Best chicken sandwich of my entire life. And my whole family feels the same way about it. I've got two teen boys - which is basically the same as eating with a professional food critic and they were both stoked on the food. Also the customer service was outstanding. The guy who took our order was so cool and welcoming. Well done yall. read more

Great place for sandwiches, and they serve breakfast all day. We were a little surprised at the average $15 price for a sandwich without fries in such a small basic spot. But our pastrami sandwich was amazing and the side of fries yummy. There are a few tables inside and also outside. The chef came to ask if we enjoyed our food and was super friendly! read more

See all

Cozy little spot! Dropped by as we were passing through because a friend highly recommended it. Felt and looked clean, smelled amazing! Staff was super friendly and helpful! And tasted even better! The sweet potato fries were crispy and perfectly seasoned. We got the Colossal Cajun Sandwich - fantastic. Portion size was great for cost. Chicken was seasoned and cooked to perfection. Will come back EVERY time! These guys do it right! read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

See all

I have to say I was not expecting this quality of food in the middle of nowhere Fairplay. I had the Hot Strami sandwich and it was magical. The pastrami was a little spicy and had absolutely zero fat in it! The meat to bread to coleslaw ratio was perfect! The fries were hot and crispy! The menu was much more diverse than I had anticipated. I wanted to try so many things but I'm happy with what I ate. Be prepared to spend a small fortune for this food. A sandwich, French fries and can of soda cost me $27. Despite the price, the place was packed. It's a small building with seating for 15-20 people maybe? And the parking is very minimal but aside from that it was a very good meal. read more

Otto’s - Hot Strami and fries! - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Went on a last min trip to Colorado w/o much planned besides hiking. Being gluten free & driving hrs between parks I was sure I wouldn't have anything to eat until my daughter found this place. She read the menu & I was shocked. I haven't had a fried chicken sandwich in ages. Everything about this place was 5 stars. The service was perfect, friendly, attentive, answered all questions. You could tell they cared. The atmosphere was adorable, South Park bathroom had us giggling. The food was amazing. The gluten free bun didn't fall apart even with wet toppings such as cole slaw. The chicken was moist and very flavorful. We drove 2 hrs back to eat here twice on our trip and both times I had the hot honey chicken sandwich, gluten free with Cajun fries (also gf). I can't wait to get back out to Colorado to eat here again! read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Excellent food. Excellent service - we wanted to eat while hiking, and to keep the buns from getting soggy, we asked for them on the side. I visited 6-7 while in FairPlay, and their entire menu was delicious. read more

Driving through the mountains in Colorado and was hungry. Didn't see much but then spotted a small place on the side of the road with 12 people outside. Pulled into a small parking area and walked in to a counter where you order. It was lunch so we skipped the delicious sounding breakfast burritos and decided on an Original Chicken Sandwich, Hot 'Strami, and Cheesy Bacon Cowgirl Fries. The latter was a large platter of excellent, crispy fries with melted cheese and bacon, a special ranch sauce and a side of sour cream. Very good. The chicken sandwich was large breast meat on a bun with dill pickles and a honey butter. Superb. The pastrami sandwich was thin sliced meat, a great coke slaw with heat, Swiss cheese and their special sauce. It was also very good. Place your Oder with a very efficient counter girl, pay, then grab a seat on the outside picnic tables. They bring it out to you. Overall great lunch, a little pricey but what isn't now. read more

See all

We always drive through Fairplay and never stop. But today we needed lunch. Ottos could not have been better. The staff was top notch- so helpful and friendly. Pair that with some perfect fried chicken, and you've got yourself a new road-trip favorite. Get the fries. Get the side of ranch. read more

Otto’s - Perfection - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Heaven touched my lips here, tonight. The best way I could describe this place is like finding a haystack in a pile of needles. I was carted to this unsuspecting location and shortly discovered the Atlantis of chicken sandwiches. In this day and age, Otto's location stands head and shoulders above the leviathan of monopolized convenience chicken. I was shaking with all of my hedonistic might after inhaling the bun, coleslaw, chicken, and participating sauces. I'll be back. read more

