We tried the Outlaw Potato Shack for the first time and couldn't have been more please. I got the 1/2 rack of ribs and they were very meaty and delicious. Could not finish them. My husband got the brisket and pulled pork and, again, he loved both but could not finish them. He also got the raisin bread pudding and thought it was the best he had ever had. We have enough leftovers for another meal. We definitely will be going back. Everything came so hot that we didn't have to nuke them. read more

This was our first time coming here after receiving a recommendation to try it. We ordered online and the food was ready for pick up in the stated time frame. You would think that a restaurant who only does take out would have a better presentation in its to go containers. My husband ordered a 2 meat 2 side plate and both his sides were essentially combined, as were his meats. His container was on the top in the oversized bag on top of a container with a potato and then a container with a sandwich at the bottom. Stacked completely out of weight order. His had also leaked all over everything else so it was a mess. The food itself was just OK. The best item was the cow boy baked potato. The side of corn tasted fresh out of a can, not sure how it's "Cajun". The beans (now mixed with corn) had a nice flavor and probably would have been really great by themselves. My husband didn't eat much of his chopped brisket so that must have not been tasty. He did eat all the chicken. My pulled pork sandwich was really lacking on the amount of meat. I ending up eating it open face because there was way too much bread for the tiny smear of pork. My daughter liked the Mac n cheese and she's picky. If I ever come back it will probably only be for a potato. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - The portion advertised (and standard at most bbq places) - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

First time at Outlaw Potato Shack. The menu is quite large for a literal shack size establishment. We ordered the outlaw potato with all toppings and chopped brisket. We did a mobile order and drove thru to pick up our food. Our food was ready quickly. Service was friendly. There is no indoor seating pure drive up. The location is strange but it seemed like they were getting a good amount of business. The potato is huge, the brisket was delicious. I'd prefer the cheese was melted but overall it was good. The potato easily fed 2 adults possibly 3. read more

See all

Food was enough and good. I would recommend you go for there hungry. My first time was a delight

Very quick service, food was amazing! We had the Outlaw potato which was huge (shared between two people) and the pulled pork sandwich. read more

See all

Parked by there with my truck during a snow storm overnight...walked over and got some food during the snow. AMAZING. That loaded baked potato was so freaking good, and huge. Turned into three meals for me. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The food was AMAZING. We ordered at the drive through and it was super quick basically no wait time read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - The Golden Outlaw - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

They should let u know that sides are extra. Asked me what sides I wanted and I thought they came with ribs. $5 for a tiny portion. Full rack of ribs were small and one half was burned. Called Texas bbq restaurant and complained to no avail. Shake didn't answer phone. Done with them. Waste of $43. read more

I tried the Outlaw Potato Shack on a whim becauseI was in the area.. I ordered the Chili and the Chocolate Bread Pudding. The Chili was bland and not flavorful at all but the Bread Pudding was delicious! I enjoyed the Chocolate Bread Pudding so much that I returned the following week to order more for myself and my family. HOWEVER, when we drove up to the shack there was only one attendant working, and she was taking the trash to the dumpster. When she came back into the Shack, she came straight up to the window to take our order without washing her hands. We left because that's pretty gross. No thank you. read more

Love potatoes? Love barbecue meat? Love classic barbecue sides? If yes to any of these questions then Outlaw Potato Shack has your cravings covered - and then some. This little nondescript shack in the corner of a shopping plaza off W Ridge Rd in Greece serves up tasty, potato-fied barbecue goodness via drive-thru. Portions are massive (I've tried to power through the Outlaw Potato, but alas... I can't eat it all in one sitting), and that may be because each potato is over 1lb before toppings. Okay, okay... they offer non-potato options too, including ribs, sandwiches (pulled pork, brisket, or bbq chicken), and platters (choice of meat + 2 sides + corn bread). Sides includes classics like coleslaw and baked beans or blazn' corn and broccoli & cheese. Service is quick. This isn't a 5 star rating mainly because I would have liked some plastic cutlery or napkins to be included in the 'to go' bag since a friend and I were planning to go to a nearby park and eat lunch, picnic, and read for a bit. We figured things out though! read more

See all

Highly recommended by a friend. Service was good. I ordered online & food was ready right on time. Cornbread is delicious too. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Famous Outlaw Potato with Brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great alternative to fast food. Great portion size. Friendly atmosphere and tons of options. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Bbq chicken cowboy potato - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

An amazing lunch on a cold winter day! The potato is huge, and the toppings are generous. I got the Cowboy potato (without meat), and it was so good! Tasty and filling. I only managed to eat half and look forward to eating the rest later. Customer service was friendly and fast. And the delicious smells coming from inside the shack need to be made into a candle :-) ! If you've been wondering about the Potato Shack - treat yourself and try it soon! read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - The picture doesn't do it justice. The ride home kind of smooshed it, but believe me, the Cowboy Potato is amazing! - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

