I came here yesterday afternoon, & i always drive pass here. I was craving a panini, but I didn't know what I wanted. The nice ladies at the counter was helpful & i asked them what they recommended. They made good recommendations, i decided to have turkey, bacon & avocado with spicy sauce, the number is S35. MANNNN its was fire & i busted that shit down.. Good job ladies. the vibe was cool & the music was on point. Ill definitely come back, yah gain new customer read more

If you love Paninis you'll love Panino Rustico. Everyone is so nice and the service is fast and friendly. I love getting the breakfast Panini and a Double espresso, their Coffee is really good. Try the French fries, they are the best I've ever had. Whether it's the Parmesan truffle fries or regular fries, you'll love them. Very crispy and delicious, and large portions. The cafe is nice to eat in with large French doors so you feel like your outside or order to go or delivery. read more

The food really tasty and great variety of sandwiches,paninis,salads with alot of different combinations of ingredients.

Panino Rustico was a recommendation from a friend in the neighborhood. It must be a popular takeaway spot because I was the only one in there on a Thursday evening around 5pm in January. A few patrons came for pickups. The girls behind the counter are very nice. I felt the sandwich was just okay. I think it was a cold sandwich and I was expecting hot? Warm? Panini gets put in a press and cooks it ? I might be misinformed. I would try again if I was in the neighborhood. I don't think there are many places left to eat on that side of AVe N. read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - p57 - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Discovering this place has improved my dining options considerably. Workers showed kindness that felt personal. Their kitchen knows good flavor. Very cool and different. This spot has a pleasant charm. read more

Bruh. Panino Rustico doesn't play games. Bomb AF paninis. I had the P44 and added fontina cheese on an everything panini and oh my was it good. And massive. And filling. And incredible. Get their basil dressing on the side to dip into. Their cream of tomato soup (with chicken and orzo) was also really good. New favorite spot in Brooklyn. read more

See all

Great quality tasty food, highly recommend!! Lots of options too many too choose and everything is good !! read more

See all

been coming here for almost a tear now and food is very good and service even better. Girls are friendly and polite, service always good. I've tried a bunch of different paninis and all were very good. Coffees and cold drinks also very good. They just started with some different soups, again very good. Nice neighborhood place to have lunch or dinner its clean has good food and service. Bravo to Gennaro and his staff read more

I love this place!! I can't explain how much I loved that they stayed open during the quarantine it was my saving food grace. I always seem to order the burrata appetizer the A9, the truffle oil one (there are two), it is so incredibly delicious I am in love with this appetizer. For actual Panini's I usually go for their ham and Swiss with lettuce and avocado or I'll get a chicken, bacon and cheese kind of panini. No matter what panini I order I always make sure to order a side of their PESTO!!!!! Holy sh*t is it so delicious. I always tell myself to order as much as I can because I could eat it on anything. I also always order an unsweetened Iced Tea or Green tea and add my own honey. Pretty tasty and a nice pick me up through my day. If you order from here try to call and ask for delivery instead of using a food delivery app (even thought they are on it), it saves them some money and it's a local spot so support local! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - How cute!! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered Panino Rustico for dinner this week on Seamless. I got the tuna panini and added lettuce, tomato, mayo, bacon, and cheese as well as a two scoop chocolate gelato. I was disappointed when the restaurant called me to tell me they ran out of everything paninis, but at least they let me know in advance. Overall, this place is good but my tuna was a bit dry and the bacon was microwaved even though I asked for extra crispy bacon. I'll probably give this place another try again. read more

Their Paninis are great. Don't sleep on their coffee though they make a good latte. Staff always friendly. Nice vibe with seating inside and out. read more

