Retro Grill

I ordered a 4 foot long sandwich and the potato salad for an office lunch. They did an amazing…read morejob! The food was fresh and absolutely delicious! They also made ordering over the phone very quick and easy. It was also ready for pickup at the time they promised. if I could give them more stars I would! They have my business for life!

I just want to update this review to share that we recently catered sandwiches and apps from the OG…read moreJohn's on Stilwell, and everything was just phenomenal! Did an OG Johnny Roast Beef 2 foot hero - and it was fantastic. They kept the onions and gravy on the side and people could add it at their leisure - it was perfect. Also did an Eric Murphy 3 foot hero - and it was soo good. Ari even gave us some balsamic and olive oil on the side it was a big hit! We also order potato croquettes which are always delicious, as well as mini rice balls. I was very impressed cause we shared our concerns about a nut allergy and they were sure to take every precaution making sure no pistachios made it near the order. It was so nice to know that our go to for sandwiches will now easily become our go to for catering large groups too! Big shout out to Ari, really went above and beyond on this one! Thank you!

Pictures and menu

Johnny boy roast beef

See all

Liberty exterior shot

Jimmy's Famous Heros

4.2(169 reviews)

0.9 mi•Sheepshead Bay

Hands down my favorite sandwich shop in Brooklyn, can't go wrong with the turkey heroread more

The food is incredible and fresh. The portion sizes are huge! The service and ambiance is so…read moreAmerican. Everything is wonderful, best sandwich place you'll ever come across

Pastrami Sandwich

See all

Spicy Hot Italian Sandwich

Neptune Deli & Grocery

5.0(1 review)

1.4 mi•Coney Island

The best bagel place ever! They were fast and courteous and the chicken salad and bagel were…read morefantastic!

1.3 mi•Coney Island, Gravesend, Bath Beach

See all

John's Deli II

3.6(61 reviews)

WOW! The 2 two things I tried were oustanding! The fried ravioli was delicious & that marinara…read moresauce was to die for. The godfather sandwich was amaazzzing! It is definitely one of my top 5 sandwiches in NYC. The sandwich doesn't look anything special, but when you eat it you will be amazed! There was so much different delicious flavors at every bite: savory, sweet, spicy, tangy. It was a party in my mouth! I make happy sounds whenever I eat delicious foods & I was making too much of that. I also kept saying "jesus christ this is one delicious sandwich"! The cool thing is that u can tell them how to season the sandwich. I asked for the red pepper tomato concoction, pesto, basil, mayo, black pepper, frated parmesan cheese, white vinegar, balsamic glaze. That combo seasoning made that sandwich even more delicious! I have passed by this shop many times & I regret not trying it earlier. I can't wait to try their other sandwiches. I highly highly recommend this shop!

I've lived in the area for many many years and never tried John's deli. Decided to come here and…read morepick up some sandwiches. They have a big menu so it's overwhelming. I ordered The Godfather and a hot roast beef sandwich (forgot the name). The Godfather wasn't bad but nothing special about it. The roast beef sandwich was really bland, this could just be a normal thing because I've had other roast beef where it's also bland. If I ever make it back here again I'd love to try their hot foods instead of another sandwich.

1.5 mi•Coney Island, Bath Beach

Godfather

Johns Roast Beef w/ Mozzarella & Gravy

See all

Pumpkin

Cropsey Bagels & Deli

3.6(83 reviews)

Absolutely LOVE their bagels -- always soft & fresh! Fast service & pleasant staff. The worst part…read moreabout the location is finding parking but the food is totally worth the hassle!

Fresh bagels A variety of bagels…read more Need more spread options. Service was okay Very clean and spacious.

1.3 mi•Coney Island, Bath Beach

Cream cheese

Poppyseed bagel with cream cheese

See all

Plain Cream Cheese Bagel

Bread Plus

4.4(120 reviews)

5 -stars... This was a nice little find. I originally came…read morein for the tri color cookies which looked great on their social media posts. I ordered the grilled chicken and vegetable sandwich. It was great, it was filling and very reasonable at $12. I also ordered the Tri -Color cookies which were great as well. Prices are fair, the two women at the counter were friendly and kept all the customers happy. They have sandwiches, square pizza by the slice, personal size pizza, cakes cookies, Italian specialities, oil, coffee, drinks and of course bread. There is outside seating and unfortunately no inside seating as it is a small space. I would highly recommend them and will try some of their other items like cakes or pastries next time.

This is the best bakery to go to and buy deserts I highly recommend This bakery to anyone who loves…read moreItalian bakeries

Cakes as pastries

Tasty carrot cake!

