Paolo's jewelry boutique in Cincinnati's Gaslight District delivers on artistry, value, meticulous attention to detail, and exceptional customer service. This jeweler proved highly responsive and was consistently willing to accommodate my particular requirements; highly recommend them to those in the market for wedding jewelry. I recently asked their team of jewelers to repair and upgrade a platinum three-stone engagement ring years after they moved from their Ludlow Garage location. They just replaced two cornflower blue sapphires with truly beautiful AAA+ medium blue ones. Nothing changed in terms of their commitment to their clientele or desire to attain excellence in what they produce. In 2003, it was incredible to find a custom jeweler in Cincinnati that could produce a handmade 1+ carat colorless diamond platinum ring that undercut competitors by 30%. Paolo took a detailed sketch I drafted and produced jewelry mirroring the exact concept, well-exceeding my expectations. While sophisticated and knowledgeable, Paolo lacks the ostentatiousness and snob vibe other high-end jewelry stores emanate. Staff at Paolo are just as pleased to serve you whether you spend $100 or thousands. The engagement ring we purchased in 2003 appreciably eclipsed offerings by larger premier retailers like Tiffany & Co. at the same price point. Frankly, there wasn't much of a comparison in terms of quality, and certainly, nothing to justify the premium for a longstanding brand name. Paolo sourced excellent stones within our limited budget, making sure we could compare them against others in contrasting light (a must for anyone purchasing loose gems). Paolo's practice is to remain transparent throughout the buying process, and they are patient when educating customers learning how to evaluate various grades of gemstones. My wife's handmade engagement and wedding rings by Paolo simply outshined everything we looked at within our limit (around $10K), and both rings have held up very well over nearly two decades. Eventually, one of the side-stone sapphires cracked along the exposed girdle due to rough wear. To all you would be ring buyers out there, take my advice and consider a bezel setting before going with prongs. We returned in 2019 to replace the sapphires and change the prong setting to a bezel, which custom work looks superb. If you're looking to establish a longstanding relationship with a jeweler that can do it all; then Paolo is the way to go whether you live in Cincinnati or move all over the world like we do. Paolo is a wise choice... read more

It seems like a sheer coincidence that Jordan and I first met in 2010 at Murray State University. After both growing up in Louisville, Kentucky and unknowingly crossing paths on several occasions, we both chose to attend and run cross country for the same college. Our relationship that began as teammates quickly grew to friendship and dating. It was during this dating period that I lost my favorite bracelet that I had worn every day for years. When Jordan graduated, he moved to Cincinnati for graduate school at the University of Cincinnati. Living in the Gaslight District and working at Children's Hospital he frequently walked past Paolo's shop. As our dating anniversary was approaching, Jordan wanted to replace the bracelet I lost. However, he could not find an exact replica (it was authentic and made/purchased in Chile) and decided that if he couldn't find the same bracelet he would just have to make a new one. He stopped by Paolo's while walking home from work and went in to discuss the possibility of recreating my lost bracelet. Paolo's recreation of the bracelet was phenomenal: it still had the old South American design with a modern edge. After experiencing Paolo's craftsmanship first hand, Jordan started consulting Paolo with a bigger project in mind; an engagement ring. The ring Jordan and Paolo created is stunning and suits me perfectly. Jordan was so excited to give it to me that he blew off his original plans and proposed the first chance he got seemingly out of the blue early one morning back in March. Since then, I have graduated and followed Jordan to Cincinnati. There was never any doubt that we would trust Paolo with the next exciting step; designing wedding bands! We trust his opinion and expertise implicitly and could never imagine sharing this adventure with the help of any other jeweler. We've been married 2 years now and we're still finding excuses to stop by the store and see what new designs he's created! read more