The meat tasted alright, the sides were amazing and the customer service was great as well. The only downside was the meat I am from Texas and I wouldn't really compare it to anything from down there. read more

A little shack looking joint with good food and friendly service. We decided to try outlaw Potato Shack on a Saturday evening. We pulled up and the server was ready at the window (this is sort of drive thru, but they do have a picnic table outside in case you want to eat right away vs bringing home) we paid $12.00 a piece for the outlaw potato. You can pick what type of BBQ meat you want on top. They were huge!!! Definitely worth $12.00 and not to mention delicious and not greasy like fast food. I would definitely at least trying it once. They do have regular BBQ options as well, not just potatoes. Don't let the shack like atmosphere turn you away. We will definitely be back. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Famous Outlaw Potato with chopped brisket - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

I really felt like barbecue tonight so decided to order takeout from the outlaw potato on Ridge road which is only 3 minutes from me.. The whole ordering process and the pickup process couldn't have gone any easier. I ordered the pulled pork sandwich with a side of coleslaw, baked beans, and a corn muffin. Overall the food was good. The muffin was great, very tender, moist and full of rich corn flavor. The coleslaw had a lot of flavor and the beans were very tasty, but a bit sweet for my liking. I was disappointed in the sandwich though. First of all I got there five minutes early from when they said it would be ready. When I pulled up they had it all bagged and ready to go. My sandwich in the container was disassembled or had all come apart. No biggie, I can throw the meat back on. The meat was cold and was very skimpy, which surprised me for a bbq restaurant. They usually pile on the meat. It barely covered the lack luster burger style roll. Good thing they gave me extra sauce because without it the meat would have been very dry. I only live 3 minutes away, so the meat wasn't very warm when the sandwich was built. They are so close and convenient, so I may give them another chance, hopefully they learn from this review and do a better job of making a sandwich the next time. read more

First time and got it delivered! Everything came neatly packaged without spills. We split a three meat combo plate and found it to be more than enough food for two. I thought the pulled pork was on the sweeter side, which I didn't mind and the pulled chicken was quite moist with a tangy flavor. The beef wasn't the prettiest girl at the party, but it was my boyfriend's favorite out of the three for its smokiness. The meal came with two sides and corn bread. The baked beans were a win for both of us. The broccoli and cheese casserole was comforting, but next time we will switch it up to something different. The corn muffin was tasty but really sweet. I didn't mind this, but they did remind me more of a sweet glazed breakfast muffin or a corn cake, just in case you like your corn bread more on the savory side. That being said it was not dry and definitely had flavor. A huge plus was the price, which is quite affordable compared to other big bbq spots locally. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Three meat plate with beans, broccoli and rice casserole, corn muffin - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The food is top notch! And the service was better!! It's a small building that looks like a train car. If you like baked potatoes this is the place! read more

Went here to grab a few gift cards and decided it was perfect time to get some food. This potato is more than enough for two adults if not three. The staff are super friendly and the food came out super quick! I am so glad we have this location for food read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

This place was so good! I got the outlaw potatoe with extra pulled pork. It came with sour cream, melted cheese, chives and a side of BBQ sauce. It was so big and had a ton of flavor. I shared it and we still couldn't eat it all. It was totally worth every penny. I can't wait to have my daughter try it because she loves potatoes and I'm already craving it again. Lol! read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Famous Outlaw Potato - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

This place comes in clutch when you crave some BBQ but don't want to sit at a restaurant. Fast service, great price for the large amount of food, and the BBQ sauce is AMAZING! read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Outlaw potato with brisket! - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

feb 14 2025 I ordered two outlaw potatoes one pulled pork and a chicken one with the chicken on the side when uber eats delivered the food everything was in the bag EXCEPT THE CHICKEN for the potato that we paid for....we tried calling the restaurant but no answer...this was disappointing to say the least...BUT other than that everything was delicious I guess I won't ask for toppings on the side next time read more

Fantastic service and food. OMY I can say how good it was because all the items tasted great, hot, and better than expected by far. The preparers did a wonderful job in making sure the food didn't spill out, very good packaging. I don't know anyone working there so don't think this isn't a real review. Thanks for the special care I received for my order. Monroe Generator Anthony read more

