Boston! Great slice of cheese and had a few other fun flavors.

Awful experience on Saturday, December 23, 2022 around 8:30-9pm ish. I've never been so I wasn't sure whether Otto was a sit down restaurant or a place I ordered at the counter. We weren't greeted, ever. But other people were. After not being tended to for a few minutes, I asked someone who seemed to be a host of some sort if this was a sit down or if we'd order from the counter. It's a sit down. They told us the dining area had a wait but the bar was open so we headed to the bar. The bar was freshly vacant but had not been cleaned yet so the host offered to have it cleaned before we sat there. The bartender lets us know they'll clean the bar, we nod, say thank you, and sit down once they're done. Then a party of two sits down at the bar. Then a party of one sits down at the bar. The bartender greets the two other parties and hands them menus. But not my party of two, despite us being there first and having had contact with each other prior to sitting down. So weird but maybe they'll get to us. No. They pour glasses of water for the two other parties and tend to other orders. Still no menus. No greeting. No acknowledgment despite them being aware that we are there. They talk to the other parties and still no menus or acknowledgment. It's hard to not feel like it has something to do with us being Black and brown people when the other patrons were white. The pizza looked good but it was hard to want to stay in a place that was treating us like that while treating others so well right in front of us. The bartender knew we were there, they talked to us when the host asked if they could clean the bar for us to sit there. To blatantly ignore us, two Black and brown people, knowing we were there but to be so attentive to the other patrons that were white, it's hard to believe it wasn't for that reason alone. Horrible horrible experience. I love Coolidge Corner but very disappointed an establishment that condones such behavior is located there. read more

Great food meatballs are great and sauce was outstanding. Will definitely go back , their meatballs sauce OMG to die for. I could dip Italian bread in it. Yum yum and meatballs just outstanding. read more

OTTO - Ricotta,Basil, mushrooms/plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookline, Massachusetts

Their pizzas are very good, they have a lot of different types of topping which is really nice. A good go to pizza place when I find one

Food is a 5. Service was awful. I was there for an early lunch, so I was the only one at the bar. Brought food and wine and never checked in with me. When I ordered a second slice (land a glass of wine (via the hostess not the server), they never took away the used paper plate and used wine glass. Just left it there with the dirty napkins and didn't give me a clean napkin. I would understand but I was the only one at the bar--they were just busy socializing with each other. And in the totally gross category, the male server was standing at the edge of the kitchen picking his teeth with a toothpick. Folks,if you have an open kitchen, behaviors that are private should be kept private. I tipped because people are trying to make ends meet, but I'm not sure I would be back for sanitary reasons. read more

otto's never misses! i love their pear pizza, it's to die for! they are also very accommodating with allergies (tested nuts, dairy, eggs, sesame) and you can still have a delicious pizza. this location is close to other cute places to visit and look around, with a huge window to people watch through! read more

Otto always offers great variety of choices and innovative pizza. Long time favorite! The staff there are really nice. read more

Solid four star pizza with quality ingredients...from the meat selection and extra ricotta...