I don't normally write reviews...however i just had to take the time to let everyone know the AMAZING experience I had at "Paolo A Modern Jeweler" ....Paolo and his team are very respectful and truly dedicated to what they do...their work is truly breathtaking!!! I had spoke with several places before i found Paolo ...and my gut told me that he was who i needed to put my trust in for this project!!! I had 2 engagement rings that needed sized before Valentines day...mine and my fiancee's....hers of course was a Valentines day secret!!!! She thought i was just looking for a jeweler to get mine sized because it was a little to big and that's what i wanted for Valentine's day...little did she know i had finally found the perfect ring for her...but it was a little to small....and i needed it to be able to fit on her finger when i proposed!!! Paolo and his team was more than happy to help me the very same day so that i would have the ring ready in time for the big day!!! I felt completely safe and comfortable with them the whole time....of course their pricing differs for everything just like anyone...but the price for my project was definitely affordable and only took about an hour to complete!!! Thanks again to Paolo and his team for their amazing work...because of you guys her ring was able to fit her finger for the big day....and yes SHE SAID YES!!!!! I will definitely be coming back to you guys for all my jewelry needs!!!!! -Hailie Baird read more

Our experience with Paolo was incredible! Our youngest daughter, Eden, is 15 years old and we wanted to create a custom necklace to commemorate her Rite of Passage into womanhood. We knew that Paolo's team was the perfect choice to create this beautiful piece. I am a designer / architect by trade and had a very unique design prepared that reflected Eden's Identity, beauty and personality. There is deep meaning and symbolism behind the composition. Also, jewelry that was given to us from her grandparents was integrated into the piece. At the first meeting with Paolo, he listened to our thoughts and reviewed my sketches. He was immediately excited about what we were trying to create. He did voice some concerns about how the necklace would sit/ hang and how each diamond would be set. His team put together a digital model of the design along with some sketches for our initial review in a very timely manner. Once received, it become evident that the design wasn't quite in line with my vision so I proposed some changes and provided some new sketches for Paolo to review. They respectfully received my requests and were very willing to revise the design. Within a few days he sent back the new model which beautifully represented what we were trying to achieve. The details and craftsmanship of the necklace were phenomenal. I am thankful we chose Paola AGAIN and highly recommend his services for all your jewelry needs. Thanks Paolo! - Ryan D. read more

Dear Paolo, Jim and I just wanted to thank you and Toby for a wonderful evening, Saturday. We had so much fun and so appreciated the attention and patience that you both had with us! Will the pieces be ready by Christmas??? Haha, just kidding! I know it is February. I'm really excited about it! We had a great dinner at Prime, the food was terrific. Our driver, David, was also wonderful! I just can't tell you how much we enjoyed being spoiled. This is something that we have never experienced! I really loved how Toby listened to my specific requests and details and designed some perfect pieces of jewelry that were important to me. Kudos! I'm very excited to see the final pieces in person! Please, give that pup a kiss for me! He's a big sweetie! Don't forget to try some honey on his sores. Well, thank you again for a wonderful evening! Please tell Toby, and the rest of the staff, how much we appreciate their special attention, as well! Thanks for everything and look forward to seeing you in February! Merry Christmas, Joanne and Jim read more

My husband and I were looking for unique wedding bands and had been to several jewelry store around Cincinnati, however, we couldn't find anything we liked. A friend recommended we go see Paolo, knowing that he had a different collection of jewelry and also made custom pieces. When we first met Paolo at his studio, he took the time to sit down with us, talk about our ideas, show us some examples... all while sipping a glass of wine. It was a very relaxed environment, and it was great to be one on one so we had his full attention. We had Paolo design two custom bands for us. I was slightly nervous as these were custom pieces, so we only had an idea of what they would look like. When we picked up our rings a few weeks later, we were thrilled with the result. The rings are gorgeous... even better than we imagined. Paolo was responsive and delivered our rings on time, even though we didn't give him much of a window to get them done before our big day. I would highly recommend Paolo if you are looking for unique, gorgeous jewelry. read more