Had the hot honey chicken wrap- the monthly special and I'd like to petition to have it added to the menu. Perfect mix of hot and sweet with cool fixins. The cinnamon sugar sweet potato fries are top notch and the frosting dip was delightful! Just delicious all around! read more

This place is perfect if you're looking for a quick stop! The breakfast sandwiches are super tasty. The bacon and cheese fries come loaded with bacon. Highly recommend stopping here! read more

Omg - could we clone the people that work here and spread their beautiful spirits around Colorado! Awesome food - amazing friendly staff read more

Only on rare occasions do I wish I had the ability to leave more than 5 stars. Otto's is truly a local gem. My wife and I stayed in Fairplay for our honeymoon and ate here almost every day. If you're passing through town or staying nearby you should absolutely take the time to try this place! read more

Otto’s - "There's nothing behind those eyes haha" - Otto's Cashier - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

You can never go wrong with a hamburger unless they fry it to long. It is what it is. I thought kind of pricey for a hamburger but again it is what it is, Enjoy. read more

We almost left when we walked in and saw that it was an order-at-the-counter setup, and we were SO glad we stayed! UNREAL fried chicken sandwiches, crispy fries, and little saladS PACKED with the good stuff (avocado, sprouts, pomegranate seeds, etc). The staff was SO friendly and cared SO much about everyone's experience there. We won't drive through Fairplay again without a stop at Otto's! A new favorite, 100%. Literally the best chicken sandwiches either of us has ever had. Not basic, and loads better than stopping at a sportsbar or something and getting meh food. Exceptional!! Thanks, fellas! read more

Food was absolutely amazing and most items are gluten free or can be accommodated. The fried chicken sandwich was off the charts! A must stop! Staff was fab also! read more

This place was awesome! The service was great, the vibes were upbeat, and me and my fiancé both loved our chicken sandwiches. Would highly recommend this place to anyone rolling through town. read more

Otto’s - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Meh. Food was 5/10. Chicken sandwich was bland, Cubano had too much beef, fries were mushy and burnt at the same time??? Staff weren't very friendly, we had to ask for forks/napkins. Not worth the $60 for 2 people. This ain't it. read more

Yelp to the rescue again! We enjoy traveling, but with the cost for food we want to make sure that we enjoy our meals. Based on the reviews we came here. It was crowded but they get you through pretty quickly. Everything is made to order, so times vary. We had enough to take back for a snack later. The chicken was cooked well, crunchy but not dried out. The fries were the same. read more

See all

Stopped on our way through FairPlay while traveling. AMAZING!!! The original chicken sandwich was great as well as the hot honey which was recommended to us. It was fresh, crispy and flavored. Any time I'm through this way again I am stopping. Little place with quick and friendly service! read more

Great customer service. Always our first choice driving from Breck to the hot springs or another mountain resort, and the food is on point every time! read more

Exceptionally friendly and fast service. Very accommodating for gluten allergies. Love the ability to get the different dipping sauces. Would recommend. read more

Otto’s - Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich and Cajun Fries! - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Absolutely 1000% worth stopping, supporting local, and enjoying the tasty chicken! I had the Hot 'Strami with pepper Jack. My companion had the hot honey chicken sandwich. We were so hungry and about to eat gas station food. I'm so glad we stopped here Heads up - It comes quick. It's a little house off the highway on the west side. Pet friendly - Dogs look to be welcome at the outdoor seating. read more

Otto’s - Yum! Hot 'Strami - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Absolutely loved this place! Everyone was nice, and friendly. I probably had the best chicken sandwich ever! The spicy sauce was the bomb! Highly recommend if you're staying or passing through! read more

Ambiance was great, food was amazing!! And friendly service definitely recommend 10/10 read more

Otto’s - OG chicken sandwich, hot honey chicken sandwich, sweet potato fries. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Wow! We found this place by accident. There were 9 of us after a 14'er climb. The food, outside seating and GREAT service were fantastic. Some said the Fried Chicken Sammies are the best - and I must agree. This will be our stop into Fairplay every time now. read more

