The pizza was a little thicker than I prefer and there was a lot of cheese. If you're going there…read moreto eat there are just two tables. It's more of a take out place. Wings were solid. I'd probably give this place three stars but the fact that I wasn't even asked for a tip (when nowadays counter service wants to know if you want to tip 25%) makes me inclined to give this place 4 stars.

We ordered Schifano's pizzeria delivery to our hotel the night prior to our flight home from…read moreBuffalo NY. I will say we all truly enjoyed it. The pizza had really good flavor and they pack on the toppings. The delivery service was an hour but it was understandable due to a Friday night. Schifano's is worth the wait great pizza.

Not like I needed a reminder, but One Pie Pizza Co. serves up an excellent, truly authentic…read moreBuffalo-style pizza. This time I ordered their take on a WNY specialty pizza: the chicken finger pizza. In short, it was fantastic! Since I'm a member of their rewards program, I received a "$5 off your next order" code and figured it'd been a couple months since my last visit. The coupon couldn't have come at a better time. I placed my order online on a Saturday around 4:15pm for a 5:05pm pick-up. I know, you lose a bit of the personability when you don't call the restaurant to place an order, but online ordering is so easy and quick, and I love being able to pick my pick-up time and know my order will be ready, and paid for, when I arrive. As of 07/2026, the inside of One Pie Pizza Co. underwent a remodel. It's not as spacious, but I think it opens up their kitchen more, which I'm 100% on-board with since that means more pizza and other goodies. The staff are just as friendly and courteous as ever, I'm glad that hasn't changed. So, for dinner, I ordered a QTR Sheet (six slice) from their "SUPER Specialty Pizza" menu - The BFLO Chicken Finger (blue cheese base) cooked "LIGHT WELL DONE", which is a choice between their homemade red sauce or blue cheese base that is topped with diced chicken fingers, mozzarella cheese, and Frank's (medium) sauce. The "LIGHT WELL DONE" option is for cooking the dough underneath a bit more, firming it up, making it crispier. I like a little extra cook on my pizza as, sometimes, the Buffalo-style dough is a bit too limp, almost soggy/wet, which makes holding a slice... challenging. haha Now, I've had a few chicken finger pizzas throughout the years and while I love them, they don't always love me back. They're typically very dense pizzas thanks to all the cheese (blue cheese base AND cheese blends on top) but I was impressed with how well One Pie Pizza Co.'s sat. Don't get me wrong, this pizza is absolutely loaded. When I opened the box, I was worried how I was going to pick it up as it looked messy, but as they say, appearances can be deceiving! I was impressed and didn't finish my meal wearing it all over my hands and face. Every slice was generously topped, the flavor was spot-on. Now, I love a cheesy pizza, but I really appreciate the constraint One Pie Pizza Co. showed with not going overboard with a "blend" of cheeses on top of a blue cheese base - The layer of mozzarella was plenty, a great flavor on its own. As with all of their pizza, this left me happy and full. With that $5 off coupon, this brought the price to under $20, an incredible price, especially in 2026! One Pie Pizza Co. remains one of my favorite pizzas in Buffalo. I'm glad I finally tried their chicken finger pizza, this was excellent. With how well it agreed with me, I'm pretty confident in saying One Pie Pizza Co. will be where I order chicken finger pizzas from exclusively going forward!

Ordered a vegan pizza and was advised twice they had vegan pepperoni. After getting the pizza home…read moreand consuming some, reached out again to find out they don't carry vegan pepperoni. Brought the situation to their attention and not only did they not accept responsibly, they did not offer a refund and they essentially called me a liar. Will never order again nor recommend them. Edit: They called and left a voice mail explaining they reviewed tape and reprimanded the employee. Refunded the whole check. While the overall resolution is satisfactory, it took for days of attempted communication, of which many of my attempts when unanswered.

Stumbled upon this place as an out of state visitor, staying nearby. Cute spot, food was delicious…read moreand service was outstanding! I recommend for anyone looking for good quality pizza and wings.

Deliciousness served in a box!…read more My employer ordered a sheet pizza and it was amazing. It was brought to us and was sooo hot that you can tell it was fresh out of the oven. It took about an hour to get but totally worth the wait!!! The crust and undercarriage had a great crispness which was to die for! I'll def be bringing a pizza home from this place after work sometime soon! Can't speak about the ambiance because the pizza was delivered!

Always the best need my Wally wings pizza subs only problem is online ordering with no option for…read moreplain wings with no option to add sauce on the side

My favorite ...Mae sure you get the hot honey and sweet sauce on the pizza....it's absolutely…read moreridiculous...so good i look forward to it ...

Ordered a personal Pizza here for pickup recently through the Toast App…read more Ready in about 40 minutes. the Pizza was OK, surprisingly bland vs other Chicken Finger Pizza's I've tried, not bad but not great. Better options in the area.

My orders: ciabatta bread, alfredo, lasagna…read more Pros + Parking + Service: every waitress I get is such a darling! + Unlimited soup and salad bar + Food The food here is positively scrumptious! I love their lasagna and garlic knots.

I grew up in Cheektowaga, but have not been to the area in many years. As soon as I checked into…read morethe hotel, I could not shake the feeling that I needed a royal sub so I get my rent a car and off I go to Johnny's. For you Non locals a royal sub is an Italian sausage patty with capicola ham on it. Johnny's is a counter service pizzeria. Everything is made fresh so it took a few extra minutes to get our order, but it was worth the wait. Jonnny' brought back memories of growing up in Cheektowaga in the early 80s. There is still Buffalo sports memorabilia in the restaurant mainly the Sabres. The royal sub is the best thank you.

Flew in from Dallas, texas. Staff is friendly and helpfull answering my question. Got the…read morepepperoni and cheese. Overall great solid pizza. Plenty of cheese, pepperoni and sauce. The the crust was hand tost, fluffy and cooked through. Now this is just me but would have liked it a little thinner. Would I come back - absolutely.

Got a large cheese pepperoni and double hot wings for my grandson and his girlfriend who cant be…read morehere for Thanksgiving. It's been awhile since I had Picasso it was really good nice soft bites into the dough with spicy pepperoni and sprinkled with extra spice just the way I like it and plenty of sauce the crust was dark and crispy . Wings were good made crispy not too much sauce on it that makes the wings soggy. Glad they suggested Picasso 's even have leftovers

Another solid lunch special. Was greeted immediately upon…read morewalking in, and my order was taken promptly. Within moments I had my pizza ready to go. Great pepperoni to bite ratio I just wish for a little less sauce... Highly advise against even attempting to eat a slice on the go. Will be back again sometime soon.

Its been a few years since we've been here. For Super bowl weekend, we decided to get some pizza…read moreand wings, one more time for the season. Upon looking at various deals online, we decided to order it online and pick it up. As has happened many times in the past, parking was challenging, but it made sense as it was right before the Super Bowl. The pizza was good, and we also ordered hot BBQ chicken fingers. I am a HUGE FAN of the hot BBQ sauce. I'm not sure if I will go back for the pizza, but I definitely will order their fingers with the hot BBQ sauce. While ordering, I was surprised with the abundant variety of sauces we could've picked from.

Ordered large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms. No pepperoni. Duh. Look like it got tossed aside as…read moreeverything shifted to one side. One and done, never going back. What a waste of money. Taste was fair at best. Very disappointing. Save your time and money and go to Mattia's for quality pizza that will have the toppings and taste better.