Panino Rustico is by FAR one of the best restaurants I've ever had the pleasure to dine at. Loved everything about this place which provides much more than simply quality food. The aesthetic & color scheme of the storefront are unique which stands out and catches the eye. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming! The menu is extensive, but they were willing to answer our questions & guide us through their favorites. I am a huge fan of restaurants with plenty of options, as it leaves me always wanting to come back to try something new. I ordered a savory crepe and my friend ordered one of their paninis sandwiches. When I say this was the best crepe I've ever had, I'm not being hyperbolic. It was BOMB! The crepe was cooked perfectly with great texture and so much flavor from the turkey + sauce. I stole a bite of my friends sandwich while he stepped away from the table...it was so good I wanted to order one myself! Gives me a feeling every panini there is worth trying with such a variety of ingredients and combinations they offer. I ordered a mocha coffee which was perfect to start the day and wash everything down, but I was left with a bit of a sweet tooth after my crepe....so I ordered a cannoli and 7 layer rainbow cake. The cannoli was executed very well & was stuffed to the brim with filling. The 7 layer cake wasn't up my alley, but I did enjoy the crumble on top! All in all, I have nothing but great things to say about Panino Rustico and am excited to see their brand growing across NY. Go support them & try to tackle their menu! Trust me, you'll become a regular in no time. read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Savory Crepe - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Love this place. Came with my bestie for her bday a week ago and I'm already back!!!! I had the sausage egg and cheese on a wrap and it was amazing!!! So I'm having it again. The Nutella crepe was also delicious. I'm going to try there canoli's as well. Such a cute mom and pop shop right in mill basin. Staff is friendly, service is amazing and the restaurant is CLEAN double plus!!! Returning happy customer! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Bacon egg and cheese wrap and sausage egg and cheese wrap - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I'm regret not trying this place sooner. I've passed by many times but never stopped in. This place is absolutely amazing. The staff is super friendly and the food is always on point. Fresh high-quality ingredients. But the coffee, out of this world. I get the caramel latte or the caramel cappuccino and it never disappoints. You have got to give this place a try. You will never be the same. I got everyone in the office hooked.. they love this place, we order at least once a week. read more

See all

Amazing panini. Big enough for us to share. The flavors were so good! Service was great. The staff greeted us, took order quick and food came right out. Definitely recommend if you're in the area. Very clean space read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Everything panini with prosciutto, truffle oil, roasted red pepper, burrata - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

What can I say the about the best panini in Brooklyn. I'm very familiar with his other location where all the magic started. This location is fairly new and is just as amazing. I haven't sat down in this location yet but my sister and I have ordered seamless and delivery through the phone many times and they ACCEPTED CREDIT CARDS. I'm not sure how it is sitting down if it's cash only like the other location. Whichever panini you order you can't go wrong I've tried many of them! You can always make modifications to all of them. FYI secret menu they have everything paninis or plain. If your a fan of everything bagels you'll love the everything panini! The bruschetta is also tasty.. eggplant carponata will rock your socks if your a fan of eggplant. They also have bruschetta with mozzarella tomato and pesto. There mocha(chocolate) shake is beyond good and they make it using a whole chocolate bar!! The mini cannoli are addicting so BEWARE. I always order 2 if I'm not stuffed. There creamy BASIL SAUCE IS AMAZING!! I literally order like 3 extra sides of it with any panini, standard. Paninis come with a small side salad when you sit down, but if you order delivery you have to ask for it...Prices are reasonable but not cheap average $8-12 for a panini. GO! read more

Always the best, from their apps/ salads/ paninis/ drinks to their service. I'm so addicted to panino that I spent my 30th bday lunch here over anywhere else! Thank you to the owner who sent out bday desserts- you don't get this kind of gestures anymore #PaninoForevs read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Bomb! - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Deliciously authentic and fresh ingredients are used I love the atmosphere highly recommend to dine in or delivery a great addition to the Bergen beach neighborhood read more