My Fiance and I could not be happier! After shopping around for what seemed like forever. I could not find the perfect ring in my price range. Everything was either too expensive or too bland and basic. I wanted something that represented the life I want to build with my partner. With the expert help of Paolo and his team we created a masterpiece. I didn't even have to ask "will you marry me." She said yes! as soon as she saw the ring. I got a tip about Paolo from my uncle who said they were some of the best custom jewelers in Cincinnati. At first when I head custom I thought ,$$$, I cant afford that. However after coming in and talking with Paolo and his friendly staff we came up with the prefect design in my price range. We created a beautiful rose gold band featuring a diamond sourced ethically from the southwest, which is where she is from! She could not be happier. I got more than a ring. I got an experience and a ring as unique as my love. I could not recommend paolo and his staff enough. read more

We recently married this past year. As we look back, we can't help but think of the wonderful experience we had with our Jeweler of choice, now and forever, Paolo A MODERN JEWELER of Clifton. From the education process, to design selection, and delivery, Paolo and staff were 1st class A #1. They were patient with us knowing it was our first diamond/shopping experience, which we appreciated most. They encouraged us to shop around, after doing so we had no doubt that we felt most comfortable going back to Paolo. We ended up with beautifully designed and unique rings. Both within our price range. Further more, we asked the designer Paolo to be present for our wedding, he surprised us with a stunning necklace for my wife to wear on her wedding day, which just blew us away. We are forever appreciative of his creativity, professionalism and generosity. Thank You Paolo! Ron and Monica Newport, Kentucky read more

I needed an engagement ring for my then girlfriend and spent some time wandering from jeweler to jeweler. I knew what I wanted and nobody had anything similar. My girlfriend knew of Paolo and wanted to see his work at a convention where he had a showroom so we went. I knew instantly I needed to talk to him. I spent a couple weeks working out the design in my head and then scheduled an appointment. Within an hour he had a sketch of my ring and a week later I had a 3D rendering. We traded ideas back and forth for a month or so and then the design was perfect. A few months later I picked up a ring more perfect than I had ever imagined one being. engagements only happens once and I'm glad years from now I can look back and know I have something personal which I designed and nobody else has. I will never trust any other jeweler and will return everytime I need a real piece of art. read more

First class experience from the professional driver who arrived to pick me up at my home to the appraisal, cleaning and redesign of my jewelry. I even brought old jewelry items that I thought had no value. THAT was wrong! My inherited items were cleaned and appraised and honestly, left me speechless. Paolo made recommendations about which items could be gifted to my granddaughter now, and which ones to save for when she is older and can care for them appropriately. He designed a necklace using my wedding ring and that of my late husband. It is so special and brings me such joy to wear. Paolo really listens to your preferences to redesign pieces that you will cherish for the rest of your life. It is without hesitation that I recommend that you invest in yourself with this incredibly special one-of-a-kind experience read more

Visiting Cincinnati over the Christmas holidays looking for the perfect wedding band for myself. I entered Paolo with low hopes of finding anything as I had been struggling to find the perfect ring in my price range. In comes Paolo (the owner), he was super helpful about trying to find the right ring for me. He showed me a lot of bands which were fantastic, and then I found it. The perfect band. However, it was outside of my price range. Well, Paolo, the lovely gentleman was able to bring the price down into my budget, not only this, but he was able to have the ring resized on the same day within 30 minutes. All in all, it was a fantastic experience at Paolo's. I'll definitely be coming back for my next piece. Very friendly and they have a great attitude in regards to finding you you're perfect piece. read more

My boyfriend and I had the true pleasure of experiencing Paolo's date night experience yesterday. From start to finish everyone was so kind, thoughtful, professional, and determined to make sure we had nothing short of an exceptional experience. Paolo took us through his beautiful store, listened to our ideas and what pieces inspired us and provided such creative options to redo some of my more sentimental pieces and for other pieces that just needed an update. At no point were we pressured into anything and his years of experience and love of jewelry and working with his clients came through clearly during our entire time there. I couldn't be more thrilled to give him a rave review and am looking forward to seeing my finished necklace. Treat yourself to this unique experience. You won't regret it. read more