Amazing food! We shared the boneless bites, a SIDE (huge) of Cajun fries, and a special sandwich. It was all amazing. Forget about ketchup and just order a couple extra sides of the best ranch you'll ever eat. Staff was friendly and our pup enjoyed being able to hang with us on the patio as we ate. Chill atmosphere and excellent food, what more can you ask for?! read more

See all

Everything about this place was perfection. Sandwich. fries. Staff. Will be back any chance we can

This is a little gem in a small Colorado town! The building is small but has lots of character. Everything is clean and the smell of chicken coming out of the kitchen is amazing. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. There are multiple options for type of chicken sandwiches and the staff explained the menu to help us decide on our meal. My BF and I both had 2 different chicken sandwiches. I had the Cajun chicken sandwich. It's served on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce and tomato. My BF had the hot honey chicken sandwich. It's served with toasted brioche bun with handmade coleslaw and your choice of blue cheese or ranch. Both sandwiches were perfectly breaded and fried. The chicken is tender and moist. The toppings are fresh and the sandwich melted in my mouth! This is an amazing chicken sandwich! The fries with the Cajun seasoning are fire and well cooked. We would give Otto's a 4.8 stars for food and quality. The only thing that would have made it better was the price. We paid almost paid $50 for 2 sandwiches and a basket of fries without drinks. read more

See all

Amazing the owner's wife has celiac so almost entire menu is gluten free. Separate fryers, very knowledgeable about Gluten free and cross contamination. Incredible buns and just seriously good chicken. Got the Cajun style sweet potato fries too. So good I ordered a sammy to go with me thank you Otto's read more

See all

Decent food. Not the best chicken sandwich I've ever had, but definitely good. However, most definitely NOT worth $30 a person. For what this place is, it extremely over priced. Friendly service. Small dining room (seats about 20) but does have outdoor eating areas. Music was obnoxious and played too loudly. If it didn't cost so much, I would definitely go back and try other items. But I can't justify $30 for a quick lunch just for myself. read more

Best damn chicken sandwich in Colorado. I could eat the cajun fries all day everyday they are so perfect. You must try the special dilly sauce. Everything hit the spot! read more

Great food, friendly service, and a quaint atmosphere. Highly recommended the Cajun chicken sandwich, el Cubano, and sweet potato fries.

One of those places that you swear to everyone it's amazing, then you have it again, and it's even better than you remember. Seriously, eat here. read more

Such lovely employees!! They were friendly and efficient. My husband said The chicken sandwich was top 3 he's ever had!! Great fries too. Thanks Otto! read more

We stopped here on our way to the Western Slope based on the reviews. They didn't disappoint. We had the Mountain Cristo. Great food, friendly staff and some pretty nice music. read more

Okay this is THE CLASSIC roadside restaurant that you gotta stop at if you're passing through. I got the Mountain Cristo without the sausage and let me tell you it was AMAZING. sweet, spicy, and savory all in one. I've never seen blueberries on an egg sandwich before but hey it worked. It had me dancing in my seat! Inside is small but comfy and they were playing great music. All around a good time. read more

Otto’s - Mountain Cristo minus the sausage (egg, cheese, hash brown, spicy sauce, blueberries, and jam!) sooo good. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fairplay, Colorado

Really amazing chicken sandwiches, super friendly service, and great vibes! Stop here if you're anywhere near Fairplay, NM!

Best chicken sandwich of my life!! Incredibly crispy, juicy and flavorful!! We got the original, the hot honey, and the special sandwiches along with a basket of fries and our group had only crumbs left. Fries were very crispy and fresh too! The workers were so friendly and restaurant was clean! Come here if you want good fried chicken!! I'll be driving from Colorado Springs to come back here just to eat this again! 10/10 read more

The food was great and they were very friendly. I had the hot honey chicken burger and my husband had the original chicken burger. They were both excellent. read more