A small drive through place, I've read about it a lot but have never really had the circumstance to be in Greece. Ordered online, got the outlaw potato with brisket. I arrived 10 min early but the food was pretty much ready. The portion size is huge. Brisket was more minced and slightly dry but had good flavor. It was a little bit sweeter than I personally like. there was a sizable portion on top of the large potato. Oddly, the bacon on the potato for me kind of more competed than complimented the brisket. I think next time I would be happier with just the potato without the extra meat. The baked potato with fixings was more than enough to fill me up and make me satisfied. Worth coming back - if I am ever in Greece again. read more

Outstanding. The place is owned by Texas BBQ and is literally a shack that is only a drive through on W Ridge Rd. Food is excellent. It was made extremely quickly as well. We got a pulled pork outlaw potato and a lasso BBQ chicken sandwich. Everything was delicious. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Pulled pork outlaw potato ($9) - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Holy moly! Why did I wait so long to try this?! Quite the treat!! We are certainly fans of Taste of Texas but it is 20min or so away so if we are going to drive out for food we like to try new places. This was a pit stop! Fast and delicious! I think we found our new go-to for convenient bbq!!! My husband had a pulled chicken sandwich and I had a Cowboy Loaded baked potato! If you're reading this and haven't checked the picture associated with this review... stop what you are doing and look. A-ma-zing! We will be visiting again! read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - The cowboy baked potato without sour cream. - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

I had to go to Lowe's to pick up some stuff and couldn't think of what we could have for dinner and then I saw it - the Outlaw Potato Shack! This place is kind of easy to miss tucked in next to the hill as you're heading down to Lowe's. I think it's an old Fotomat building or something like that. Kind of like those tiny houses! But I know the type of food that they have and it comes from Texas BBQ joint in Spencerport - where the food is excellent! I drove right up to the drive-through window - cool! - And ordered two pulled pork sandwiches with two sides -potato salad and mac & cheese. They handed me my order in about one minute and I was on my way. Very fast! My wife and I ate at home and it was an excellent dinner. The pulled pork was smoky and excellent and they give you some extra barbecue sauce on the side. The sides are fantastic too - great mac & cheese-Cheesy! And the potato salad had nice chunks of hard boiled egg in it too. I will try to remember this as a good option that is very close to my house. What a great little joint. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Da place! - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

First time experience. Ordered the Shack Pack which was full order of ribs, choice of meat - we choose pulled pork, 4 sides: mac n cheese, corn, Cole slaw and baked potato loaded. We were given a bottle of bbq sauce and 2 rolls and 2 corn muffins. The ribs were fall off the bone, moist and good. Not a fan of burned- burnt on the rib. Mac n cheese was good. Corn was horrible oily with no flavor. Cole slaw was good. Pulled pork good. Nothing was mind blowing, but solid good. Would be order again if in the mood for bbq? Yes, because it's convenient and maybe it was simply an off day. Oh, the potato was exceptional. read more

My potato skin was dirty. Ruined the experience..... Dirt. In. My.Teeth I will not be going back.

This a drive thru only. Small place in a plaza parking lot. Humongous baked potatoes. Brisket chili was good.

Cafeteria Style Dinner Meal with a price tag; let me explain ... Decided to order dinner from here for my Father's 60th birthday since it was closer to home than the Spencerport location. We have always had fantastic meals from the Spencerport location so didn't think anything of it. We ordered around 1pm for a pick up at 6:15 knowing the current circumstances of people ordering out... order was ready timely. However, when we got home, the portion sizes weren't anything close to what we normally received from the Spencerport location. The food looked like something I would get at a cafeteria, right down a scoop shaped plop of meat in the styrofoam container. To say I was disappointed is an understatement - the look on my father's face when he opened his to-go box literally broke my heart. Definitely not what I had planned for his 60th birthday. The food was good, but definitely not worth the $40+ that I paid for it. If you get a platter, make sure you order the cattle drive so you can get some protein; if you get the outlaw potato with shredded chicken make sure to order extra meat or you will be pretty disappointed. This location is good for lunch or the outlaw potato, but if you want a dinner portion, definitely don't bother. We ordered: 1 - wrangler platter: chopped beef, corn, baked beans 1 - cattle drive platter: chopped beef, pulled pork, mac&cheese, corn 1 - outlaw potato w/ pulled chicken 1 - outlaw potato w/ pulled pork read more

See all

Beyond upset!!! Look them up online and see they close at 7PM (meaning last customer at 7PM). Drive from Greece near Dewey to them and I get there at 6:20 and was told they are about to close and they are out of potatoes but if they had them it would still take like 35 minutes to cook them. Is that how a business is managed? Hope boss sees message and cares to reply. Never mind read some responses given to others and looks like he doesn't care anyway. Not even bothering on going back. read more