See all

Tiramisu sfingi

Lioni Italian Heroes

4.4(552 reviews)

2.7 mi•Bensonhurst

Rarely do I rate a place I've never actually been to. However in this case of someone bringing me 2…read moreof the best Italian heroes ( sangwiches) I think Ive ever had, I'm making an exception. I've eaten MANY Italian heroes all over northern NY & NYC and this has to be the best Ive ever had. This place is well established in the local community and I am sure someone has done a video or segment on TV about this place. The amount of food on a sandwich and the quality of their food is impeccable. No heroes loaded up with tomato and lettuce. Just plenty of the "good stuff". Don't give the prices a 2nd glance as these sandwiches have to weight 4-5 lbs each and a full ( 10"?) hero is plenty for 2 very hungry people. They have over 150 Signature sandwiches named after ( mostly) Italian celebrities. ( Fran Sinatra, Yogi Berra, Sophia Loren, etc) I was very satisfied with these 2: ---#119 EDDIE ARCARDO "Try This Thoroughbred"-- Chicken cutlet, salami, ham, olive oil, basil mix, LIONI FRESH MOZZARELLA, Sun-dried tomatoes, and a drizzle of balsamic vinegar ----#P1 THE ROSANNA SCOTTO "You'll Have A Good Day With This One" Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers OMG! so loaded, so fresh, amazing bread. Home made roasted peppers, sundried tomatoes, AMAZING mozzarella! Be hungry & GO! Top notch!

Food: This is an old school Italian sub shop that makes over 100 different types of sandwiches…read more They are well known for their fresh mozzarella which is delicious. The subs are always packed with meat and fresh ingredients; the bread is delicious. Their shop also sells traditional Italian breads ($1.50 for an Italian loaf), sides, desserts, and groceries. They also do catering and long subs for parties and events. The number of choices of subs can be overwhelming! Service: Service was average, nothing bad but nothing great either. Ambiance: There is a small table that seats about 6 people in the shop if you want to eat there. The sub shop/counter is in the back, and the front is a small grocery store with Italian products. Overall, I would recommend this sandwich spot!

0.9 mi•Sheepshead Bay, Midwood

See all

G & S Salumeria & Pork Store

4.6(58 reviews)

I love this place. G & S has a nice assortment of freshly butchered meat and chicken…read more I'm always trying something from their selection of prepared hot food and the hero sandwiches are made to order. The whole crew is awesome and very informative with food preparation. Did I say I love this place? You will too.

Sandwich was big and filling but waiting for it in a dusty, grimy grocery store was not on my list…read moreof expectations. The man serving me was friendly, I even tipped him. He made the sandwich per my request as best he could. But y he dirt in the front of the shop, plus all the dust and grime accumulated throughout the shelves and cans/non perishables is the ONLY reason I wouldn't come back. If the front of shop looks this bad, how clean is the kitchen?

G&S Italian Hero

Potato croquettes and rice balls

See all

Doña Zita Mexican Restaurant

4.2(96 reviews)

1.7 mi•Coney Island

Dona Zita - 1221 Bowery St, Brooklyn, NY 11224 : Coney…read moreIsland hidden gem Stopped by Dona Zita for a flavor bomb of a meal and left seriously impressed. I ordered the Pork Cemita -- a beautiful sesame seed bun stacked with tender pork, Oaxaca cheese, creamy avocado, onion, papalo, chipotle, and mayo. This was hands down the best Cemita I've ever had. Every bite had that perfect mix of smokey heat, richness, and crunch. And let's talk about their Flamin' Hot Cheetos Elotes... they did it RIGHT. Spicy, cheesy, creamy, crunchy -- everything you want in street corn and then some. If you're near Coney Island and looking for some real-deal Mexican street food vibes, Dona Zita is a must. #DonaZita #ConeyIslandEats #CemitaCravings #FlaminHotElotes #BrooklynEats #NYCFoodie #StreetFoodGoals #FoodieInTheBigApple2025

Good value for your money for sure. The sandwiches are ENORMOUS; I was absolutely stuffed after…read moreonly eating half. I had the cemita with breaded chicken and was it the best sandwich I've had? No, but there's something to be said about a sandwich that feeds you for 2 days. Of the cons-- couldn't get used to the papalo leaves, wasn't a fan of the flavor (although that's a personal thing). I also thought the breaded chicken could have been crispier. Adding their complimentary salsa verde sauce improved the flavor by a lot though. They also have a bathroom and a decently sized seating area, which is a definite plus for Coney Island.

0.8 mi•Gravesend, Midwood

Flamin hot cheetos ELOTES

See all

Cemita

Think Sweet

4.8(44 reviews)

5/29/24 My brother introduced me to this "hole in the wall…read morewith great Shakshuka". The cozy restaurant is tiny with 2 tables on the ground floor but there is also seating upstairs. We had the freshly toasted sliced baguette with Zatar spiced cream cheese, pickled jalapenos, and pickled banana peppers. Then each of our Shakshuka was brought out individually by the owner. It was in a skillet, covered to stay hot. My shakshuka was fresh, flavorful, and prepared exactly the way I requested (eggs over hard instead of the typical over easy). The owner kept coming to check on all the customers and make sure they had everything they wanted. Before leaving the owner ran to the kitchen to prepare a Nite Toast for us to sample. It was so delicious. I may start with that next time. This was a wonderful homey experience with warmth, hospitality, and excellent food.

The Mefuneket sandwich may be simple, but is so so delicious! I love that it comes with some many…read morefresh veggies. Moti the owner is so sweet. He's always checking in on everyone and making each customer feel like they're one of his friends. If you want more pepper, no problem! Moti will give you extra banana peppers or jalapeños if you ask. The store itself isn't the prettiest to look at, but the service and food more than make up for that. I highly suggest you come to Think Sweet for breakfast or lunch if you're in the neighborhood.