Papa Kelseys

Typical Panera experience. Great location. Fast service. Good food and no complaints.read more

I know this isn't related to much about the place, and I basically almost never got food from here,…read morebut every single day in summer I went to this place because we got a free soda subscription. As a kid, Im kind of scared of talking to strangers and workers at stores and restaurants. But, I felt more comfortable in this place. I would always have to go inside to pick up my mom's orders, and I actually began to get used to it. The workers there are so nice, and the place is almost spotless. Thank you Panera Bread workers!

Hearty Fireside Chili & Rustic Baked Potato Soup

Kickin' Grilled Cheese & Creamy Tomato Soup Value Duet

See all

New Sandwiches

Applebee's Grill + Bar

2.9(76 reviews)

0.8 mi

The food is always decent, that's no issue. The server was nice enough and we got our food and…read moredrinks quickly. However, the photos of the food and drink did not match what we received in any way. Bit disappointing to order a fun bright pink drink with gold sugar rim and just get a dull vaguely pink drink, no rim. The drinks are also very watered down, which is probably not surprising for Applebees.

After driving 10 hours from Flagstaff, AZ this was the perfect spot for a drink and dinner. We sat…read moreat the bar. Service was excellent and the food was great! We'll be back for sure!

See all

Goody's

4.0(97 reviews)

2.2 mi

UPDATE: Still love the food. But I am tired of being treated like a bother when I come in, so will…read moreprobably be looking for another place for my family and I to grab our sandwiches. Been coming here for 7+ years and am currently disappointed with employees' inability to say "Hello," or even "Thank you," when the transaction is finished. Definitely noticed both last night when the sandwich starter employee acted like it was a huge bother to make one more sandwich. If you're too tired to make a sandwich or greet a customer maybe it's time for you to take a break. Or a walk around the block. The man who rang me up acted like he couldn't be bothered-he wasn't really paying attention-and there was no "thank you" at the end. Seems like the front line on the "restaurant" side is more concerned about helping customers and staff from the "pub" side. So disappointing.

A really well run, locally loved sandwich place. The food was great, lots of choices, hot, grilled…read moreor cold sandwiches, a solid selection of salads, & pizza! Prices were also quite reasonable. The service was very good, it was lunchtime when we arrived & were served & enjoying our meal in less than 10 min. Plenty of outside seating if the day is nice.

46 years ago when ISU upset FUCLA bruins

Italian salad with everything.

See all

Daily specials

The Healthier Place To Eat

4.2(131 reviews)

2.1 mi

Wow, far exceeded my expectations! The Reuben sandwich was maybe the best I've ever had. The sweet…read morepotato chips were fresh made and delicious, like way better than you think they'll be. My wife has celiac and loved her GF (gluten free) Philly steak sandwich and fries. Very allergy friendly. We had a GF empanada for dessert that was super good, you don't find those GF anywhere.

The owner was very friendly and helpful. We enjoyed the staff and there were delicious and healthy…read morechoices. The empanadas were excellent and I loved the cashew burger.

Taste so good , Nothing but empty plates all around.

See all

ButterBurr's Lickety Split

3.6(46 reviews)

0.5 mi

The music was too loud. Couldn't talk among ourself ask for it to be turned down, they said they…read morecouldn't. Also the The pies weren't very good and I can't say the food was very good either Nothing like butterburrs itself I would have gave no star but there wasn't that option

I've given this place a try three times in the last five years and all three times the food was…read morenot great. Service was okay. I've heard really great things about this place but one thing is consistent, the place is not quite the same as it used to be

Dirty.

See all

Palate Street Bistro

4.3(17 reviews)

1.8 mi

My family of 6 eats everything family style, this allows us to try it all :-)…read more We had... *Corn chowder(very good, but seemed pricey for the size, especially in comparison to other items), this was served with thin slices of grilled bread instead of crackers, which was amazing!!! *Blondie mac&cheese. This is super yum!! With bacon?!?!?! Extra indulgent!! So good!! *Palate burger. Bacon jam? Yes, please! Pickle Aioli? Interesting, sign me up! This was a yummy burger, although I never did find the cheese on it....yet still happily ate my piece. *Ambitious Blonde Burger. I would have preferred a bit more beer cheese-or maybe a 2nd type of cheese too? but it was still very yummy!! The generous amount of yummy bacon made up for any smaller amount of cheese ;-) *Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich. Super yum, although we are used to more of an oil based "sauce" and this was something else. Still good, still spicy, just not super authentic(we lived in the Nashville/Huntsville area for a decade) *Pulled pork Sandwich. Super good. Sauce seems homemade, great compliment to the sandwich! *Smoked Tri-tip Sandwich. Really good. The bbq sauce, toppings make it next level! This is coming from someone who never understood the hype of tri-tip(when living in CA), but finally did-just took going to ID to figure it out ;-) *Cuban Sandwich. This was good. Had the pulled pork from above & was very yummy!! Condiments once again took it to the next level! Exactly what it should be! *Pretzel Bites. These were served with beer cheese & super yum, kids loved them! Everything was amazing & we cannot wait to go back for more!! All 4 kids loved everything!!