This is a little place for take out. I order online so that it is ready when I get there. Everything has been very good. I love the potatoes, they are huge. One potato feeds 3-4 people! I love the sides also and their cornbread is the best. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Monster potato - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

This is probably the best shack ever!!! Our chicken and beef potatoes take out meals were prepared with the best intentions! We took things to another level and ordered 4 sides (corn, mashed potatoes, potato salad, mac & cheese) - (all tasted better than the other) corn bread and cookies. You guys the sides were amazing but the corn bread and cookies!!!! Omggggg! We loved the pre packaged utensils and wet wipes included. We appreciated that at the end of our meals very much. All of our meals were prepared as requested. More importantly everything was delicious!!! So worth the drive from Webster! My significant other works in Greece and he is excited to try the other selections from the menu. We will return regularly! :) read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

I wanted SO badly to love this place. Based on other reviews I had been so looking forward to getting here, but always thought of it only after they were closed. I finally had a lunch free in the area and checked it out. I ordered the platter with pork and beef, sides of mashed potatoes and gravy and mac and cheese. The pork was dry, I mean it had a sauce on it so was technically wet, but the meat itself was dry. It was definitely overcooked. The flavor of the pork was quite good to me, but as it was very sweet, I could see this not being to the liking of some. The beef was terrible, in fact I couldn't really taste beef. It was extremely over seasoned and that's about all I could taste. I ate a few bites to try to give it a chance, but threw the rest away as inedible. The mac and cheese had zero flavor. I used the entire salt and pepper packet they gave me trying to liven it up. The mashed potatoes had good flavor, but a gluey texture. The gravy tasted like it was made from a powder, like at KFC. The cornbread ended up being my favorite part of the meal, and really, that wasn't all that special either. It was dry and crumbly, but had a nice corn flavor and was on the sweeter side. Ordering at the drive up window was very convenient and the order was prepared quickly, I liked this concept. Although I was disappointed in my order, I might go back once more to try the Outlaw potato with pork in hopes that the dry meat was a one off on a bad day. read more

This place is located in the parking lot area of Lowe's by PetSmart on West Ridge Road. You drive up to the shack, order your food, and get it in a to-go box. I've been there twice now, and both times I got the Outlaw Potato (it's essentially a massive loaded baked potato). It is enormous, and definitely enough to share between two or three people. The service was quick and friendly. read more

See all

Great customer service; the owner reached out to me after I said the meat was overcooked. He enticed us to give it another try. And we did... It was excellent. Hubby had a platter with various meats and sides, I had an "Outlaw Potato" that was huge, perfectly cooked deliciousness that will last me at least three meals. The owner is a great businessman and the young man behind the counter was personable and prompt. Win-win-win. read more

We finally stopped in today to see how it was, well, it was AWESOME. We ordered at the walk up window and the lady working was very professional and friendly, answering any questions we had. Our food was ready and in our hands in less than 3 minutes. I ordered an Outlaw Potato with pulled bbq chicken. Let me tell you, it was HUGE (see photos below.) Basically a loaded baked potato with your choice of pulled beef, pork or chicken on top. My fiance had the Platter with bbq beef and pulled pork, and he picked a side of macaroni and cheese (delicious) and baked beans which were really good and had a lot of bacon in them. Our total came to $21 even. Not bad considering its bbq and you can easily spend that much at some fast food places on 2 meals. We will definitely be back. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - The Outlaw Potato with pulled bbq chicken. HUGE portion. - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

So you know how it is... you're driving along in Greece and you get a hankering for a loaded baked potato AND pulled pork. Well, see that little shack that sits in front of Lowe's Plaza? (Undoubtedly it was a Fotomat Booth back in the day, and if you know what I'm talking about: sssh! I won't mention your age)... Just drive in, place your order through their Drive-Thru, and pull around to the other side of the shack for your food. They have a limited menu available at the Outlaw Potato Shack (in relation to their full menu available at their Texas Bar-B-Q Joint in Spencerport) but all I ever get is their famous "Outlaw Potato". It's HUGE!!! (see my pic). I get mine with pulled pork on top. I have a good 15-20 minute drive home and they wrap it well and it's hot and yummy when I get home - no reheating needed. For $9, you can't go wrong. You could easily eat this over two meals, or share with someone else and be satiated. Stop just driving by and wondering what the heck that little shack is.... drive in and grab yours! P.S. In case the picture doesn't say it all, this is a Take-Out joint only. Want to sit down for full service and a larger menu? Stop into their Spencerport location in the village. read more

Outlaw Potato Shack - Barbeque Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

WOW That was a potato. Don't let the small booth fool you as this place is filled with flavor. Was so excited to start eating I forgot to take a picture !!! Would definitely return next time in town. May even need to make a special trip. read more