Panini ($15) was really filling and had decent amount of chicken but was a little dry and could use a little more seasoning. You can definitely taste the pesto and mozzarella was melted perfectly. The panini was still crispy on the outside. The Nutella crepe ($8.50) was okay - they kind of just tossed the blueberries in at the end and some of them were really soggy. Crepe would do with less blueberries. The crepe itself is really good and the Nutella wasn't overpowering. Lemonade ($3 for large) was refreshing (well balanced between sourness and sweetness). I ordered from Ubereats and total was $40 (including tip). Seems a little pricey but it should be less expensive if you order in store or for pickup. read more

See all

One of my favorite places to get a delicious & fresh Tuna wrap ! I request the panini be made into a wrap and they do it with no issues read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Italian tuna wrap with olive spread soooo good - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food was ok. Waitress sucked. Kept asking for toasted and she didn't understand what that was and got mad that I re asked her to toast my bagel that I asked toasted three times. read more

Panini rustica of Mill basin is awesome. I've also been to the Staten Island store. All of the Panini's on their menu are phenomenal fresh ingredients. The girls who worked there awesome the coffees delicious if you get a chance to check them out, you should. read more

What a great find! We were visiting friends and had to kill some time so we thought we would grab something to eat. To be honest we thought it was a pizza place but we were not disappointed for long. Although it's a smaller space there is sufficient seating. I also have to comment on the service that was outstanding. I'm so sorry I didn't get our waitress name but she was just so helpful and sweet. I explained I was vegetarian so she picked a few dishes she thought I might like. I went with the roasted vegetables and my boyfriends had steak with cheese and bacon. There were young girls behind the counter who were just delightful and courteous. I'll tell you for a delicious meal that won't break the bank this is the place to go! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Lovely outdoor seating - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I have been here twice and Everything here is delicious! The staff is also so friendly and sweet! There is indoor and outdoor seating for those concerned. I highly recommend their E1 salad, which has candied walnuts, goat cheese, fresh strawberries, greens, and a delicious fig dressing! Absolutely amazing! I wasn't expecting to enjoy a salad so much! Also ordered a grilled chicken, avocado, prosciutto, and pesto #57 panini. Also absolutely amazing!! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - E57 panini - grilled chicken, avocado, cheese, prosciutto - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I don't think you can go wrong with any of the paninis. There are so many options that taste great here. The portion is right on point. We had takeout here and the paninis were still hot at home. Don't forget to try out their homemade soups as well. Cash only! read more

The food and service is amazing. Everything is fresh and delicious. We got the E1 (goat cheese, strawberry, fig glazed candied walnuts) and. P37 (grilled chicken, bacon and ranch dressing). Highly recommend. read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - P37 - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Just had to update with another picture of my amazing sandwich! Got a wrap today! Asked if I could have red onion and my brother wanted chicken cutlets in his panini. I swear any time we ask for a substitution or addition they accommodate It. Literally the best. I can't get enough of this place and will give It 5 stars every day read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Tried the P44 today (obviously couldn't wait to devour half the paninj before I took a pic!) - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I really like this place . But it really depends what you order . I ventured outside my comfort zone and I was very disappointed. Service is terrific . Sometimes great other times so so . read more

I order from here three times a week... Food is always impeccable, delivery always on time... And the prices are perfect! I highly recommend this place! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - E2 Salad with Shrimp - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great food. They keep forgetting sauce which they charge you for so I'm giving low stars. Nice customer service though

I've ordered from here for delivery three times since this past Saturday 5/20, and I'm honestly amazed that I've found an Italian place in Brooklyn that doesn't suck and isn't overpriced. Their food is amazing and my mom loved their olive bowl from our order that we placed on Monday. It doesn't hurt that they have a panini Nutella, since Nutella is a staple in my life. It also doesn't hurt that this location of Panino Rustico is two blocks away from my vet's office aka Mill Basin Vet Clinic. I'd like to dine in sometime - hopefully sometime when my younger cat needs a dental cleaning from the vet, since procedures like that take awhile and we'd need to wait for the vet to be done anyway. read more