I got a recommendation from an old friend to come here while in town. We accidentally went to the…read morelocation at Jim Dandy's Brewing. When we walked in the server insisted that we sit inside instead of going out back. I wish we had gone out back to the truck, our server was super attentive but we felt a bit forced to buy a drink from them and ordering via the bistro QR code from the table was a little clunky. We were also traveling and the drink menu from Jim Dandy's didn't tickle our fancy. My husband got the Piggyback Burger with truffle fries and it was delicious! All of the flavors went well together and were plentiful. I had the pork tacos and the brussel sprouts. The brussels could've feed four people and were a bit on the very well done side. The tacos were full of meat but just okay and the chimichurri was nothing to write home about. The location was clean and quiet. Loads of seating inside and had some fun decor touches. Maybe we'll head to the other location next time we are in the area.

Truffle Fries Piggyback Burger

Tacos Brussel Sprouts

See all

BBQ Pulled Pork

MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub

3.5(210 reviews)

1.5 mi

The pizza here is really delicious. Hannah and the team in Chubbuck were awesome!!! The place was…read moreclean and inviting.

Great service, food and fun atmosphere! We live in WA State and were visiting family, we tend to go…read moreto the same places, o wanted to mix it up! Winner

See all

Brick 243 Gastropub

4.6(31 reviews)

2.1 mi

This is the best dinning experience in Pocatello and best food and service!! The ambiance is…read moreincredible!

It was the owner's Birthday and they gave us a free glass of her favorite wine. The wine was…read moreamazing. I took a picture of the bottle so I can purchase it when we are back home. We ordered the Wedge Salad (the best) and a pizza, which was great also. Comfy seating and fun wall art.

Brick 243 Gastropub - Great vibe, music, food, wine & ambiance! The pork sandwich tasty, beer cheese soup the best & crostini sampler so yummy! Great people!

Great vibe, music, food, wine & ambiance! The pork sandwich tasty, beer cheese soup the best & crostini sampler so yummy! Great people!

Family Wedge salad, "The Eight"

See all

Menu JUL 23

Sandpiper Restaurant & Lounge

3.8(208 reviews)

0.8 mi

We searched for good clam chowder in the area and this popped up. My husband and I ordered a bowl…read moreeach, it was so good! We split the fish and chips and it was delicious as well! We each had a cocktail and because we sat in the bar and it was before 6pm we received a happy hour discount The service was spot on And the price we paid for the whole meal was barely $50 which we were pleasantly surprised about I would definitely go back on our travels through

Servers are SO NICE. Ambiance casual but nice. Food was meh good. Had the trout. (Super fishy but…read moretrout is). Baked potato was actually cold. Took so long to get the food I didn't want to wait (and I didn't want them to microwave it) Steak was good. Steamed veggies were NOT. (Tasteless & soggy) They were busy but not fully. We had a beer and and out entrees and it took 90min

Back patio, table setting

See all

Back patio

Food For Thought Take Out

4.7(3 reviews)

1.9 mi

So happy they are back in Pocatello! The cobb salad is just like I remember! Ps the roll that comes…read morewith it is Yummy!

Great Cobb Salad and great customer service since your dealing with the owners and family. Once…read morethey left something off my order and I went back and they took care of it and gave us some sweet goodies for the inconvenience. They too are amazingly delicious!

Best Cobb salad ever!!!

See all

Cobb salad with Jamaica Mistake dressing.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Tom S.

0

29

0

14 years ago

I had almost every one of their hot subs and they are delicious.

Josh F.

4

5

0

16 years ago

Freaking amazing! Best sandwich joint in Pocatello.

Cassie V.

0

6

0

14 years ago

Get the sandwiches, always amazing

Papa Kelseys - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Papa Kelseys also viewed

Buddy's Italian Restaurant

3.5

(191 reviews)

Visiting some family and everybody said I needed to try Buddy's salad. It was definitely worth the…read morehype, the dressing is so delicious. Also the best minestrone soup I've ever had.