My ​experience having my engagement ring resized was wonderful! They were very versatile and could work with materials that were denied at several other jewelers when asking for a ring resize (moissanite and rhodium plated sterling silver). Paolo gave me his personal number and was available via text and call when setting up my appointment and when I had questions. The shop itself was a bright, modern space that was cozy. Everyone was lovely to work with and listened to my questions and concerns. My ring fit perfectly and the work was done beautifully; I couldn't tell it had been resized (a warning that other jewelers had given me). They were transparent about pricing and kept the process affordable for me as a new customer. I look forward to coming back in the future for my fine jewelry. read more

I took some of my mother's jewelry to Paolo to see how we could use the diamonds in a more contemporary setting. He took great care to acknowledge that it was very special to me since my mother recently passed. He came up with several ideas on how to use the diamonds she had in her rings. Working with my fiance and I, Paolo created our wedding rings. He made it possible to save some of the vintage design elements from her setting for my wedding ring. He also designed a fabulous second ring for my right hand! I am so pleased with the results that my next venture with Paolo will be a cool design of his for a cuff bracelet! He not only creates beautiful jewelry, he makes the process a beautiful event! We now consider Paolo a friend! Thank you Paolo. read more

I have absolutely loved our experience with Paolo! There is no better jeweler in Cincinnati. He custom made my engagement ring last year, and just recently designed our wedding bands. I have never seen such beautiful pieces of jewelry in my life! He took the time to figure out what we really wanted and explained the entire process to us. I am absolutely in love with my engagement ring, and can't wait for our wedding bands to be finished! Not only did he do a wonderful job with our jewelry, but he even helped my fiancé coordinate our proposal! All around Paolo is a great man, and we are excited to keep coming back to him for many years to come! read more

Paolo (A Modern Jeweler) has far exceeded my expectations. When my fiance asked me to marry him with the most beautiful, custom diamond engagement ring, I was so thrilled to say 'yes' to my best friend and blown away by the beauty of the ring he custom designed with Paolo. Stunning rose gold band with a pear shaped diamond that is absolutely flawless. Not only is Paolo's work stunning, he is such a pleasure to work as we designed my wedding band too - just as gorgeous as the engagement ring. Totally recommend to anyone who wants exceptional design and service. Ladies, your man can't go wrong by going to Paolo! read more

If you're looking for something special for your special someone that is crafted locally and is NOT from some cookie cutter jewelry store in the mall or grocery store, you have to check out Paolo's. I'd purchased a ring for my fiance from someone else and two months after proposing we started having some issues with the setting. Instead of going back to the original seller, I took the ring to Paolo. Not only did Paolo point out why we had issues he helped me pick a new setting that my fiance absolutely loves. Great handcrafted work and excellent customer service! read more

I would first like to thank you and your staff for making our Date Night so comfortable and easy. From the wine and cocktails, looking at/selecting different designs, and finishing the evening with a delicious dinner at Prime, we could not have asked for better date night out. Paolo and Brett were amazing hosts ~ fun, friendly and helpful. I now have custom pieces, a renewed bracelet, and my husband has a set of cufflinks for our 35th wedding anniversary. It was a very special and unique experience. Thank you, Paolo! Terri and Craig read more

At Paolo modern jeweler, they really take great care of and consideration for you your aesthetic and what you want. I'm beyond grateful to have Paolo as my jeweler and family friend for over 11 years now and counting! Paolo and his team just finished a great custom piece for me and picked out an amazingly stellar white gold and stunning diamond piece. I love my new necklaces and bracelets! If you ever need any custom jewelry, cleaning or fine estate pieces Paolo modern jeweler is the place to check by far; best in city. Thank you again! read more