This place is terrible. I ordered a panini for delivery and it simply.....never came. Was left starving and alone. I'm usually alone but the issue is I'm usually well fed. Being both brought me to a dark place. Thanks Panino Rustico. read more

Panino Rustico has been amongst my favorite restaurants for a long time. I just discovered how fantastic their delivery service is now that we're self quarantining. The girls taking the orders over the phone are consistently super polite and patient and always make great recommendations if I'm torn. The delivery guys are also very friendly and arrive quickly. My favorites are their chicken caesar wrap and grilled vegetable crepe with balsamic or fig glaze. This usually comes in a panini, but they will happily substitute with a crepe or wrap. My mom loves the egg and bacon wrap which is served all day. Yay! Love their apple cinnamon crepe and the cannolis, which are filled upon ordering. Just heavenly and much better than the ones in bakeries in my opinion. We've been ordering at least twice a week and couldn't be more pleased. read more

Normally I enjoy eating from this place and they always get my order right! But today, I don't have a clue as to what happened!! They didn't care about my substitution for sun-dried tomatoes instead of roasted red peppers...no everything panini as requested and paid for...no basil pesto on the sandwich which it's supposed to come with and I have a hole in one half of my sandwich and it's extremely soggy!!! Very disappointed and not satisfied!! read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I would rate Panino Rustico four and a half stars. This is my new favorite cafe in south Brooklyn. They specialize in paninis, crepes, and pastries. We started off with a sampling of their different bruschettas. We had the original, original with mozzarella, original with mozzarella and pesto, and one with eggplant and goat cheese. It was interesting to taste all of the different flavor combinations. Each one was great. For my main course, I ordered a panini with porchetta, broccoli rabe and cheese. I'd highly recommend it. It has a brothy savoriness to it. It hearty, warning, and flavorful, I liked the contrast between the crispy panini with the tender porchetta and broccoli rabe. I'd definitely recommend it. For dessert, we had some cannolis. You can't go wrong with these. It's a small corner spot yet there is room for about a dozen tables comfortably. The service was outstanding. The staff was incredibly attentive and polite. I'll absolutely be back! read more

Thank goodness for Panino Rustico of Mill Basin! They keep me and my coworker happily fed each time we order from them when at work. They have a lot of great options on their menu and every delivery is always fresh and arrives quickly. They have the best lattes and so glad they can make it with almond milk. We like to order their Caesar salad, wraps, and just recently I had their cream of tomato soup and it was splendid! Thank you for always making us a great lunch as we care for our patients at a nearby hospital. It makes our days at work a bit brighter! read more

Absolutely, a great find here. The expresso is of great quality, the machines are top notch as well as the waitresses that make the coffee. As for the sandwiches, the selections are unending . You get a great meal and a small salad that's a nice touch with your panini. Service is quick as well. Just an all around great experience. read more

Panino Rustico of Mill Basin - What's left of the meat board - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had to write a review because there breakfast panini is always on point. I absolutely love it. It's so tasty and filling and everyone that I've introduced there paninni's to absolutely agree. Surprised by consistent quality of the ingredients as I order it 3x a week sometimes. I'm telling you guys you won't be disappointed. If you think starbucks coffee is good there's is awesome silky smooth no after taste best coffee in bklyn let me tell you . They make awesome salads as well. They are high quality and pay attention to order instructions as well. read more

Came here for lunch with my significant other. We ordered one of the chicken paninis. It had bacon and cheese on it. The panini bread itself was perfectly toasted which is extremely important to me and a bread lover. The panini ingredients were also very delicious. We tried the hot chocolate after seeing a picture of how it looked and it tasted just as good as it looked. The price is just right for the amount of food we got and we would definitely recommend coming here if you want a good tasting panini for a good price. Just be aware, it is cash only! read more

See all

Love this place. But very few people behind the counter are wearing masks. At this time, I think that absolutely should!