I got a small spaghetti with a 1/4 salad to go. The sauce was so overcooked it was brown instead of…read morered and the meat was mealy and the texture was awful . The salad was put in a container and placed on top of the spaghetti in addition to the horrible over dressed vinegary flavor it was now warm and slimey. A waste of time and money i will not be back

Big Foot Pizza

4.3

(85 reviews)

Pizza was amazing! I love how many tops you put on your pizza. Service was fast and friendly.read more

We had delivery for pizza and salad. The pizza was delish!!! The pizza has a ton of toppings and…read morethe sauce was great. It all tasted quite fresh. The salad was a strange bag of lettuce and since they forgot sending plates or utensils we couldn't eat it. All in all it was a great dinner. I wish it was closer to where I live.

Red Rabbit Grill - Pocatello

3.6

(48 reviews)

Service is terrible. I've been here 3 times now and the wait is insanely long to get seated while…read moretables sit empty. Food is okayish but the service is what will keep me away from this place in the future.

Food is great! Love that we can switch out the ciabatta bun for croissant making it a lighter…read moreoption. Great place for lunch!

Works Deli & Grill

3.8

(28 reviews)

The staff was helpful and friendly. The gyros, tots and deep fried pickles were great! We'll be…read moreback for more!

It was our first time trying this place. We were driving home from a trip to Yellowstone and…read morestopped in Pocatello for lunch. We were in the mood for some sandwiches and this place sounded great. It didn't disappoint. The employees were nice and really helpful, giving us good recommendations since we had never been here before. The sandwiches we ordered were delicious. We will definitely be back next time we are passing through.

Geraldine's Bake Shoppe & Deli

3.6

(32 reviews)

The Good: Chicken noodle soup was okay. Dinner roll -- buttered -- was good. Restaurant was clean…read more Service was not unacceptable (but not particularly friendly). Needs Improvement: $6.52 for 8 oz soup and a small roll? Terrible value. 3 pieces of chicken in this serving. Counter attendant asked if I wanted the roll buttered. I assumed that meant a pat of butter would be provided. Nope, they butter it for you. Cost savings for them, I imagine. Thanks I can butter my own roll and have you handle my food less. Bottom Line: Geraldines has great baked goods but is overpriced on about everything. Visit on special occasions, I guess.

so good, breakfast sandwich and cookies 10/10. The bread was great and the sandwich was simple.read more

The Nook

4.9

(14 reviews)

If you're looking for an indulgent, gooey and crusty burger/sandwich, The Nook is your place…read more Situated within Station Square, The Nook offers a variety of deliciousness. I had the Huck Fin, an Idaho staple laden with Huckleberry Habanero cream cheese, a creamy and picante blend against the richness of American beef. My order was a little delayed, but I didn't mind. The server kept me updated and was overly effuse with apologies. Very kind, gracious, and customer focused! Go on a weekend and enjoy the surrounding crafter market, from gnomes to paintings and more, a spot that serves quaint as much as food!!

This place is a Gem. It's not easy to find as it is inside the Salon building. Park in train…read morestation parking and walk over. I have reviewed a lot of burger places but I will tell you for me it is at the top of my list. It is a small place but not crowded which is hard to believe because the food was so amazing. We had the cheese burger and the BLT. The burger is not you regular frozen burger but real ground beef and the BLT looks like it has a lb of yummy bacon on perfectly toasted bread. The owner does it all. He was super friendly and besides the fact that he is the only employee the food came out fast. If you are in this area it is worth the drive.

Jeri's Jumbos Cafe

4.2

(194 reviews)

They actually serve mimosas in this restaurant (harder to find in this town than you would think )!…read more Food was excellent diner food with huge portions! Service was great, you're basically family. I loved the traditional diner aesthetic...great breakfast/brunch spot! Check-it out if you happen to be in Pocatello.

We came in before 8 AM on Memorial Day and were seated immediately, which was a great start to the…read moreexperience. Parking was a little tight with smaller parking spaces, but manageable. The service was quick, and the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. The food came out fast and in large portions. The eggs were cooked exactly as requested, and the French toast was especially good--thick slices of bread coated well in egg and full of flavor. The seating area and restrooms were both very clean and organized, which made the restaurant feel well-maintained overall. The biscuits and gravy were okay, but probably not something I would order again. Aside from that, we had a very positive breakfast experience.

Mo' Bettahs Hawaiian Style Food

3.2

(5 reviews)

The food is sooo salty. The mac salad is super bland. And they forgot the veggies for both orders…read moreeven though it was on the box. The food was cold, too (except for the mac salad which was disturbingly warm)

Finally made it. And hit about 7:45pm and no line. Just a group of very friendly service people…read more Had the teriyaki steak and the grilled chicken and loved every bite. Definitely get extra sauce-you will want it for the rice!

PV's Uncorked on Main

3.9

(18 reviews)